Guest guest Posted June 13, 2008 Report Share Posted June 13, 2008 Yes.. I feel the same as Carol. I know that she is not just going to sit in the chair all day and mentally rot. She can color, play with toys or watch signing times. She likes to work her puzzle while they are in " school" It helps to teach her that there is a quite learning time. Steph [DownSyndromeInfoEx change] HomeschoolingTo: DownSyndromeInfoExc hange@yahoogroup s.comDate: Thursday, June 12, 2008, 5:59 AM I homeschool three of my kids but not Nicolas (DS) at this point. I do think about it at times and my thoughts are going that way again. But the reason it didn't work before was I just couldn't keep him constructively occupied when I worked with my other kids. The oldest is pretty independent but the middle two have learning disabilities themselves and so take some time. Nicolas just doesn't sit for seatwork long, and when I work with the other kids, he will be creating mayhem, getting into things. It has been so hard for him to find toys that he will engage with, other than Mr. Potato Head.As someone mentioned, it almost seems easier to me to homeschool than to battle the school for everything but I would have to at least get my oldest son working more independently. It still seems a long way in the future!a____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ __ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2008 Report Share Posted June 16, 2008 Thank you ette, I need to reword my words. I do not restrain Amber all the time. I have used it. She does like to be buckled in but she asks me to do it. Mostly because she sees me doing it with the younger kids. For those that do not know I babysit. She has always wanted to sit in the high Chair type seats. And when I have done it ,( buckle her in) is for time outs, or for her safety Or Because she wanted me too and would not take no for an answer. She uses the chairs now. Because they give her a better view at the table. My chairs are at the kitchen table all the time. So if she is not in the chair , she will sit on the table. She does not like sitting in the regular chair because she can not see. And it is hard for her to write. We don't sit in them for hrs. & hrs. She can get out if she wants. She is not always buckled in. At first when she was younger I did. Everyone has there points of view. I feel I have and am doing what is right for my child. I may take the easy road here and there. But who ever said this was an easy journey we are on. Carol P Subject: [sPAM]Re: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Now restraints- was Homeschooling (Carol)To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Date: Monday, June 16, 2008, 8:04 AM I wasn't going to say anything, but I would like to point out something for any who are wondering if this is the "norm" to teach children with DS. Faith is now 10 and will sit for quite some time, at school, at home, at a restaurant, or theater. I thought this might never happen! She has not been in a restrained seat for teaching since I told her speech therapist I didn't like that and changed therapists (Faith was 5). Yes, it was a challange to get her to this point without restraining her. But, I think young children learn more when they can explore their environment. Also, I think children with DS reach some of these exploration milestones later than other children. So, Faith was probably not ready to sit and learn until she was 7 or 8, when many typical children can sit and learn at 5 or 6.JMHOette> > From: a Mesa <marya.mesa@ gmail. com>> Subject: [DownSyndromeInfoEx change] Homeschooling> To: DownSyndromeInfoExc hange@yahoogroup s.com> Date: Thursday, June 12, 2008, 5:59 AM> > > I homeschool three of my kids but not Nicolas (DS) at this point. I do think about it at times and my thoughts are going that way again. But the reason it didn't work before was I just couldn't keep him constructively occupied when I worked with my other kids. The oldest is pretty independent but the middle two have learning disabilities themselves and so take some time. > > Nicolas just doesn't sit for seatwork long, and when I work with the other kids, he will be creating mayhem, getting into things. It has been so hard for him to find toys that he will engage with, other than Mr. Potato Head.> > As someone mentioned, it almost seems easier to me to homeschool than to battle the school for everything but I would have to at least get my oldest son working more independently. It still seems a long way in the future!> > a> > > ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ __> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2008 Report Share Posted June 16, 2008 My daughter is 12 yrs old and has Down Syndrome along with sensory problems and autistic behaviors. Not a true diagnosis of autism yet. We have just bought a larger stroller for her after many years of trying to be age appropriate. My daughter developmentally is not 12 and due to the sensory problems in new places and large noisy activities will shut down which includes dropping to the floor and will not get up. I absolutely cannot pick her up when she is in this mode. I had her sit down on me in the middle of traffic and thank God! my husband was nearby and could come pick her up. We will use a stroller or wheelchair or whatever because she feels safe there and will participate with her family. She is not restrained and we would praise any efforts she makes to walk with us. We try social stories, pictures of where we are going, rewards and sometimes it works but most often not. We came to the choice of her staying home or providing her with something that makes her feel safe. To us the choice of her not being with us was not acceptable. I post this just to show another side of the story. I know how often we have felt alone in this situation. Thanks, Carla > I agree with both of you guys and I too fired a ST when she would strap > into the swing at 2 years old!! Egads..... who's going to learn > to speak when all you want to do is get out and play, and at 2, that is > age appropriate behavior and a good therapists is going to work with their > natural tendencies. > > And when she was school aged, again, that is not age appropriate to buckle > someone in or have them ride in a stroller to keep them contained. Riding > in the stroller for a bit if they are tired, is OK and all my kids have > done that, but they have the power to get out if they want to and I expect > them to listen to me and not go wandering off. > I have the same age appropriate expectations for her, though trust me, it > was NOT EASY. For a few *years* shopping with her, was all about her > learning to stick with me and I did very little shopping for me or anyone > else for that matter. Same at school when she moves from classroom to > classroom or they went on field trips. > > Sitting is another work in progress and a team effort as well. You get > them to do it by making sitting the favorable activity at the moment and > not rewarding them by allowing them to go off and play.You also have to > work up to it and build in breaks to make it successful. When you see they > are tired of sitting, have them run some kind of errand and then come back > to sitting and make sure you have something interesting and fun to come > back to. For them to learn the behavior, it really has to be an internal > lesson or something they do of their free will and not because they have > no choice in the matter. > > Now I can get her to sit just because I said so with out ANY thing fun to > do. That has been quite the challenge, but we did it by offering her > something in the future, like Kathy did with the reward of going to see > the the toys. > > Sometimes what *we* view as mis-behavior is really the child asserting > their independence. Danny wanting to look at the toys is the perfect > example. All kids that age love to go and check out all the toys and have > that freedom. Last week while at the Playhouse, was telling her > teacher about the new clothes we had just bought for her and all of a > sudden she ran outside to the car to get the bag of them and bring them > in. We of course had an attack, but honestly, how appropriate for a 2nd > grader to do that!!! Wanting to go and run 'with the pack' of kids in the > neighborhood is the challenge this year. > > The tricky part comes when age appropriate meets DD and the person is > willing and wanting, but not always able to do it totally on their own > safely. That's when you have to sometimes allow for failure and find > accommodations to allow the child to do what other kid's their age do too. > > Interesting discussion!!! > > > > Carol in IL > > AIM doihavtasay1 GigaTribe doihavtasay > Mom to seven including , 7 with TOF, AVcanal, GERD, LS, Asthma, > subglottal stenosis, and DS. > > My problem is not how I look. It's how you see me. > > > Join our Down Syndrome information group - > http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/DownSyndromeInfoExchange/ > > Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace.com/vennamusic > > > > [sPAM]Re: [DownSyndromeInfoEx change] Now restraints- was > Homeschooling (Carol) > > I wasn't going to say anything, but I would > like to point out > something for any who are wondering if this is the " norm " to teach > children with DS. Faith is now 10 and will sit for quite some time, > at school, at home, at a restaurant, or theater. I thought this might > never happen! She has not been in a restrained seat for teaching > since I told her speech therapist I didn't like that and changed > therapists (Faith was 5). Yes, it was a challange to get her to this > point without restraining her. But, I think young children learn more > when they can explore their environment. Also, I think children with > DS reach some of these exploration milestones later than other > children. So, Faith was probably not ready to sit and learn until she > was 7 or 8, when many typical children can sit and learn at 5 or 6. > JMHO > ette > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 16, 2008 Report Share Posted June 16, 2008 My daughter is 12 yrs old and has Down Syndrome along with sensory problems and autistic behaviors. Not a true diagnosis of autism yet. We have just bought a larger stroller for her after many years of trying to be age appropriate. My daughter developmentally is not 12 and due to the sensory problems in new places and large noisy activities will shut down which includes dropping to the floor and will not get up. I absolutely cannot pick her up when she is in this mode. I had her sit down on me in the middle of traffic and thank God! my husband was nearby and could come pick her up. We will use a stroller or wheelchair or whatever because she feels safe there and will participate with her family. She is not restrained and we would praise any efforts she makes to walk with us. We try social stories, pictures of where we are going, rewards and sometimes it works but most often not. We came to the choice of her staying home or providing her with something that makes her feel safe. To us the choice of her not being with us was not acceptable. I post this just to show another side of the story. I know how often we have felt alone in this situation. Thanks, Carla > I agree with both of you guys and I too fired a ST when she would strap > into the swing at 2 years old!! Egads..... who's going to learn > to speak when all you want to do is get out and play, and at 2, that is > age appropriate behavior and a good therapists is going to work with their > natural tendencies. > > And when she was school aged, again, that is not age appropriate to buckle > someone in or have them ride in a stroller to keep them contained. Riding > in the stroller for a bit if they are tired, is OK and all my kids have > done that, but they have the power to get out if they want to and I expect > them to listen to me and not go wandering off. > I have the same age appropriate expectations for her, though trust me, it > was NOT EASY. For a few *years* shopping with her, was all about her > learning to stick with me and I did very little shopping for me or anyone > else for that matter. Same at school when she moves from classroom to > classroom or they went on field trips. > > Sitting is another work in progress and a team effort as well. You get > them to do it by making sitting the favorable activity at the moment and > not rewarding them by allowing them to go off and play.You also have to > work up to it and build in breaks to make it successful. When you see they > are tired of sitting, have them run some kind of errand and then come back > to sitting and make sure you have something interesting and fun to come > back to. For them to learn the behavior, it really has to be an internal > lesson or something they do of their free will and not because they have > no choice in the matter. > > Now I can get her to sit just because I said so with out ANY thing fun to > do. That has been quite the challenge, but we did it by offering her > something in the future, like Kathy did with the reward of going to see > the the toys. > > Sometimes what *we* view as mis-behavior is really the child asserting > their independence. Danny wanting to look at the toys is the perfect > example. All kids that age love to go and check out all the toys and have > that freedom. Last week while at the Playhouse, was telling her > teacher about the new clothes we had just bought for her and all of a > sudden she ran outside to the car to get the bag of them and bring them > in. We of course had an attack, but honestly, how appropriate for a 2nd > grader to do that!!! Wanting to go and run 'with the pack' of kids in the > neighborhood is the challenge this year. > > The tricky part comes when age appropriate meets DD and the person is > willing and wanting, but not always able to do it totally on their own > safely. That's when you have to sometimes allow for failure and find > accommodations to allow the child to do what other kid's their age do too. > > Interesting discussion!!! > > > > Carol in IL > > AIM doihavtasay1 GigaTribe doihavtasay > Mom to seven including , 7 with TOF, AVcanal, GERD, LS, Asthma, > subglottal stenosis, and DS. > > My problem is not how I look. It's how you see me. > > > Join our Down Syndrome information group - > http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/DownSyndromeInfoExchange/ > > Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace.com/vennamusic > > > > [sPAM]Re: [DownSyndromeInfoEx change] Now restraints- was > Homeschooling (Carol) > > I wasn't going to say anything, but I would > like to point out > something for any who are wondering if this is the " norm " to teach > children with DS. Faith is now 10 and will sit for quite some time, > at school, at home, at a restaurant, or theater. I thought this might > never happen! She has not been in a restrained seat for teaching > since I told her speech therapist I didn't like that and changed > therapists (Faith was 5). Yes, it was a challange to get her to this > point without restraining her. But, I think young children learn more > when they can explore their environment. Also, I think children with > DS reach some of these exploration milestones later than other > children. So, Faith was probably not ready to sit and learn until she > was 7 or 8, when many typical children can sit and learn at 5 or 6. > JMHO > ette > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 Carla, There are always exceptions and kids who have extenuating circumstances, and each child has their moments when they are just not able to do what they might not be able to do what they could at another time. I am sure we have all been there, done that. I have certainly had to remove from situations where she was just not able to handle it due to being tired, stressed or just plain over stimulated.No one is judging anyone, we are simply having a conversation about your garden variety kid with DS. It's often assumed that is some how more capable than others, and it bugs me cause she is not. It took a few *years* to get her to even remotely stay with us while out shopping. We still have our days. I think what we are talking about is a difference in approach that has been bantered back and forth since for me since her birth. Seems there are two camps: those who start working on their children's skills before they need them and plan to show them how to do everything and then repeat those lessons till you can't stand it anymore.Examples from my life are potty training starting at 9months and working on reading since birth.Another example is teaching kids sign so they can communicate at an earlier age since speech is typically delayed.The other camp believe that children will learn these skills in due time with very little help and wait til they see readiness or the child can do it on their own. *Some* people in this camp don't teach sign because they would rather wait till the child speaks thinking that signing may delay speech more. Others feel if the child learns a skill on their own, no matter the age, that the child has then really learned it rather then being 'trained' or 'drilled' They feel that when the child is ready, they will learn the skill.( keep in mind these are pretty loose definitions!!!!!)I can only speak for my "camp' here, but I feel that teaching a child the age appropriate skill before or at least at the time actually INCREASES a child's over all abilities. It keeps them with their peers more, which in turn helps them learn even more at their age level. ( Not saying they will be the same...) I think it also helps actual brain growth. I don't think that kids with DS learn too well on their own. The DO learn fantastically with modeling and lots of help and are very capable of taking skills from one area and transferring them to another. The more they learn, the more they can learn. The more you wait, the more time lost learning and the more entrenched they become in the wrong behavior.This is not as well written as I would like... have to go and set up our POOL while I have help!!!!!Hope this means the rains stop and the sun bakes us now.... Carol in IL AIM doihavtasay1 GigaTribe doihavtasayMom to seven including , 7 with TOF, AVcanal, GERD, LS, Asthma, subglottal stenosis, and DS.My problem is not how I look. It's how you see me. Join our Down Syndrome information group - http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/DownSyndromeInfoExchange/ Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace.com/vennamusic----- Original Message ----From: Carla Mayer To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Sent: Monday, June 16, 2008 11:39:35 AMSubject: Re: [sPAM]Re: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Now restraints- was Homeschooling (Carol)My daughter is 12 yrs old and has Down Syndrome along with sensory problems and autistic behaviors. Not a true diagnosis of autism yet. We have just bought a larger stroller for her after many years of trying to be age appropriate. My daughter developmentally is not 12 and due to the sensory problems in new places and large noisy activities will shut down which includes dropping to the floor and will not get up. I absolutely cannot pick her up when she is in this mode. I had her sit down on me in the middle of traffic and thank God! my husband was nearby and could come pick her up. We will use a stroller or wheelchair or whatever because she feels safe there and will participate with her family. She is not restrained and we would praise any efforts she makes to walk with us. We try social stories, pictures of where we are going, rewards and sometimes it works but most often not. We came to the choice of her staying home or providing her with something that makes her feel safe. To us the choice of her not being with us was not acceptable. I post this just to show another side of the story. I know how often we have felt alone in this situation. Thanks, Carla > I agree with both of you guys and I too fired a ST when she would strap > into the swing at 2 years old!! Egads..... who's going to learn > to speak when all you want to do is get out and play, and at 2, that is > age appropriate behavior and a good therapists is going to work with their > natural tendencies. > > And when she was school aged, again, that is not age appropriate to buckle > someone in or have them ride in a stroller to keep them contained. Riding > in the stroller for a bit if they are tired, is OK and all my kids have > done that, but they have the power to get out if they want to and I expect > them to listen to me and not go wandering off. > I have the same age appropriate expectations for her, though trust me, it > was NOT EASY. For a few *years* shopping with her, was all about her > learning to stick with me and I did very little shopping for me or anyone > else for that matter. Same at school when she moves from classroom to > classroom or they went on field trips. > > Sitting is another work in progress and a team effort as well. You get > them to do it by making sitting the favorable activity at the moment and > not rewarding them by allowing them to go off and play.You also have to > work up to it and build in breaks to make it successful. When you see they > are tired of sitting, have them run some kind of errand and then come back > to sitting and make sure you have something interesting and fun to come > back to. For them to learn the behavior, it really has to be an internal > lesson or something they do of their free will and not because they have > no choice in the matter. > > Now I can get her to sit just because I said so with out ANY thing fun to > do. That has been quite the challenge, but we did it by offering her > something in the future, like Kathy did with the reward of going to see > the the toys. > > Sometimes what *we* view as mis-behavior is really the child asserting > their independence. Danny wanting to look at the toys is the perfect > example. All kids that age love to go and check out all the toys and have > that freedom. Last week while at the Playhouse, was telling her > teacher about the new clothes we had just bought for her and all of a > sudden she ran outside to the car to get the bag of them and bring them > in. We of course had an attack, but honestly, how appropriate for a 2nd > grader to do that!!! Wanting to go and run 'with the pack' of kids in the > neighborhood is the challenge this year. > > The tricky part comes when age appropriate meets DD and the person is > willing and wanting, but not always able to do it totally on their own > safely. That's when you have to sometimes allow for failure and find > accommodations to allow the child to do what other kid's their age do too. > > Interesting discussion!! ! > > > > Carol in IL > > AIM doihavtasay1 GigaTribe doihavtasay > Mom to seven including , 7 with TOF, AVcanal, GERD, LS, Asthma, > subglottal stenosis, and DS. > > My problem is not how I look. It's how you see me. > > > Join our Down Syndrome information group - > http://health. groups.yahoo. com/group/ DownSyndromeInfo Exchange/ > > Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace. com/vennamusic > > > > [sPAM]Re: [DownSyndromeInfoEx change] Now restraints- was > Homeschooling (Carol) > > I wasn't going to say anything, but I would > like to point out > something for any who are wondering if this is the "norm" to teach > children with DS. Faith is now 10 and will sit for quite some time, > at school, at home, at a restaurant, or theater. I thought this might > never happen! She has not been in a restrained seat for teaching > since I told her speech therapist I didn't like that and changed > therapists (Faith was 5). Yes, it was a challange to get her to this > point without restraining her. But, I think young children learn more > when they can explore their environment. Also, I think children with > DS reach some of these exploration milestones later than other > children. So, Faith was probably not ready to sit and learn until she > was 7 or 8, when many typical children can sit and learn at 5 or 6. > JMHO > ette > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 have to go and set up our POOL while I have help!!!!!Hope this means the rains stop and the sun bakes us now.... Speaking of the sun baking you. I got in the car yesterday, the Temp said 103 !! That is HOT Texas weather for ya !! The Sun is brutal. Not to mention the Heat. Carol send your rain our way, We will give you our Sunshine !! Carol P Subject: Re: [sPAM]Re: [DownSyndromeInfoExchange] Now restraints- was Homeschooling (Carol)To: DownSyndromeInfoExchange Date: Tuesday, June 17, 2008, 3:35 PM Carla, There are always exceptions and kids who have extenuating circumstances, and each child has their moments when they are just not able to do what they might not be able to do what they could at another time. I am sure we have all been there, done that. I have certainly had to remove from situations where she was just not able to handle it due to being tired, stressed or just plain over stimulated.No one is judging anyone, we are simply having a conversation about your garden variety kid with DS. It's often assumed that is some how more capable than others, and it bugs me cause she is not. It took a few *years* to get her to even remotely stay with us while out shopping. We still have our days. I think what we are talking about is a difference in approach that has been bantered back and forth since for me since her birth. Seems there are two camps: those who start working on their children's skills before they need them and plan to show them how to do everything and then repeat those lessons till you can't stand it anymore.Examples from my life are potty training starting at 9months and working on reading since birth.Another example is teaching kids sign so they can communicate at an earlier age since speech is typically delayed.The other camp believe that children will learn these skills in due time with very little help and wait til they see readiness or the child can do it on their own. *Some* people in this camp don't teach sign because they would rather wait till the child speaks thinking that signing may delay speech more. Others feel if the child learns a skill on their own, no matter the age, that the child has then really learned it rather then being 'trained' or 'drilled' They feel that when the child is ready, they will learn the skill.( keep in mind these are pretty loose definitions! !!!!)I can only speak for my "camp' here, but I feel that teaching a child the age appropriate skill before or at least at the time actually INCREASES a child's over all abilities. It keeps them with their peers more, which in turn helps them learn even more at their age level. ( Not saying they will be the same...) I think it also helps actual brain growth. I don't think that kids with DS learn too well on their own. The DO learn fantastically with modeling and lots of help and are very capable of taking skills from one area and transferring them to another. The more they learn, the more they can learn. The more you wait, the more time lost learning and the more entrenched they become in the wrong behavior.This is not as well written as I would like... have to go and set up our POOL while I have help!!!!!Hope this means the rains stop and the sun bakes us now.... Carol in IL AIM doihavtasay1 GigaTribe doihavtasayMom to seven including , 7 with TOF, AVcanal, GERD, LS, Asthma, subglottal stenosis, and DS.My problem is not how I look. It's how you see me. Join our Down Syndrome information group - http://health. groups.yahoo. com/group/ DownSyndromeInfo Exchange/ Listen to oldest dd's music http://www.myspace. com/vennamusic [sPAM]Re: [DownSyndromeInfoEx change] Now restraints- was> Homeschooling (Carol)>> I wasn't going to say anything, but I would> like to point out> something for any who are wondering if this is the "norm" to teach> children with DS. Faith is now 10 and will sit for quite some time,> at school, at home, at a restaurant, or theater. I thought this might> never happen! She has not been in a restrained seat for teaching> since I told her speech therapist I didn't like that and changed> therapists (Faith was 5). Yes, it was a challange to get her to this> point without restraining her. But, I think young children learn more> when they can explore their environment. Also, I think children with> DS reach some of these exploration milestones later than other> children. So, Faith was probably not ready to sit and learn until she> was 7 or 8, when many typical children can sit and learn at 5 or 6.> JMHO> ette>>>>>> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 17, 2008 Report Share Posted June 17, 2008 Oh we've had our pool open for 1 month now and it's wonderful!! Carol, are you near any of the flooding? [sPAM]Re: [DownSyndromeInfoEx change] Now restraints- was> Homeschooling (Carol)>> I wasn't going to say anything, but I would> like to point out> something for any who are wondering if this is the "norm" to teach> children with DS. Faith is now 10 and will sit for quite some time,> at school, at home, at a restaurant, or theater. I thought this might> never happen! She has not been in a restrained seat for teaching> since I told her speech therapist I didn't like that and changed> therapists (Faith was 5). Yes, it was a challange to get her to this> point without restraining her. But, I think young children learn more> when they can explore their environment. Also, I think children with> DS reach some of these exploration milestones later than other> children. So, Faith was probably not ready to sit and learn until she> was 7 or 8, when many typical children can sit and learn at 5 or 6.> JMHO> ette>>>>>> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.