Italian court: MMR vaccine cause autism. Read the Daily Mail article

[Guest guest]

Italian Court: MMR Vaccine Causes

Autism

http://capwiz.com/a-champ/issues/alert/?alertid=61471836

More Info

Italy's Hannah Poling, how many more?

An Italian court ruled that the Measles/Mumps/Rubella (MMR) vaccine

caused autism when given to Valentino Bocca at 15-months of age. The

Italian court reached the same conclusion about the MMR as the US Vaccine

Injury Compensation Program in the case of Hannah Poling, and dozens of

other cases identified in the study Unanswered Questions: A Review of

Compensated Cases of Vaccine Induced Brain Injury. (See the study at

http://www.ebcala.org/unanswered-questions)

Don’t expect to see anything about this in the corporate media in the US.

Below is an article on the decision from the UK’s Daily Mail. Just goes

to show that the official position is, " Vaccine’s never cause

autism--except when they do.”

MMR: A mother's victory. The vast majority of doctors say there is no

link between the triple jab and autism, but could an Italian court case

reignite this controversial debate?

Landmark ruling in an Italian court has said Valentino Bocca's autism

was provoked by the MMR jab he had at aged nine months

His parents have already been awarded £140,000 and could be paid an

additional £800,000 in their case against the Italian government

The case could set a precedent for many similar civil proceedings

By

Sue Reid

PUBLISHED: 17:03 EST, 15 June 2012 | UPDATED: 03:57 EST, 16

June 2012

At nine months old, Valentino Bocca was as bright as a button. In a

favourite family photo, taken by his father, the baby boy wriggles in his

mother’s arms and laughs for the camera.

His parents look at the precious picture often these days. It is a

reminder of their only son before they took him on a sunny morning to the

local public health clinic for a routine childhood vaccination.

Valentino was never the same child after the jab in his arm. He developed

autism and, in a landmark judgment, a judge has ruled that his

devastating disability was provoked by the inoculation against measles,

mumps and rubella (MMR).

The judgment in a provincial Italian court challenges the settled view of

the majority of the medical profession ­ and could have profound

implications in Britain and across the world.

Valentino’s parents, Antonella, 44, and Maurizio, 43, have been awarded

£140,000, to be paid by Italy’s Ministry of Health and they plan a civil

action against the Italian government that may get them £800,000

more.

‘But, of course, the money will never bring back the perfect and

beautiful child of 15 months that we had before the doctors gave him the

inoculation,’ said his mother this week at the family’s small but

beautifully designed flat near Rimini in northern Italy.

‘We have a different Valentino today. We love him just as much, but our

lives will never be the same again.

‘He is nine, but cannot speak, and only sings a little to himself. He

cannot hold a pencil. He has a special teacher at school to help him and

finds it difficult to mix with other children. What the future holds for

him, or for us, we do not know.’

The story of Valentino Bocca is a tragic one. His family have

agreed to reveal their identity for the first time as the outcome of

their case became public last week. They spoke exclusively to the Mail

because they believe other parents all over the world should learn what

has happened to their son.

Autism covers a huge range of developmental disorders which affect a

child’s communication, social skills, and ability to lead a normal

life.

Families caring for severely autistic children say their lives are

blighted. Care of sufferers and related disorders costs the British state

billions of pounds a year.

The number of autism cases has soared over the past four decades ­ at the

last count researchers found one in 64 British children have some kind of

autistic condition ­ and there has been widespread speculation over the

cause of this widespread curse on so many families. In the Eighties, only

four in every 10,000 children showed any signs of autism.

Suspicion has long been directed by some parents at the MMR vaccine, a

triple cocktail of the measles, mumps and rubella viruses, although the

Department of Health and NHS doctors have argued forcefully that better

diagnosis of autism and environmental factors are responsible for the

extraordinary rise in the number of cases.

In 1998, a highly controversial article in the medical journal The

Lancet written by Dr Wakefield made a connection between the

MMR jab and autism.

His research methods were later discredited, but as a result of the

article countless numbers of parents in Britain refused to let their

children have the jab, and cases of measles ­ which is very occasionally

fatal ­ went up significantly.

In recent years, public confidence in the MMR inoculation has returned,

but the Italian court’s judgment could reopen the controversy. This week,

Luca Ventaloro, the Bocca family’s lawyer who specialises in helping

families with vaccine-damaged children, proclaimed that the Rimini court

judgment was the ‘first public admission’ that the MMR vaccine could, in

some cases, lead to a healthy child developing autism.

Crucially, it came after Barboni, a doctor of forensic medicine

and appointed by the judge to independently advise the court, wrote a

report saying that ‘in the absence of any other pre-existing

conditions’ it is a ‘reasonable scientific probability’ that Valentino’s

autism can be ‘traced back to the administration of the MMR vaccine . . .

by the health authority’.

Dr Barboni’s findings were endorsed by two other eminent doctors who

examined Valentino, investigated his medical background, and gave

evidence to the court hearing.

Judge Lucio Ardigo, awarding compensation to the family, agreed. He said

it was ‘conclusively established’ that Valentino had suffered from an

‘autistic disorder associated with medium cognitive delay’ and his

illness, as Dr Barboni stated, was linked to receiving the jab.

Lawyer Mr Ventaloro explained yesterday: ‘This is very significant for

Britain which uses, and has used, an MMR vaccine with the same components

as the one given to Valentino.

‘It is wrong for governments and their health authorities to exert strong

pressure on parents to take children for the MMR jab while ignoring that

this vaccine can cause autism and linked conditions.’

Claudio Simion, a leading member of the lobby group Association for

Freedom of Choice in Vaccination (Comilva), adds: ‘The Rimini judgment is

vitally important for children everywhere. The numbers with autism are

growing. It is a terrible thing that the authorities turn a blind eye to

the connection between the MMR vaccination and this illness.’

No doubt the Bocca family would agree. They turned to Comilva for advice

on compensation after they were finally told that their son had autism

when he was five years old.

They had travelled to a world-renowned children’s clinic in Milan,

bewildered as to why their son screamed all night, refused to eat

anything but bread, could not keep still or concentrate and refused to

look them in the eye.

After 14 days of tests into his genetic background to rule out a family

connection for his illness, a neurologist explained the

diagnosis.

‘We were handed a big file with Valentino’s name on it and stamped with

the word ‘autism’,’ remembers his mother Antonella. ‘Up to then, we had

suspicions he had autism. But the nurses, the doctors, and the

specialists we had seen before said we were dreaming up fairy

tales.’

Father Maurizio adds: ‘When we mentioned our suspicions about the

MMR jab and how Valentino had been an ordinary happy little boy until he

had it, these medical people looked at us as if we were crazy,’

As they talk in the park near their home, with Valentino tightly holding

each of their hands, Antonella and Maurizio reveal how their nightmare

began.

The couple had been married for a year before Valentino was born in 2003.

His birth was normal and they were thrilled to take their healthy baby

home.

Antonella, who worked part-time in a textile factory, and Maurizio, a

civil engineer, went together with Valentino for all his routine

vaccination appointments.

It was on the last Friday of March, 2004, that the boy was given the MMR

jab. The dark-haired toddler was already saying ‘Mama’ and ‘Dada’,

walking a few steps and enchanting his two grandmothers because he would

not stop chattering. His parents had delayed for a month the triple MMR

jab (normally given at 13 months) because Valentino had a bout of

gastro-enteritis. Antonella told the doctor about the illness and asked

if it was safe for Valentino to have the jab. The doctor said there was

‘no problem’.

‘He cried when they gave him the injection,’ remembers Maurizio. ‘We were

asked to wait half an hour afterwards at the clinic to make sure he was

all right. When the doctors said he was OK, we just went home.’

They drove away ­ not knowing their lives had changed for ever. By the

evening their normally hungry son was refusing to eat very much. That

night he had diarrhoea and was restless. But neither of his parents

attributed this to the jab.

Maurizio continues: ‘A few days after that, Valentino stopped using his

spoon to eat. We started having to put food into his mouth. It was as

though he was a baby again.

‘It was as if we’d gone to the vaccination clinic with one child and had

been given another to take home. Valentino was not interested in what was

happening around him any more. He could not concentrate on a single

thing.’

But worse was to follow. The little boy stopped sleeping at night. He

would wake up and scream in pain. During the day he ran around in circles

without stopping. His parents were getting exhausted and were at their

wits’ end.

Maurizio explains: ‘About two weeks after the jab he began screaming

every night. He woke up three or four times each night and cried. It was

like something out of The Exorcist. He was obviously in pain and we could

do nothing to comfort him.’

They went back to the vaccination clinic for advice. ‘We were not being

over fussy but the medical staff did not seem to grasp the gravity of the

situation,’ added Antonella.

The clinic just gave them some cream to put on Valentino’s skin. After

six months of no improvement in his condition, they took Valentino to the

casualty department of the local hospital.

For the first time Antonella mentioned that the MMR vaccine might be to

blame. ‘They said it was not possible,’ she says. Bewildered, the couple

still looked for answers. Valentino was still screaming at night and like

a wild child during the day.

When he was nearly two-and-a-half (14 months after the jab), they went to

see an expert in neuropsychiatry and told her that their son had changed

after the jab.

Antonella says: ‘She did not even write down what I was saying. She

downplayed the situation, although she said he was not developing

normally for a child of his age. But she could not offer any explanation

and said it might be temporary in such a young boy.’

Desperately, they started to do some research on the internet. It

suddenly occurred to them, after reading of other parents’ experiences,

that Valentino might have autism.

When this was confirmed by the Milan children’s clinic, he was put on a

milk-free and gluten-free diet.

‘Within a week, Valentino was sleeping at night and not shouting out in

pain,’ says Maurizio.

‘He started to look us in the eye for the first time since the jab. He

began to feed himself again. Progress was slow, but at last there was

some hope.’

But, sadly, it was too late to find a complete cure for Valentino. At

nine years old, he will never lead a normal life, and may need care for

the rest of his days.

However, the Rimini court judgment has brought his parents some comfort

because, for the first time, it supports their long-held belief that the

MMR jab caused their son’s autism.

In the UK, this much-debated link has never been established in the

courts. In 2010, a boy called Fletcher received £90,000, for

severe brain damage provoked by the MMR jab, under the Government’s

Vaccine Damage Payment Scheme. But he did not have autism.

In the U.S., nearly 5,000 families blame the MMR jab for causing their

children’s autism ­ despite continuing protests from the medical and

scientific world that there is little evidence.

In 2008, a girl called Hannah Poling was awarded $1.5 million damages by

the U.S. government when a court ruled that receiving nine vaccines in

one day (including the MMR) had caused her autistic condition.

But the court said that Hannah had an underlying cell disorder,

mitochondria, which had been aggravated by the vaccinations and

manifested itself as autism.

The Italian judgment has important implications for Britain for a number

of reasons.

First, the jab given to Valentino ­ called MMR 11 ­ contains the same

active measles, mumps and rubella viruses in the same quantities as MMR

VaxPro, one of only two approved MMR vaccines in the UK which is used on

hundreds of thousands of children every year. (Prior to the introduction

of MMR VaxPro in 2006, MMR II had been used in the UK since

1988).

This match of ingredients is confirmed in the Department of Health Green

Book ­ a guide for doctors on inoculation against infectious disease ­

and by detailed data on MMR vaccines released by the European Medicines’

Agency.

Second, in the UK, like Italy, the MMR jab is not compulsory.

However, the judge in Valentino’s case said that because the Italian

government’s medical authorities so strongly recommend child vaccination

against measles, mumps and rubella, the state should take responsibility

for the devastating damage to Valentino.

The judge’s view has since been endorsed by Italy’s High Court of Law

(the equivalent of our Supreme Court) which ruled that the Italian

government must pay compensation to children damaged by any jabs given

under the Ministry of Health auspices ­ even if they are not compulsory

ones.

Today, Antonella and Maurizio believe this is only fair for families.

‘The medical authorities were really pushing us to take Valentino for his

childhood jabs,’ recalls Antonella.

‘We were sent endless appointment letters from the clinic. They started

arriving when he was three months old. There was huge pressure. The

letters made us, and other parents, feel obliged to have the MMR jab in

order protect our beloved child from a dreadful illness.’

Little did they know that, soon after that jab, their son would suddenly

develop a devastating condition from which he would never recover. The

consensus of medical opinion in Britain remains that autism symptoms

emerge suddenly and inexplicably around the age at which MMR is

administered ­ making it inevitable that some cases will arise just after

the jab.

Most doctors continue to argue that this is merely coincidence and that

no convincing mechanism to explain a link has been set out.

The Department of Health has insisted: ‘MMR remains the best protection

against measles, mumps and rubella. It is recognised by the World Health

Organisation as having an outstanding safety record and there is a wealth

of evidence showing children who receive the MMR vaccine are no more at

risk of autism than those who don’t.’

However, the Italian judgment clearly suggests this important debate is

far from over.

Sheri Nakken, former R.N., MA, Hahnemannian

Homeopath

Vaccination Information & Choice Network

Vaccines -

http://vaccinationdangers.wordpress.com/ Homeopathy

http://homeopathycures.wordpress.com

Vaccine Dangers, Childhood Disease Classes & Homeopathy

Online/email courses - next classes start June 1