Florida undecided as states sue over costly drug program

[Guest guest]

http://www.news-journalonline.com/NewsJournalOnline/News/Headlines/frtHEAD020110\

08.htm

January 10, 2008

Florida undecided as states sue over costly drug program

By M.C. MOEWE

Staff Writer

They're powerful psychotic drugs, used to treat conditions like schizophrenia.

No one knows what their effects are on children, especially infants, yet within

seven years the number of children prescribed the drugs in Florida's health

insurance program for the poor has nearly doubled.

There's no doubting one side effect, though -- drug companies watched sales

soar, aided by a Florida program they helped create.

Florida is far from unique. Several states also noted the costly boom of

atypical antipsychotics -- a new class of the drug that was touted to have fewer

side effects. The states are suing drug makers, alleging the companies pushed

newer, untested drugs that proved no more effective in treatments -- but were

far more costly.

In Florida, the taxpayers' bill for the drugs jumped from $9 million seven years

ago to nearly $30 million in 2006. Whether Florida will join states like Texas,

Pennsylvania and South Carolina in trying to recoup some of those costs is

unclear.

" Our office is aware of concerns with antipsychotics in Florida's Medicaid

program but we cannot acknowledge nor provide any information pertaining to

ongoing criminal investigations, " said Sandi Copes, a spokeswoman with the

Florida Attorney General's office.

Florida Medicaid records show the number of children -- some just months old --

who were prescribed the drugs went from 9,364 seven years ago to 18,137 in 2006.

No records for privately insured patients are available.

" The situation is out of control, " said Cohen, a professor at Florida

International University who has been studying the use of antipsychotics since

1983. While no long-term studies have been done on the effects the drugs have on

children, there is evidence children on the drugs face greater risks of

diabetes, hyperglycemia and extreme weight gain, Cohen said.

'MOOD STABILIZERS'

Orange City child psychiatrist Mota-Castillo said age shouldn't be a

factor in determining whether the drug is needed. He has prescribed

antipsychotics to children frequently, with the youngest being a 25-month-old

child.

" I don't want to use the name 'antipsychotic.' I use 'mood stabilizer,' " said

Mota-Castillo, who also worked for three years at Act Corp., the area's main

mental health facility.

The 25-month-old child had been kicked out of five day-care centers where

complaints included punching other children, he said. " The child's mother came

to me in shorts so I could see the bruises and marks (on her), " he said.

Crystal Lamson of Sanford said Mota-Castillo has been treating her bipolar son

for more than two years. Ryland, now 7, broke a Plexiglas window at a day-care

center when he was 5.

" I get criticized all the time from family members, " Lamson said. " (But) there

are some children out there who do need them. "

Another Sanford parent, , said he watched in horror as his daughter

Ciara, then 6, gained 40 pounds, developed breasts and had uncontrollable tongue

and facial movements.

" Those drugs were killing her, " said.

Over his objections, he said Ciara was given antipsychotics by her mother and

while in foster care. A court-appointed guardian also noted the effects in an

August 2003 report, describing a visit in which Ciara " never once kept her

tongue in her mouth. "

Ciara, now 11, was taken off the drugs after about a year, her father said, and

she quickly dropped the added weight.

'TAINTED' MONEY

In Florida, even as drug makers were being told to issue warnings about risks, a

Florida Legislature-directed program partly funded by pharmaceutical companies

was recommending the drugs as treatment for attention deficit hyperactivity

disorder (ADHD) with tics or intermittent explosive disorder, according to the

program's Web site that has since been shut down.

According to a study that looked at three years of data, about 40 percent of the

antipsychotics prescribed to Florida Medicaid children were given to children

diagnosed with ADHD -- a use not approved by the Food and Drug Administration.

The Florida program was patterned after a Texas project that has spurred a

whistle-blower lawsuit. The Florida Algorithm Project used some of the

Texas-developed medical formulas that recommended drug treatments for mental

diseases.

A year ago Texas joined the whistle-blower suit against Janssen Pharmaceutica

and several other & subsidiaries. The suit alleges the program's

treatment guidelines -- " improperly influenced " and paid for by the drug

companies --increased sales of the antipsychotic Risperdal.

An official with Janssen said the company will defend its actions.

" We believe our participation in all aspects of our Texas Risperdal activities

were in accordance with what the law required, " said Ambre Morley, a company

spokeswoman.

Florida pilot programs using the Texas-developed guidelines began in 2001,

according to state documents. Act Corp. in Volusia County was one of 15 sites

that adopted the program until it was discontinued in September 2004.

Bax, a former director of the Florida program, said the project began with

funding from pharmaceutical companies.

" It did not take me long to realize that the money from the drug companies was

tainted, " Bax said. " Once I got into it, I saw what I thought was very

insidious. "

According to the program's defunct Web site, Bax was director only a couple of

months before a retired & employee took the title.

In 2002, the Florida Legislature permitted the Department of Children & Families

to accept grants from pharmaceutical manufacturers to develop training for

health care organizations serving public sector clients, according to a

September 2003 Agency for Health Care letter about the Florida program.

When first interviewed, those familiar with the program said they did not recall

any ADHD-related information. But archived pages from the program's Internet

site show the program had more guidelines on how to treat ADHD than any other

ailment. A 2004 report about the program's progress pointed to the development

of an ADHD guideline as an accomplishment.

Rajive Tandon, chief psychiatrist for the Mental Health Program Office with

Florida's Department of Children & Families, said he's not sure how much impact

the Florida program had on the increased use of antipsychotics.

" It certainly was a contributing factor, " he said.

Doctors believed the new antipsychotics were better, Tandon said, citing

" aggressive marketing. "

But the new antipsychotics proved no more effective than older drugs in two

significant studies -- one published in 2005 in the New England Journal of

Medicine and another in the Journal of the American Medical Association

published in 2003, said Cohen, the antipsychotics expert at Florida

International.

Tandon said Florida should consider a lawsuit like other states.

" Should we at least look into it? Absolutely, " he said, calling for, at minimum,

an investigation into the Florida program's funding and impacts. " Then basically

hold the appropriate people responsible. "

-- News researcher Janice Cahill contributed to this report.

mary.moewe@...

More Drugs

Atypical antipsychotics were touted to have fewer side effects than older

antipsychotics, and their use increased among children in Florida's Medicaid

program under guidelines that drug companies helped create between 2000 and

2006. Here's a rundown on the drugs that have been prescribed.

Brand name; drug maker; number of prescriptions

Risperdal; & subsidiary; 304,762

Seroquel; AstraZeneca; 161,823

Zyprexa; Eli Lilly and Company; 90,052

Abilify; Bristol-Myers Squibb/Otsuka; 82,499

Geodon; Pfizer; 28,884

SOURCE: Florida Agency for Health Care Administration. Data analyzed by Janice

Cahill and M.C. Moewe