Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 Wow Lottie, you really put it out there in plain English! I HAD healthcare until I was injured on the job, mind you, and once I went on short term disability that I paid for every 2 weeks out of my check, I lost my heath insurance because I was unable to pay for it through Cobra. It was more than I was getting on short term. My husband took insurance out on me through his job but it wouldn't cover me with the pre-existing problems I was having at the time. Then we separated for a little over a year so he dropped it on me. I don't blame him for that, I would have done the same thing if it was in reverse order. Now we are back together and his insurance won't cover me for CML because it is pre-existing. What are we supposed to do when we struggle just to make the bills we have to pay to survive. Who can afford health insurance today when you have to pay the whole thing. It's bad enough when your employer pays half of it but you have to do it totally on your own, it's just impossible. Then you get put in the hospital and have thousands of dollars in medical bills coming in that you can't pay and sometimes you wonder why in the world we are in this shape. It sickens me to know that I may not be able to get the care I need because I can't afford health insurance. I have had a job of some sort since I was15 years old and now that I am disabled, I can't work so therefore I can't get health insurance. What am I supposed to do...just sit here and wait for the good Lord to call me home? Sometimes I feel like that is my only choice. Everywhere I turn for help here in TN is a deadend road for me. I can't seem to find anyone willing to take me with no insurance and low income. All I can do is keep praying that God will open a door for me somewhere so I can get the care I need. Thanks for posting this, it helps to just get it off my chest for a change. Keeping on keeping on, From: Lottie Duthu <lotajam@...> Subject: [ ] Health care " CML " < > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM Dear Group, I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to buy junk food? I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to take care of them from the womb to the grave. When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for their insurance and upkeep? I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. That's my 2 cents. Blessings, Lottie Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 Hello, I live in Ca.Our state is in a hell of a mess.I have been disabled for about 10 years.I recieve Social Security.My social security benefits have been cut again for the 2nd time in two months.I recieve $840.00 per month to live on.My mortgage is $560.00 per month.I can not find housing any cheaper than this.The state just stopped providing Dental and Vision coverage.I pray nothing else goes wrong with me.I have many health issues. I can not work or work overtime to make more income as I am disabled.I am now forced to decide between eating or taking care of my health.What a wonderful choice.After paying the mortgage I have $280.00 left to pay for food,car insurance,medicine and utilities.I have no spouse for a second income or to help me.I am alone..I am so stressed.I am having daily headaches that are causing nausea.I am not sure if it is CML related or Gleevec related or just plain stress from my whole situation.I feel ill so much that I spend 5-6 days a week in bed non functioning.When I go food shopping I am entiely wipped out for 2-3 days.I need help with house cleaning and daily cooking.My 61 year old mother comes and takes care of me and my yardwork.Some days I wonder exactly what it is I am living for.To feel ill,bedridden daily and no funds to even feed myself anymore.Hell I read here how 80 year olds have a way more active/productive life than me at age 41.I'm just one more person all you tax paying individuals have to pay for..So sorry but I have no other choice. It makes me sick to watch the news.I hear how Obama spent 35,000 for take his wife on a date.That is more than 3 YEARS worth of income for me.I am faced with food or health care..What's wrong with this picture?I think it's wonderful if you have been blessed with a great job,family,life etc that allows for such things but others are not s blessed.I suppose I should be grateful to have a roof over my head as many don't even have that much.I may not for long if things keep getting cut.I see no hope,no future and really no reason to occupy space and expect my monthly handout each month. I hope others here are not faced with these type issues.May you all be of the blessed population. Thanks SharonS In , " Lottie Duthu " <lotajam@...> wrote: > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 I really think the private vs public insurance is not the core of the problem. As long as a 3h hospital stay with just an iv is charged ~$18,000, or a drug company can blackmail cancer patients into charging their pills ~$4000 to $8000 a month when they paid their investment 10 times over, I can't see the problem going away. I am all for free market but like the mad subprime scam this isn't free market in my book. Marcos. On Sun, Jun 14, 2009 at 7:20 PM, <wendyphillips54@...> wrote: > > > Wow Lottie, you really put it out there in plain English! I HAD healthcare > until I was injured on the job, mind you, and once I went on short term > disability that I paid for every 2 weeks out of my check, I lost my heath > insurance because I was unable to pay for it through Cobra. It was more than > I was getting on short term. My husband took insurance out on me through his > job but it wouldn't cover me with the pre-existing problems I was having at > the time. Then we separated for a little over a year so he dropped it on me. > I don't blame him for that, I would have done the same thing if it was in > reverse order. Now we are back together and his insurance won't cover me for > CML because it is pre-existing. What are we supposed to do when we struggle > just to make the bills we have to pay to survive. Who can afford health > insurance today when you have to pay the whole thing. It's bad enough when > your employer pays half of it but you have to do it totally on > your own, it's just impossible. Then you get put in the hospital and have > thousands of dollars in medical bills coming in that you can't pay and > sometimes you wonder why in the world we are in this shape. It sickens me to > know that I may not be able to get the care I need because I can't afford > health insurance. I have had a job of some sort since I was15 years old and > now that I am disabled, I can't work so therefore I can't get health > insurance. What am I supposed to do...just sit here and wait for the good > Lord to call me home? Sometimes I feel like that is my only choice. > Everywhere I turn for help here in TN is a deadend road for me. I can't seem > to find anyone willing to take me with no insurance and low income. All I > can do is keep praying that God will open a door for me somewhere so I can > get the care I need. Thanks for posting this, it helps to just get it off my > chest for a change. > > Keeping on keeping on, > > > > > From: Lottie Duthu <lotajam@...> > Subject: [ ] Health care > " CML " < > > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt > to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will > be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we > run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I > think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I > have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or > don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the > whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The > children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending > machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to > buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want > to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to > support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 It is an awful predicament to be in, Sharon, and I am outraged on your behalf. The state just keeps whack, whack, whacking away at those who can afford it the least. Something has got to change! From: serenitywon@... Date: Mon, 15 Jun 2009 03:06:02 +0000 Subject: [ ] Re: Health care Hello, I live in Ca.Our state is in a hell of a mess.I have been disabled for about 10 years.I recieve Social Security.My social security benefits have been cut again for the 2nd time in two months.I recieve $840.00 per month to live on.My mortgage is $560.00 per month.I can not find housing any cheaper than this.The state just stopped providing Dental and Vision coverage.I pray nothing else goes wrong with me.I have many health issues. I can not work or work overtime to make more income as I am disabled.I am now forced to decide between eating or taking care of my health.What a wonderful choice.After paying the mortgage I have $280.00 left to pay for food,car insurance,medicine and utilities.I have no spouse for a second income or to help me.I am alone..I am so stressed.I am having daily headaches that are causing nausea.I am not sure if it is CML related or Gleevec related or just plain stress from my whole situation.I feel ill so much that I spend 5-6 days a week in bed non functioning.When I go food shopping I am entiely wipped out for 2-3 days.I need help with house cleaning and daily cooking.My 61 year old mother comes and takes care of me and my yardwork.Some days I wonder exactly what it is I am living for.To feel ill,bedridden daily and no funds to even feed myself anymore.Hell I read here how 80 year olds have a way more active/productive life than me at age 41.I'm just one more person all you tax paying individuals have to pay for..So sorry but I have no other choice. It makes me sick to watch the news.I hear how Obama spent 35,000 for take his wife on a date.That is more than 3 YEARS worth of income for me.I am faced with food or health care..What's wrong with this picture?I think it's wonderful if you have been blessed with a great job,family,life etc that allows for such things but others are not s blessed.I suppose I should be grateful to have a roof over my head as many don't even have that much.I may not for long if things keep getting cut.I see no hope,no future and really no reason to occupy space and expect my monthly handout each month. I hope others here are not faced with these type issues.May you all be of the blessed population. Thanks SharonS In , " Lottie Duthu " <lotajam@...> wrote: > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 I'm with you, Marcos! From: montereyunderwater@... Date: Sun, 14 Jun 2009 20:06:05 -0700 Subject: Re: [ ] Health care I really think the private vs public insurance is not the core of the problem. As long as a 3h hospital stay with just an iv is charged ~$18,000, or a drug company can blackmail cancer patients into charging their pills ~$4000 to $8000 a month when they paid their investment 10 times over, I can't see the problem going away. I am all for free market but like the mad subprime scam this isn't free market in my book. Marcos. On Sun, Jun 14, 2009 at 7:20 PM, <wendyphillips54@...> wrote: > > > Wow Lottie, you really put it out there in plain English! I HAD healthcare > until I was injured on the job, mind you, and once I went on short term > disability that I paid for every 2 weeks out of my check, I lost my heath > insurance because I was unable to pay for it through Cobra. It was more than > I was getting on short term. My husband took insurance out on me through his > job but it wouldn't cover me with the pre-existing problems I was having at > the time. Then we separated for a little over a year so he dropped it on me. > I don't blame him for that, I would have done the same thing if it was in > reverse order. Now we are back together and his insurance won't cover me for > CML because it is pre-existing. What are we supposed to do when we struggle > just to make the bills we have to pay to survive. Who can afford health > insurance today when you have to pay the whole thing. It's bad enough when > your employer pays half of it but you have to do it totally on > your own, it's just impossible. Then you get put in the hospital and have > thousands of dollars in medical bills coming in that you can't pay and > sometimes you wonder why in the world we are in this shape. It sickens me to > know that I may not be able to get the care I need because I can't afford > health insurance. I have had a job of some sort since I was15 years old and > now that I am disabled, I can't work so therefore I can't get health > insurance. What am I supposed to do...just sit here and wait for the good > Lord to call me home? Sometimes I feel like that is my only choice. > Everywhere I turn for help here in TN is a deadend road for me. I can't seem > to find anyone willing to take me with no insurance and low income. All I > can do is keep praying that God will open a door for me somewhere so I can > get the care I need. Thanks for posting this, it helps to just get it off my > chest for a change. > > Keeping on keeping on, > > > > > From: Lottie Duthu <lotajam@...> > Subject: [ ] Health care > " CML " < > > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt > to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will > be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we > run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I > think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I > have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or > don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the > whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The > children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending > machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to > buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want > to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to > support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 I guess the free market ideal works right up until the point when you ask a sick person who doesn't have the means to pay for the overly inflated price of health care. Haven't we begun to treat health care like any other like any other commodity? We need to first ask ourselves if we are going to keep approaching healthcare like consumers and whether or not it is necessary for someone to profit from it before we begin to solve the problem of unaffordable healthcare and escalating costs. Personally I could do with out the acronym: HMO. > > > > From: Lottie Duthu <lotajam@...> > > Subject: [ ] Health care > > " CML " < > > > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM > > > > Dear Group, > > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt > > to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will > > be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we > > run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I > > think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I > > have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or > > don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the > > whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The > > children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending > > machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to > > buy junk food? > > > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > > their insurance and upkeep? > > > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want > > to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to > > support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > > That's my 2 cents. > > Blessings, > > Lottie > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 Dear Sharon S I am so very sorry for all that you are going through. Are there no other programs that can help you? How about Welfare? That is what it is for. For someone that needs it. I wish I could help. I feel very fortunate to be one of the ones that has good health coverage and I wish that I could do something for you. Please talk to someone about your situation (I am sure you probably feel you have) As far as the President spending all that money. I wish you did not feel that way. President Obama said if he could he would not have done it that way. He would rather have driven his own car and not the helicopter. I am sure Dinner and the Show was not half of that price. He is our president and I feel being a president he is entitled to some time off and some enjoyment. Just seeing him out with his wife made me feel very good about having a NORMAL president. He is trying all that he can to fix the big mess we are in. I think we should have more faith in him. Sharon T _____ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of serenitywon Sent: Sunday, June 14, 2009 8:06 PM Subject: [ ] Re: Health care Hello, I live in Ca.Our state is in a hell of a mess.I have been disabled for about 10 years.I recieve Social Security.My social security benefits have been cut again for the 2nd time in two months.I recieve $840.00 per month to live on.My mortgage is $560.00 per month.I can not find housing any cheaper than this.The state just stopped providing Dental and Vision coverage.I pray nothing else goes wrong with me.I have many health issues. I can not work or work overtime to make more income as I am disabled.I am now forced to decide between eating or taking care of my health.What a wonderful choice.After paying the mortgage I have $280.00 left to pay for food,car insurance,medicine and utilities.I have no spouse for a second income or to help me.I am alone..I am so stressed.I am having daily headaches that are causing nausea.I am not sure if it is CML related or Gleevec related or just plain stress from my whole situation.I feel ill so much that I spend 5-6 days a week in bed non functioning.When I go food shopping I am entiely wipped out for 2-3 days.I need help with house cleaning and daily cooking.My 61 year old mother comes and takes care of me and my yardwork.Some days I wonder exactly what it is I am living for.To feel ill,bedridden daily and no funds to even feed myself anymore.Hell I read here how 80 year olds have a way more active/productive life than me at age 41.I'm just one more person all you tax paying individuals have to pay for..So sorry but I have no other choice. It makes me sick to watch the news.I hear how Obama spent 35,000 for take his wife on a date.That is more than 3 YEARS worth of income for me.I am faced with food or health care..What's wrong with this picture?I think it's wonderful if you have been blessed with a great job,family,life etc that allows for such things but others are not s blessed.I suppose I should be grateful to have a roof over my head as many don't even have that much.I may not for long if things keep getting cut.I see no hope,no future and really no reason to occupy space and expect my monthly handout each month. I hope others here are not faced with these type issues.May you all be of the blessed population. Thanks SharonS In groups (DOT) <mailto:%40> com, " Lottie Duthu " <lotajam@...> wrote: > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 , I am in the same boat as you Itoo have worked since I was 16 paying taxes. I had really good insurance until I had to quit my job due to CML and was not able to keep up the high cost of insurance. Thus I live in Houston and go to a Charity hospital am seen by a new dr every 6 mths (I see a dr every 3 mths now so I may see 1 Dr twice) MD refused me because I do not have insurance, Yet they take people from other states and countries who do not have insurance. Our system is broke. Anita ________________________________ From: Marcos Perreau Guimaraes <montereyunderwater@...> Sent: Sunday, June 14, 2009 10:06:05 PM Subject: Re: [ ] Health care I really think the private vs public insurance is not the core of the problem. As long as a 3h hospital stay with just an iv is charged ~$18,000, or a drug company can blackmail cancer patients into charging their pills ~$4000 to $8000 a month when they paid their investment 10 times over, I can't see the problem going away. I am all for free market but like the mad subprime scam this isn't free market in my book. Marcos. On Sun, Jun 14, 2009 at 7:20 PM, <wendyphillips54> wrote: > > > Wow Lottie, you really put it out there in plain English! I HAD healthcare > until I was injured on the job, mind you, and once I went on short term > disability that I paid for every 2 weeks out of my check, I lost my heath > insurance because I was unable to pay for it through Cobra. It was more than > I was getting on short term. My husband took insurance out on me through his > job but it wouldn't cover me with the pre-existing problems I was having at > the time. Then we separated for a little over a year so he dropped it on me. > I don't blame him for that, I would have done the same thing if it was in > reverse order. Now we are back together and his insurance won't cover me for > CML because it is pre-existing. What are we supposed to do when we struggle > just to make the bills we have to pay to survive. Who can afford health > insurance today when you have to pay the whole thing. It's bad enough when > your employer pays half of it but you have to do it totally on > your own, it's just impossible. Then you get put in the hospital and have > thousands of dollars in medical bills coming in that you can't pay and > sometimes you wonder why in the world we are in this shape. It sickens me to > know that I may not be able to get the care I need because I can't afford > health insurance. I have had a job of some sort since I was15 years old and > now that I am disabled, I can't work so therefore I can't get health > insurance. What am I supposed to do...just sit here and wait for the good > Lord to call me home? Sometimes I feel like that is my only choice. > Everywhere I turn for help here in TN is a deadend road for me. I can't seem > to find anyone willing to take me with no insurance and low income. All I > can do is keep praying that God will open a door for me somewhere so I can > get the care I need. Thanks for posting this, it helps to just get it off my > chest for a change. > > Keeping on keeping on, > > > > > From: Lottie Duthu <lotajamcomcast (DOT) net> > Subject: [ ] Health care > " CML " <groups (DOT) com> > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt > to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will > be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we > run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I > think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I > have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or > don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the > whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The > children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending > machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to > buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want > to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to > support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 I agree! It is absolutely Not Right! [ ] Re: Health care                          Hello,   I live in Ca.Our state is in a hell of a mess.I have been disabled for about 10 years.I recieve Social Security.My social security benefits have been cut again for the 2nd time in two months.I recieve $840.00 per month to live on.My mortgage is $560.00 per month.I can not find housing any cheaper than this.The state just stopped providing Dental and Vision coverage.I pray nothing else goes wrong with me.I have many health issues. I can not work or work overtime to make more income as I  am disabled.I am now forced to decide between eating or taking care of my health.What a wonderful choice.After paying the mortgage I have $280.00 left to pay for food,car insurance,medicine and utilities.I have no spouse for a second income or to help me.I am alone..I am so stressed.I am having daily headaches that are causing nausea.I am not sure if it is CML related or Gleevec related or just plain stress from my whole situation.I feel ill so much that I spend 5-6 days a week in bed non functioning.When I go food shopping I am entiely wipped out for 2-3 days.I need help with house cleaning and daily cooking.My 61 year old mother comes and takes care of me and my yardwork.Some days I wonder exactly what it is I am living for.To feel ill,bedridden daily and no funds to even feed myself anymore.Hell I read here how 80 year olds have a way more active/productive life than me at age 41.I'm just one more person all you tax paying individuals have to pay for..So sorry but I have no other choice. It makes me sick to watch the news.I hear how Obama spent 35,000 for take his wife on a date.That is more than 3 YEARS worth of income for me.I am faced with food or health care..What's wrong with this picture?I think it's wonderful if you have been blessed with a great job,family,life etc that allows for such things but others are not s blessed.I suppose I should be grateful to have a roof over my head as many don't even have that much.I may not for long if things keep getting cut.I see no hope,no future and really no reason to occupy space and expect my monthly handout each month. I hope others here are not faced with these type issues.May you all be of the blessed population. Thanks SharonS In , " Lottie Duthu " <lotajam@...> wrote: > > Dear Group, >  I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email.  So far I haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with.  Maybe our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt to boot.  We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will be over $200.  We are drowning ourselves in medical bills.  Some say that we run to doctors for everything.  I don't, I hate going to doctors.  While I think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families.  They can't or don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly.  The children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them.  The vending machines are  being emptied of everything.  Where does the money come from to buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu.  What about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, too?  Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line?  People come to the food banks with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I supposed to pay for that, too?  I am tired of paying for goods and services for people who do not want to help themselves.  They expect the government to take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the month.  I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs.  Personally I think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes.  Why doesn't the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for their insurance and upkeep?  > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance.  They deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical insurance, but go to work every day.  These are the exceptions.  Also the elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they are incurring today.  Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance?  > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire.  I'll be darned if I want to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of health care, people already in the business of health care.  I don't want some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have a clue.  A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 Sharon, Thanks for the reply.I am not eligable for any other programs.I recieve Social Security(SSI) and with that you are automatically not eligable for food stamps or cash aid.So there is no other help available.. There are programs like welfare as you mentioned but you have to meet requirements to get it and I have ssi so am disqualified. I can't say that I have spoke with anyone regarding my issues.Don't belong to any church or that type thing.Dr says talk to shrink.Can't get into a shrink.Only 1 Dr who takes my insurance and he is booked and not accepting new patients.Been to him in the past and was pretty useless.It's a 20 mile drive and to be honest I don't have money for car gas..It's just not in my budget now. I sure hope Obama is able to save the american people but just not sure it can happen.It can't be done over night and in the mean time many suffer and lose everything they have/had.Many officials not just presiadent waist money on frivilous stuff that us Normal people don't have.Never will have.We have a 1.50 money house about 20 miles away that plays older released movies.I used to go there from time to time as I could afford it.I haven't been to a movie now for several months,entertainment just isn't in my budget now even if I felt good enough to go.It's just all very depressing and watching the news makes me physically ill.So far I have been able to keep my internet service but it may go next.It and the tv are my only source of entertainment.I leave the home only for Dr appointments. I can only hope things improve and that I am not cut again or have the entire program cut.Then what..Can't borrow that one,may not happen. Thanks again SharonS In , " Sharon Teichera " <onthewtr@...> wrote: > > Dear Sharon S > > I am so very sorry for all that you are going through. Are there no other > programs that can help you? How about Welfare? That is what it is for. For > someone that needs it. > > I wish I could help. > > I feel very fortunate to be one of the ones that has good health coverage > and I wish that I could do something for you. > > Please talk to someone about your situation (I am sure you probably feel you > have) As far as the President spending all that money. I wish you did not > feel that way. President Obama said if he could he would not have done it > that way. He would rather have driven his own car and not the helicopter. I > am sure Dinner and the Show was not half of that price. He is our president > and I feel being a president he is entitled to some time off and some > enjoyment. Just seeing him out with his wife made me feel very good about > having a NORMAL president. He is trying all that he can to fix the big mess > we are in. I think we should have more faith in him. > > Sharon T > > > > _____ > > From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of > serenitywon > Sent: Sunday, June 14, 2009 8:06 PM > > Subject: [ ] Re: Health care > > > > > > > > > Hello, > I live in Ca.Our state is in a hell of a mess.I have been disabled for about > 10 years.I recieve Social Security.My social security benefits have been cut > again for the 2nd time in two months.I recieve $840.00 per month to live > on.My mortgage is $560.00 per month.I can not find housing any cheaper than > this.The state just stopped providing Dental and Vision coverage.I pray > nothing else goes wrong with me.I have many health issues. I can not work or > work overtime to make more income as I am disabled.I am now forced to decide > between eating or taking care of my health.What a wonderful choice.After > paying the mortgage I have $280.00 left to pay for food,car > insurance,medicine and utilities.I have no spouse for a second income or to > help me.I am alone..I am so stressed.I am having daily headaches that are > causing nausea.I am not sure if it is CML related or Gleevec related or just > plain stress from my whole situation.I feel ill so much that I spend 5-6 > days a week in bed non functioning.When I go food shopping I am entiely > wipped out for 2-3 days.I need help with house cleaning and daily cooking.My > 61 year old mother comes and takes care of me and my yardwork.Some days I > wonder exactly what it is I am living for.To feel ill,bedridden daily and no > funds to even feed myself anymore.Hell I read here how 80 year olds have a > way more active/productive life than me at age 41.I'm just one more person > all you tax paying individuals have to pay for..So sorry but I have no other > choice. > > It makes me sick to watch the news.I hear how Obama spent 35,000 for take > his wife on a date.That is more than 3 YEARS worth of income for me.I am > faced with food or health care..What's wrong with this picture?I think it's > wonderful if you have been blessed with a great job,family,life etc that > allows for such things but others are not s blessed.I suppose I should be > grateful to have a roof over my head as many don't even have that much.I may > not for long if things keep getting cut.I see no hope,no future and really > no reason to occupy space and expect my monthly handout each month. > > I hope others here are not faced with these type issues.May you all be of > the blessed population. > Thanks > SharonS > > In groups (DOT) <mailto:%40> com, " Lottie Duthu " > <lotajam@> wrote: > > > > Dear Group, > > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and > bankrupt to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary > policy will be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some > say that we run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. > While I think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very > upset when I have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. > They can't or don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so > they bring the whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring > constantly. The children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects > them. The vending machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the > money come from to buy junk food? > > > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > their insurance and upkeep? > > > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I > want to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised > to support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > > That's my 2 cents. > > Blessings, > > Lottie > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 15, 2009 Report Share Posted June 15, 2009 Anita, I have spent all day on the phone and the internet trying to find a Dr who specializes in CML around where I live and although there are some that even practice at the same hospital that I worked at when I became disabled, so far I have not found even ONE that is willing to take me as a patient because I have NO health insurance. I think it's a crying shame that some Drs can't be more compassionate and are in this field just for the money. What happened to the times when all you had to do is let someone know that you needed something and people were lined up with a willing hand and compassionate heart. I absolutely loved my job as a CNA and would give anything if I could go back to work but unfortunaltely I can't. Some days I can't even get out of the bed because I can't walk from pain in my right side and back.. I still have no idea what is causing that. It's like they just gave up on trying to find out what it was. One Dr even said that is was in my head....well excuse me, but when I can't walk, I don't think that is in my head. When I am walking and I fall for no reason, I don't think that is in my head. Then I go to the ER with what I thought was a gall bladder attack and ended up staying a week in the hospital with no insurance and then find out that I have CML and gastritis. So I am paying a little each month on the $35,000 bill that I incurred during that stay. Thank God I have a good Dr in SC and can get the care that I need there because he is willing to give one day a month to the ones of us who can't get care any other way. It just sickens me to think about the people out there that are just too blame lazy to work so they live off welfare and with Mommy or Daddy or both and expect handouts from other people. I can say this with a clear conscious because I had to work for everything I had. I raised 4 kids pretty much on my own because I had a husband that would rather have his liquor and cigarettes than to make sure his kids had food to eat. If it wouldn't have been for my Mom helping us, there are lots of times me and my kids would have gone without things and there were times that we did because I was too embarassed to ask her for help. She is no longer able to help me since she passed away a year ago. Now I have a son in law that won't hit a lick at a snake and he depends on his Mommy to support his wife and kids. Sometimes I just want to blow up at him but I try to be a good mother in law and keep my mouth shut and stay out of their business. Gosh, how did I get off on this subject. It just really ticks me off for people to be so lazy they won't even get off the couch long enough to do things that need to be done. Instead he expects his wife and kids to wait on him like he is some kind of king!!!! I think I need to stop before I get my blood pressure boiling! Thanks for letting me vent though. Best wishes to all, > > From: Lottie Duthu <lotajamcomcast (DOT) net> > Subject: [ ] Health care > " CML " <groups (DOT) com> > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt > to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will > be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we > run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I > think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I > have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or > don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the > whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The > children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending > machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to > buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want > to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to > support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2009 Report Share Posted June 16, 2009 Dear My heart goes out to you. I have a question. How do you pay for your medication and what are you on??? I know Gleevec, sprycel and Tasigna are vry very very expensive. Sharon T _____ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Monday, June 15, 2009 3:29 PM Subject: Re: [ ] Health care Anita, I have spent all day on the phone and the internet trying to find a Dr who specializes in CML around where I live and although there are some that even practice at the same hospital that I worked at when I became disabled, so far I have not found even ONE that is willing to take me as a patient because I have NO health insurance. I think it's a crying shame that some Drs can't be more compassionate and are in this field just for the money. What happened to the times when all you had to do is let someone know that you needed something and people were lined up with a willing hand and compassionate heart. I absolutely loved my job as a CNA and would give anything if I could go back to work but unfortunaltely I can't. Some days I can't even get out of the bed because I can't walk from pain in my right side and back.. I still have no idea what is causing that. It's like they just gave up on trying to find out what it was. One Dr even said that is was in my head....well excuse me, but when I can't walk, I don't think that is in my head. When I am walking and I fall for no reason, I don't think that is in my head. Then I go to the ER with what I thought was a gall bladder attack and ended up staying a week in the hospital with no insurance and then find out that I have CML and gastritis. So I am paying a little each month on the $35,000 bill that I incurred during that stay. Thank God I have a good Dr in SC and can get the care that I need there because he is willing to give one day a month to the ones of us who can't get care any other way. It just sickens me to think about the people out there that are just too blame lazy to work so they live off welfare and with Mommy or Daddy or both and expect handouts from other people. I can say this with a clear conscious because I had to work for everything I had. I raised 4 kids pretty much on my own because I had a husband that would rather have his liquor and cigarettes than to make sure his kids had food to eat. If it wouldn't have been for my Mom helping us, there are lots of times me and my kids would have gone without things and there were times that we did because I was too embarassed to ask her for help. She is no longer able to help me since she passed away a year ago. Now I have a son in law that won't hit a lick at a snake and he depends on his Mommy to support his wife and kids. Sometimes I just want to blow up at him but I try to be a good mother in law and keep my mouth shut and stay out of their business. Gosh, how did I get off on this subject. It just really ticks me off for people to be so lazy they won't even get off the couch long enough to do things that need to be done. Instead he expects his wife and kids to wait on him like he is some kind of king!!!! I think I need to stop before I get my blood pressure boiling! Thanks for letting me vent though. Best wishes to all, > > From: Lottie Duthu <lotajamcomcast (DOT) net> > Subject: [ ] Health care > " CML " <groups (DOT) com> > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt > to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will > be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we > run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I > think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I > have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or > don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the > whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The > children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending > machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to > buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want > to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to > support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2009 Report Share Posted June 16, 2009 Dear : You said you do not work due to being disabled. Are you receiving disability of any type? If you are getting SS Disability then you would be eligible for Medicare. How are you getting your medications etc.? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2009 Report Share Posted June 16, 2009 OMG and Sharon - I cannot believe your stories with the health system over there! I truly find it frightening that you have so little to live on with the pittance that you receive and having to pay back a hospital bill. Everyday I count my lucky stars I live in Australia where our health care is " free " through Medicare. We pay a surcharge on our tax, but that is all. If you have private health insurance it is very expensive - we live in the country, so very fortunate that we have good regional base hospitals and doctors that we don't need to go to our major city (Melbourne) where it is better to have private insurance to access services more readily. As my husband is on a disability pension, we have a concession card which means we only have to pay no more than $5.30 for our meds and also have access to free dental too (although waiting list is high). Previously I used to pay the capped rate of $34.60 (something like that). If we pay more than $1,500 per year for our meds, we get them free after that for the rest of the year. My haem/t charges $80 with pension discount, then get another $35 back and when I go to the gastric specialist I only get charged $20 and the rest is rebated from Medicare. The concession card also gives rebates on electricity, phone, gas, car and public transport and free ambulance subscription. Waiting lists for most of our services is 2 months which I find most acceptable. I agree with Marcos's sentiments re the costs - it is the unfair charges put on that cause the damage. As the majority of our hospitals are public and funded by our governments, they don't have shareholders to pay off. I can remember when I had my hysterectomy 6 years ago, the figure was costed at $15,000 for a 4 day stay, so when an IV costs $13,000 for a few hour stay, the mind boggles at the rorts going on. Regards, From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Tuesday, 16 June 2009 8:29 AM Subject: Re: [ ] Health care Anita, I have spent all day on the phone and the internet trying to find a Dr who specializes in CML around where I live and although there are some that even practice at the same hospital that I worked at when I became disabled, so far I have not found even ONE that is willing to take me as a patient because I have NO health insurance. I think it's a crying shame that some Drs can't be more compassionate and are in this field just for the money. What happened to the times when all you had to do is let someone know that you needed something and people were lined up with a willing hand and compassionate heart. I absolutely loved my job as a CNA and would give anything if I could go back to work but unfortunaltely I can't. Some days I can't even get out of the bed because I can't walk from pain in my right side and back.. I still have no idea what is causing that. It's like they just gave up on trying to find out what it was. One Dr even said that is was in my head....well excuse me, but when I can't walk, I don't think that is in my head. When I am walking and I fall for no reason, I don't think that is in my head. Then I go to the ER with what I thought was a gall bladder attack and ended up staying a week in the hospital with no insurance and then find out that I have CML and gastritis. So I am paying a little each month on the $35,000 bill that I incurred during that stay. Thank God I have a good Dr in SC and can get the care that I need there because he is willing to give one day a month to the ones of us who can't get care any other way. It just sickens me to think about the people out there that are just too blame lazy to work so they live off welfare and with Mommy or Daddy or both and expect handouts from other people. I can say this with a clear conscious because I had to work for everything I had. I raised 4 kids pretty much on my own because I had a husband that would rather have his liquor and cigarettes than to make sure his kids had food to eat. If it wouldn't have been for my Mom helping us, there are lots of times me and my kids would have gone without things and there were times that we did because I was too embarassed to ask her for help. She is no longer able to help me since she passed away a year ago. Now I have a son in law that won't hit a lick at a snake and he depends on his Mommy to support his wife and kids. Sometimes I just want to blow up at him but I try to be a good mother in law and keep my mouth shut and stay out of their business. Gosh, how did I get off on this subject. It just really ticks me off for people to be so lazy they won't even get off the couch long enough to do things that need to be done. Instead he expects his wife and kids to wait on him like he is some kind of king!!!! I think I need to stop before I get my blood pressure boiling! Thanks for letting me vent though. Best wishes to all, > > From: Lottie Duthu <lotajamcomcast (DOT) net> > Subject: [ ] Health care > " CML " <groups (DOT) com> > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt > to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will > be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we > run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I > think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I > have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or > don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the > whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The > children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending > machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to > buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want > to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to > support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2009 Report Share Posted June 16, 2009 , I am so sorry for your loss and pain over your mom's passing. OMG the issues you go through with all the CML doctor's Hospital... In the beginning I too had a lot of pain but it will subside if you can just hang in there and keep your head up Just do not give up. Yes, I too have come across my unfair share of ignorant Dr's and do not let them get me down. I went misdiagnosed for 6 months and 6 know it all DR's and did not have the strength to open a closed door when I finally found one Dr that paid attention and did the one simple blood test. Finding this site is what gave me the knowledge and Praying gave me the strength to get to where I am today. You too will learn so much here. Yes Lottie is a very special Lady she has been a God send to me on here and in private emails and phone calls. She is a Rock. Thank you Lottie Big Hug sent your way Anita ________________________________ From: <wendyphillips54@...> Sent: Monday, June 15, 2009 5:29:00 PM Subject: Re: [ ] Health care Anita, I have spent all day on the phone and the internet trying to find a Dr who specializes in CML around where I live and although there are some that even practice at the same hospital that I worked at when I became disabled, so far I have not found even ONE that is willing to take me as a patient because I have NO health insurance. I think it's a crying shame that some Drs can't be more compassionate and are in this field just for the money. What happened to the times when all you had to do is let someone know that you needed something and people were lined up with a willing hand and compassionate heart. I absolutely loved my job as a CNA and would give anything if I could go back to work but unfortunaltely I can't. Some days I can't even get out of the bed because I can't walk from pain in my right side and back.. I still have no idea what is causing that. It's like they just gave up on trying to find out what it was. One Dr even said that is was in my head....well excuse me, but when I can't walk, I don't think that is in my head. When I am walking and I fall for no reason, I don't think that is in my head. Then I go to the ER with what I thought was a gall bladder attack and ended up staying a week in the hospital with no insurance and then find out that I have CML and gastritis. So I am paying a little each month on the $35,000 bill that I incurred during that stay. Thank God I have a good Dr in SC and can get the care that I need there because he is willing to give one day a month to the ones of us who can't get care any other way. It just sickens me to think about the people out there that are just too blame lazy to work so they live off welfare and with Mommy or Daddy or both and expect handouts from other people. I can say this with a clear conscious because I had to work for everything I had. I raised 4 kids pretty much on my own because I had a husband that would rather have his liquor and cigarettes than to make sure his kids had food to eat. If it wouldn't have been for my Mom helping us, there are lots of times me and my kids would have gone without things and there were times that we did because I was too embarassed to ask her for help. She is no longer able to help me since she passed away a year ago. Now I have a son in law that won't hit a lick at a snake and he depends on his Mommy to support his wife and kids. Sometimes I just want to blow up at him but I try to be a good mother in law and keep my mouth shut and stay out of their business. Gosh, how did I get off on this subject. It just really ticks me off for people to be so lazy they won't even get off the couch long enough to do things that need to be done. Instead he expects his wife and kids to wait on him like he is some kind of king!!!! I think I need to stop before I get my blood pressure boiling! Thanks for letting me vent though. Best wishes to all, > > From: Lottie Duthu <lotajamcomcast (DOT) net> > Subject: [ ] Health care > " CML " <groups (DOT) com> > Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 12:47 AM > > Dear Group, > I was asked my opinion on the health plans in a private email. So far I > haven't seen anything comprehensive that I would be comfortable with. Maybe > our Canadian, English, French, Isralei and Australian members could post > what kind of health care they have and voice their own opinion to give us a > better grip on what we think is the most equitable plan. > > Whoever said our healthcare system is a train wreck is correct and bankrupt > to boot. We just received a notice that my husband's secondary policy will > be over $200. We are drowning ourselves in medical bills. Some say that we > run to doctors for everything. I don't, I hate going to doctors. While I > think everyone should pay something for health care, I get very upset when I > have to go to ER and the waiting room is filled with families. They can't or > don't have someone to take care of the younger children, so they bring the > whole family and it is chaos; their cell phones ring constantly. The > children run around with wheel chairs and no one corrects them. The vending > machines are being emptied of everything. Where does the money come from to > buy junk food? > > I would like to see them all replaced with bottles of water and tofu. What > about people who don't take care of their bodies by taking drugs and are > brought in on a stretcher because they have O.D. Do I have to pay for that, > too? Yes, I do, but where do we draw the line? People come to the food banks > with cell phones and demand certain foods and disposible diapers, am I > supposed to pay for that, too? I am tired of paying for goods and services > for people who do not want to help themselves. They expect the government to > take care of them from the womb to the grave. > > When I had my babies, there was no insurance and I paid the doctor by the > month. I expected to pay it, it was my duty, I never expected my neighbors > to pay for it any more than they expected me to pay for theirs. Personally I > think that is what is wrong with our health care, there are too many free > loaders who could be working and contributing by paying taxes. Why doesn't > the government track down the fathers of these babies and make them pay for > their insurance and upkeep? > > I know there are people who have lost their jobs and their insurance. They > deserve to have free health care, as do children through no fault of their > own have parents who can't afford to pay for the high costs of medical > insurance, but go to work every day. These are the exceptions. Also the > elderly who never made enough money to save up for the medical expenses they > are incurring today. Waiters and waitresses are paid below minimum wage, how > can they be expected to pay for expensive health insurance? > > Who knew 40 years ago we would be in this quagmire. I'll be darned if I want > to continue to have money taken from my fixed income or my taxes raised to > support people who never worked. I know wealthy people who have 6 figure > incomes whose children are on welfare while they continue to live at home in > the lap of luxury because they are drug addicts. It makes me sick to think > of our taxes being wasted on people who don't want to help themselves. I > would like to see someone who is really minding the store take care of > health care, people already in the business of health care. I don't want > some bean counter to tell me what treatment I can have, when he doesn't have > a clue. A health care think tank is sorely needed. > That's my 2 cents. > Blessings, > Lottie > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 17, 2009 Report Share Posted June 17, 2009 I am so grateful I have medical coverage in Canada. I am only 38 years old and if I had to pay for every test I have had to have done in the past few years we would not have a home anymore. Sometimes it takes a while to get in to a specialist.. it took me a month or so to get in to the haematologist the first time, but after that the care has been excellent. I think all systems have strengths and weaknesses and I hope President Obama finds something that works for those without adequate coverage .. you really never know when you are going to need it. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 13, 2009 Report Share Posted September 13, 2009 I've lived in two countries that had socialized health care. I didn't care for either one. My wife, or ex wife now, really didn't like the one where no matter what your ailment or what you were being checked for, you had to see your neighborhood doctor first. He was a general practitioner. If he or she didn't think you needed to see a specialist, then you didn't see one, or paid out of pocket for it. My ex sure didn't like getting female exams by a doctor that only received the minimum training on women's body parts. In Texas, each county has a hospital tax. This is in indegent healthcare tax for the county hospital. I was billed 8,000 dollars for airlife when my son in law was shot and killed. An indigent wouldn't be charged. So, from my standpoint, anyone that wants medical care can get it without paying, they just have to stand in line at the ER to get it. It's estimated that as much as 25% of the families that don't have healthcare insurance, don't have it by choice, preferring to save the money and run the risk, and attend ER's when needed. We don't even need to talk about the French trauma system where a doctor is on each ambulance, and he stabilizes the patients at accident scenes before transport. Of course, severe trauma can't be resolved in the field, so there are many injured that die. The golden hour is a very rough frame of reference. One major city in the US, would not allow ambulances on shooting scenes. The responding officers bagged the victim, threw them in a van, and transported. Very high survival rates. A friend of mine is a chiropractor. She gets 18 dollars for a medicare visit. So she would have to crank them through at a rate of more than 10 an hour to break even for office expenses and salaries, exempting hers, or lose money and treat them fairly, which she does. Allowing the market to fully function would be a much better option than the government doing or meddling in the system. Regards, Don, Seguin Tx Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 13, 2009 Report Share Posted September 13, 2009 I could never see the logic of this kind of argument. We could also be saving the next Hitler, or mass murderer. On 9/13/09 12:39 PM, " jwwright " <jwwright@...> wrote: We now save the lives of babies with birth defects, arguable I know, but some of those have IQ's that exceed yours and mine. The life of ONE super baby could be the solution for many of the problems today. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 13, 2009 Report Share Posted September 13, 2009 JR, I don't see how Germany's system could be viewed as mostly private. From Wikipedia: " According to the World Health Organization, Germany's health care system was 77% government-funded and 23% privately funded as of 2004. " I have lived in two different developed countries - Canada, 1 year and Sweden, 3 years. While working and enjoying their hospitality, I required hospitalization 4 times, once in Canada and three times in Sweden. I would compare the service comparable to the U.S., with the exception that there was no waiting time in Canada and in Sweden, while the costs were dramatically lower than in the U.S. $10 dollars per visit. When in the U.S. under the coverage of an HMO, I had to see a general practitioner first before I could see a specialist. I also had to wait a year before I was covered due to the HMO's pre-existig illness clause. The GOP had a number of years in power and did a horrendous job in keeping health care costs down. Health care is too precious to allow " free market " forces to keep the costs low as the " free market " has utterly failed to do so in the past. Eventually prices will be regulated because the greed involved in the health care insurance industry will eventually drive health care too health too high and then the government will be forced to step in just like they were in the housing mortgage bubble. The bottom line is that there are numerous developed countries whose health care costs are dramatically lower than ours and the quality of care is comparable or better (as indicated by the life expectancy data from the CIA https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2102rank.h\ tml) Nearly all these countries have the " public option " . Ben , <robertsjohnh@...> wrote: > > For the record, I noted early on this discussion could be a can of > worms. In the interest of " truth " lets try to keep this fact based, > as much as possible. Accusing Don of reciting republican talking > points, is a common partisan technique used to discredit statements > while ignoring their content. > > I didn't take his comments as anything more than one rat anecdotal, > but he has at least some first hand experience that most of us don't. > > I have learned more than I ever wanted to know about other country's > healthcare systems, and have several decades of experience watching > how politicians act. Predictions about the future are never perfect > but even their own budget office predicts a huge cost (and those > predictions are routinely low). > > I applaud the many promises made by " our " president on Wed night, but > I frankly don't see how the math could possibly add up. > > My " opinion " of the present situation is that we are not in some > short term crisis. We are feeling the same demographic pressure as > the rest of the (western) world from an aging population who is > living longer, with new and more expensive treatment options. FWIW > the French public health system has been operating at a deficit for > years (Pres Obama promised his heath care system would not borrow > money or raise taxes). > > There are several areas of our health care system that are ripe for > harvesting out waste or inappropriate profits. > > --Health insurance administration. We lose some 25-30% of every > dollar spent to administration. Even Germany with private health > insurance (heavily regulated) only cost 5.5%. Note: Medicare > administration only wastes 3% or so. > > --Drug costs. We pay far more than most other nations for the same > drugs. This should be normalized, which would eventually raise costs > for every body else, but that's life. > > --Malpractice/Tort reform. The total cost from this is not just > nuisance lawsuits and malpractice premiums, but " just in case " tests > and procedures. But as a healthcare professional you should be aware > of this. > > The difficulty with releasing or harvesting this fat or waste out of > our system is that all three of these vested interests are over > represented by lobbyists and campaign contributions. > > Remodeling the insurance industry from where it is to where we want > it to go will cause much economic dislocation within a private > industry, so they will resist. A more conservative approach is not to > create a government funded competitor. There are many obstacles to > competition that could be removed first (like state regulated > monopoly or duopolies) > > Drug costs. They have traditionally avoided mandated price controls > (here), and even practice some shady behaviors (like paying generic > makers not to compete and subsidizing co-pays to influence users). > Legal but not in our national interest for less expensive health > care. I have seen what appears to be less long term research > investment in anticipation of future price cuts (now they prefer to > buy smaller drug companies). Let's go ahead and get this over with. > More pain for a private industry that will resist. > > Finally the lawyers- At the risk of sounding partisan, I believe I am > stating fact that they have strong influence with the current party > in power and none of the legislation has bothered to address this > third leg of the cost problem. In the president's speech he gave a > nod to Bush's pilot program to reduce malpractice costs, but > promising to restore a pilot program by executive order is a far way > from tort reform legislation. > > The math is too convoluted to address succinctly but Don's anecdote > about medicare under-compensating for services (albeit chiropractic) > is not a unique observation. One non-profit hospital administrator > suggested he was compensated at roughly 80% for medicare procedures, > and being a non-profit he shifted those costs to his other patients. > The plan to fund the new legislation calls for cutting hundreds of > billions from current medicare spending while expanding the system. > Some doctors already avoid medicare patients, I don't see this being > addressed. > > I really wish the president could actually deliver what he promised > but I just don't see how. Even the congress broke out in laughter > when he said there were details to work out... I didn't find it that > funny, the devil is in the details. He made an " artful " speech full > of promises. He will be on 60 minutes tonight making more promises > and perhaps throwing out his latest scare tactic (we will lose the > insurance we already have). I don't have insurance so I am not > scared. While I am not pleased that I will be fined if I don't buy > his insurance under this new legislation. > > I suspect we will get a one sided bill of some sort . I am > apprehensive about the likelihood of what we will get, but > acknowledge the vote math in congress. That math they understand. > > Good luck to us all.... > > JR > > On Sep 13, 2009, at 8:39 AM, Jeanette Mannino wrote: > > > Don, > > > > While I certainly agree that we are entitled to our own opinions, I > > thought this listserv has an emphasis on truth that can be debated > > on interpretation of science. > > > > On that basis, your opinions of your PERSONAL experiences with > > health care in " socialized " system are rather worthless to the > > debate about the future of health care in the US. > > > > Most of the people who have an interest in CRON, have an inherent > > interest in health and its relationship to a long and quality > > life. Longevity without health is not the goal of this group nor, > > my personal goal. While we all wish we would never need medical > > intervention to achieve good health, even the healthiest of us will > > need to seek medical attention at some time in our life. > > > > Those of us in favor of health care reform in America understand > > that some assurance of basic access and affordability is > > consistent with a civilized society. When you give a figure of the > > number of people who choose not to have health coverage, you do not > > consider why they make that choice. When someone has to choose > > between feeding their family or paying outrageous health insurance > > premiums, the choice becomes quite personal. I could go on and > > one, but my post is based on over 50 years experience as a health > > care professional, and not out of the Republican talking points, as > > yours appears to be. > > > > One last point, The Golden Hour of trauma is now being reconsidered > > by the military. History has shown us that most trauma care > > standards have come from the military and a lot of weight is given > > to their vast experience. Maybe the French have it right. > > > > Considering all sides of an issue is the mature, intellectual thing > > to do, especially when it is as complicated, yet personal as health > > care. > > > > MJM > > > > On Sep 12, 2009, at 6:51 PM, searcher555 wrote: > > > >> > >> I've lived in two countries that had socialized health care. I > >> didn't care for either one. My wife, or ex wife now, really didn't > >> like the one where no matter what your ailment or what you were > >> being checked for, you had to see your neighborhood doctor first. > >> He was a general practitioner. If he or she didn't think you > >> needed to see a specialist, then you didn't see one, or paid out > >> of pocket for it. My ex sure didn't like getting female exams by a > >> doctor that only received the minimum training on women's body parts. > >> > >> In Texas, each county has a hospital tax. This is in indegent > >> healthcare tax for the county hospital. I was billed 8,000 dollars > >> for airlife when my son in law was shot and killed. An indigent > >> wouldn't be charged. > >> > >> So, from my standpoint, anyone that wants medical care can get it > >> without paying, they just have to stand in line at the ER to get > >> it. It's estimated that as much as 25% of the families that don't > >> have healthcare insurance, don't have it by choice, preferring to > >> save the money and run the risk, and attend ER's when needed. > >> > >> We don't even need to talk about the French trauma system where a > >> doctor is on each ambulance, and he stabilizes the patients at > >> accident scenes before transport. Of course, severe trauma can't > >> be resolved in the field, so there are many injured that die. The > >> golden hour is a very rough frame of reference. > >> > >> One major city in the US, would not allow ambulances on shooting > >> scenes. The responding officers bagged the victim, threw them in a > >> van, and transported. Very high survival rates. > >> > >> A friend of mine is a chiropractor. She gets 18 dollars for a > >> medicare visit. So she would have to crank them through at a rate > >> of more than 10 an hour to break even for office expenses and > >> salaries, exempting hers, or lose money and treat them fairly, > >> which she does. > >> > >> Allowing the market to fully function would be a much better > >> option than the government doing or meddling in the system. > >> > >> Regards, > >> Don, Seguin Tx > >> > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 13, 2009 Report Share Posted September 13, 2009 I agree with your comments, as truth, and in fact the reason for the need to improve. I don't see how we can fear the growth in the nat'l debt NOW. It will likely double in the next 8 years anyway, so any funding for improved HC can easliy be covered. Individual insurance companies will fold as they incur increased costs, or be refused by doctors. They're doing that now. I doubt they will resist refunding any more than GM did. My company folded and the company that took over raises rates to a level to force people out. Regards Re: [ ] Health care For the record, I noted early on this discussion could be a can of worms. In the interest of " truth " lets try to keep this fact based, as much as possible. Accusing Don of reciting republican talking points, is a common partisan technique used to discredit statements while ignoring their content. I didn't take his comments as anything more than one rat anecdotal, but he has at least some first hand experience that most of us don't. I have learned more than I ever wanted to know about other country's healthcare systems, and have several decades of experience watching how politicians act. Predictions about the future are never perfect but even their own budget office predicts a huge cost (and those predictions are routinely low). I applaud the many promises made by " our " president on Wed night, but I frankly don't see how the math could possibly add up. My " opinion " of the present situation is that we are not in some short term crisis. We are feeling the same demographic pressure as the rest of the (western) world from an aging population who is living longer, with new and more expensive treatment options. FWIW the French public health system has been operating at a deficit for years (Pres Obama promised his heath care system would not borrow money or raise taxes). There are several areas of our health care system that are ripe for harvesting out waste or inappropriate profits. --Health insurance administration. We lose some 25-30% of every dollar spent to administration. Even Germany with private health insurance (heavily regulated) only cost 5.5%. Note: Medicare administration only wastes 3% or so. --Drug costs. We pay far more than most other nations for the same drugs. This should be normalized, which would eventually raise costs for every body else, but that's life. --Malpractice/Tort reform. The total cost from this is not just nuisance lawsuits and malpractice premiums, but " just in case " tests and procedures. But as a healthcare professional you should be aware of this. The difficulty with releasing or harvesting this fat or waste out of our system is that all three of these vested interests are over represented by lobbyists and campaign contributions. Remodeling the insurance industry from where it is to where we want it to go will cause much economic dislocation within a private industry, so they will resist. A more conservative approach is not to create a government funded competitor. There are many obstacles to competition that could be removed first (like state regulated monopoly or duopolies) Drug costs. They have traditionally avoided mandated price controls (here), and even practice some shady behaviors (like paying generic makers not to compete and subsidizing co-pays to influence users). Legal but not in our national interest for less expensive health care. I have seen what appears to be less long term research investment in anticipation of future price cuts (now they prefer to buy smaller drug companies). Let's go ahead and get this over with. More pain for a private industry that will resist. Finally the lawyers- At the risk of sounding partisan, I believe I am stating fact that they have strong influence with the current party in power and none of the legislation has bothered to address this third leg of the cost problem. In the president's speech he gave a nod to Bush's pilot program to reduce malpractice costs, but promising to restore a pilot program by executive order is a far way from tort reform legislation. The math is too convoluted to address succinctly but Don's anecdote about medicare under-compensating for services (albeit chiropractic) is not a unique observation. One non-profit hospital administrator suggested he was compensated at roughly 80% for medicare procedures, and being a non-profit he shifted those costs to his other patients. The plan to fund the new legislation calls for cutting hundreds of billions from current medicare spending while expanding the system. Some doctors already avoid medicare patients, I don't see this being addressed. I really wish the president could actually deliver what he promised but I just don't see how. Even the congress broke out in laughter when he said there were details to work out... I didn't find it that funny, the devil is in the details. He made an " artful " speech full of promises. He will be on 60 minutes tonight making more promises and perhaps throwing out his latest scare tactic (we will lose the insurance we already have). I don't have insurance so I am not scared. While I am not pleased that I will be fined if I don't buy his insurance under this new legislation. I suspect we will get a one sided bill of some sort . I am apprehensive about the likelihood of what we will get, but acknowledge the vote math in congress. That math they understand. Good luck to us all.... JR Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.