Guest guest Posted November 28, 2000 Report Share Posted November 28, 2000 --- Kit Keyes <kit.keyes@...> wrote: > Who knows what your reaction might have been if you were measured at mid-30's when you started? That's it!!! I'm going to tell myself that the first reading was wrong, and it was really in the mid 30s, how does 34% sound? And so I can convince myself that I've lost 6.4%! That would be Start: 203#, 34%...133 lean, 70 fat End: 189# 27.6%...137 lean, 52 fat. A loss of 18# of fat and a gain of four pounds of muscle. That does not sound to unreasonable, and would go along with the change in size that I am experiencing. LOL...I will just convince myself that is the truth. Thanks for all your supportive posts; it helps a lot when things are not looking the way I want them to. Barbara __________________________________________________ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 28, 2000 Report Share Posted November 28, 2000 Yes Barbara, I really do hear what your saying. I remember when you posted those numbers and I did some math on it, because at the time it seemed as if you'd have to lose muscle to make any major change and it didn't make sense. We all agreed that the measurement was faulty. Please don't take this as a hit on you, but it is my educated guess that skin fold testing only works to a certain bodyfat percentage and then it exponentially decreases in validity. It's really hard, I know. You expect that person to be an expert in their field and that what they have to offer you is truthful. But, as we've been learning in this program, most trainers don't know it all. I think this is a good lesson in trusting YOURSELF. You can SEE and FEEL the changes yourself.....everyday! You feel muscles building, your clothes fit differently, your energy levels are higher and more stable, allowing you to do more with more enthusiasm, and you probably sleep better at night too...actually feeling rested. Now who are you gonna believe? The trainer? Or yourself? You know YOU better than anyone else in the world. I applaude your progress and your continuing transformation. I applaude you for sticking with this program. It's a tough one, but one that has lasting results. 96% of the people who accept the Challenge DON'T complete it. Consider yourself one of the few when you finish. =) Hang in there Champ! You're gonna do great! {{{hugs}}} - Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 29, 2000 Report Share Posted November 29, 2000 Barbara, How do your clothes fit? Take measurements with a tape measure. Throw out the bodyfat numbers! They are a very good way to see if you are losing fat but a quick, reliable method is not around. Calipers are dependent upon the skill of the person using them, the electronic bodyfat monitors are very unreliable and not many of us have access to BodPods or hydrostatic testing. I believe that's why BFL no longer requires bodyfat - people had bodyfat numbers that didn't even match the bodies they were in! And, yes, something as " little " as that can be VERY discouraging! You have worked so hard for one little number to slap you down! Sara Depressed >Way back, on Sept 2nd, I had a trainer at my club take >my BF calibration. At that time I posted the results >here, and some of you were sure there had been an >error. At the time I was 203#, 5'6 " , and the BF% came >out to 27.6%. > >Well, now I'm despratly trying to convince myself that >the first figure WAS an error. I went last night and >had the same trainer take my measurement. Guess >what...27.6%. I was so depressed. And the worst >thing was, when he told me the number and I said that >couldn't be right, he asked " Well, have you been >working at loosing? " . I told him everything I've been >doing. I told him that I KNOW I have changed my >muscles because I can see and feel the change every >day. Then I went into the locker room and cried. > >I know, logically that the first figure must have been >wrong. After all, that would have put my lean mass at >147#, and my fat at 56#. I'm 5'6 " , so 147# of lean >seems pretty high. So logically that measurement must >have been faulty. But still the feeling of " what the >heck have I been working so hard for " is nagging at >me. > >Funny how such a little thing can ruin a mood, huh? > >Barbara Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 19, 2001 Report Share Posted January 19, 2001 Yeah baby.....smile Z Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 21, 2003 Report Share Posted March 21, 2003 I'm sure the lighting and tanning makes for better looking pics. Some are trying to win $$$ and want to look there best. I on the other hand am going to be posting my 12 week pics in one more week just as white as I started. I'm not in it to win I'm in it for me & only me !! I plan to be tan for my Ch2 pics however. Don't let what you read diappoint you....BFL works !!! Sheryll > Hi all, > Okay, I was checking out Physique Transform which is suppose to be a > companion to BFL . For 3 days I logged my food and thought I'd be getting a > new way of eating etc. Well, it told me how much protein, carbs, and fat , > but not a new way of eating. For instance what kinds of foods etc. I guess > you would eat the way of BFL. Anyway, I thought it would give me more > direction , maybe I'm missing something. I feel like I'm still at square > one. > Then, I was checking on one of the sites and it was saying how alot of > people will just gloss themselves up and turn a certain way for shots and > look totally fit in 15 min. I was SO disappointed. I thought when I found > BFL, now I've got hope , but after reading this I'm thinking or should I say > wondering will this really work ? Will I see the results that I thought? > others had ? Or is it just the lighting , tanning , and such that has made > them look so good? > Disappointed, > Patti Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 21, 2003 Report Share Posted March 21, 2003 Ummm...I would have to argue...I don't think there is anyway to hide 30-50 extra pounds on anyone. Most the changes that inspire me are weight loss. Plus... I watched my sil and bil drop the pounds...that was enough for me...But sure a tan don't hurt! HOLLY depressed Hi all, Okay, I was checking out Physique Transform which is suppose to be a companion to BFL . For 3 days I logged my food and thought I'd be getting a new way of eating etc. Well, it told me how much protein, carbs, and fat , but not a new way of eating. For instance what kinds of foods etc. I guess you would eat the way of BFL. Anyway, I thought it would give me more direction , maybe I'm missing something. I feel like I'm still at square one. Then, I was checking on one of the sites and it was saying how alot of people will just gloss themselves up and turn a certain way for shots and look totally fit in 15 min. I was SO disappointed. I thought when I found BFL, now I've got hope , but after reading this I'm thinking or should I say wondering will this really work ? Will I see the results that I thought? others had ? Or is it just the lighting , tanning , and such that has made them look so good? Disappointed, Patti Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 21, 2003 Report Share Posted March 21, 2003 Hi Sheryll, Thanks for the input. It's good to hear that people are out there that are changing , that BFL does work. I was just so disappointed when I read that " some " were able to so quickly spruce themselves up. I guess there's polished apples in every bunch. Blessings, Patti > I'm sure the lighting and tanning makes > for better looking pics. Some are trying > to win $$$ and want to look there best. > I on the other hand am going to be posting > my 12 week pics in one more week just as > white as I started. I'm not in it to win > I'm in it for me & only me !! I plan to be > tan for my Ch2 pics however. Don't let what > you read diappoint you....BFL works !!! > > > Sheryll > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 21, 2003 Report Share Posted March 21, 2003 Do not read the anit-body for life stuff!! There's only one way to lose weight. Exercise and control your eating. Period. There is no magical food that will do it for you. Your grocery store is full of good stuff. Check out the food list on www.bodyforlife.com There's plenty of stuff there to eat. Eating should not be a problem here. You get any fruit you want, any veggie you want, any lean meat you want, vegan fake meat, whole wheat breads, whole wheat pasta, regular pasta in small amounts, canned, frozen, or fresh fruits and veggies. You can adapt the recipes you already use by cutting the fat off the meat and leaving out the butter or lard. Your tastebuds do have to adjust but it doesn't take long. You can do this. It might take longer than 12 weeks, but this program is not called the 12 weeks to a great body and then you can quite doing everything weight loss plan. It's body for life. Start adjusting and plan on doing this til you die! And if you do that, dieing will be a long time off. Hang in there girl. You can do it. debra > Hi all, > Okay, I was checking out Physique Transform which is suppose to be a > companion to BFL . For 3 days I logged my food and thought I'd be getting a > new way of eating etc. Well, it told me how much protein, carbs, and fat , > but not a new way of eating. For instance what kinds of foods etc. I guess > you would eat the way of BFL. Anyway, I thought it would give me more > direction , maybe I'm missing something. I feel like I'm still at square > one. > Then, I was checking on one of the sites and it was saying how alot of > people will just gloss themselves up and turn a certain way for shots and > look totally fit in 15 min. I was SO disappointed. I thought when I found > BFL, now I've got hope , but after reading this I'm thinking or should I say > wondering will this really work ? Will I see the results that I thought? > others had ? Or is it just the lighting , tanning , and such that has made > them look so good? > Disappointed, > Patti Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 21, 2003 Report Share Posted March 21, 2003 Hi Patti! I'm not completely sure what the Physique Transformation program you're talking about is supposed to do, but all you need to succeed on this program is what is in the BFL book. Don't get mired down in the little details. Just stick to the basics in the beginning and you'll see results. You have all the time in the world to explore tweaks in the future. Also, I know the thread you're talking about with the 15min before/after pics. That discussion really revolves around people who have been doing the program for a long time and the technicalities of competing and maintaining a low bodyfat over an extended period of time. There's no way to hide tons of extra weight in after pics, and there's no magic pill or powder to drop the pounds quickly. It's all hard work, dedication and sweat. You give that much to the program and you will see results. This program WORKS, there's many, many women here who have astounding before/after pics. Keep working hard! Maggie depressed Hi all, Okay, I was checking out Physique Transform which is suppose to be a companion to BFL . For 3 days I logged my food and thought I'd be getting a new way of eating etc. Well, it told me how much protein, carbs, and fat , but not a new way of eating. For instance what kinds of foods etc. I guess you would eat the way of BFL. Anyway, I thought it would give me more direction , maybe I'm missing something. I feel like I'm still at square one. Then, I was checking on one of the sites and it was saying how alot of people will just gloss themselves up and turn a certain way for shots and look totally fit in 15 min. I was SO disappointed. I thought when I found BFL, now I've got hope , but after reading this I'm thinking or should I say wondering will this really work ? Will I see the results that I thought? others had ? Or is it just the lighting , tanning , and such that has made them look so good? Disappointed, Patti Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2006 Report Share Posted April 11, 2006 , have you had your thyroid checked??? as this could be the the culprit!!!!! >From: " mkgould1 " <mgould@...> >Reply- > >Subject: Depressed >Date: Tue, 11 Apr 2006 02:46:09 -0000 > >Today was not a good day. I hardly ever post but need to today. I >just had to buy a size larger in clothing for summer. I had given all >my larger clothes away. > >I was reconciled to the fact that I wouldn't lose all the weight I >wanted to but I was hoping I wouldn't regain. I had my MGB in 2000 >and then a redo in 2002. After the first one I lost down from 270 to >about 195 and then regained to 225. After the second MGB I didn't >lose anything for four months and then finally lost down to settle at >about 182. I stayed this weight until about 3 months ago. All of a >sudden I am up to 194. I haven't changed the way or amount I eat or >anything else. The weight just jumped on. I feel like crying. > >I really don't understand why weight is coming back on when I haven't >changed anything I'm doing. As you all know the thought I regaining >the weight is the most frightening thing I can think of. After the >first MGB I could tell I could eat more after awhile. Now I still >can't eat that much and eat mostly healthy. > >I guess from the posts I need to try to get in more protein. What >kind of drinks do you recommend? I can't drink milk or eat eggs any >more. I can't eat that much meat and usually only chicken or fish. I >guess the best thing would be some kind of protein drink. Any ideas >would be much appreciated. > >Thanks. > Gould >MGB 9/00 & 5/02 Dr. R > >270/182/194 > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2006 Report Share Posted April 11, 2006 Hi Your post really touched my heart. Don't give up! I am only 6 MOS post op but I can totally relate to what you had to say. I would like to share with you some of the same things. I go through. First off I am not a 'fast loser I started at 299 in October and now weigh 6 MOS later 243 a 56 lbs loss . I didn't lose anything in month 4. So I started being diligent about exercise. ( which I loathe) I get on my treadmill everyday and in the last 10 days I ve lost 7 lbs. That has really helped with my feelings of failure. However before my mgb I couldn't lose no matter what I tried. So I am very grateful for the loss even if its slow compared to the averages. I use unjury protein mix. You can check out www.unjury.com its a whey protein mix with 20 grams of protein per scoop. I make a protein shake every day for breakfast. I add a cup of yogurt that adds another 8 grams of protein and I use fat free lactose free milk which adds another 8 grams of protein. For a total of 36 grams of protein. It may take me hours to get it all down but it really helps with my energy level.( when I get full I just but it away in the fridge to stay cold) Like you ...I can't drink milk or do eggs either and all beef doesn't sit will in my new tummy. Chicken is doable for a few bites but not enjoyable. But the milk in my protein shake doesn't bother me at all. The unjury can be mixed with water or juice also. The taste isn't chalky. I like to use the unflavored with yougurt and strawberries and sometimes even a banana added. For me a revision isn't an option. So I am trying my best to use the tool Dr Rutledge has given me and even though I had visions of the fat just falling off of me while I ate pizza... Reality is I have to work at my weight loss. People told me I wasn't eating enough and that's why I was losing slow that I made my body go into starvation mode. I tried eating more and I gained 2 lbs. So now I eat what I know is right for me. I've gone back to eating less. I have my protein drink for breakfast and eat some veggies for lunch or a pb sandwhich or sometimes skip lunch snack on celery mid afternoon and eat a little dinner. Bottom line I don't worry about how " little " I eat now and along with exercise the weight is coming off. You didn't mention if you're doing any exercise. Or how much you eat. It sounds like you may need to experiment a bit ( as I had to) and find out what will work for your own body. I am still learning what I can and can't eat. Stage 1 and 2 foods with some stage 3 is what works best for me. I had horrible eating habits ( obviously) pre mgb so now I am working on learning to enjoy a more healthy eating lifestyle. I make veggie soup a lot. And when the weather is warmer I'll be back into salads. Hang in there and come here often for support. I hope you'll let us know how things are going for you. I am confident you can lose those few lbs you gained and get back down to the size you have been. You have a family here that truly does care about you and wants to give you support and encouragement. Blessings Cheri Dr Rutledge Las Vegas 10/26/05 299/243/150 some day -- Depressed Today was not a good day. I hardly ever post but need to today. I just had to buy a size larger in clothing for summer. I had given all my larger clothes away. I was reconciled to the fact that I wouldn't lose all the weight I wanted to but I was hoping I wouldn't regain. I had my MGB in 2000 and then a redo in 2002. After the first one I lost down from 270 to about 195 and then regained to 225. After the second MGB I didn't lose anything for four months and then finally lost down to settle at about 182. I stayed this weight until about 3 months ago. All of a sudden I am up to 194. I haven't changed the way or amount I eat or anything else. The weight just jumped on. I feel like crying. I really don't understand why weight is coming back on when I haven't changed anything I'm doing. As you all know the thought I regaining the weight is the most frightening thing I can think of. After the first MGB I could tell I could eat more after awhile. Now I still can't eat that much and eat mostly healthy. I guess from the posts I need to try to get in more protein. What kind of drinks do you recommend? I can't drink milk or eat eggs any more. I can't eat that much meat and usually only chicken or fish. I guess the best thing would be some kind of protein drink. Any ideas would be much appreciated. Thanks. Gould MGB 9/00 & 5/02 Dr. R 270/182/194 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2006 Report Share Posted April 11, 2006 Thanks for your suggestions. I can't do a lot of walking because of a bad knee (will eventually have knee replacement). I have a stationary bike that my doc says to use. I'll try to use it in the morning first thing and see if that helps. I will try more protein, adding protein drinks especially. I never was a quick loser. After second MGB I didn't lose weight even while I was on liquids. Dr. R said my body evidently went into starvation mode. We discussed a third MGB for after 6 mo. but I finally started to lose after 4 mo. I'll try staying away from carbs as much as possible. I usually eat whole grain bread and brown rice, etc. I wish I could eat more meat or eggs and milk. Thanks for your ideas and support. Today was not a good day. I hardly ever post but need to today. I > just had to buy a size larger in clothing for summer. I had given all > my larger clothes away. > > I was reconciled to the fact that I wouldn't lose all the weight I > wanted to but I was hoping I wouldn't regain. I had my MGB in 2000 > and then a redo in 2002. After the first one I lost down from 270 to > about 195 and then regained to 225. After the second MGB I didn't > lose anything for four months and then finally lost down to settle at > about 182. I stayed this weight until about 3 months ago. All of a > sudden I am up to 194. I haven't changed the way or amount I eat or > anything else. The weight just jumped on. I feel like crying. > > I really don't understand why weight is coming back on when I haven't > changed anything I'm doing. As you all know the thought I regaining > the weight is the most frightening thing I can think of. After the > first MGB I could tell I could eat more after awhile. Now I still > can't eat that much and eat mostly healthy. > > I guess from the posts I need to try to get in more protein. What > kind of drinks do you recommend? I can't drink milk or eat eggs any > more. I can't eat that much meat and usually only chicken or fish. I > guess the best thing would be some kind of protein drink. Any ideas > would be much appreciated. > > Thanks. > Gould > MGB 9/00 & 5/02 Dr. R > > 270/182/194 > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2008 Report Share Posted April 10, 2008 Renny, Cliffs are for lemmings only sweetie. We need you to stay here with us please! In answer to your question... a big YES, depression most certainly is linked to your current state of health and there is a lot of data that will explain the chemical reason for this, let alone the misery of feeling ill all the time, very clearly. Dr Peatfield dedicates a whole chapter of his book, Your Thyroid, to it! If you haven't read this book ... please do. Either see if you can borrow it from the TPA loan service, your libary or (depending on your finances!) purchase it. Regardless of the fact that your forthcoming changes have been known in advance, there is a good chance that you are still aprehensive so again, not surprising you are down. You don't say if you are on any medication for depression (and I sincerely hope you are not on Prozac as this can exacerbate HypoT due to it's chemical composition) but there are natural, alternatives you could try, such as St 's Wort. I frequently use the Bach Flower Remedies to get me through various ups and downs and I do find they help. They also do not adverseley interact with anything else you may be taking. There are those that say they only have a placebo effect - but lets face it - who cares? If they lift you, that's all that matters, regardless of the method. If you would like to know about these, drop me an email. I have suffered with depression for YEARS and have had all sorts of treatment. But I now understand the whole thing much more clearly, and I'm in the same position as you, whereas I've just done a month of boosting my Adrenals on NAE and have just started (yesterday) taking Armour (half a 60mg tab). So, I am all excited at what the future holds, as this could be the BIG change, and hopefully you are feeling this too... so you have some positive things to look forward to. As you are obviously at rock bottom, can you think of anything you can do that will lift you ... a book, song, film that you know makes you smile? Can you chat to a friend, stroke a pet? When I'm really down, I force myself to think of what I could do that will give me a little lift (one that doesn't involve a lot of energy or money .... both in rather short supply at the mo!). I've learnt over the years that I can, with a big effort, pull myself around - but I truly know this realy depends on just how low you are, so please don't think I'm being patronising! I get so worried when people are as low as you sound - having been there, on that " Cliff Edge " myself. So please, try and find a way to make yourself smile or laugh (even if it's a little) it does help to " chemically " lift your mood. And if you need a good cry - LET IT ALL OUT! Too many people are too quick to say, there, there - don't cry. WRONG.... crying is good for your soul. It's the best way to let out deeply held fears, hurts, angers, hates ... and swallowing it down only allows these negative emotions to build up and work against you eventually. Ugh ... I've written an essay! Sorry! Hope there is something in the above that will help you. My very best wishes to you, xxx > > Hi, > Does anybody out there suffer with bouts of depression? I would be > interested to know if anyone else suffers with the same as, at times > like this I feel like jumping of a cliff! > Love Renny > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2008 Report Share Posted April 10, 2008 Hello Renny I am sorry to hear you are feeling so low - especially at a time when you are going to need all the energy and the 'right' state of mind to get you over your impending move. I think what is causing your 'depression' is that you are probably not getting the amount of T3 that your body requires to make it function. T3 is also needed to get through the brain barrier to make it function, and if not enough is getting through, you get brain fog, short term memory and generally unable to function as it should, and doctors don't recognise this and put it down to 'depression' and hand out the antidepressants. Hopefully, as soon as your Armour arrives and you start on that, this should help you enormously. I honestly think this is 'physical' rather than psychological. I hope your move goes well and that things start looking up for you from now on, as you have had enough problems lately to last you a lifetime. Luv - Sheila Hi,Does anybody out there suffer with bouts of depression? I am currently going through a terrible bout which started a couple of days ago, there doesn't seem to be any reason for it although I am going through a divorce and will be moving out of my house in the next three weeks. There, you might say, lies the problem but I have known about the move for a long time and it hadn't really affected me too much. It always seems to happen when I am coming down with something or trying to fight something off. There have been colds and the like around for a while and it feels like I am trying to fight one off, it's just that when this happens I always come down with severe depression. I started on Nutri Adrenal extra around 2 weeks ago and I am waiting for my Armour to arrive. Could it be one of the symptoms of Hypothyroid? I would be interested to know if anyone else suffers with the same as, at times like this I feel like jumping of a cliff!Love Re nny No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG. Version: 7.5.519 / Virus Database: 269.22.11/1368 - Release Date: 09/04/2008 16:20 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2008 Report Share Posted April 10, 2008 HiThanks for the replies. Yes I also believe the depression is 'physical' due to the way my body feels. I am going through an awful time at present but in the past I would have felt down but manage to pick myself up and get on with things. Since all this fatigue started following my first operation for Crohn's (1997) I have had regular bouts of uncontrolable depression and it always coincides with 'coming down with something' ie; a cold, it always comes about 3 days before the virus or whatever comes out so I do believe it is more physical than mental. To control it I have to get my blood sugar (I am type 1 diabetic) spot on and then I dont feel so bad. I am just hoping that the Thyroid treatment will help get rid of these debilitating symptoms and I can get on with my life.Once again, thanks for all your kind wordsLove RennyRenny Proudlove for Good helps you make a difference Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2008 Report Share Posted April 10, 2008 Renny, Oh yes....with bells on! Did you see my intensely depressing post yesterday? And it really doesn't help when patronising doctors suggest it's depression which is causing your symptoms. I'm still very new to this but my experience is that it's feeling so rotten makes me fed up and not the other way round, although I also guess that feeling poorly probably diminishes optimism because the tiredness etc makes it hard to feel bouncy. Anyway, yesterday I was losing the plot....today is another day and I've been a whole lot better. And with the help of this group there is light at the end of a very long tunnel. In the words of the song " ...the only way is up! " Pen x Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2008 Report Share Posted April 10, 2008 Depression? Oh I KNOW for a fact that is a hypo symptom, hold on there, you will still get lows but thyroid gives you ultra lows. lotsa luv Dawnx Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2008 Report Share Posted April 11, 2008 Hi renny, Depression is one of the symptoms of low thyroid and is especially helped by T3, so the Armour that you are waiting for should make a difference. Depressed Hi, Does anybody out there suffer with bouts of depression? …………I started on Nutri Adrenal extra around 2 weeks ago and I am waiting for my Armour to arrive. Could it be one of the symptoms of Hypothyroid? I would be interested to know if anyone else suffers with the same as, at times like this I feel like jumping of a cliff! Love Renny Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2008 Report Share Posted April 11, 2008 Further to 's comments, I also think a good Vitamin B complex tablet works wonders when feeling depressed. This has helped everyone I know who has been depressed, however it may not work for everyone. > > > > > > Hi, > > Does anybody out there suffer with bouts of depression? I would be > > interested to know if anyone else suffers with the same as, at times > > like this I feel like jumping of a cliff! > > Love Renny > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2008 Report Share Posted April 11, 2008 Dear Renny, Did I see someone had posted this source recently? <url>http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/299/14/1738</url> Do you know what your tested copper/zinc/selenium status is? If your zinc status is low do you take anything for it (supplement?) <url>http://www.dr- bob.org/babble/alter/20031122/msgs/283745.html</url> <url>http://www.dr- bob.org/babble/alter/20031218/msgs/291841.html</url> trace elements in pregenancy (Ethiopia) <url>http://springer.r.delivery.net/r/r?2.1.Ee.2Tp.1h7% 2a8l.BwOx5K..H.Ey6e.2ysm.BPcEce00</url> Post-natal depression may be due to zinc/copper imbalance(s) as well as to low thyroid status. With Crohn's disease, trace element deficiencies can be expected and that might also be true of IBS, Gluten intolerance, Candidiasis etc Any condtion where the tiny 'vili' along the gut are compromised (missing, deformed or short) will cause serious malabsorbtion of all nutrients. A competent doctor might be testing for serum zinc/copper/selenium/molybdenum to maintain your serum trace elements as part of a comprehensive management programme ( given your known condition and history ). Your local PCT has a PALS department where they could engage the immediate attention of your local practice in a positive and dis- enagaged manner...only needs a telephone call and they are discreet (make sure that they know you would like any contact to be anonymised with your local practice). Good luck on your journey. best wishes Bob > > Hi, > Does anybody out there suffer with bouts of depression? I am currently > going through a terrible bout which started a couple of days ago, there > doesn't seem to be any reason for it although I am going through a > divorce and will be moving out of my house in the next three weeks. > There, you might say, lies the problem but I have known about the move > for a long time and it hadn't really affected me too much. It always > seems to happen when I am coming down with something or trying to fight > something off. There have been colds and the like around for a while and > it feels like I am trying to fight one off, it's just that when this > happens I always come down with severe depression. I started on Nutri > Adrenal extra around 2 weeks ago and I am waiting for my Armour to > arrive. Could it be one of the symptoms of Hypothyroid? I would be > interested to know if anyone else suffers with the same as, at times > like this I feel like jumping of a cliff! > Love Renny > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2008 Report Share Posted April 11, 2008 Hi,Thanks again for the replies. You're right aboout the patronising Docs! I have been told so many times that depression is causing my symtoms when I know full well that it's the other way round, the problem is doctors dont like to be told anything because we are 'not qualified', but I know my body, I should do I've lived in it long enough!!!I hope you are feeliing wellLuv RennyRenny Proudlove for Good helps you make a difference Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2008 Report Share Posted April 11, 2008 HI Renny It isn't that doctors don't like to be told anything because we are "not qualified" - they don't like to be told anything because they don't know what we are talking about and have not been taught well at their medical school. They are GENERAL practitioners only. Most of us here know more about thyroid problems than GP's and that is what they don't like. Stick with what YOU know, not what they try to make you believe. luv - Sheila Hi,Thanks again for the replies. You're right aboout the patronising Docs! I have been told so many times that depression is causing my symtoms when I know full well that it's the other way round, the problem is doctors dont like to be told anything because we are 'not qualified', but I know my body, I should do I've lived in it long enough!!!I hope you are feeliing wellLuv Renny Renny Proudlove for Good helps you make a difference No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG. Version: 7.5.519 / Virus Database: 269.22.11/1371 - Release Date: 10/04/2008 12:23 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2008 Report Share Posted April 11, 2008 Hi Sheila That's right about the GP's. My GP certainly doesn't like it if I try to suggest anything like Thyroid problems or the like. The reason I am self medicating is quite simply that I have had enough of trying to get through to him, if I do try to tell him what I think may be wrong I am made to feel like an insolent schoolboy. I have always maintained that people know their own bodies better than any doctor and I personally have always 'felt' something was not right. I am NOT clinically depressed, I just get depressed when my body is trying to fight something and that is a physical thing but will my GP listen? No way, he knows best and will give me a wheelbarrow full of anti depressants that I don't need so to be quite honest I am better off self medicating, at least with Armour I will soon know if they are doing me any harm because I have read all the info in the 'Files' section of the group and know what to look for. Prozac, Seroxat, Effexor, Mirtazapine, you name it he has tried to push them on me, sometimes I think they are nothing more than legalised drug dealers!!!Renny Proudlove for Good helps you make a difference Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2008 Report Share Posted April 11, 2008 H Renny You should take a copy of the following - take it to your GP as a reminder of his duties. WHY do we let our doctors get away with what they are doiong and how they are treating us when they are supposed to be following the GMC "Duties of a doctor..." Good Medical Practice (2006) The duties of a doctor registered with the General Medical Council Patients must be able to trust doctors with their lives and health. To justify that trust you must show respect for human life and you must: Make the care of your patient your first concern Protect and promote the health of patients and the public Provide a good standard of practice and care Keep your professional knowledge and skills up to date Recognise and work within the limits of your competence Work with colleagues in the ways that best serve patients' interests Treat patients as individuals and respect their dignity Treat patients politely and considerately Respect patients' right to confidentiality Work in partnership with patients Listen to patients and respond to their concerns and preferences Give patients the information they want or need in a way they can understand Respect patients' right to reach decisions with you about their treatment and care Support patients in caring for themselves to improve and maintain their health Be honest and open and act with integrity Act without delay if you have good reason to believe that you or a colleague may be putting patients at risk Never discriminate unfairly against patients or colleagues Never abuse your patients' trust in you or the public's trust in the profession. You are personally accountable for your professional practice and must always be prepared to justify your decisions and actions. Re: Depressed Hi Sheila That's right about the GP's. My GP certainly doesn't like it if I try to suggest anything like Thyroid problems or the like. The reason I am self medicating is quite simply that I have had enough of trying to get through to him, if I do try to tell him what I think may be wrong I am made to feel like an insolent schoolboy. I have always maintained that people know their own bodies better than any doctor and I personally have always 'felt' something was not right. I am NOT clinically depressed, I just get depressed when my body is trying to fight something and that is a physical thing but will my GP listen? No way, he knows best and will give me a wheelbarrow full of anti depressants that I don't need so to be quite honest I am better off self medicating, at least with Armour I will soon know if they are doing me any harm because I have read all the info in the 'Files' section of the group and know what to look for. Prozac, Seroxat, Effexor, Mirtazapine, y ou name it he has tried to push them on me, sometimes I think they are nothing more than legalised drug dealers!!! Renny Proudlove for Good helps you make a difference No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG. Version: 7.5.519 / Virus Database: 269.22.11/1371 - Release Date: 10/04/2008 12:23 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2008 Report Share Posted April 11, 2008 Hi Renny, This PhD thesis (in German) contains the information you need, but see the references to point you to the relevant papers. http://edoc.ub.uni-muenchen.de/5122/1/Alajbegovic_Lejla.pdf I can't do technical German but you may be able to get a rough idea from one of the autotranslators (eg BabelFish). ask if you need more resources. best wishes Bob > > Hi, > Does anybody out there suffer with bouts of depression? I am currently > going through a terrible bout which started a couple of days ago, there > doesn't seem to be any reason for it although I am going through a > divorce and will be moving out of my house in the next three weeks. > There, you might say, lies the problem but I have known about the move > for a long time and it hadn't really affected me too much. It always > seems to happen when I am coming down with something or trying to fight > something off. There have been colds and the like around for a while and > it feels like I am trying to fight one off, it's just that when this > happens I always come down with severe depression. I started on Nutri > Adrenal extra around 2 weeks ago and I am waiting for my Armour to > arrive. Could it be one of the symptoms of Hypothyroid? I would be > interested to know if anyone else suffers with the same as, at times > like this I feel like jumping of a cliff! > Love Renny > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.