Guest guest Posted August 27, 2008 Report Share Posted August 27, 2008 Geraldine: is definitely getting this now within Conroe ISD but my worry is what happens after he leaves this teacher. BTTC still can come in for occasional consults where I will get written reports on their observations. But the road to get here was ugly. Very ugly. I don't trust their BCABA because she was in charge of training the 4 teachers who completely decimated his education. It's only because of the nonpartial outside observation of BTTC that I've built up any trust that they are doing this right. Of course now they are playing catch up of what I will continue to call the educational rape of my child. But for now, last year and this year they are doing it right. Hilda In a message dated 8/27/2008 6:09:43 P.M. Central Daylight Time, gbliss1@... writes: Hmmm.okay, maybe this question really comes down to the definition of ABA. Yes, I think a lot of school districts are starting to use some practices from the field of ABA. BUT are public school programs adhering to the same standards that are employed in peer-reviewed comparative studies of different types of educational programs for students with autism (such as the et al study)? I'm in a district which has dedicated autism classrooms, but the quality of instruction across the autism classrooms varies from teacher to teacher, from what I have seen and heard. I think one of the biggest issues districts face is getting teachers and paras trained in ABA. It's a problem that's further compounded by the challenge districts face in retaining good teachers in autism classrooms. I've heard from both consultants and teachers that the reason turnover rates are so high is because teachers feel abused by parents. It's a tough job, for sure. I'm all for the idea of performance compensation bonuses for teachers who consistently use the principles of ABA. Another component that's generally missing, in my opinion, is enough support for teachers. I mean beyond just training teachers. It's really hard to teach, collect data, input data, analyze it, and then trial new interventions. If you look at how private programs do it, they have systems for getting all of that done - including the involvement of senior classroom trainers, BCABAs, and BCBAs who share in that workload. Even for the very best teachers, there are times when another set of eyes is needed to help analyze what is going on. In my opinion, an effective ABA-based classroom has the regular, frequent, and hands-on involvement of a behavior analyst. The other component that's missing in public schools is ongoing, hands-on training for teachers. It's one thing to attend a workshop, but it's another thing altogether to try to apply the principles of ABA to a child with severely challenging behaviors. School districts really need behavior analysts to be actively involved in supporting teachers by working side-by-side with them to teach them HOW to apply the principles of ABA on the fly. Just my opinion. Geraldine _____ From: _Texas-Autism-Texas-AutTexas-AutismTex_ (mailto:Texas-Autism-Advocacy ) [mailto:_Texas-Autism-Texas-AutTexas-AutismTex_ (mailto:Texas-Autism-Advocacy ) ] On Behalf Of Dr. Graham-Garza Sent: Wednesday, August 27, 2008 3:26 PM To: _Texas-Autism-Texas-AutTexas-AutismTex_ (mailto:Texas-Autism-Advocacy ) Subject: Re: [Texas-Autism-Subject: Re: [Texas-Autism-<WBR>Advocacy] school districts Now that ABA wording is in the autism supplement, all the districts will " say " they are using ABA principles - even before Katy had an ECAP and YCAP program but no formal ABA training. I believe it is eclectic - lisa [Texas-Autism-<WBR>Advocacy] Question for pa districts Do any of you parents in any school district in the Houston area --- know of a campus or district that has an " Autism ABA " program. A campus or program specifically for those with autism, using the principles of ABA - Applied Behavior Analysis - as the curriculum/methodolBeha Please let me know... M. Guppy My autism journey isn't about waiting for the storm to pass, it's about learning to dance in the rain.... Texas Autism Advocacy: www.TexasAutismAdvoTexas Au " There are some aspects of a person's life that we have no right to compromise. We cannot negotiate the size of an institution. No one should live in one. We cannot debate who should get an inclusive education. Everyone should. We cannot determine who does and who does not get the right to make their own choices and forge their own futures. All must. " [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] ------------------------------------ Texas Autism Advocacy www.TexasAutismAdvowww.Texa Texas Disability Network Calendar of Events www.TexasAutismAdvowww.TexasAutismAdvo<WBR>cacy.or [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] **************It's only a deal if it's where you want to go. Find your travel deal here. (http://information.travel.aol.com/deals?ncid=aoltrv00050000000047) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 27, 2008 Report Share Posted August 27, 2008 Conroe ISD used to until MKA came along and hired Stetson & Associates to back her up in her opinion to crush all autism programs. I was part of their autism focus group and they said that these classrooms lead to " learned helplessness. " Of course, I had a lot to say about that. Now, does have in place this methodology with a teacher and paraprofessional appropriately trained. Last year and this year same two people. God help us next year when he has to change schools. Hilda In a message dated 8/27/2008 3:05:59 P.M. Central Daylight Time, michellemguppy@... writes: Do any of you parents in any school district in the Houston area --- know of a campus or district that has an " Autism ABA " program. A campus or program specifically for those with autism, using the principles of ABA - Applied Behavior Analysis - as the curriculum/methodol A c Please let me know... M. Guppy **************It's only a deal if it's where you want to go. Find your travel deal here. (http://information.travel.aol.com/deals?ncid=aoltrv00050000000047) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 27, 2008 Report Share Posted August 27, 2008 You're very fortunate to have the involvement of BTTC in your son's public school program. I shouldn't use the word fortunate - I know you worked hard to get that. I don't know the BCABA in your district, and I don't know what her job responsibilities are within CISD. In a lot of places, behavior analysts working in public schools are stretched so thin they can do little more than offer cookbook solutions and attend ARDs. That's not what ABA is about, but that's what happens because there aren't enough professionals available to meet the huge needs in public schools. Districts need to find systematic ways of getting more behavior analysts into schools and making the most effective use of the behavior analysts. For example, if districts would create professional development tracks for special ed teachers, which would allow them to become BCBAs under the mentorship of an experienced BCBA, districts would eventually have lots of qualified behavior analysts. Though it would take a bit of an investment up front (to pay for a full-time BCBA), there would be a payout within a couple of years when the district has, say, 6 homegrown BCBAs or BCABAs, who could then train other teachers. Just an idea. Geraldine _____ From: Texas-Autism-Advocacy [mailto:Texas-Autism-Advocacy ] On Behalf Of HildaBowen@... Sent: Wednesday, August 27, 2008 8:45 PM To: Texas-Autism-Advocacy Subject: Re: Question for parents in Houton area school distri... Geraldine: is definitely getting this now within Conroe ISD but my worry is what happens after he leaves this teacher. BTTC still can come in for occasional consults where I will get written reports on their observations. But the road to get here was ugly. Very ugly. I don't trust their BCABA because she was in charge of training the 4 teachers who completely decimated his education. It's only because of the nonpartial outside observation of BTTC that I've built up any trust that they are doing this right. Of course now they are playing catch up of what I will continue to call the educational rape of my child. But for now, last year and this year they are doing it right. Hilda In a message dated 8/27/2008 6:09:43 P.M. Central Daylight Time, gbliss1comcast (DOT) <mailto:gbliss1%40comcast.net> net writes: Hmmm.okay, maybe this question really comes down to the definition of ABA. Yes, I think a lot of school districts are starting to use some practices from the field of ABA. BUT are public school programs adhering to the same standards that are employed in peer-reviewed comparative studies of different types of educational programs for students with autism (such as the et al study)? I'm in a district which has dedicated autism classrooms, but the quality of instruction across the autism classrooms varies from teacher to teacher, from what I have seen and heard. I think one of the biggest issues districts face is getting teachers and paras trained in ABA. It's a problem that's further compounded by the challenge districts face in retaining good teachers in autism classrooms. I've heard from both consultants and teachers that the reason turnover rates are so high is because teachers feel abused by parents. It's a tough job, for sure. I'm all for the idea of performance compensation bonuses for teachers who consistently use the principles of ABA. Another component that's generally missing, in my opinion, is enough support for teachers. I mean beyond just training teachers. It's really hard to teach, collect data, input data, analyze it, and then trial new interventions. If you look at how private programs do it, they have systems for getting all of that done - including the involvement of senior classroom trainers, BCABAs, and BCBAs who share in that workload. Even for the very best teachers, there are times when another set of eyes is needed to help analyze what is going on. In my opinion, an effective ABA-based classroom has the regular, frequent, and hands-on involvement of a behavior analyst. The other component that's missing in public schools is ongoing, hands-on training for teachers. It's one thing to attend a workshop, but it's another thing altogether to try to apply the principles of ABA to a child with severely challenging behaviors. School districts really need behavior analysts to be actively involved in supporting teachers by working side-by-side with them to teach them HOW to apply the principles of ABA on the fly. Just my opinion. Geraldine _____ From: _Texas-Autism-Texas-AutTexas-AutismTex_ (mailto:Texas-Autism- <mailto:Texas-Autism-Advocacy%40yahoogroups.com> Advocacy ) [mailto:_Texas-Autism-Texas-AutTexas-AutismTex_ (mailto:Texas-Autism- <mailto:Texas-Autism-Advocacy%40yahoogroups.com> Advocacy ) ] On Behalf Of Dr. Graham-Garza Sent: Wednesday, August 27, 2008 3:26 PM To: _Texas-Autism-Texas-AutTexas-AutismTex_ (mailto:Texas-Autism- <mailto:Texas-Autism-Advocacy%40yahoogroups.com> Advocacy ) Subject: Re: [Texas-Autism-Subject: Re: [Texas-Autism-<WBR>Advocacy] school districts Now that ABA wording is in the autism supplement, all the districts will " say " they are using ABA principles - even before Katy had an ECAP and YCAP program but no formal ABA training. I believe it is eclectic - lisa [Texas-Autism-<WBR>Advocacy] Question for pa districts Do any of you parents in any school district in the Houston area --- know of a campus or district that has an " Autism ABA " program. A campus or program specifically for those with autism, using the principles of ABA - Applied Behavior Analysis - as the curriculum/methodolBeha Please let me know... M. Guppy My autism journey isn't about waiting for the storm to pass, it's about learning to dance in the rain.... Texas Autism Advocacy: www.TexasAutismAdvoTexas Au " There are some aspects of a person's life that we have no right to compromise. We cannot negotiate the size of an institution. No one should live in one. We cannot debate who should get an inclusive education. Everyone should. We cannot determine who does and who does not get the right to make their own choices and forge their own futures. All must. " Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 28, 2008 Report Share Posted August 28, 2008 Great idea!!!!!! Lesli Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile Re: [Texas-Autism-<WBR>Advocacy] school districts Now that ABA wording is in the autism supplement, all the districts will " say " they are using ABA principles - even before Katy had an ECAP and YCAP program but no formal ABA training. I believe it is eclectic - lisa [Texas-Autism-<WBR>Advocacy] Question for pa districts Do any of you parents in any school district in the Houston area --- know of a campus or district that has an " Autism ABA " program. A campus or program specifically for those with autism, using the principles of ABA - Applied Behavior Analysis - as the curriculum/methodolBeha Please let me know... M. Guppy My autism journey isn't about waiting for the storm to pass, it's about learning to dance in the rain.... Texas Autism Advocacy: www.TexasAutismAdvoTexas Au " There are some aspects of a person's life that we have no right to compromise. We cannot negotiate the size of an institution. No one should live in one. We cannot debate who should get an inclusive education. Everyone should. We cannot determine who does and who does not get the right to make their own choices and forge their own futures. All must. " Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.