Symptoms of atypical gallstone

[Guest guest]

Couple of years back routine ultrasound (not related to liver or bilary

problems) detected two gallstones in gallbladder. It also indicated

some 'fatty liver'. A scan about a year later detected one stone and

the fatty liver was not observed. I have been having GERD for about 8-

10 months. (I guess another stone may have passed out or the scan did

not pick it up!). I do not have any gallbladder attacks or significant

pain that I can relate to gall stones.

HIDA scan with CCK done last month showed gallbladder filling ok. One

GI wants me to take the gallbladder out as a remedy against GERD while

another GI wants me to try different Acid reflux medicines and says

taking the gallbladder out is not necessary. The acid reflux medicines

do not help. Endoscopic exam showed a little bit of hiatal hernia only -

nothing significant.

Anybody in similar situation or have some ideas?

Thanks