Guest guest Posted August 27, 2001 Report Share Posted August 27, 2001 - I can only tell you about our own experience. Our son, who just turned 4 in June, has been chelating (DMSA only, 3 days on 4 days off) for almost a year now (in October). He has made such tremendous gains. He still has Speech Therapy, Occupational Therapy, and individual Developmental Therapy, and I know that we still have a long road ahead of us, but just to get him to the point where he's at now in such a short period of time has made us very happy and completely amazed all of his therapists. His OT and At-Home Therapist have both commented on what incredible gains he's made in such a short span of time compared to the average amount of time their patients with autism take. His OT has been so impressed by his fast progress that she has asked if she can tell parents of other kids about chelation therapy and if she can refer them to us to find out how to get started. It has even gotten to the point now, because I have gone off on my soapbox about how much these metals are hurting our kids and where they're getting them from, that his OT has actually been recommending that people not have their kids vaccinated unless they personally read the ingredients for the vial and it says no mercury. Our son isn't talking yet, but he is trying now, and he wasn't even doing that since his autism set in. He used to speak in 4 to 5 word sentences, and then he lost all language. He is becoming more social, and actually wanting to play with other kids now. He is very sweet and loving (always has been), and even when he's stimming, you can see him look out the corner of his eye at you if he hears his name mentioned in conversation. Evening the playing field is definitely a big thing, don't underestimate how important it is. If you haven't had your child tested already, I urge you to do so, because the sooner you get started, the sooner your child is going to get to that evened playing field. Please keep us posted. Kris askeralkris@... [ ] Expectations > Hi, > > I'm new to this group (and new to chelation, 3rd round DMSA only) so > please forgive me if this is a tired and/or painful subject here, but > I'd really appreciate more experienced parents' insights. > > What result do we expect from the successful chelation of an autistic > child? > > I read in this group's FAQ that we know of no child who has yet > been " cured " of autism by chelation. It seems to me that even if, for > a given child, mercury is the problem and chelation is the solution, > and this biomedical intervention (and/or others) is a complete > success, you still don't get a " cured " or " normal " child out the > other end, because years of normal development have still been > missed. The earth only spins in one direction, and the best we can > achieve is for our kids to go forward on a better less-impaired > basis, having more normal sensory and cognitive experiences of the > world. Put another way, the best we can do is level the playing > field, so that ABA or floortime or whatever educational and > behavioral therapies our kids get, have a better chance to take hold > and work. Maybe (I hope!) after successful chelation PLUS some > interval of catch-up time enhanced by educational/behavioral therapy, > a kid could meet the Young Autism Project definition of recovery > (functioning at grade level without special support, and > indistinguishable from peers in a group evaluation by a psychologist > blind to which kid had autism). Is this a plausible goal? > > Prior to starting chelation my four-year-old son has had over a year > of 40-hour/week ABA and almost two years of individual speech > therapy. (He's also been on the GFCF diet about a year, and he did > get better at the outset of the diet.) All these interventions have > the quality (seems to me) of pushing a rope uphill. We are fortunate > to have outstanding skilled and peristent people working with him, > and to their credit they've gotten a whole lot of rope a long way up > the hill, but I don't know that you can ever rebuild a child's mind > completely by pushing information in there. The change we've seen > with chelation is a marked increase in spontaneous language, > curiosity, improvisation, mischievousness, and general desire to pull > in the world -- and THAT, combined with ongoing ABA and speech, are > how I hope we're going to get this child to the goal one day. > > Any comments? > > Thanks > > > > > > ======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 28, 2001 Report Share Posted August 28, 2001 Dear , Hello, and welcome to the list. >I'm new to this group (and new to chelation, 3rd round DMSA only) so >please forgive me if this is a tired and/or painful subject here, but >I'd really appreciate more experienced parents' insights. I don't qualify as a parent (I have no kids) but shall go ahead and tell you my opinion anyhow. (I'm doing chelation on myself, and have been hanging around here for about a year.) >What result do we expect from the successful chelation of an autistic >child? Generally I would say, expect improvement. But you already know that--- you have a kid who is improving! >I read in this group's FAQ that we know of no child who has yet >been " cured " of autism by chelation. I think the text you mention is not as helpful as it could be. I would say that chelation leads to " significant progress " for MANY children with ASD. Your mileage will vary. I am certain I have read a couple of accounts of kids who no longer meet the " criteria " for the dx of autism. However, what you should expect is an adventure! That is, it is unknown how much improvement will occur. Also, as your post suggests, " cure " may not be the most relevant concept for measuring progress. > Maybe (I hope!) after successful chelation PLUS some >interval of catch-up time enhanced by educational/behavioral therapy, >a kid could meet the Young Autism Project definition of recovery >(functioning at grade level without special support, and >indistinguishable from peers in a group evaluation by a psychologist >blind to which kid had autism). Is this a plausible goal? I think it is a possible outcome.... and you may as well hope for this or something better. Hoping for the best certainly keeps ones spirits up, and hoping for the best is a practical thing to do. The " tricky bit " is to have these hopes while not getting too carried away with the hopes, and while knowing that chelation takes a long time. It can be sort of a rollercoaster what with hoping for the best while not knowing how long to keep hoping, maybe not seeing progress, and a lot of waiting. (I say that from experience: I experience my hopes and waiting as pretty taxing at times.) > The change we've seen >with chelation is a marked increase in spontaneous language, >curiosity, improvisation, mischievousness, and general desire to pull >in the world -- and THAT, combined with ongoing ABA and speech, are >how I hope we're going to get this child to the goal one day. How wonderful! That's after 3 rounds? THAT SOUNDS GREAT. Since you said you are new, I'll include some recommended reading--- these relate to the issue of progress seen by others, and I hope you can use them as inspiration and information: /files/KennysProgressReportsFrom I love 's collection for a number of reasons, including that it has lots of " the bad side " along with the " good side " of the results they have seen with Kenny. I also love that is includes some of her doubt and uncertainty as to whether the chelation was the cause of early improvements they saw. http://www.healing-arts.org/children/holmes.htm#results This is info on the results seen so far with Dr. Amy's patients. They report only on those who have been " at it " for a while. /files/LOVE_LETTERS Progress reports and commentary on progress, from the people on this list. All success to you & your son. best regards, Moria [doing chelation on mySELF: ALA only; I'm on round 15.] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 28, 2001 Report Share Posted August 28, 2001 Hi there, Expect to see major improvements to recovery. Our daughter is recovered - been chealating for over a year. We are about to test on wedneday to see if there are any more metals coming out. Feel free to e-mail me privately for details. Weatherman6001. We have a large support group in our area where all the parents are chealating their children and all seeing results! Jane Weatherman Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 28, 2001 Report Share Posted August 28, 2001 > Hi, > > I'm new to this group (and new to chelation, 3rd round DMSA only) so > please forgive me if this is a tired and/or painful subject here, but > I'd really appreciate more experienced parents' insights. > > What result do we expect from the successful chelation of an autistic > child? > > I read in this group's FAQ that we know of no child who has yet > been " cured " of autism by chelation. Actually I recall a few mentions of children ceasing to meet the diagnostic criteria, which is a " cure " in a technical sense. They were still not normal, however. >It seems to me that even if, for > a given child, mercury is the problem and chelation is the solution, > and this biomedical intervention (and/or others) is a complete > success, you still don't get a " cured " or " normal " child out the > other end, because years of normal development have still been > missed. The earth only spins in one direction, and the best we can > achieve is for our kids to go forward on a better less-impaired > basis, having more normal sensory and cognitive experiences of the > world. Chelating makes the brain work right. Then use APPROPRIATE therapies, like vision therapy, auditory integration training, sensory integration therapy, etc. to give them a more normal sensory experience of the world (this does not happen with many of the other therapies). Once their cognition and perception are normalized, they will pick the rest up just fine. If these are not normalized, all the other therapies in the world will never manage to make them " normal. " >Put another way, the best we can do is level the playing > field, so that ABA or floortime or whatever educational and > behavioral therapies our kids get, have a better chance to take hold > and work. Maybe (I hope!) after successful chelation PLUS some > interval of catch-up time enhanced by educational/behavioral therapy, > a kid could meet the Young Autism Project definition of recovery > (functioning at grade level without special support, and > indistinguishable from peers in a group evaluation by a psychologist > blind to which kid had autism). Is this a plausible goal? > > Prior to starting chelation my four-year-old son has had over a year > of 40-hour/week ABA and almost two years of individual speech > therapy. (He's also been on the GFCF diet about a year, and he did > get better at the outset of the diet.) All these interventions have > the quality (seems to me) of pushing a rope uphill. We are fortunate > to have outstanding skilled and peristent people working with him, > and to their credit they've gotten a whole lot of rope a long way up > the hill, but I don't know that you can ever rebuild a child's mind > completely by pushing information in there. The change we've seen > with chelation is a marked increase in spontaneous language, > curiosity, improvisation, mischievousness, and general desire to pull > in the world -- and THAT, combined with ongoing ABA and speech, are > how I hope we're going to get this child to the goal one day. > > Any comments? > > Thank Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 29, 2001 Report Share Posted August 29, 2001 Dear Jane, Thanks for this encouraging news (and the following longer post you also sent). I am very curious about the support group that you go to. Could you say a little more about this: how many parents/families are in the group? Where is it located? Did the people join with the intent to learn about chelation, or was the group focused more broadly on autism, then it moved towards chelation? Are there some members who are not interested in chelating? Thanks for any answers you may wish to share. This just sounds novel and wonderful to me. Moria At 05:27 PM 8/28/2001 EDT, you wrote: >Hi there, > >Expect to see major improvements to recovery. Our daughter is recovered - >been chealating for over a year. We are about to test on wedneday to see if >there are any more metals coming out. Feel free to e-mail me privately for >details. Weatherman6001. We have a large support group in our area where >all the parents are chealating their children and all seeing results! > > Jane Weatherman Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 29, 2001 Report Share Posted August 29, 2001 My thanks to everyone who replied to this post. You have really reinforced my desire to aim high with my son. Although we have a terrifying rate of autism here in Southern California (my previous school district had 22 diagnosed preschoolers out of a cohort of about 600) chelation seems to be brand new. I go to a couple different parents' support groups and nobody but me has heard of it, so they give me the hairy eyeball. I think there is widespread emotional fatigue among parents who have tried a whole series of " fad cures " unsuccessfully. I also think we parents each have to find our own way in dealing with this tragedy upon our children and families, and I wouldn't judge or criticize a parent who makes different choices than my husband and I do. Having said all that, it's WONDERFUL to find some more parents out there whose chosen method of coping DOES include trying to FIX THE PROBLEM and not just endure its consequences. God bless the Internet, and you guys are terrific. Thanks, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 29, 2001 Report Share Posted August 29, 2001 Wow, Jane! Are you fortunate or what! We've been chelating for a year, and are still only getting out small amounts of mercury, and trying to get that arsenic down. Also starting to pull uranium at higher levels. I'm so glad for you, really! Every child that is recovered is such a JOY, and a witness to what has been done to our kids! Blessings to all the little ones in your neighborhood, and good work! Barb Re: [ ] Re: Expectations >Hi there, > >Expect to see major improvements to recovery. Our daughter is recovered - >been chealating for over a year. We are about to test on wedneday to see if >there are any more metals coming out. Feel free to e-mail me privately for >details. Weatherman6001. We have a large support group in our area where >all the parents are chealating their children and all seeing results! > > Jane Weatherman > > >======================================================= > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 29, 2001 Report Share Posted August 29, 2001 Dear , I hope you are very successful (you sure are so far!) and then you can spread the message to other people Your non- judgement will go far in helping you with this. I think it is much more effective if you do not judge. If you tell people what they are doing is wrong, they are unlikely to hear anything else after that! I try to remember that I AVOIDED learning about mercury poisoning for years (I did not want to even THINK about anything that would involve dental work!) I remind myself this as a reminder to have compassion for others who are ill and doubtful. It is very understandable, as is the fatigue and doubt you cite. best, Moria At 03:03 PM 8/29/2001 -0000, you wrote: >My thanks to everyone who replied to this post. You have really >reinforced my desire to aim high with my son. > >Although we have a terrifying rate of autism here in Southern >California (my previous school district had 22 diagnosed preschoolers >out of a cohort of about 600) chelation seems to be brand new. I go >to a couple different parents' support groups and nobody but me has >heard of it, so they give me the hairy eyeball. I think there is >widespread emotional fatigue among parents who have tried a whole >series of " fad cures " unsuccessfully. I also think we parents each >have to find our own way in dealing with this tragedy upon our >children and families, and I wouldn't judge or criticize a parent who >makes different choices than my husband and I do. Having said all >that, it's WONDERFUL to find some more parents out there whose chosen >method of coping DOES include trying to FIX THE PROBLEM and not just >endure its consequences. God bless the Internet, and you guys are >terrific. > >Thanks, > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 29, 2001 Report Share Posted August 29, 2001 , Where in southern CA are you? Im in San Diego, would love to get a support group going here for parents with children chelating! God Bless... (Luke's Mom 4.5yrs old) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 30, 2001 Report Share Posted August 30, 2001 > I go to a couple different parents' support groups and nobody but >me has heard of it, so they give me the hairy eyeball. I think there >is widespread emotional fatigue among parents who have tried a whole >series of " fad cures " unsuccessfully. I also think we parents each >have to find our own way in dealing with this tragedy upon our >children and families, and I wouldn't judge or criticize a parent >who makes different choices than my husband and I do. Having said >all that, it's WONDERFUL to find some more parents out there whose >chosen method of coping DOES include trying to FIX THE PROBLEM and >not just endure its consequences. God bless the Internet, and you >guys are terrific. > > Thanks, > > I second that ! I get the hairy eyeball (LOVE that saying) everywhere but here too. That's why I no longer tell anyone but you guys what we are doing anymore. I think I've become the crazy/ desperate mother to everyone because they don't care to learn about the underlying turmoil going on inside my baby's body. Sincerely, Kaye Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 How do you know that I what I have is definately an infection -- a bone infection? > > Hi ALL > I'm sorry to if I sounded harsh, it was FRUSTRATION that the > job wasn't done correctly that got me a lit bit annoyed with the way > your sample was handled. Imagine the loss of a finger due to bad > pathology IMO. > I'm also so proud of BArb who addressed her inflammation/infection > aggresively and now is growing stronger bones. A very important part > of healing the body is to be able to do everything everyone else > that's normal does- eat everything- go into dusty emnvronments that > would normally make you ill-basically you can't hide behind your > finger, these are very serious problems that need the best science and > the longer you leave the problem the worse you can get IMO. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 Cause I do microbiology- and the fact that they reported nothing grew- tells me that the 'coagulase negative staph' in the area that they alway's ignore (unless told otherwise) is a strong bacteria as it doesn't allow anything else to grow. I had fibromyalgia and my fingers swelled and I cut both my rings of due to the extreme discomfort. Your also the MRSA carrier if I'm not wrong- or was it someone else. > > > > Hi ALL > > I'm sorry to if I sounded harsh, it was FRUSTRATION that > the > > job wasn't done correctly that got me a lit bit annoyed with the way > > your sample was handled. Imagine the loss of a finger due to bad > > pathology IMO. > > I'm also so proud of BArb who addressed her inflammation/infection > > aggresively and now is growing stronger bones. A very important part > > of healing the body is to be able to do everything everyone else > > that's normal does- eat everything- go into dusty emnvronments that > > would normally make you ill-basically you can't hide behind your > > finger, these are very serious problems that need the best science > and > > the longer you leave the problem the worse you can get IMO. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 I have no idea what an MRSA carrier is -- so it must be someone else. > > > > > > Hi ALL > > > I'm sorry to if I sounded harsh, it was FRUSTRATION > that > > the > > > job wasn't done correctly that got me a lit bit annoyed with the > way > > > your sample was handled. Imagine the loss of a finger due to bad > > > pathology IMO. > > > I'm also so proud of BArb who addressed her > inflammation/infection > > > aggresively and now is growing stronger bones. A very important > part > > > of healing the body is to be able to do everything everyone else > > > that's normal does- eat everything- go into dusty emnvronments > that > > > would normally make you ill-basically you can't hide behind > your > > > finger, these are very serious problems that need the best > science > > and > > > the longer you leave the problem the worse you can get IMO. > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 , don't get offended. Take what you can use, ignore the rest. Tony is an amateur microbiologist who cured himself with testing and treating the organisms that most everyone ignores. He believes, based on lots of experience, that just about every illness is caused by an infection of some sort. The fact that your joint is inflamed is evidence enough for him. Whether he's right or wrong, I've read that gout of finger joints can be linked to arthritis, and there's a school of thought that says arthritis is an inflammatory reaction to a bacterial infection. It's certainly the case with me. There's also a link between uric acid and fibromyalgia, which I also believe is, in most cases, caused by infection. It's also coincidental that a few months ago, Tony was advocating that people should experiment with gout medication as an antimicrobial. He was finding success with it in his petri dish and friends who were using it. I'm personally interested in what's going on with your finger as I AM diagnosed with chronic osteomyelitis and also worry that my right toe isn't quite right and have had a nagging feeling that I may devevlop gout there some day. It almost always feels cold, a little numbish, and just very slightly painful. It became very painful for a short time after I started Benicar for it's antiinflammatory effects. My toe, and both arches became extremely painful (another sign of gout) and then cleared up, except for the slightly odd sensation in my right toe which continues. The point is, don't worry about personalities, just process the info and see if it makes any sense for your situation. Tony's only speaking out of concern, as is everyone here. He's frustrated with the medical system that is so negligent in its care. He has taken a lot of time to try to answer your questions out of his concern for you. Nobody's going to agree with everything. He and I certainly disagree often, but it doesn't make me respect him or his experience any less. penny > > How do you know that I what I have is definately an infection -- a > bone infection? > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 Methicillin resistant staph. I thought it was you too. But I think it was actually ? Both of you were posting a lot at the same time. penny > > I have no idea what an MRSA carrier is -- so it must be someone else. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 Penny There's a lot of energy that goes into trying to inform people to get there cultures right, we have mentioned this on a 100 plus occasions.When someone comes back and tells us there's no growth after 2 weeks- you yourself a witness of many, many of your own and friends cultures, surely you must feel the frustration of another oppurtunity missed in getting these ilnesses put into perspective. We actually gave tips recently to change the wording to deep wound in a culture sample so that a truer picture of what may be there is reported. Sorry but this is not exciting when you just got moved away from a diagnosis into a holding pattern(gout) that may last many years.. tony > > > > How do you know that I what I have is definately an infection -- a > > bone infection? > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2006 Report Share Posted May 22, 2006 Yeah, I do understand the frustration. It's been years and nothing much seems to change. Over at another site on CFS I kind of went off the deep end after reading yet another post like hundreds I've seen before where somebody's created a page "explaining" CFS and the most important factors that need treatment. It's nothing but the same old recycled opinions being taken as gospel just because they're repeated over and over. Conventional wisdom that's been around for what seems like a hundred years. Deficiencies, viruses, mercury, etc. It feels like 1996 instead of 2006. Most of the time, because it's such an exhausting battle, it seems like all I can do is give up until someone finally comes along and makes the breakthrough of all breakthroughs. If we live that long. Other times I get frustrated enough to take matters into my own hands, which is what' I've been feeling lately. Because I'm tired of so many sick people being neglected. That's why I want to create a non profit, and raise the funds to hire some respected researchers to test pwcs for all kinds of microbes along with their resistances and sensitivities. Leaving no organism out. Then we'll publish the data and look for trends so people can see what's really going on here. And we'll finally be able to get the specific treatments we need, based on what we've been infected with. Not based on guesswork or apathy. penny dumbaussie2000 <dumbaussie2000@...> wrote: PennyThere's a lot of energy that goes into trying to inform people to get there cultures right, we have mentioned this on a 100 plus occasions.When someone comes back and tells us there's no growth after 2 weeks- you yourself a witness of many, many of your own and friends cultures, surely you must feel the frustration of another oppurtunity missed in getting these ilnesses put into perspective.We actually gave tips recently to change the wording to deep wound in a culture sample so that a truer picture of what may be there is reported. Sorry but this is not exciting when you just got moved away from a diagnosis into a holding pattern(gout) that may last many years..tony> >> > How do you know that I what I have is definately an infection -- a > > bone infection? > >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 > It's also coincidental that a few months ago, Tony was advocating > that people should experiment with gout medication as an > antimicrobial. He was finding success with it in his petri dish and > friends who were using it. > This may be why Dr. St Amand found that various gout medications seemed to all help his patients with fibromyalgia. He came up with a different theory to explain it, which isn't generally accepted, but obviously these medications do help some people. Does guaifenesin do anything to bacteria in a petri dish? It's only weakly a gout medication, I think. It's been a while since I read that stuff because it wasn't helpful for me. - Kate Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 Kate Guai is targeting the bacteria/slime and it's adhesion properties > > > It's also coincidental that a few months ago, Tony was advocating > > that people should experiment with gout medication as an > > antimicrobial. He was finding success with it in his petri dish and > > friends who were using it. > > > > This may be why Dr. St Amand found that various gout medications > seemed to all help his patients with fibromyalgia. He came up with a > different theory to explain it, which isn't generally accepted, but > obviously these medications do help some people. Does guaifenesin do > anything to bacteria in a petri dish? It's only weakly a gout > medication, I think. It's been a while since I read that stuff > because it wasn't helpful for me. > > - Kate > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 That's a good question. Tony have you ever tested guaifenisen on microbes? In the files section there's an analysis of guaifenisen called "Truths & Myths" by Mark London. You can access it here: http://web.mit.edu/london/www/guai.html I was really surprised to learn that not only does it thin mucous, it's an analgesic (pain reliever), a blood thinner, and a muscle relaxer. It's been used for centuries for various ailments. Guai comes from tree bark, as aspirin does. Aspirin, and many bark derived meds seem to have some antimicrobial properties. I'd been using it for mucous thinning and there is a noticeable effect on pain. Tony, if you can, why don't you test it out, see what happens? penny Kate <KateDunlay@...> wrote: > It's also coincidental that a few months ago, Tony was advocating> that people should experiment with gout medication as an> antimicrobial. He was finding success with it in his petri dish and> friends who were using it.>This may be why Dr. St Amand found that various gout medications seemed to all help his patients with fibromyalgia. He came up with a different theory to explain it, which isn't generally accepted, but obviously these medications do help some people. Does guaifenesin do anything to bacteria in a petri dish? It's only weakly a gout medication, I think. It's been a while since I read that stuff because it wasn't helpful for me.- Kate Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 I think you may be onto something with the quai and slime theory. I'd kind of forgotten about it, but think I'll start taking it again. I definitely notice less of the infection taste coming from around my teeth when I take guai. It definitely has helped thin mucous when I needed it. pennydumbaussie2000 <dumbaussie2000@...> wrote: Kate Guai is targeting the bacteria/slime and it's adhesion properties>> > It's also coincidental that a few months ago, Tony was advocating> > that people should experiment with gout medication as an> > antimicrobial. He was finding success with it in his petri dish and> > friends who were using it.> >> > This may be why Dr. St Amand found that various gout medications > seemed to all help his patients with fibromyalgia. He came up with a > different theory to explain it, which isn't generally accepted, but > obviously these medications do help some people. Does guaifenesin do > anything to bacteria in a petri dish? It's only weakly a gout > medication, I think. It's been a while since I read that stuff > because it wasn't helpful for me.> > - Kate> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 Penny The only way it comes is in a mainly high sugary syrup which is sort of antibacterial on it's own - Not too many things grow on christmas puddings that are high in sugar. There's some preservative aspects of high sugar in use in many domnestic recipes for many years that make a test of this sort a little odd. tony > > It's also coincidental that a few months ago, Tony was advocating > > that people should experiment with gout medication as an > > antimicrobial. He was finding success with it in his petri dish and > > friends who were using it. > > > > This may be why Dr. St Amand found that various gout medications > seemed to all help his patients with fibromyalgia. He came up with a > different theory to explain it, which isn't generally accepted, but > obviously these medications do help some people. Does guaifenesin do > anything to bacteria in a petri dish? It's only weakly a gout > medication, I think. It's been a while since I read that stuff > because it wasn't helpful for me. > > - Kate > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Share Posted May 23, 2006 Ah shucks, I had a large container of the powdered pure stuff. Probably I threw it away, as it was a few years ago. - Kate On May 23, 2006, at 3:51 AM, dumbaussie2000 wrote: > Penny > The only way it comes is in a mainly high sugary syrup which is sort > of antibacterial on it's own - Not too many things grow on christmas > puddings that are high in sugar. There's some preservative aspects > of high sugar in use in many domnestic recipes for many years that > make a test of this sort a little odd. > tony Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Share Posted October 4, 2006 Les, you're asking a question that can't be answered. When my mother got RA in the mid 60's, Darvon was the only medicine offered to her. She was terribly disfigured and in constant pain. I guess her death was a good thing because she didn't have to suffer any more. My RA showed up in 1990, and I could enjoy a few meds that had been developed. I was home-bound for over 2 years and bed-ridden for 1 year. Now, I'm better most of the time but still fight the flares occasionally. My mother and 3 of her sisters had RA, but my 5 siblings haven't a bit of pain except from getting older. We can't guess what RA will do to you. You have to have faith that at some point, a med will come to you that will do as best it can for control of your own personal RA. It's different for all of us, but still the same overall. Good luck to you. Dennis in Eastexas " It's not Rocket Surgery " [ ] expectations > Hi everyone, > > I have another question that I am sure has already been addressed, but > since I'm relatively new here I wanted to ask about expectations. I > am now 5 weeks post MTX injection treatments since being diagnosed > with RA 8 weeks ago. > > Can anyone let me know what my expectations should be with regard to > pain relief and relief from stiffness as well. After sitting for > periods of time, I get up and I feel like I'm 90 years old. This is > true after rising in the mornings after sleeping. Will I get complete > pain free? I know that there may be periods of flare ups, but so far, > I have had no evidence of anything. No real improvement, and > certainly no pain relief. It may be helping as far as medically goes > in prevention of erosion, but that's something I can't determine > without the doctor doing tests, etc. I basically want to know if I > have better days ahead, or if I am to expect continual pain from here > on out. > > Thanks, > > Les Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2006 Report Share Posted October 5, 2006 Hi everyone: I too (like Les) have just recently been diagnosed with RA, although I have suffered for years with joint and muscle pain. As a kid I was shspitalized twice cause the docs thought I had JRA. However, in the " dark ages " they weren't able to diagnose it. At the moment, I am on MTX and folic acid. I got some relief from the pain during the time I was on prednisone, but am now not on it. Thanks God for hot tubs! Anyway, what can we expect as newly diagnosed as far as pain relief. Fortunately, I have some Hydrocodone from a previous shoulder injury and I am currently using that when the pain is too bad. Is there something out there that any would recommend. Also, do you all find that the pain roams around your body on a daily basis? For instance, sometimes my hips are on fire, and then the next day, it might be my elbows. My father and all his brothers had the same time, we just joked and called it " smithitis " . They probably had RA too! I really appreciate any input. I know the rest of the newbies will too. Thanks a million, Vicki Hi everyone, > > I have another question that I am sure has already been addressed, but > since I'm relatively new here I wanted to ask about expectations. I > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.