Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Study: pesticides and brain ailments

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Study connects banned pesticides to brain ailments

Farmers who say they used the

now-banned chemicals reported

more health problems.

By TONY LEYS

REGISTER STAFF WRITER

May 15, 2005

Evidence is mounting that farm chemicals designed to kill insects can

damage people's brains.

A new study of 19,000 Iowa and North Carolina farmers suggests that

those who routinely used certain types of insecticides on their crops

can be left with lasting problems.

Compared with other farmers, the heavy users of insecticide were more

than twice as likely to say they had suffered dizziness, numb feet,

trembling hands or twitching arms and legs. They also were more than

twice as likely to report blurred or double vision, poor night vision,

depression, absent-mindedness or difficulty speaking.

The study's lead author, Dr. Freya Kamel, said she believes her research

is the broadest look ever into the long-term effects of insecticides on

farmers.

" We've always known they were harmful to the brain, " she said. " The

question is whether they're only harmful if you have a very high level

of exposure. What this study does is expand the level of concern to more

moderate levels of exposure. "

It also feeds suspicion that insecticides can contribute to Parkinson's

disease, which destroys brain cells and causes tremors and other serious

problems.

The government banned several of the chemicals amid safety concerns

raised in the 1970s. But many of the farmers with neurological problems

told researchers that they had used those products before they were

taken off the market.

Kamel works for the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences,

a federal agency based in North Carolina. Her new article focused on

participants in the Agricultural Health Study, a 12-year-old project

designed to uncover the risks of farm-chemical use. Iowans make up about

two-thirds of the farmers Kamel's team looked at.

Nearly 3,000 participants said in questionnaires that they had used

insecticides more than 500 days in their lifetime, the researchers said.

Nearly 800 of them reported suffering more than 10 neurological

symptoms.

The study, which is being published next month in Environmental Health

Perspectives, found no strong association between neurological problems

and use of weed killers or anti-fungus chemicals. It also didn't

directly address the suspicion that insecticides can help cause

Parkinson's disease. Kamel's team is following the participants who

reported tremors to see if they develop Parkinson's. She also is

involved in another study that is looking into whether other Parkinson's

patients were exposed to insecticides.

A scientist who works for a national farm-chemical industry group said

those studies will be crucial. Dr. Angelina Duggan, who represents

CropLife America, cautioned against reading too much into the current

article from Kamel's team.

The Ag Health Study has made some associations that they intend to

follow up on, " she said. " What they propose is a theory. That theory is

as yet unproven. "

Duggan stressed that the new findings are based on voluntary

questionnaires that asked about broadly defined symptoms. They are not

based on physicians' diagnoses of actual diseases.

She also noted that some of the chemicals in question have been banned

for decades. Their replacements are much safer, she said, and the

products carry strict warnings on how farmers should safely use them.

Duggan said that, overall, the Agricultural Health Study has indicated

that farmers live longer than non-farmers. She said chemical

manufacturers support research into the long-term effects of pesticides

on farmers.

It's really an important issue for our industry, " she said. " These are

our customers, and we want them to use our products safely. "

A Des Moines neurologist also said she looked forward to the results of

Kamel's follow-up studies. Dr. Lynn Struck, who treats many Parkinson's

patients, said she shares suspicions that pesticides can be a cause. But

she said Kamel's current study doesn't prove a link.

Struck said she's sure the farmers in the study did their best to answer

the questions honestly. She wonders, however, if the ones who routinely

used chemicals are more likely to remember that they had suffered a bad

headache or other passing symptom. Most farmers have heard about the

possible dangers of farm chemicals, she said, and the ones who used the

most tend to worry about their health. " A lot of these guys are

extremely tuned into this, " she said. " They're always asking, 'Could

this have hurt me?' "

Struck also said it's difficult for farmers to remember exactly what

poisons they used decades ago.

Kamel acknowledged the concerns about the accuracy of the participants'

reports of their health and their chemical use. But she contended that

the large number of participants should ease those problems. She also

noted that the pattern of symptoms was strong only among farmers who

used insecticides, not among those who mainly used herbicides. That

seems to negate the theory that farmers are biased against chemicals in

general, she said.

The studies and the debate will go on for years. But Struck said the

main lesson is already clear: Pesticides are strong chemicals, and no

one should take them lightly. " You have to use extreme care, " she said.

Copyright © 2004, The Des Moines Register.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...