Guest guest Posted January 15, 2008 Report Share Posted January 15, 2008 What if the kid whose arm they recommended removing and did not-- died? Will the kid be so lucky next time? Will the cancer return (as so often happens) and this kid now will be convinced that medical treatments are useless when in fact it could save their life? How do we explain why nothing was done and the worst outcome happened? There's a whole lot to consider when looking at this kind of situation from the doctor's point of view versus our own. We in this group, and others in the GEIPE etc, are not tasked with any legal or other responsibility for anyone's health, so it's easy for us to encourage people to do things in a hopeful way, out of concern and caring, but without the ultimate responsibility for the outcome! Not so the doctors. They are called to account, into court, harrassed by families, sued, threatened all the time, even if their treatments had nothing to do with the outcome. Sometimes just so someone can get a large cash settlement. It's a very hard position to be in and remain cheerful and encouraging to patients if those patients do not cooperate yet are under their care! Let's be real, doctors are tasked with ordering treatments that have " a chance " of healing, a chance of killing, a chance of maiming, and a chance of doing nothing at all. Failure is built-into such treatments. They have to prescribe them knowing it. A calculated chance is still better than something untested with no idea if it works at all, let alone how often it might work. I don't envy and I do understand that situation, but only from a safe distance. They are up close (and frightened of it). Someone is dying and it is very scary if you are the caregiver! Be well for heaven's sake, and if not, use the best of everything, and understand that a doc is not just another caring person, they are in an impossible spot for your sake. I think most of them really do care. bG Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.