Guest guest Posted October 15, 2005 Report Share Posted October 15, 2005 Hi All, Apples are rather low in goodies, but their peels have more. See the below pdf-available paper excerpts. Great Differences in Antioxidant Properties Exist between 56 Apple Cultivars and Vegetation Seasons Barbara ata, Marzenna Przeradzka, and Marzena Bikowska Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry in press Web Release Date: 15-Oct-2005; (Article) DOI: 10.1021/jf051503x Abstract: The contents of ascorbate, thiols, and phenolic compounds and antioxidative enzyme activity were measured in the apple peel of 56 genotypes after harvest in two vegetation seasons, 2003 and 2004. The main reason of great interest in these bioactive compounds is their well-established physiological role in all living systems. The biggest differences between tested genotypes were noted for ascorbate peroxidase and glutathione reductase (GR) activity, followed by total ascorbate, phenolics, and glutathione concentration; the least difference was observed in the case of catalase. A large cultivar variation was noted in the anthocyanins and flavonols contents. Distinguishing the cultivars with the lowest, highest, relatively stable or those in which antioxidant content greatly differed depending on growing seasons was attempted. The GR activity is proposed as an environmental stress marker of apple fruit. AA, L-ascorbic acid; DHAA, dehydroascorbic acid; GSH, reduced glutathione; GSSG, oxidized glutathione; CYS, L-cysteine; -GC, -glutamylcysteine; GR, glutathione reductase; APX, ascorbate peroxidase; CAT, catalase; SOD, superoxide dismutase; AOS, active oxygen species. The concentration and composition of phytochemicals in apples vary greatly between the apple peel and the apple flesh (6, 10-13). Depending on variety, the apple peel contained from 2 to 6 times more phenolic compounds and from 2 to 3 times more flavonoids (14). Table 2. Concentrations of Ascorbate, L-Cysteine, and Glutathione Depending on Cultivar and Harvest Year a ============== ascorbate (AA + DHAA) (nmol g -1 of fm) L-cysteine (nmol g -1 of fm) glutathione (GSH + GSSG) (nmol g -1 of fm) cultivar 2003 2004 2003 2004 2003 2004 ============== Alwa 1421.8a-c 1832.8a-c 7.60b-h 6.17b-h 85.9h-k 59.8d-l Arlet 2673.3a-i 4255.5i-o 7.47b-h 6.00b-h 53.5a-g 41.8a-f Auralia 2823.6b-i 2622.1a-h 7.53b-h 8.43d-j 50.6a-g 78.8k-m Britemac 1366.1a-c 1299.8a 6.23a-g 5.77b-h 55.2a-h 47.0a-h Cortland 1823.9a-g 2519.1a-g 9.07f-h 9.03g-j 73.4e-j 63.4e-m ’s Orange Pippin 4492.5j-l 2921.7a-j 8.47c-h 8.53e-j 87.2i-k 76.8i-m Egeria 1693.8a-f 2114.0a-e 6.90b-h 5.53b-h 46.0a-g 46.1a-h Elstar 4255.0i-l 2564.1a-g 7.57b-h 5.57b-h 48.3a-g 32.5a-c Fiesta 2905.4b-i 5537.0o 7.17b-h 9.10g-j 69.5c-j 65.4f-m Freedom 2795.8b-i 2734.3a-i 5.63a-g 5.67b-h 49.2a-g 41.5a-f Fuji 1401.4a-c 2045.6a-e 4.70a-d 5.13b-f 56.2a-i 58.4c-l Gala 1292.2a-c 2158.1a-e 6.53b-g 7.00b-j 53.2a-g 41.6a-f Gloster 1638.6a-e 2015.0a-e 5.13a-f 8.57e-j 43.7a-f 64.4f-m Golden Delicious 3302.1d-j 4377.7j-o 5.03a-f 8.30c-j 35.5a-c 55.3b-k Gorjaczkowski Seedling 1582.6a-e 2724.7a-i 4.90a-e 8.37d-j 104.8k 109.9n Granny 1850.9a-g 4092.7g-n 7.50b-h 9.23h-j 79.4g-j 84.7m Haralson 2250.6a-g 3545.1c-m 5.57a-f 4.93b-e 68.3c-j 63.4e-m Honeygold 3268.6d-j 2265.8a-f 4.87a-e 6.53b-j 47.7a-g 50.3a-h Jester 1839.2a-g 3344.1b-m 5.07a-f 5.83b-h 46.5a-g 49.5a-h Jonamac 2036.6a-g 1808.9ab 7.07b-h 6.57b-j 70.3d-j 59.8d-l King of the Pippins 3003.1c-i 2972.0a-k 6.70b-h 8.97f-j 37.2a-d 61.9e-m Liberty 1486.1a-c 2137.5a-e 8.00c-h 8.10b-j 55.2a-h 46.3a-h Ligol 3513.6g-k 3647.5e-m 7.83c-h 6.77b-j 65.8a-j 45.8a-h Ligolina 1984.5a-g 3187.5b-m 7.73c-h 6.30b-i 46.9a-g 42.3a-f McIntosh 926.6a 1666.3ab 4.43a-c 4.87b-e 42.6a-f 37.1a-d Melodie 3955.0h-l 5398.8no 10.40h 8.53e-j 76.3f-j 82.6lm Melrose 1132.4ab 3652.6e-m 5.13a-f 5.40b-h 54.3a-h 70.0g-m Monroe 2428.3a-h 2807.4a-j 7.30b-h 5.80b-h 68.7c-j 41.8a-f Mutsu 2438.0a-h 3879.6f-m 6.23a-g 6.80b-j 66.3b-j 54.5a-k Nova Easygro 1417.3a-c 2091.6a-e 3.60ab 7.20b-j 52.9a-g 77.0j-m Odra 2829.5b-i 3219.1b-m 5.20a-f 4.93b-e 42.0a-f 51.8a-i Pilot 4242.7i-l 4083.0g-n 8.70d-h 10.07j 72.3e-j 82.0lm Pinova 2427.8a-h 3192.8b-m 5.37a-f 6.63b-j 32.1a 42.5a-f Priam 1890.1a-g 2415.8a-f 8.90e-h 5.47b-h 61.5a-j 43.7a-f Prima 1861.2a-g 1927.6a-d 6.83b-h 5.10b-f 42.6a-f 35.1a-d Priscilla 2140.1a-g 2310.5a-f 9.53gh 8.43d-j 60.9a-j 58.7d-l Rajka 3455.8g-k 4184.3h-n 8.20c-h 5.93b-h 73.6e-j 61.8e-m Redgold 2009.8a-g 1990.1a-e 6.57b-g 4.90b-e 62.3a-j 54.2a-k na 1909.4a-g 2634.7a-h 6.20a-g 4.60b-d 46.9a-g 44.2a-g Rubin 5202.2l 3852.0f-m 6.27a-g 5.50b-h 46.9a-g 42.6a-f Rubinette 2921.2b-i 2907.0a-j 5.97a-g 8.83f-j 52.7a-g 81.9lm Ruby 1992.7a-g 2063.2a-e 5.07a-f 5.73b-h 89.5jk 58.1c-l Sÿ ampion 4769.4kl 4522.6k-o 7.10b-h 4.60b-d 63.0a-j 66.1f-m Sawa 2011.0a-g 2200.7a-e 7.10b-h 4.53b-d 46.3a-g 31.2ab Selena 2194.3a-g 2105.0a-e 6.10a-g 9.90ij 44.9a-f 70.1h-m S & #322;awa Pobieditieliam 1526.9a-d 2174.0a-e 5.33a-f 6.20b-h 41.3a-e 41.3a-f Spartan 1613.7a-e 1343.4a 4.97a-e 4.46bc 68.8c-j 44.3a-g Spencer 1567.6a-e 2541.6a-g 4.47a-c 4.93b-e 56.1a-i 41.9a-f Topaz 3402.9f-k 4596.9l-o 5.67a-g 5.33b-g 50.8a-g 64.9f-m U 1065 1595.9a-e 2130.2a-e 2.67a 4.27b 36.1a-d 52.9a-j U 1165 2917.7b-i 3598.0d-m 6.70b-h 4.37b 71.8e-j 63.7f-m U 633 1856.5a-g 2461.5a-g 4.47a-c 1.27a 33.9ab 29.3a Undine 3326.7e-j 3043.3b-l 5.07a-f 5.17b-f 37.5a-d 34.6a-d Vanda 2521.7a-h 3159.0b-m 7.50b-h 6.70b-j 55.0a-h 63.1e-m Wealthy 2920.0b-i 4683.2m-o 5.07a-f 5.67b-h 40.1a-e 42.5a-f Witos 1862.8a-g 1879.4a-c 5.03a-f 6.63b-j 50.8a-g 57.9c-l av 2428.0 2918.5 6.40 6.40 56.6 55.5 ===================== a Means followed by the same letters do not differ significantly. Bold type indicates the highest and lowest values Table 3. Concentrations of Some Subgroups of Phenolics Depending on Cultivar and Harvest Year a ===================== phenolics b (íg g -1 of fm) flavonols c (íg g -1 of fm) anthocyanins d (íg g -1 of fm) cultivar 2003 2004 2003 2004 2003 2004 ===================== Alwa 1581.5f-m 1049.4a-d 222.3ab 314.0a-c 256.3l-u 183.8b-i Arlet 1458.4c-m 1270.7b-g 667.4g-k 694.9b-g 195.0e-p 155.4a-h Auralia 1019.7a-i 672.1ab 348.0a-g 340.5a-d 92.9a-g nd e a Britemac 1549.7e-m 964.6a-d 350.1a-g 325.1a-c 100.4a-h 100.4a-h Cortland 1408.8b-m 878.7a-d 404.1a-h 296.5a-c 183.0e-p 229.8g-j ’s Orange Pippin 1512.8e-m 1120.0a-d 699.0h-k 599.1a-g 71.6a-e 144.7a-h Egeria 1265.1a-m 1317.8b-g 371.1a-g 698.4b-g 263.5m-u 144.4a-h Elstar 927.8a-e 1055.0a-d 262.3a-c 492.8a-f 114.5a-j 165.7a-i Fiesta 880.4a-d 826.0a-d 256.6a-c 398.1a-e 149.3b-m 150.0a-h Freedom 1207.1a-l 1949.1hi 462.4a-k 976.7g 129.0a-k 235.4g-j Fuji 1630.2h-m 1029.5ad 765.1k 398.7a-e 94.9a-g 148.8a-h Gala 875.0a-d 944.1a-d 177.2a 362.7a-d 37.5a-c 138.1a-h Gloster 1503.6e-m 1243.9a-f 513.1b-k 789.4d-g 340.9t-w 458.3k Golden Delicious 1130.9a-k 962.7a-d 293.0a-d 349.2a-d 41.5a-d nda Gorjaczkowski Seedling 1465.3c-m 1194.0a-f 628.9e-k 674.3a-g 248.6k-u 141.2a-h Granny 1697.1k-m 1843.5f-i 530.1b-k 1525.1h 36.4a-c 58.1a-e Haralson 1842.9m 2349.5i 614.5d-k 976.2g 168.3e-o 234.8g-j Honeygold 961.7a-f 1028.2a-d 289.0a-d 484.3a-f 9.9a nda Jester 983.9a-g 1242.9a-f 283.3a-d 629.5a-g 27.9ab 58.4a-e Jonamac 1132.8a-k 799.3a-d 487.2a-k 358.6a-d 379.9w 224.1e-j King of the Pippins 1666.6k-m 1910.0g-i 597.3d-k 727.5c-g 176.1e-p 56.6a-e Liberty 1662.9j-m 2286.6i 744.7jk 655.5a-g 516.7y 501.5k Ligol 812.9ab 997.5a-d 302.0a-d 524.6a-f 112.3a-j 168.3a-i Ligolina 1034.7a-i 707.2ac 287.9a-d 289.8a-c 106.0a-i 51.9a-d McIntosh 1489.9d-m 1073.9a-d 566.6c-k 630.5a-g 183.8e-p 136.4a-h Melodie 1622.2h-m 939.0a-d 575.6c-k 431.8a-f 345.2t-w 137.4a-h Melrose 1510.4e-m 1486.2c-h 510.8b-k 503.4a-f 281.2n-w 344.5j Monroe 1543.9e-m 962.8a-d 773.5k 553.0a-f 335.8s-w 272.8h-j Mutsu 1438.9c-m 774.0a-d 466.5a-k 215.6a 30.6ab nd a Nova Easygro 1524.4e-m 1050.3a-d 429.7a-i 359.3a-d 165.2d-n 63.0a-g Odra 1384.7a-m 1798.6e-i 508.4b-k 668.2a-g 357.1uw 560.2k Pilot 1024.2a-i 743.7a-d 255.8a-c 301.9a-c 77.0a-f 37.4a-c Pinova 1024.5a-i 761.1a-d 319.8a-e 379.8a-d 118.8a-j 37.6a-c Priam 1305.4a-m 957.6a-d 334.4a-f 343.9a-d 194.7e-p 186.0b-i Prima 1164.1a-l 1204.3a-f 444.6a-j 340.7a-d 232.4i-t 267.5h-j Priscilla 1755.1lm 798.4a-d 656.8f-k 325.8a-c 295.1p-w 113.9a-h Rajka 999.4a-h 710.9a-c 554.5c-k 391.9a-e 167.5e-o 169.0a-i Redgold 1508.6e-m 1094.6a-d 603.2d-k 516.5a-f 317.8r-w 310.8ij na 1151.8a-l 1314.7b-g 475.8a-k 606.9a-g 193.0e-p 197.5c-j Rubin 1026.7a-i 476.2a 355.7a-g 257.3ab 226.2h-s 111.1a-h Rubinette 1091.2a-k 984.9a-d 350.5a-g 562.6a-f 122.0a-j 56.1a-e Ruby 1688.9k-m 929.7a-d 379.6a-g 225.3a 160.7c-n 22.5ab Sÿ ampion 1001.6a-h 1149.6a-e 438.1a-j 404.9a-e 117.2a-j 114.8a-h Sawa 1446.1c-m 1354.2b-g 552.0b-k 529.6a-f 286.9o-w 272.0h-j Selena 1375.8a-m 1280.9b-g 594.3d-k 632.8a-g 212.2g-r 118.6a-h S & #322;awa Pobieditieliam 1611.3g-m 950.9a-d 399.2a-h 362.2a-d 139.5b-l 90.5a-g Spartan 1266.8a-m 1113.6a-d 506.4b-k 446.2a-f 236.0j-t 317.5ij Spencer 1381.9a-m 731.9a-c 522.8b-k 444.7a-f 149.0b-m nda Topaz 919.7a-e 1040.5a-d 301.0a-e 395.4a-e 108.9a-j 174.0b-i U 1065 1030.0a-i 832.6a-d 291.5a-d 354.6a-d 205.6f-r 228.1f-j U 1165 1020.7a-i 1384.5b-h 356.9a-g 396.7a-e 138.5b-l 272.6h-j U 633 1087.9a-k 1076.8a-d 311.8a-e 471.9a-f 316.7r-w 216.4d-j Undine 1645.7i-m 835.1a-d 724.8i-k 419.5a-f 133.4a-l 86.8a-g Vanda 777.8a 1287.2b-g 387.8a-h 826.7e-g 126.6a-k 147.6a-h Wealthy 1046.9a-j 1521.7d-h 374.6a-g 846.0fg 40.8a-d 141.0a-h Witos 851.5a-c 782.5a-d 285.1a-d 305.8a-c 86.1a-g 86.6a-g av 1284.1 1137.6 447.4 509.9 177.4 172.2 =================== a Means followed by the same letters do not differ significantly. Bold type indicates the highest and lowest values b Expressed as equivalent of gallic acid. c Expressed as equivalent of quercetin. d Expressed as equivalent of cyanidin-3,5-di-glucoside. e Not detected. Table 4. Antioxidative Enzyme Activity Depending on Cultivar and Harvest Year ================== GR (nkat g -1 of fm) APX (nkat g -1 of fm) CAT (nkat g -1 of fm) cultivar 2003 2004 2003 2004 2003 2004 ================== Alwa 2.49a-k 2.67ab 67.1a-g 152.1f-k 5.46a-g 7.97b-m Arlet 3.05a-n 8.42g-m 94.6a-g 148.4f-k 5.91a-h 8.81f-m Auralia 4.04i-o 9.62j-n 133.3c-h 113.9b-k 5.22a-g 6.37a-i Britemac 1.57a-e 4.48a-f 53.4a-e 124.8c-k 5.58a-g 5.76a-g Cortland 2.79a-l 6.91c-m 105.9a-g 74.6a-g 4.63a-e 8.50e-m ’s Orange Pippin 3.26b-n 6.51c-k 82.5a-g 87.8a-i 6.75a-j 7.62a-l Egeria 1.51a-e 5.96b-j 147.0f-h 137.5d-k 8.62ij 8.22d-m Elstar 3.57e-n 3.76a-d 86.4a-g 122.6c-k 4.10ab 6.50a-j Fiesta 2.19a-j 10.35k-n 44.5a-c 171.4i-k 4.96a-g 9.93k-m Freedom 3.96i-o 7.30d-m 81.1a-g 87.6a-i 5.41a-g 7.60a-l Fuji 2.35a-k 9.82k-n 128.0c-h 75.0a-g 7.65g-j 7.82a-l Gala 4.22j-p 4.05a-e 84.3a-g 26.9a 4.30a-c 5.13a-d Gloster 5.78p-t 9.01i-m 126.9c-h 75.9a-g 7.38e-j 7.64a-l Golden Delicious 5.91p-t 10.28k-n 156.5gh 143.7e-k 5.91a-h 5.45a-e Gorjaczkowski Seedling 2.80a-l 12.83no 100.9a-g 156.0f-k 5.79a-g 8.98f-m Granny 1.71a-g 10.73mn 53.1a-e 150.0f-k 5.30a-g 8.34d-m Haralson 2.88a-m 6.84c-l 90.0a-g 41.9ab 6.38a-j 9.06g-m Honeygold 2.00a-i 7.18d-m 137.5d-h 125.8c-k 5.80a-g 5.66a-f Jester 1.71a-g 4.45a-f 74.8a-g 116.3b-k 5.18a-g 7.79a-l Jonamac 6.01r-t 7.88f-m 149.9f-h 158.1g-k 6.59a-j 9.12h-m King of the Pippins 6.86s-u 8.08f-m 81.9a-g 65.2a-e 6.82b-j 8.96f-m Liberty 3.84g-o 9.02i-m 102.5a-g 99.8a-j 4.82a-f 7.74a-l Ligol 4.42k-r 8.77h-m 142.3e-h 149.9f-k 7.57f-j 11.05m Ligolina 1.30a-d 7.93f-m 93.9a-g 108.4b-j 6.79a-j 8.04b-m McIntosh 1.80a-h 3.42a-c 42.3a-c 104.8b-j 4.76a-e 6.16a-h Melodie 3.37d-n 12.56no 107.6a-g 107.4b-j 5.43a-g 11.13m Melrose 1.91a-i 10.33k-n 122.1b-h 158.3g-k 5.92a-h 8.75f-m Monroe 1.64a-f 4.75a-g 31.4ab 169.1i-k 4.38a-d 6.16a-h Mutsu 1.89a-i 10.53l-n 47.8a-d 58.3a-d 5.02a-g 5.20a-d Nova Easygro 1.07a 5.23a-h 145.9e-h 79.5a-h 6.42a-j 6.86a-l Odra 5.53o-s 5.11a-h 134.5c-h 54.7a-c 7.37e-j 7.86a-l Pilot 2.94a-n 6.88c-m 144.8e-h 109.4b-j 5.33a-g 6.99a-l Pinova 2.75a-l 7.00c-m 154.2f-h 162.2h-k 5.56a-g 7.80a-l Priam 1.45a-e 5.33a-i 138.7d-h 141.0e-k 6.56a-j 8.35d-m Prima 2.54a-k 3.61a-d 74.5a-g 113.6b-k 3.97a 4.9a-c Priscilla 3.48d-n 8.30g-m 74.7a-g 136.9d-k 4.50a-d 6.62a-k Rajka 6.19r-u 6.75c-l 32.2ab 116.5b-k 8.51h-j 6.75a-l Redgold 4.94n-r 10.15k-n 88.9a-g 139.2d-k 6.39a-j 9.77j-m na 3.76f-o 7.65e-m 119.4b-h 178.3jk 5.19a-g 9.08g-m Rubin 6.14r-u 5.63a-i 120.1b-h 136.7d-k 5.96a-h 7.51a-l Rubinette 7.77u 14.54o 85.3a-g 156.8g-k 7.04c-j 9.34h-m Ruby 1.60a-f 7.04c-m 106.6a-g 158.3g-k 3.99a 6.33a-i Sÿ ampion 7.34tu 9.88k-n 200.7h 143.3e-k 8.87j 10.01lm Sawa 3.09a-n 2.23a 124.7c-h 71.9a-f 5.73a-g 4.85a-c Selena 7.19s-u 6.04b-j 87.2a-g 154.2f-k 8.76ij 7.08a-l S & #322;awa Pobieditieliam 1.15a-c 2.76ab 155.5gh 98.7a-j 5.34a-g 4.64a Spartan 2.95a-n 3.73a-d 91.8a-g 103.9c-j 4.26a-c 5.34a-e Spencer 2.85a-l 9.02i-m 53.7a-e 145.7e-k 6.76a-j 7.04a-l Topaz 2.70a-k 10.16k-n 25.6a 105.2b-j 4.95a-g 8.79f-m U1065 1.66a-f 7.06c-m 93.8a-g 109.5b-j 6.26a-i 9.68i-m U1165 2.70a-k 9.97k-n 148.8f-h 77.4a-g 7.59f-j 4.81ab U633 3.32c-n 9.63j-n 63.3a-g 192.6k 4.71a-e 10.00lm Undine 4.81l-r 7.45e-m 61.2a-f 137.9d-k 7.18d-j 8.11c-m Vanda 4.90m-r 9.65j-n 85.2a-g 80.2a-h 6.51a-j 9.39h-m Wealthy 1.10ab 8.64h-m 128.6c-h 112.6b-k 6.27a-i 8.24d-m Witos 3.92h-o 5.97b-j 130.9c-h 129.0c-k 7.61f-j 8.76f-m av 3.40 7.50 100.0 118.9 6.00 7.69 ======================== a Means followed by the same letters do not differ significantly. Bold type indicates the highest and lowest values The distinct differences between apple cultivars in phytochemical content were found in relation to smaller (4, 6, 14) and greater numbers of cultivars (7-9). Also, this study shows the significant differences between examined genotypes of apple in antioxidant content. Mean contents of total ascorbate, glutathione, and phenolics represented 5.6-4.3-, 3.3-3.7-, and 2.4-4.9-fold variations, respectively, in their concentration depending on the year, whereas GR, APX, and CAT activities exhibited 7.3-6.5-, 7.8-7.2-, and 2.2-2.4-fold variations, respectively. Davey and Keulemans (8) testing 31 cultivars of apple noted 3.6- and 4.6-fold variations for total ascorbate and total glutathione, respectively. However, they analyzed a whole apple fruit. In the case of phenolics, 5.4-fold variation in total phenolics concentration was recorded (7). The years 2003 and 2004 considerably differed with regard to mean temperature and rainfall; therefore, it could also be noted which compounds and cultivars exhibited the highest intensity of responses to changing weather conditions. We tried to distinguish the cultivars with the lowest, highest, and relatively stable concentrations or those in which antioxidant concentrations greatly differed depending on the growing seasons. Irrespective of the year, high contents of ascorbate were obtained for Rajka, Topaz, Pilot, ampion, and Melodie; for glutathione, Gorjaczkowski Seedling, Granny , 's Orange Pippin, Melodie, and Pilot; and in the case of phenolics, Haralson, Liberty, King of the Pippins, and Granny . Simultaneously, among these cultivars the differences in the given compound content in a successive year were rather small, especially for glutathione and, in general, they did not exceed 30%. It was noted that it is difficult to find cultivars " rich " or " poor " in all of the tested phytochemicals and additionally in both years. Pilot and Melodie had the highest ascorbate and glutathione contents and McIntosh the lowest, irrespective of growing season. Granny was in the group of the highest contents of glutathione and phenolics. Compared to phenolics, there were more cultivars described as " stable " in relation to the concentration of ascorbate and glutathione despite tested year. It is interesting that, in the case of ascorbate, in this group there were rather cultivars with low or medium levels of this compound. As opposed to this, the " stable " cultivars with respect to glutathione concentration were predominantly those with the content of over the mean value or rather high. Al Pater, PhD; email: old542000@... __________________________________ Music Unlimited Access over 1 million songs. Try it free. http://music./unlimited/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.