Book Review: Seth Mnookin The Panic Virus (LA Times)

[Guest guest]

Book review: 'The Panic Virus' by Seth Mnookin

The anti-vaccine movement is studied as are the health risks that its actions

present to the wider population.

By Panosian Dunavan Special to the Los Angeles Times February 13, 2011

Readers take note. If you're already convinced that vaccines cause autism, that

vaccine-preventable infectious diseases no longer threaten children's lives here

and abroad, and that certain modern, anti-vaccine gurus are motivated by nothing

but tender concern for your family's health, Seth Mnookin's " The Panic Virus " is

not the book for you.

If, on the other hand, you want to learn how a " perfect storm " of angst,

deception and reckless media fanfare led to years of backlash against childhood

vaccines, step right up. It's apt that " The Panic Virus " opens with the quote:

" A lie will go round the world while truth is pulling its boots on. " The person

who said this, 19th century preacher Haddon Spurgeon, did not hesitate

to rail against the " truthiness " of our age. Nor does Mnookin, a contributing

editor at Vanity Fair whose books include " Hard News, " about the New York Times

and its scandals.

Mnookin describes the case of Dr. Wakefield, the leading proponent of the

theory that measles-mumps-rubella vaccine triggers autism, who lost his medical

license in May 2010 after a British tribunal found his original research

" dishonest and irresponsible. " (Last month the British Medical Journal

characterized Wakefield's work as an " elaborate fraud " riddled with falsified

data and financial self-interest.)

Sadly, even if Wakefield ends up in court, the vast sums of money and energy

that he and his sympathizers diverted from legitimate studies of autism can

never be recovered. Nor can the lives and health of innocent youngsters who

suffered illnesses that simple jabs would have prevented—if their parents hadn't

been scared to allow them.

Mnookin's book begins, appropriately, with a long look at the history of

vaccine-making and -giving, warts and all. Yes, it took courage to develop and

receive early prototypes targeting smallpox and polio, among other plagues, and

injuries and tragedies occurred along the way. Vaccines have also improved over

time. But, despite what opponents of vaccines allege, an unholy alliance with

Big Pharma is not the reason why physicians recommend vaccines to patients and

family members and take them themselves.

The reason, as Mnookin shows, is because people need them. Despite measles'

decline over the last decade, for example, the world's most contagious

respiratory virus continues to circle the globe, often arriving in

underimmunized communities via jet-setting offspring of vaccine-averse families.

The long-hoped-for global eradication of polio now appears an elusive goal. Last

year, California's worst epidemic of whooping cough in 50 years claimed 10

babies' lives.

In developing countries, one learns in " The Panic Virus, " new vaccines are a

beacon of hope for millions of youngsters at risk of succumbing to meningitis,

pneumonia and diarrhea, while childhood immunizations against hepatitis B and

human papillomavirus are preventing future deaths from liver and cervical

cancer. In light of growing global antibiotic resistance, vaccines directed

against common bacterial killers as well as influenza (a frequent prelude to

bacterial pneumonia) could become a vital lifeline for us all.

The braiding of well-researched scientific information with riveting takes on

the people fueling recent vaccine wars is one of the book's chief strengths. The

latter group, as Mnookin details, includes a celebrity with a self-described

degree from " the University of Google, " ratings-hungry talk show hosts and

support group pundits holding forth in midnight chat rooms. Rounding out the

cast are entrepreneurial MDs happy to ride the anti-vaccine wave while enjoying

the " herd immunity " still protecting (for now, at least) the majority of their

under-vaccinated patients.

One of the most important aspects of " The Panic Virus, " however, isn't a person:

It is the brash, sometimes blind self-confidence of our modern age. As Mnookin

acutely observes: " The vernacular of 24-hour news channels and Internet search

engines is freeing us to take on tasks that we'd long assumed were limited to

those with specialized training. "

Of course, few parents eschew such medical expertise when ill-judged experiments

go awry and children fall ill.

Ironically, over 25 years of infectious diseases practice, I have seen a number

of young adults seeking vaccines that their parents once blocked. Someday,

perhaps one of them will pen an account of life inside the maelstrom of

anti-vaccine anger and fear. For now, however, " The Panic Virus " remains the

definitive text.

Dunavan is a professor of medicine, infectious diseases and global health at

UCLA.

http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/books/la-ca-seth-mnookin-20110213,0,52\

10801.story