Guest guest Posted January 11, 2002 Report Share Posted January 11, 2002 Survey. > 1. Name Ed Fitzgerald > 2. Location (city and state/province, country) Missouri> 3. Age you developed achalasia 14> 4. Age you are today 68 > 5. Your main treating doctor's name and practice location Norton Greenberger GI Dr. Jon Moran Surgeon > 6. How happy you are with your doctor and current medical care. Marginally happy> 7. What standard treatments they have had and their outcome (briefly 1. Three Surgeries a Heller Myotomy w/wrap 2. Wrap was taken down 14 months later. 3. Esophagectomy> 8. What alternative treatments they have had and their outcome > (briefly). Not taking any meds or treatments related to Achalasia at the present time > 9. Something that they are greatful for (a happy note to end our > survey) After 54 years of this disease I am finally able to eat most anything in small quantities, and am extremely grateful for that. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2002 Report Share Posted January 14, 2002 Ed, where do you live in Missouri? I live in a suburb of St. Louis and it's called Creve Coeur. Where did you have your surgery? Why was the wrap taken down? Did you have the traditional surgery or the laprascopic? I'm going to a doctor at -Jewish in St. Louis and will have the lap March 7th. What is the esophagectomy? Does that mean you had your esophagus removed? Please explain. > Survey. > > 1. Name Ed Fitzgerald > > 2. Location (city and state/province, country) Missouri> 3. Age you developed achalasia 14 > > 4. Age you are today 68 > > 5. Your main treating doctor's name and practice location > Norton Greenberger GI Dr. Jon Moran Surgeon > > 6. How happy you are with your doctor and current medical care. Marginally happy> > 7. What standard treatments they have had and their outcome (briefly 1. Three Surgeries a Heller Myotomy w/wrap 2. Wrap was taken down 14 months later. 3. Esophagectomy > > 8. What alternative treatments they have had and their outcome > > (briefly). Not taking any meds or treatments related to Achalasia at the present time > > 9. Something that they are greatful for (a happy note to end our > > survey) After 54 years of this disease I am finally able to eat most anything in small quantities, and am extremely grateful for that. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2002 Report Share Posted January 14, 2002 Survey. > 1. Name Fagan > 2. Location (city and state/province, country) Virginia Beach, VA 3. Age you developed achalasia 20 > 4. Age you are today 32 > 5. Your main treating doctor's name and practice location Dr. Trent , Gastro. Consultants > 6. How happy you are with your doctor and current medical care. So far, so good..he sent me to motility specialists and did extensive testing> 7. What standard treatments they have had and their outcome (briefly Dilitation-painful and didn't work, 2 botox injections-the last injection lasted over a year! > 8. What alternative treatments they have had and their outcome > (briefly). Nothing alternative yet > 9. Something that they are greatful for (a happy note to end our > survey) After so many years of not eating, I am incredibly grateful for those days when I feel great and can eat what I want ( well, minus steak:) ) I have learned to understand what is really important in life..... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2002 Report Share Posted January 14, 2002 I live in Independence, MO. Surgery was done at Kansas University Medical Center. The wrap was taken down because after 14 months as it began to cause more trouble with swallowing and severe pain. Yes I had the traditional thoracic surgery. Esophagectomy is the removal of the esophagus. I have stayed in Creve Coeur several times, a nice area. I would be glad to answer any other questions you might have. Ed Re: Survey > Ed, where do you live in Missouri? I live in a suburb of St. Louis > and it's called Creve Coeur. Where did you have your surgery? > Why was the wrap taken down? Did you have the traditional surgery or > the laprascopic? I'm going to a doctor at -Jewish in St. Louis > and will have the lap March 7th. What is the esophagectomy? Does > that mean you had your esophagus removed? Please explain. > > > > Survey. > > > 1. Name Ed Fitzgerald > > > 2. Location (city and state/province, country) Missouri> 3. Age > you developed achalasia 14 > > > 4. Age you are today 68 > > > 5. Your main treating doctor's name and practice location > > Norton Greenberger GI Dr. Jon Moran Surgeon > > > 6. How happy you are with your doctor and current medical care. > Marginally happy> > > 7. What standard treatments they have had and their outcome > (briefly 1. Three Surgeries a Heller Myotomy w/wrap 2. Wrap was > taken down 14 months later. 3. Esophagectomy > > > 8. What alternative treatments they have had and their outcome > > > (briefly). Not taking any meds or treatments related to > Achalasia at the present time > > > 9. Something that they are greatful for (a happy note to end > our > > > survey) After 54 years of this disease I am finally able to eat > most anything in small quantities, and am extremely grateful for that. > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 31, 2002 Report Share Posted May 31, 2002 All (forward hither and yon to all interested parties) Would you all do me a favor and please go to this URL (geocities-forwarded email below) and complete the survey. This will help our efforts in getting a newborn screen for our children, particularly their fragile iron metabolism. We see YET another interesting corrolation here that may be preventable and testable. Thanks Chairperson of VOSI standard v50.3 " NEWBORN SCREENS TO DETECT ADVERSE NEUROLOGICAL SEQUALE BEFORE VACCINATING " www.voicesofsafety.com Chair of Oregons Autism Autoimmunity Project http://www.gti.net/truegrit Pres of CHILDSCREEN, a non profit to push forward these standards to change the laws of newborn screens, especially detecting the propensive to injury child. www.childscreen.org (pardon our dust). ----- Original Message ----- > Ladies and Gents, > Can you please visit the survey and give suggestions. > Please let me know if I should add any more questions. > http://www.geocities.com/upadhye10/index.html > Thank you very much. > > U.Padhye > > > __________________________________________________ > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2003 Report Share Posted December 22, 2003 Dear , Fortunately the poll results input by YOU and YOU alone can be altered by You by clicking on 'edit' in the oll section. Also fortunately you do not have to undo any poll answers because you did not answer any. So no harm done. You are correct the Poll is for those who took the November PTCB exam AND have used this site. This is a wayof monitoriing the quality service of the site and if there is anyone taht I need to give special help to and if I am meeting the needs of the community that it serves. Sort of a self-evaluation thing. Must be the teacher in me. Also it gives those who took the exam and studied here something to compare themselves to because as humans that is what we do. I am not justifying this nor am I saying that we should compare ourselves to others nor am I saying that iti si good or bad. I am saying is that it is human nature. And before I began 'polling' all of my 'students' would post their grades and ask each other how they did in a post. So I now provide an avenue to post anonymously so that everyone can see the 'fruit'of our labor and the changes that may need to be made, and so that test takers can compare themselves without embarrassment or feeling 'naked and raw'. Now here is my question to you. Do YOU feel bad that you are not included in the poll? do you think others like yourself who may have tuned in 'late' after the exam may want their own poll? If so I can provide one. After all your scores and stats are equally important. And you may wish to compare to others who did not use the site. So I am up for it if you are. Just say the word and I will make something up as soon as I have a moment. I respect your honesty and integrity. Thank you for asking if you should take the exam or not,and brining to my attntion that there may be another need to satisfy. In addition thank you for using this site to further educate yourself. Congratulations on that too! Many people who used this site until the exam was over have also unsubscribed before the PTCB test results were in. The membership numbers do not change much because I get new members for the next exam study period while older members, who took the Nov exam, are leaving. This always happens, and it distresses me. I always wonder if they had stayed if I would find 'failures' in the polls. To date there have been 'none'. But how accurate is that if some leave before the results aer known? , I failed to 'capture' them sooner with an earlier announcement of the up coming poll, because of my own absence due to my very ill parents hospitalized or having surgery etc. I appologize for that. Therefore there may not be too many respondents to this survey. You can tell the total number of respondents by totaling the different results to the 'scores'. Yesterday there were 6 respondents. I will check after this post. , for someone who did not use this site until after the exam, you sure have a lot of fire in you. I do hope that you and others who just took the November exam will stay around and help out the next 'study round " of PTCB March 2004 test takers! You are most welcome here. Thank you again for your enthusiasm, Respectfully, Jeanetta Mastron CPhT BS Chem Pharm Tech Educator Founder/Owner > Hey Jeanetta. I haven't taken the poll because I came to this site > after taking the PTCE. I wanted to know when the results would come > in. I thank the Lord things turned out well. Although the wait was > long. So I wasn't sure if I should take the survey, so I didn't. No > information is better than bad information, I'm sure you know that. > I do feel that this website has been helping me in preparing to > further learn more about being a CPhT. Thanks alot for that. If I > should take the survey anyway, let me know. Otherwise, I hope more > people take the survey. Thanks. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 21, 2004 Report Share Posted January 21, 2004 Sorry, the german word " angst " just means fear, nothing else. > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate: .... > 3. The word " anger " comes from a German word, " angst " which means > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or > small? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 21, 2004 Report Share Posted January 21, 2004 Hi Diane, I know in the early stages it seems to happen more with chicken nuggets, sometimes steak. I know if i was rushing it happened more. also if i got stressed. I don't have any problem with anger, i'm kindamellow and just go with the flow. Hope this helps. dra > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate: > > 1. In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food to be > meat; beef, chicken, fish etc? > > 2. Did you sense you were stressed or nervous or upset at the time? > > 3. The word " anger " comes from a German word, " angst " which means > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or > small? > > Thanks for participating..... I have some ideas on this depending > how the survey turns out. Please be honest if you do participate. > We may be onto something here and have figured something out many > Drs. haven't yet. > > More later, > God bless you as you do your best to deal with this, > Love, Diane Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 21, 2004 Report Share Posted January 21, 2004 Surveys are best done in the "polls" section. Too hard to keep track of things like that in the posts. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 21, 2004 Report Share Posted January 21, 2004 > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate: > > 1. In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food to be > meat; beef, chicken, fish etc? YES, PORK AND BEEF > > 2. Did you sense you were stressed or nervous or upset at the time? > DEFINITELY STRESSED. > 3. The word " anger " comes from a German word, " angst " which means > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or > small? I DO HAVE A SHORT FUSE (MOSTLY WHEN I HAVE WORKED MANY HOURS WITH LITTLE SLEEP) > I HOPE THIS HAS HELPED OUT. when I am stressed out or upset I tend to hold my stress in my abdomen, I can't eat. Unlike others who eat when they are stressed. Genia Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2004 Report Share Posted January 22, 2004 jpearse@... Survey Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate:1. In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food to be meat; beef, chicken, fish etc?2. Did you sense you were stressed or nervous or upset at the time?3. The word "anger" comes from a German word, "angst" which means to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or small?Thanks for participating..... I have some ideas on this depending how the survey turns out. Please be honest if you do participate. We may be onto something here and have figured something out many Drs. haven't yet. More later,God bless you as you do your best to deal with this,Love, Diane Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 My bad. The word ANGER in ENGLISH (not German) comes from a deep meaning " to choke " I copied something from Websters for anyone interested... AN'GER, n. ang'ger. [L. ango, to choke; strangle, vex; whence angor, vexation, anguish, the quinsy, angina. Gr. to strangle, to strain or draw together to vex. The primary sense is to press, squeeze, MAKE NARROW; Heb. to strangle.] Just maybe, some emotion is involved in this condition. Just maybe our emotions are involved in this " strangling " or " choking " or NARROW passage for food. Something to think about. I for one, am always looking for truth, even when it hurts. With love and prayers for all who suffer with Achalasia, Diane > > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate: > ... > > 3. The word " anger " comes from a German word, " angst " which means > > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or > > small? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 Thanks dra, That helps a LOT! 3 out of 4! I think you are not the only one who early on suffered from steak and chicken. Me too! One other thing I am surveying is blood type! Seriously! I'm type O positive. Do any of you out there know what type you are and are many of you O? I read Type O's (either positive or negative) offen have this sort of disorder due to too much acidity in our stomach juices. When we are hugnry, and begin eating too fast, something (the empty stomach full of acid) triggers the shutting down of the valve and it clamps shut. I am wondering if perhaps there are MORE Achalasia sufferers who are Type O than any other type!!!??? Help me out here? Still seeking. Love, Diane > > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate: > > > > 1. In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food to > be > > meat; beef, chicken, fish etc? > > > > 2. Did you sense you were stressed or nervous or upset at the time? > > > > 3. The word " anger " comes from a German word, " angst " which means > > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or > > small? > > > > Thanks for participating..... I have some ideas on this depending > > how the survey turns out. Please be honest if you do participate. > > We may be onto something here and have figured something out many > > Drs. haven't yet. > > > > More later, > > God bless you as you do your best to deal with this, > > Love, Diane Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 WOW Genia! Yes, that deffinely helped! Thank you for responding! So you agree that meats are the main cause or trigger. And you agree that stress is also a factor. And you also admit to being well.... high strung, or with a short fuse, however you want to put it. LOL (me too) I have found that when I'm really hungry, stressed, and eat too fast, it happens most. So naturally, I try and eat more than 3 times a day and I do not allow myself to get very very hungry. And, I try and slow down especially during the first half of my meal.... I also take time to pray and to find some quiet time to relax and think, and read the Bible. This has helped so much. I also discovered that Blood Type O's may have this more than other types? So if you know your blood type, let me know??? Thanks again, Genia and have a wonderful, stress-free day. Love, Diane in Florida > > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate: > > > > 1. In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food to > be > > meat; beef, chicken, fish etc? > > YES, PORK AND BEEF > > > > 2. Did you sense you were stressed or nervous or upset at the time? > > > DEFINITELY STRESSED. > > > 3. The word " anger " comes from a German word, " angst " which means > > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or > > small? > I DO HAVE A SHORT FUSE (MOSTLY WHEN I HAVE WORKED MANY > HOURS WITH LITTLE SLEEP) > > > I HOPE THIS HAS HELPED OUT. > when I am stressed out or upset I tend to hold my stress in my > abdomen, I can't eat. Unlike others who eat when they are stressed. > > Genia Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 Diane wrote: >...The word ANGER in ENGLISH (not German) comes from a deep >meaning " to choke " ... Ever get the urge to strangle someone? Its name is anger. notan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 Hi Diane, I am O positive. You might find some interesting reading in the books by Dr J. D'Adamo 'The Eat Right Diet' and Live Right for your type". O type people react to certain foods and by avoiding them there is an improvement in their health and well being. I followed this diet for several years and really improved - that was before A struck. The main food I needed to avoid were wheat and milk. Joan Johannesburg South Africajpearse@... Re: Survey Thanks dra,That helps a LOT! 3 out of 4!I think you are not the only one who early on suffered from steak and chicken. Me too! One other thing I am surveying is blood type! Seriously! I'm type O positive. Do any of you out there know what type you are and are many of you O? I read Type O's (either positive or negative) offen have this sort of disorder due to too much acidity in our stomach juices. When we are hugnry, and begin eating too fast, something (the empty stomach full of acid) triggers the shutting down of the valve and it clamps shut. I am wondering if perhaps there are MORE Achalasia sufferers who are Type O than any other type!!!???Help me out here?Still seeking.Love, Diane> > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate:> > > > 1. In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food to > be > > meat; beef, chicken, fish etc?> > > > 2. Did you sense you were stressed or nervous or upset at the time?> > > > 3. The word "anger" comes from a German word, "angst" which means > > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or > > small?> > > > Thanks for participating..... I have some ideas on this depending > > how the survey turns out. Please be honest if you do participate. > > We may be onto something here and have figured something out many > > Drs. haven't yet. > > > > More later,> > God bless you as you do your best to deal with this,> > Love, Diane Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 Thank you Joan for participating. Maybe stress is more related than anger per se.... But it seems almost everyone agrees chicken or meat of some kind is an early trigger. WHy some of us can't seem to swallow chicken and others without Achalasia can is the question. Meanwhile, why eat chicken? LOL Thanks again and you have a gr8 day in South Africa. With love and best wishes, Diane, Fl. USA > > jpearse@p... > Survey > > > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate: > > 1. In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food to be > meat; beef, chicken, fish etc? > > 2. Did you sense you were stressed or nervous or upset at the time? > > 3. The word " anger " comes from a German word, " angst " which means > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large or > small? > > Thanks for participating..... I have some ideas on this depending > how the survey turns out. Please be honest if you do participate. > We may be onto something here and have figured something out many > Drs. haven't yet. > > More later, > God bless you as you do your best to deal with this, > Love, Diane > > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------- > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 Diane wrote: Do any of you out there know what type you are and are many of you O? I’m AB+. I’m also a very calm person who holds everything in, and I’m very physically affected by stress. I remember in the beginning of my A, it pretty much started with the foam, and then six months later, I started having a problem with eating just about everything, especially breads meat and fruit. Fresh fruit has always been a tough one with achalasia, and continues to be so, but I tolerate berries very well, so I eat lots of berries. I’m definitely not prone to anger…it takes a lot to get me angry. :-) We’re all very different Diane, but I do think that stress plays a big role in achalasia. Sandi in No CA Holt- Groups Links · To visit your group on the web, go to: achalasia/ · Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 Diane wrote: >.. I'm type O positive. I'm O neg.. >... I read Type O's >(either positive or negative) offen have this sort of disorder due >to too much acidity in our stomach juices. Do you have a reference for that? > When we are hugnry, and >begin eating too fast, something (the empty stomach full of acid) >triggers the shutting down of the valve and it clamps shut. There must be more to this theory, because there are a lot of type Os that also eat fast and don't have this problem, and the little bit we have here does not address that. Besides, I can assure you that a lot of people in this group have stopped eating fast a long time ago, but still have achalasia. notan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 That's right. wanting to " choke " someone (anger) and choking yourself can be connected eh? I mean if you are all bottled up inside, and angry, maybe it can effect your own throat or espohogus? Just a thought... Thanks for your input. > >...The word ANGER in ENGLISH (not German) comes from a deep > >meaning " to choke " ... > > Ever get the urge to strangle someone? Its name is anger. > > notan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 Hi , It seems anger may not be an issue, but stress definiely is. Yes we are all different; I'm just trying to find some clues. Thank you for responding to my survey. You are the first AB+ I've heard of, but perhaps there are others. Funny how many seem to be O... Maybe his book is right though - he said O's tend to have this sort of disorder more than the others due to stomach acid etc... HAve a gr8 day, Diane > Do any of you out there know what type you are and are many of you O? > > I'm AB+. > I'm also a very calm person who holds everything in, and I'm very > physically affected by stress. > I remember in the beginning of my A, it pretty much started with the > foam, and then six months later, I started having a problem with eating > just about everything, especially breads meat and fruit. Fresh fruit has > always been a tough one with achalasia, and continues to be so, but I > tolerate berries very well, so I eat lots of berries. > I'm definitely not prone to anger.it takes a lot to get me angry. :-) > We're all very different Diane, but I do think that stress plays a big > role in achalasia. > Sandi in No CA > > > Holt- > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 Diane wrote: >... WHy some of us can't seem to >swallow chicken and others without Achalasia can is the question. Just think for a moment, if you have a tight passage what kind of food is going to get stuck there. Meat is stringy and lumpy, it may have a harder time getting through than pudding. It is the tight passage not the meat that causes the choking. You were getting achalasia therefore you began to choke, not that you began to choke and therefore got achalasia. In my case it was drinks that I noticed first. I would wait until I was very thirsty and then guzzle a drink. (Often after working and breathing hard, so the " white foam " would be thicker and dryer, seems to make a great plug). The drink could not get through the tight passage fast enough and would pile up until it was high enough that I choked. I choke because I was getting achalasia. I didn't get achalasia because I choked. > Meanwhile, why eat chicken? Because I like it and I need to eat something. Also, I get tired of eating the same thing every day. notan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Share Posted January 23, 2004 - Diane, I am type 0. Jenifer -- In achalasia , " Diane " <wanabthn@y...> wrote: > Thanks dra, > That helps a LOT! 3 out of 4! > I think you are not the only one who early on suffered from steak > and chicken. Me too! One other thing I am surveying is blood > type! Seriously! I'm type O positive. Do any of you out there > know what type you are and are many of you O? I read Type O's > (either positive or negative) offen have this sort of disorder due > to too much acidity in our stomach juices. When we are hugnry, and > begin eating too fast, something (the empty stomach full of acid) > triggers the shutting down of the valve and it clamps shut. I am > wondering if perhaps there are MORE Achalasia sufferers who are Type > O than any other type!!!??? > > Help me out here? > > Still seeking. > > Love, Diane > > > > > Just curious and wanted to ask you to participate: > > > > > > 1. In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food > to > > be > > > meat; beef, chicken, fish etc? > > > > > > 2. Did you sense you were stressed or nervous or upset at the > time? > > > > > > 3. The word " anger " comes from a German word, " angst " which > means > > > to choke. Who here has a deep rooted problem with anger, large > or > > > small? > > > > > > Thanks for participating..... I have some ideas on this > depending > > > how the survey turns out. Please be honest if you do > participate. > > > We may be onto something here and have figured something out > many > > > Drs. haven't yet. > > > > > > More later, > > > God bless you as you do your best to deal with this, > > > Love, Diane Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 25, 2004 Report Share Posted January 25, 2004 Diane wrote: > I am wondering if perhaps there are MORE Achalasia sufferers > who are Type O than any other type!!!??? Well, since Type O IS THE MOST COMMON BLOOD TYPE in the US, and since the majority (certainly not all, but I daresay the vast majority) of the members of this group are from the United States, simple logic tells us that a very large percentage of us are Type O. Debbi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 25, 2004 Report Share Posted January 25, 2004 Diane wrote: > WOW Genia! Yes, that deffinely helped! Thank you for responding! > So you agree that meats are the main cause or trigger. I didn't read Genia's response to say this at all. You asked: In the early stages, did you usually find the problem food to be meat; beef, chicken, fish etc? And Genia replied: YES, PORK AND BEEF You asked us what foods we first had trouble swallowing, not what we think caused our achalasia. So taking Genia's response to meat being a " problem food " and rewording it like she's saying that meat is a " cause or trigger " isn't an appropriate conclusion to her statement. I also think that before using terms like " cause " or " trigger " that there should be some sort of definition of what those words mean; without clarification of what is meant by the terms, there's a huge potential for misunderstanding. For example, most people think of a " cause " as being a reason for why something happened. The cause of chicken pox is the varicella-zoster virus. You get chicken pox BECAUSE OF the varicella-zoster virus. The virus is the cause. You become hypothermic BECAUSE OF the cold temperature. The temperature is the cause. This does not translate into the meat/achalasia scenario. You don't get achalasia BECAUSE OF the meat --you have trouble swallowing the meat BECAUSE OF the achalasia. Same for the use of " trigger " -- a trigger sets off a process. The sight of a squirrel in the back yard triggers a dog's excited barking. The dog barks BECAUSE OF the squirrel. But the squirrel wasn't in the back yard because he wanted to hear the dog bark (well, maybe... we have some pretty crafty squirrels around here!) But we don't have achalasia because we are trying to swallow meat. We have dysphagia (trouble swallowing) because we have achalasia, and we have trouble swallowing meat because we have trouble swallowing *in general* -- it's only natural that we would have the most trouble swallowing the items (meat) which are least likely to be completely pulverized in the chewing process, as those items are going to be the largest in size and therefore the most difficult to swallow for people who have trouble swallowing. I think that clarifying the terms that are used helps to prevent misunderstandings and confusion for the ones who are reading the posts. Debbi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.