Guest guest Posted April 13, 2006 Report Share Posted April 13, 2006 I reposted the entire post here. Hope that's OK. My comments below. Okay, a few thoughts: If it has any ability to move mercury or other metals, then I would say it is potentially dangerous. If you don't know what you are doing, then I would say anything which has any hope of being effective is dangerous (possibly very dangerous). I would compare it to having sharp kitchen knives and a hot stove -- you can cut or burn yourself with them but you cannot make a meal without them. The stuff that is effective is also potentially dangerous and needs to be handled with care, by someone with a little basic knowledge about how to use them safely (knowledge you can get on this list for several chelators but cilantro is still largely a mystery). If you want a fairly detailed description of one person's experience using cilantro to good effect, you can search the archives for letters by me that talk about cilantro. I still have plans to finish going through the archives for posts with reference to cilantro and pass that info on to Moria but this has been a really butt-kicking year and I haven't gotten any further on that project in many months. So don't hold your breathe. The short version of my experiences: I was extraordinarily ill and had been working at recovering for a long time already. **This sounds a bit like me. I have celiac so my chronic problems are improving with the diet, but there are times when I get it from cross contamination or undeclared wheat starch, etc. Like there is some salsa that I absolutely love that has some problem, but the label doesn't indicate that there is any gluten source in the ingredients so if I eat it (and I won't now that I am aware of this) my hair falls out and I feel achy all over and get some gas and other gi upset. I began eating at a mexican restaurant. I felt so much better on days when I ate there that I began having lunch there almost every single day and I also began trying to figure out what was in the food that was helping me heal. I found out that some of the spices helped with my respiratory problems and that the food was organic. Those were clues but did not seem to be the whole story. About 6 months after I began eating there, I joined this list and learned that cilantro is apparently a chelator. That seemed to be the last piece of the puzzle. However, I still have amalgams in my mouth and after about 15 months of eating cilantro in my lunch, I began having a metallic taste in my mouth, headaches, nausea, and other negative side effects following lunch. It took me a couple of weeks to fully make the connection and discontinue eating lunch there. So, I would say that ANYTHING which works as a chelator has the potential to dump mercury into your body if you chelate while you still have amalgams in your mouth. The advice that you usually see on this list is to have the amalgams removed first. I think that is generally a wise precaution. **I had mine removed in 2000 or 2001 when I first saw Dr. Cave. My son has none, but has been eating Albacore this summer since we found out about the lying, irresponsible Mc 's that had gluten in their fries when they said they were gf on their web site for years. I am still mad about this and probably should have joined one of the many class action suits just as therapy. There are a lot of other things I did while eating cilantro which appear to have helped the process along (things I did to treat my health problems which just COINCIDENTALLY supported the removal of mercury from my system). I tested some of those as a hypothesis when I began having a metallic taste in my mouth . The things I had come to suspect were supporting the process did, in fact, reduce the negative side effects during that two week period. One thing which helped was hot salt-water baths. **salt water baths. Hmm, Dr. Cave recommends Epsom salt. My aunt recommends Epsom Salt and Bicarbonate together. Another which helped was taking guafenisen (an expectorant). **I can see how this would help loosen things up. A third which helped was eating fatty foods (the fat seems to absorb toxins and then I would have diarhea). **This too had occurred to me. I was actually thinking of Cod Liver Oil, but also to eat lots of coconut oil and coconut milk (which is high in Lauric acid and actually has an added benefit of being an antifungal). In fact, I may make up some chicken stock and add cilantro to it and a little coconut milk. There is a Thai soup like this that has some lemongrass in it that is delicious. We could have 1/2 or a cup twice a day, morning and evening. I was also thinking of using a flax seed and activated charcoal poultice over my thyroid a couple of hours a day to draw out toxins. My thyroid is a big problem and I suspect metals there. ### end of my comments --Connie A former list member once said that you need to promote excretion through the skin and have a toxin " sink " in the stomach as well to effectively remove metals that have been mobilized by chelators. That resonates with my experience. His view was that chlorella made an effective toxin sink in the gut. I have no experience with chlorella. Instead, I used fats for the same purpose. He is no longer on this list and I wouldn't personally desire to refer anyone to him, so I hope no one will name names here. I am just trying to give the best information available concerning cilantro and chlorella -- if you are planning on using them regardless of how many people tell you it is a bad idea, I hope you will at least try to find the best means to use them. I got really, really lucky and had a good experience with using cilantro (which I completely stumbled upon and had no idea what I was doing at first). The vast majority of folks on this list who have tried cilantro have had bad experiences. And the fact is, I simply stumbled upon something that worked and tried by observation to figure out what I was doing right. There seems to generally be a dearth of solid information on how to properly use cilantro. So the safest route would be to use one of the chelators for which a well-known protocol exists. HTH, -- Michele in Limbo (formerly in California) < /post?postID=KovgiX9 Z8QhbOpgj67_HVUDj7livVeilzpmAVwuEsMDd3ZlYr6nuDrcMKJJEn6UqBHzjZUNniOHoGnb _3svL_ver> talithamichele@... Visit Michele's World! <http://www.califmichele.com/> http://www.califmichele.com " Peace cannot be kept by force. It can only be achieved by understanding. " -- Albert Einstein Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 29, 2007 Report Share Posted August 29, 2007 > > HI I justed wanted to share this article about cilantro , I also read > other articles about how cilantro rids the body of heavy metals. > http://www.rawfoodinfo.com/articles/art_cilantroremheavymetals.html ==>Thank you for the reference. The very best chelator of heavy metals is a diet high in " good " saturated fats like this diet (butter, coconut oil, lard, etc.), along with oil soluble vitamins, omega-3, minerals, etc. Bee Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 5, 2008 Report Share Posted February 5, 2008 Cilantro The herbal and health information provided in this Web Site is intended as historical information only. The historical uses are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Nothing listed within this Web Site should be considered as medical advice for dealing with a given problem. You should consult your health care professional for individual guidance for specific health problems. Persons with serious medical conditions should always seek professional care. You say Cilantro, I say Coriander. Although it has two names, Cilantro is a single plant, sometimes called Chinese parsley. Its leaves are known as Cilantro; the seeds are called Coriander. The pack the same medicinal benefits: both ease indigestion and prevent wound infection. Coriander has a long history as a digestive aid. In Egypt, the seeds have been found in pharaohs' tombs, presumably to prevent indigestion in the afterlife. While no one has been able to attest to its post-mortem healing properties, recent studies have supported its use as a stomach soother for both adults and colicky babies. What's more, it has wound healing benefits, which were first discovered by the ancient Romans, who used both the leaves and seeds to preserve meats. The herb contains an antioxidant that helps prevent animal fats from turning rancid. It also contains substances that kill meat-spoiling bacteria and fungi. These same substances in Cilantro also prevent infection in wounds. Healing with Cilantro and Coriander: To make a medicinal tea, use 1 teaspoon of dried leaves or crushed seeds (or ½ teaspoon of powdered seeds) per cup of boiling water. Steep for 5 minutes. Drink up to three cups a day before or after meals. Both forms of the herb can: Improve digestion: The herb has been shown to improve tummy troubles of all kinds, from indigestion to flatulence to diarrhea. "Both Cilantro and Coriander have been shown to settle the stomach, " says A. Duke, Ph.D., a botanist retire from the U.S. Department of Agriculture and author of The CRC Handbook of Medicinal Herbs. Drink a cup of the tea when stomach discomfort strikes. Relieve colic: Weak Coriander tea may be give children under age 2 for colic. It's safe for infants and may relieve their pain-and help you get some much-needed sleep. Prevent infection: Cilantro and Coriander contain substances that kill certain bacteria and fungi, thereby preventing infections from developing in wounds. Sprinkle some dried Coriander seeds or leaves on minor cuts and scrapes after thoroughly washing the injured area with soap and water. Soothe arthritis pain: Intriguing new studies suggest that Cilantro and Coriander have anti-inflammatory effects. Since the pain of arthritis is cause by inflammation, a cup of this tea may help you. Safety Considerations: "I've never heard of any problems with Cilantro or Coriander," says B. Mowrey, Ph.D., director of the American Phytotherapy Research Laboratory in Salt Lake City and author of The Scientific Validation of Herbal Medicine. If there's a sticking point, it's that some people just don't like the flavor, which is reminiscent of curry. http://www.viable-herbal.com/herbdesc1/1cilantr.htm Recipe Cilantro Pesto Accompanying article: Fish Two foods that antidote mercury stored in our tissues are seaweed and cilantro. They both chelate mercury and safely discharge it from the body. I recommend their frequent use. On my weekly market trip, I always pick up a bunch or two of cilantro and generously strew it as a garnish or turn it into pesto. A flavorful topping for grilled fish (see Pacific Halibut), chicken or vegetables, cilantro pesto is also good as a dip, over pasta or grains and on sandwiches. This pesto keeps in the refrigerator for several days. For optimum flavor, bring it to room temperature before serving. Makes about 1¼ cup 1 bunch fresh cilantro, rinsed and dried (approximately 3 cups, loosely packed)½ cup grated Parmesan cheese½ cup roasted pine nuts, walnuts or macadamia nuts2 cloves garlic1 tablespoon lime juice½ cup extra virgin olive oil½ teaspoon sea salt or to taste Strip the cilantro leaves from the stems and set the leaves aside. Coarsely chop the stems and place them in a food processor or blender. Add the cheese, pine nuts, garlic, lime juice, oil and salt and process to a uniform consistency. Add the leaves and process until the leaves are coarsely chopped. May you be well nourished, Wood http://www.rwood.com/Recipes/Cilantro_Pesto.htm Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Mobile. Try it now. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 4, 2009 Report Share Posted May 4, 2009 Is cilantro a chelator? Thanks Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 4, 2009 Report Share Posted May 4, 2009 > > Is cilantro a chelator? > Thanks > > Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry > It might more accurately be called a " mercury mobilizer " . My impression is that it doesn't work the same way as the chelators typically used on this list. No one knows the active ingredient, how to properly dose it, and there is no existing protocol that I am aware of. Michele http://www.healthgazelle.com http://www.kidslikemine.com http://www.solanorail.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 13, 2010 Report Share Posted May 13, 2010 According to my herbalist, cilantro is fine by itself. Where did this information come from? On May 13, 2010, at 8:47 AM, Deb57 wrote: > From my understanding, cilantro is supposed to mobilize mercury and > then chlorella bind to it. So taking cilantro without chlorella > might do harm because the cilantro does not bind tightly to the > toxins and thus releases them elsewhere in the body. I cannot find > any immediate info on chlorella not being a good binder, although > many people cannot tolerate it. Here's a link.http://www.ehow.com/ > facts_5898368_dangers-chlorella_.html > > deb > > > > > > > > I tried chlorella but it gave me throbbing pains throughout my > abdomen. I stopped, pain went away, I started, pain returned. > Darnnit! I wanted to be able to take that stuff! > > > -Sonya > > > Sent from my BlackBerry® smartphone with SprintSpeed > > > > > > - > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 13, 2010 Report Share Posted May 13, 2010 Cilantro is a chelator of mercury. This means that there is something in cilantro (as yet unidentified) that is able to bind to mercury. Like other chelators, the binding is not " unbreakable " . Some individual mercury atoms/molecules will probably be carried out of the body. Some will not be carried out, but will be " dropped " in new locations. This is known as redistribution. The effects of redistribution range from unpleasant and transitory to devastating and irreversible. Mercury is one of the most toxic substances on the planet and damages ANYTHING in the body it comes in contact with. Bear in mind that the affinity of cilantro for mercury can be a two-way street: cilantro may also accumulate mercury present in the environment, thus *increasing* your body burden of mercury when it is consumed. Taking chlorella with cilantro will not prevent or mitigate the effects of redistribution. Chlorella is *not* a chelator of mercury. Also, since many people have trouble with chlorella, it could actually exacerbate the damage. I have always loved cilantro - it has a wonderful flavor and aroma. These days, I eat it only in minute quantities. I advise others - especially anyone whose body has been ravaged by Lyme - to exercise similar caution. I imagine that some list members have eaten tons of cilantro with no ill effects. That is great - but please don't assume that others can do the same. People who still have amalgam ( " silver " ) fillings should be especially cautious. Hope this helps, Jeff PS - for anyone interested in mercury detoxification, check out the frequent dose chelation group at: frequent-dose-chelation/ Re: [ ] Cilantro According to my herbalist, cilantro is fine by itself. Where did this information come from? On May 13, 2010, at 8:47 AM, Deb57 wrote: > From my understanding, cilantro is supposed to mobilize mercury and > then chlorella bind to it. So taking cilantro without chlorella > might do harm because the cilantro does not bind tightly to the > toxins and thus releases them elsewhere in the body. I cannot find > any immediate info on chlorella not being a good binder, although > many people cannot tolerate it. Here's a link.http://www.ehow.com/ > facts_5898368_dangers-chlorella_.html > > deb > > > > > > > > I tried chlorella but it gave me throbbing pains throughout my > abdomen. I stopped, pain went away, I started, pain returned. > Darnnit! I wanted to be able to take that stuff! > > > -Sonya > > > Sent from my BlackBerryR smartphone with SprintSpeed > > > > > > - > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 14, 2010 Report Share Posted May 14, 2010 Great, one more freaking thing that someone suspected of Lyme cannot consume. After a while, the conflicting information begins to wear me down, and I don't even have lyme. I just cook for one. I give up.Steve C. > From my understanding, cilantro is supposed to mobilize mercury and > then chlorella bind to it. So taking cilantro without chlorella > might do harm because the cilantro does not bind tightly to the > toxins and thus releases them elsewhere in the body. I cannot find > any immediate info on chlorella not being a good binder, although > many people cannot tolerate it. Here's a link.http://www.ehow.com/ > facts_5898368_dangers-chlorella_.html > > deb > > > > > > > > I tried chlorella but it gave me throbbing pains throughout my > abdomen. I stopped, pain went away, I started, pain returned. > Darnnit! I wanted to be able to take that stuff! > > > -Sonya > > > Sent from my BlackBerryR smartphone with SprintSpeed > > > > > > - > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.