Re: Document Emerge Proving Dr. Wakefiled Innocent; BMJ/ Deer Misrepresenting Facts

[Guest guest]

I read a very alarming book entitled Seeds of

Destruction that talks about a scientist who was the first to

actually test American GMO "foods" and spoke candidly on UK

television stating he would not eat the food himself. According to

the book the Royal Society slammed the scientist, he was fired

from his job and basically the same sort of thing as this

Wakefield saga, publicly thrashed over something that threatened

the "powers that be".

http://www.amazon.com/Seeds-Destruction-Hidden-Genetic-Manipulation/dp/0973714727#_

The back cover art shows the biochemists name and comment.

Jim

On 1/26/2011 12:15 PM, and Terry Bearden wrote:

I don't suppose

I'll ever be able to decide who is right, who is lying in

this case. It can't be both, eh?

T.

http://www.naturalnews.com/031116_Dr__Wakefield_British_Medical_Journal.html

(NaturalNews) New

documents have emerged that clear Dr Wakefield of the

allegations of fraud recently made by the British Medical

Journal and its reporter Deer. This new evidence

"completely negates the allegations that I committed

scientific

fraud. Deer and Dr. Godlee of the British Medical

Journal (BMJ) knew or should

have known about the facts set out below before publishing

their false allegations," says Dr Wakefield (see

sources, below).

Newly-revealed documents show that on December 20th, 1996, a

meeting of The Inflammatory Bowel Disease Study Group

based at the Royal Free Hospital Medical School

featured a presentation by Professor - on seven

of the children who would later

become part of the group of patients Dr Wakefield wrote

about in his 1998 The Lancet paper (which

was later retracted by The Lancet).

Remember, Dr Wakefield has been accused of completely

fabricating his findings about these same

children in his 1998 paper, but these documents

reveal that fourteen months before Dr Wakefield's paper

was published, two other researchers -- Professor

- and Dr Amar Dhillon -- independently

documented the same problems in these children, including

symptoms of autism.

Thus, Dr Wakefield could not have "fabricated" these

findings as alleged by the British Medical Journal,

which now finds itself in the position of needing to issue a

retraction, or it must now expand its accusations of fraud to include Professor

- and Dr Dhillon... essentially, the BMJ must now

insist that a "conspiracy of fraud" existed among at least

these three researchers, and possibly more, in order to back

up its allegation that Dr Wakefield's study results were

fabricated.

The smoking-gun evidence

Professor -'s 1996 presentation at the Royal Free

Hospital Medical School was entitled, "Entero-colitis

and Disintegrative Disorder Following MMR - A Review of

the First Seven Cases."

His presentation notes began with the following text: ""I

wish today, to present some preliminary details concerning

seven children, all boys, who appear to have entero-colitis

and disintegrative disorder, probably autism,

following MMR. I shall now briefly present

their case history [sic]."

He then went on to detail the clinical history of these

seven children as derived from his medical team as well as

senior pathologist Dr Amar Dhillon. Importantly, Dr

Wakefield was not part of this investigation. This means

that Dr Wakefield's findings were independently

replicated by another medical research team.

The British Medical Journal's accusations against Dr

Wakefield -- that he fabricated his findings -- are

therefore false. The mainstream media accusation that Dr

Wakefield's findings have "never been replicated" is also

blatantly false.

Here are the notes on the seven children, as presented in

1996, 14 months BEFORE Dr Wakefield published his

landmark paper in The Lancet:

Child 1. Immediate reaction to MMR with fever at 1 [corrected,

illegible]

Rapid deterioration in behaviour - autism

Histology active chronic inflammation in caecum

Treated Asacol

INDETERMINATE COLITIS** (1)

Child 2. MMR at 15 months - head banging 2 weeks later.

Hyperactive from 18 months.

Endoscopy - aphthoid ulcer at hepatic flexure

Caecum: lymphoid nodular hyperplasia with erythematous rim

and pale swollen

core.

Histology, Ileum mild inflammation, colon moderate inflammation

Acute and chronic inflammation.

Treated CT3211 [a dietary treatment]

INDETERMINATE COLITIS** ? CROHN'S DISEASE

Child 3. ? dysmorphism - chromosomes and normal

development

MMR at 5 months [sic]

Measles at 2.5 years* - 1 month later change in behavior

Hyperactive with food

Colonoscopy - granular rectum, normal colon and lymphoid

nodular

hyperplasia.

Histopathology: lymphoid nodular hyperplasia.

Increased eosinophils 5/5 mild increase in inflammatory

cells (Dhillon)

Routine normal

LYMPHOID NODULAR HYPERPLASIA

INDETERMINATE COLITIS**

[* correction: he received measles vaccine first at

approximately 15 months of

age and MMR at 2.5. years]

Child 4 (2). Reacted to triple vaccine 4 months -

screaming and near cot death

(DPT)

MMR at 15 months - behaviour changed after 1 week.

"measles rash" week before

Endoscopy - minor abnormalities of vascular pattern

Histology - non-specific proctocolitis**

Treated

INDETERMINTE PROCTOCOLITIS

LYMPHOID NODULAR HYPERPLASIA

Child 5 (3). MMR at 14 months.

Second day after, fever and rash, bangs head and behaviour

abnormal

thereafter.

Endoscopy - Lymphoid nodular hyperplasia

Histopathology: Marked increase in IEL's [intraepithelial

lymphocytes] in ileum

with chronic inflammatory cells in reactive follicles.

Increase in inflammatory cells in colon and IELs increased.

LYMPHOID NODULAR HYPERPLASIA

INDETERMINATE COLITIS

Child 6(7). MMR - 16 months - no obvious reaction

2 years behavioral change - 2.5 years

Screaming attacks - / food related

Endoscopy - Lymphoid nodular hyperplasia terminal ileum

Histology - Prominent lymphoid follicles

Dhillon: moderate to marked increase in IEL's, increase in

chronic inflammatory

cells throughout the colon - superficial macrophages not

quite granuloma

INDTERMINATE COLITIS

Child 78. MMR 14 months

16 months "growling voice"

18 months - behavioural changes - autism diagnosed at 3

years

Barium [follow through X ray] 5 cm tight stricture

[proximal] to insertion of

terminal ileum

Endoscopy- prominent lymphoid follicle in ileum

Mild proctitis with granular mucosa

Histology

Ileum - reactive follicles

Colon - bifid forms, increased IEL's

Slight increase in inflammatory cells

INDETERMINATE COLITIS

? CROHN'S DISEASE

NOTES:

(1) Inflammation that is not diagnostic of either Crohn's disease or ulcerative

colitis

(2) Child 6 in The Lancet paper. The chronological order was

corrected for the final Lancet paper.

(3) Child 3 in The Lancet paper

BMJ caught in its own fraud

These documents reveal that the British Medical Journal has

been caught in its own fraud for willfully ignoring this

evidence, which was presented to it long before its recent

publication of Deer's article calling Dr Wakefield

a fraud.

The BMJ willfully ignored this evidence and simply decided

to destroy Dr Wakefield's professional reputation by any

means necessary. As Dr Wakefield explains:

"In allowing itself to become the vehicle for

Deer's particular brand of journalism; in circumventing

the process of due diligence in its enthusiasm to "kill

the beast", the BMJ has taken a huge risk. As the document

presented above shows, this was a mistake. Medicine,

presented with the possibility of an iatrogenic

catastrophe, has boarded a dissonant bandwagon and has

gone after those who have concerns - genuine concerns -

that childhood vaccines may be

responsible, at least in part, for the autism epidemic.

The relevant science has been grossly

misrepresented, crushed beneath the wheels of a Public

Relations 16-wheeler that is out of control. In the

meantime a relentless tsunami of damaged children claims

this land."

Deer caught as a liar

It has also been revealed that journalist Deer, the

author of the BMJ article condemning Dr Wakefield as a

fraud, is himself a liar. In attempting to gather evidence

for his article in the BMJ, he lied about his identity and

entered the home of one of the parents of the autism

children. Specifically, he claimed he was working for

The Sunday Times even though he was never a Sunday

Times employee.

This is just the tip of the iceberg of the outright

deception that has been used by the BMJ and Deer in

their attempt to silence a doctor whose only "crime" was

publicly expressing concern about the safety of MMR vaccines.

That the BMJ and its writer Deer have now been caught

ignoring evidence and engaging in their own fraud gives

credence to the idea that MMR vaccines may, indeed, not only

be dangerous; but that they may be so dangerous that the

top medical journals have to

lie about the facts in order to protect them.

What's clear here is that the BMJ has strayed so far from

the realm of evidence-based scientific thinking that it can

no longer be called a reputable medical journal at all. Its

callous disregard for the truth -- and its

politically-motivated witch hunt against a researcher who

only sought to protect the health of children -- exposes

it as a danger to the scientific

community and the world of conventional medicine.

As this truth unfolds, these revelations will rock the

medical world and expose these science journals as the

frauds they truly are. Think about this: While these

medical journals are taking money from vaccine manufacturers (who

pay their ads), they are ignoring any scientific evidence

they don't like in order to vilify anyone who threatens the

profits of these very same vaccine companies! And yet, these

medical journals never admit that their very existence

depends on the financial flow of money from these vaccine

manufacturers who are strongly impacted by their editorial

decisions!

There is fraud taking place in the vaccine industry today, of course,

and the medical journals are the point men who push their

distorted disinformation into the minds of doctors,

journalists and anyone they can reach with their scientific

distortions. At stake is the future of the vaccine industry,

which is of course a multi-billion-dollar industry that

thrives on misinformation and the ongoing scientific

censorship of the facts surrounding the health risks

posed by vaccines.

Read the book Callous Disregard

Dr Wakefield is the author of Callous Disregard,

the book that exposes the truth behind conventional

medicine's political witch hunt.

Learn more: http://www.naturalnews.com/031116_Dr__Wakefield_British_Medical_Journal.html#ixzz1CAN6JpSQ

"The doctor of the future will give no medicine but will

interest his patients in the care of the human frame, in diet

and in the cause and prevention of disease." - Edison ---

FAIR USE NOTICE: This transmittal may contain copyrighted

material which is made available for educational purposes and to

advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific,

moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. The sender

asserts that this transmittal constitutes a 'fair use' of any

such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C.

section 107 of the US Copyright Law. This material is

distributed without profit.

[Guest guest]

The suspended scientist was Árpád Pusztai formerly of Rowett Institute

the crop was genetically modified potatoes containing the GNA lectin gene from the snowdrop plant

His group fed rats on raw and cooked genetically modified potatoes, using Red potatoes as controls.

source - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%81rp%C3%A1d_Pusztai

> >> >> > I don't suppose I'll ever be able to decide who is right, who is lying > > in this case. It can't be both, eh?> > T.> > http://www.naturalnews.com/031116_Dr__Wakefield_British_Medical_Journal.html> > (NaturalNews) New documents have emerged that clear Dr > > Wakefield of the allegations of fraud recently made by the British > > Medical Journal and its reporter Deer. This new evidence > > "completely negates the allegations that I committed scientific> > fraud. Deer and Dr. Godlee of the British Medical Journal (BMJ) > > knew or should> > have known about the facts set out below before publishing their false > > allegations," says Dr Wakefield (see sources, below).> >> > Newly-revealed documents show that on December 20th, 1996, a meeting > > of /The Inflammatory Bowel Disease Study Group/ based at the /Royal > > Free Hospital Medical School/ featured a presentation by Professor > > - on seven of the children > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/children.html> who would later become part > > of the group of patients Dr Wakefield wrote about in his 1998 /The > > Lancet <http://www.naturalnews.com/The_Lancet.html>/ paper (which was > > later retracted by The Lancet).> >> > Remember, Dr Wakefield has been accused of completely fabricating his > > findings <http://www.naturalnews.com/findings.html> about these same > > children in his 1998 paper <http://www.naturalnews.com/paper.html>, > > but these documents reveal that *fourteen months before Dr Wakefield's > > paper was published, two other researchers -- Professor - > > and Dr Amar Dhillon -- independently documented the same problems in > > these children, including symptoms of autism > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/autism.html>.*> >> > Thus, Dr Wakefield could not have "fabricated" these findings as > > alleged by the British Medical Journal > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/British_Medical_Journal.html>, which now > > finds itself in the position of needing to issue a retraction, or it > > must now expand its accusations of fraud > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/fraud.html> to include Professor > > - and Dr Dhillon... essentially, the BMJ must now insist > > that a "conspiracy of fraud" existed among at least these three > > researchers, and possibly more, in order to back up its allegation > > that Dr Wakefield's study results were fabricated.> >> >> > The smoking-gun evidence <http://www.naturalnews.com/evidence.html>> >> > Professor -'s 1996 presentation at the Royal Free Hospital > > Medical School was entitled, *"Entero-colitis and Disintegrative > > Disorder Following MMR - A Review of the First Seven Cases."*> >> > His presentation notes began with the following text: ""I wish today, > > to present some preliminary details concerning seven children, all > > boys, who appear to have entero-colitis and disintegrative disorder > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/disorder.html>, probably autism, following > > MMR. I shall now briefly present> > their case history <http://www.naturalnews.com/history.html> [sic]."> >> > He then went on to detail the clinical history of these seven children > > as derived from his medical team as well as senior pathologist Dr Amar > > Dhillon. Importantly, Dr Wakefield was not part of this > > investigation. This means that Dr Wakefield's findings were > > *independently replicated* by another medical research > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/research.html> team.> >> > The British Medical Journal's accusations against Dr Wakefield -- that > > he fabricated his findings -- are therefore false. The mainstream > > media accusation that Dr Wakefield's findings have "never been > > replicated" is also blatantly false.> >> > Here are the notes on the seven children, as presented in 1996, *14 > > months BEFORE Dr Wakefield published his landmark paper in The Lancet*:> >> > *Child 1. Immediate reaction to MMR with fever > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/fever.html> at 1 [corrected, illegible]*> > Rapid deterioration in behaviour - autism> > Histology active chronic inflammation > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/inflammation.html> in caecum> > Treated Asacol> > INDETERMINATE COLITIS** (1)> >> > *Child 2. MMR at 15 months - head banging 2 weeks later.*> > Hyperactive from 18 months.> > Endoscopy - aphthoid ulcer at hepatic flexure> > Caecum: lymphoid nodular hyperplasia with erythematous rim and pale > > swollen> > core.> > Histology, Ileum mild inflammation, colon > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/colon.html> moderate inflammation> > Acute and chronic inflammation.> > Treated CT3211 [a dietary treatment]> > INDETERMINATE COLITIS** ? CROHN'S DISEASE> >> > *Child 3. ? dysmorphism - chromosomes and normal development*> > MMR at 5 months [sic]> > Measles at 2.5 years* - 1 month later change in behavior> > Hyperactive with food> > Colonoscopy - granular rectum, normal colon and lymphoid nodular> > hyperplasia.> > Histopathology: lymphoid nodular hyperplasia.> > Increased eosinophils 5/5 mild increase in inflammatory cells (Dhillon)> > Routine normal> > LYMPHOID NODULAR HYPERPLASIA> > INDETERMINATE COLITIS**> > [* correction: he received measles > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/measles.html> vaccine first at > > approximately 15 months of> > age and MMR at 2.5. years]> >> > *Child 4 (2). Reacted to triple vaccine > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/vaccine.html> 4 months - screaming and > > near cot death*> > (DPT)> > MMR at 15 months - behaviour changed after 1 week.> > "measles rash" week before> > Endoscopy - minor abnormalities of vascular pattern> > Histology - non-specific proctocolitis**> > Treated> > INDETERMINTE PROCTOCOLITIS> > LYMPHOID NODULAR HYPERPLASIA> >> > *Child 5 (3). MMR at 14 months.*> > Second day after, fever and rash, bangs head and behaviour abnormal> > thereafter.> > Endoscopy - Lymphoid nodular hyperplasia> > Histopathology: Marked increase in IEL's [intraepithelial lymphocytes] > > in ileum> > with chronic inflammatory cells in reactive follicles. Increase in > > inflammatory cells in colon and IELs increased.> > LYMPHOID NODULAR HYPERPLASIA> > INDETERMINATE COLITIS> >> > Child 6(7). MMR - 16 months - no obvious reaction> > 2 years behavioral change - 2.5 years> > Screaming attacks - / food <http://www.naturalnews.com/food.html> related> > Endoscopy - Lymphoid nodular hyperplasia terminal ileum> > Histology - Prominent lymphoid follicles> > Dhillon: moderate to marked increase in IEL's, increase in chronic > > inflammatory> > cells throughout the colon - superficial macrophages not quite granuloma> > INDTERMINATE COLITIS> > Child 78. MMR 14 months> > 16 months "growling voice"> > 18 months - behavioural changes - autism diagnosed at 3 years> > Barium [follow through X ray] 5 cm tight stricture [proximal] to > > insertion of> > terminal ileum> > Endoscopy- prominent lymphoid follicle in ileum> > Mild proctitis with granular mucosa> > Histology> > Ileum - reactive follicles> > Colon - bifid forms, increased IEL's> > Slight increase in inflammatory cells> > INDETERMINATE COLITIS> > ? CROHN'S DISEASE> >> > NOTES:> > (1) Inflammation that is not diagnostic of either Crohn's disease > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/Crohns_disease.html> or ulcerative colitis> > (2) Child 6 in The Lancet paper. The chronological order was corrected > > for the final Lancet paper.> > (3) Child 3 in The Lancet paper> >> >> > BMJ caught in its own fraud> >> > These documents reveal that the British Medical Journal has been > > caught in its own fraud for willfully ignoring this evidence, which > > was presented to it long before its recent publication of Deer's > > article <http://www.naturalnews.com/article.html> calling Dr Wakefield > > a fraud.> >> > The BMJ willfully ignored this evidence and simply decided to destroy > > Dr Wakefield's professional reputation by any means necessary. As Dr > > Wakefield explains:> >> > /"In allowing itself to become the vehicle for Deer's particular > > brand of journalism; in circumventing the process of due diligence in > > its enthusiasm to "kill the beast", the BMJ has taken a huge risk > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/risk.html>. As the document presented > > above shows, this was a mistake. Medicine, presented with the > > possibility of an iatrogenic catastrophe, has boarded a dissonant > > bandwagon and has gone after those who have concerns - genuine > > concerns - that childhood vaccines > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/vaccines.html> may be responsible, at > > least in part, for the autism epidemic. The relevant science > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/science.html> has been grossly > > misrepresented, crushed beneath the wheels of a Public Relations > > 16-wheeler that is out of control. In the meantime a relentless > > tsunami of damaged children claims this land."/> >> >> > Deer caught as a liar> >> > It has also been revealed that journalist Deer, the author of > > the BMJ article condemning Dr Wakefield as a fraud, is himself a liar. > > In attempting to gather evidence for his article in the BMJ, he lied > > about his identity and entered the home of one of the parents of the > > autism children. Specifically, he claimed he was *working for The > > Sunday Times* even though he was never a Sunday Times employee.> >> > This is just the tip of the iceberg of the outright deception that has > > been used by the BMJ and Deer in their attempt to silence a > > doctor <http://www.naturalnews.com/doctor.html> whose only "crime" was > > publicly expressing concern about the safety > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/safety.html> of MMR vaccines.> >> > That the BMJ and its writer Deer have now been caught ignoring > > evidence and engaging in their own fraud gives credence to the idea > > that MMR vaccines may, indeed, not only be dangerous; but that *they > > may be so dangerous that the top medical journals > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/medical_journals.html> have to lie about > > the facts in order to protect them*.> >> > What's clear here is that the BMJ has strayed so far from the realm of > > evidence-based scientific thinking that it can no longer be called a > > reputable medical journal at all. Its *callous disregard* for the > > truth -- and its politically-motivated witch hunt against a researcher > > who only sought to protect the health > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/health.html> of children -- exposes it as > > *a danger <http://www.naturalnews.com/danger.html> to the scientific > > community and the world of conventional medicine > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/medicine.html>*.> >> > As this truth unfolds, *these revelations will rock the medical world > > and expose these science journals as the frauds they truly are*. Think > > about this: While these medical journals are taking money from vaccine > > manufacturers <http://www.naturalnews.com/vaccine_manufacturers.html> > > (who pay their ads), they are ignoring any scientific evidence they > > don't like in order to vilify anyone who threatens the profits of > > these very same vaccine companies! And yet, these medical journals > > never admit that their very existence depends on the financial flow of > > money <http://www.naturalnews.com/money.html> from these vaccine > > manufacturers who are strongly impacted by their editorial decisions!> >> > There is fraud taking place in the vaccine industry > > <http://www.naturalnews.com/industry.html> today, of course, and the > > medical journals are the point men who push their distorted > > disinformation into the minds of doctors, journalists and anyone they > > can reach with their scientific distortions. At stake is the future of > > the vaccine industry, which is of course a multi-billion-dollar > > industry that thrives on misinformation and the ongoing *scientific > > censorship of the facts* surrounding the health risks posed by vaccines.> >> >> > Read the book Callous Disregard> >> > Dr Wakefield is the author of /Callous Disregard/, the book > > that exposes the truth behind conventional medicine's political witch > > hunt.> >> > Learn more: > > http://www.naturalnews.com/031116_Dr__Wakefield_British_Medical_Journal.html#ixzz1CAN6JpSQ> >> > "The doctor of the future will give no medicine but will interest his > > patients in the care of the human frame, in diet and in the cause and > > prevention of disease." - Edison --- FAIR USE NOTICE: This > > transmittal may contain copyrighted material which is made available > > for educational purposes and to advance understanding of human rights, > > democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. > > The sender asserts that this transmittal constitutes a 'fair use' of > > any such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. > > section 107 of the US Copyright Law. This material is distributed > > without profit.> >> >> >> >>