Guest guest Posted November 25, 2008 Report Share Posted November 25, 2008 New member introducing himself to the group: Two or three months ago there was a series of posts on the relative merits of BW versus training with weights at the gym. Since I have experience of both over a long period I thought I'd weigh in. I'm now 59 but I began with the BW round about age 25, so a good long while ago. I worked very hard (trained twice a day 5 days a week) over a period of 2 or 3 years, and got very good all round results. I started off with some advantages, naturally broad shoulders and a barrel chest among them, but the combination of the BW and a good diet put muscle on me in every area. I can't remember the details but I do know that I went from a chest that was barely 38 inches to 43 or 44 inches in a couple of years, and I added a couple of inches to both arms and thighs. It was in my 30s that I got into weight training (free weights and machines), and after a while I was training three days a week with split routines and dealing with fairly heavy weights. Gains in bulk followed pretty steadily. The trouble with the gym is that it is expensive in terms of time as well as money, and I was never able to keep it up. So in the last 20 years I have had 3 separate periods of intensive training with long periods in between where I just haven't managed to do it at all. I ended up carrying a lot of bulk, a lot of it muscle (by my mid to late 40s I had a 50 " + chest, and legs and arms, shoulders, neck, traps and lats etc to match), but not always in good tone, and tending recently to run to flab. I have given up on gyms and returned to where I started, the Bullworker. Advantages: 1. I don't have to travel to the gym and take hours out of my day. 2. I can build the routine in every day, even if I am away from home. 3. Even for a guy carrying a lot of heavy muscle like me, the BW can tone the muscles up; I feel the burn, and know that I have connected with a given muscle group in a way that promotes tone and growth. Disadvantages: 1. I'm not sure the BW is ever as good with the legs as it is with the upper body. Since I have restarted I know that I am connecting with the shoulders, pecs, biceps, triceps, lats, traps, forearms. Legs I'm less certain about. 2. If you want to gain a lot of muscle (as I once did), there is probably no substitute for free weights. But if you're content with being well built and toned (as I think I wish I had been), the BW is fine. More than enough from me. But I'd be interested to hear from any other older guys whose BW experience goes back a long way. Max London Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.