Guest guest Posted June 26, 2009 Report Share Posted June 26, 2009 At 10:09 AM 6/25/2009, you wrote: >--- >Sam: I was just given the information about he amalgams. I guess >s doctor does not agree. What they told me was that the ALA >leaches mercury from the amalgams Think careful of what the actual mechanism must be for a chemical, any chemical you orally consume, to reach the oral cavity, at what reduced concentration, either via saliva or to the roots of the tooth, the interior of the tooth, where it can not reach the amalgam material, which is on the outside of the tooth, not the inside. Thus, only the ALA and it's by products are in the saliva, likely at 1/1000th the blood concentration, which is at least 1/1000th the orally consumed amount (much of any supplement is destroyed by the stomach acid, bile, HCl, hydrochloride acid, very strong, at a pH of 3 to 2 (2 is stronger). The ALA in the saliva must then pass through the fat coating of the teeth, that adheres to enamel, oh, the amalgam material likely does not get a fat coating, so this weak ALA saliva solution must then rest against the amalgam surface, to act upon it, and likely only 1/1000th of the ALA molecules in the saliva likely do that. So, the ALA is reduced to 1,000,000,000th the oral value, and only for a while, for several hours (that is if ALA does enter the saliva gland and is released by the gland into the mouth)... Given all this ... I'd evaluate the statement of " ALA leaches amalgam mercury " as being not just weak, in need of scientific backing, in terms of measuring the ALA in the saliva, and any increase in mercury in the saliva... that's my opinion. Ok, that evaluation done, my opinion stated, you ought to go back to these doctors, and ask for their source(s) of information, so you may have your " scientific consultant " (me) confirm the validity of the source(s), so you may act with certitude, not what appears to be anecdotal. Shoe on the other foot? >and if you are not detoxing well the mercury will build up. What I see here is a statement of " if " , the " What if ... " game. Nothing definitive. Nothing scientific. Nothing medically valid... or is it? It's a clear attempt to sow fear, uncertainty and doubt. That for sure is medically an incorrect bedside manner. At a minimum. At it's worse, it medical malpractice. In either case, or anywhere in between, it's incomplete information. Not enough knowledge. Without any proof. Just mere layman opinion, from a " doctor " who has no knowledge of oral cavity chemistry... right? >It makes sense to me. They made it sound good. Thus, it's dangerous, and imho, the doctor is dangerous, perhaps just in this one area, where they did not know they were out of their depth? >The hardest thing about this condition is that you will not get two >doctors to agree on anything. D And that is why I posted this info. Print out this email, and have the good doctors read it. Get back to us with their " reply " , or lack of one, as many doctors are 'silent', like most people, when their verbal statements are responded to with reasonable questions, that leave them wondering how they could not have thought of these points themselves, before they spoke. Hmm, put this paragraph first so the good doctor reads it first. It should " lighten " the blow to their egos. Let us know. Also, I'm interested in feedback. BTW, there are scientific studies on the amount of fluoride present in saliva from water fluoridation, and how long fluoridated toothpaste is in contact with teeth enamel, if that time is enough for the toothpaste fluoride to crystallize the enamel. Both studies indicate that fluoride so applied is ineffective, and only in the dentist chair, where extremely concentrated fluoride is applied directly to the teeth, for tens of minutes, can there be any absorption. That all said, think again about any chemical you orally consume, or do not consume (distilled water without minerals) doing any " leaching " anywhere in the body. It has to " reach " the organ, in some minimum concentration, and be in contact for some time. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.