Guest guest Posted December 26, 2008 Report Share Posted December 26, 2008 They all lie. And if you tell them your story they won't believe you. They have all been completely brainwashed and believe that depression is a chemical imbalance caused by genes. I went to my doctor saying I had become scared and shy and was not my usual self. I knew what was wrong, all my life I suffered from feelings of inferiority which I covered up by being very outgoing and extrovert. This defence against inner pain had stopped working after a traimatic event in my life and I had become depressed as a result. I was sent to see a psychiatrist and I imagined he would do some sort of pychotherapy on me. You can't believe how upset I was when he asked me loads of questions for half an hour but never taking any particular questions any further and then wrote a prescription and told me come back in a month. I'm not medically trained and yet I intrinsically knew antideprssants were not the answer. Little did I know it was going to make things worse. I hate psychiatry for making me feel that I was physically defective (with a genetic brain condition) which greatly incressed my inferioity and pychic pain. All my mates seemed to happy and yet I was always broken and with my confidence gone I felt I was born weak. No psychiatrist ever reassured me. Cognitive therapy (CBT)is the opposite of psychiatry. It believes we are not fixed by our genes and that we can overcome depression by our own effort. Even this thought starts to bring hope and undo depression. When CBT started helping people psychaitrists started saying CBT plus antidepressants is best. The psychiatrists were worried about losing business to CBT. DR Burns, a mainstream psychiatrist, says in his book, When Panic Attacks, that research has shown that CBT on its own is best. The drug companies don't want you to know this. Kavy > > Ever since I took Zyprexa combined with Prozac I have had no libido > whatsoever and also have had a very apathetic mood combined with > lethargy and lack of creativity. The only exception to my mood > symptoms was when I drank anough liquor. When i got drunk i > experienced a high like nothing i had ever experienced before in this > lifetime. There was never an exception to the sexual dysfunction > tragedy. I have lost all memories of my childhood and early > adolescence- good and bad. I don't even feel human but I am too > apathetic to get too excited about it. I feel like my growing years > are the basis for my former life and that life as I know it now is > pointless and I am worthless. I am not depressed. I just used to be > something 100% different and i had a wonderful sex life. Now i never > even think about sex. It does not repulse me but it fails to move me. > I sure hope that I live to see a cure and that if there ever is a cure > I hope I am still fairly young- like even 40,50,60's will do. Oh yeah, > i forgot another dimension of my ailiments- I lost belief in God > altogether. That at least might be somewhat liberating but i would not > mind having it back if it would also mean that I would be happy and > highly sexed. My doctor who is supposedly one of the best in his > feild, claimed that he had never heard of such a thing as PSSD and I > just emailed them a link to the free online encyclopedia page that > goes into great depth about it. I feel like he was probably lying. The > mental health industry as it stands today is highly corrupt. Thanx for > reading this. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2008 Report Share Posted December 27, 2008 It's certainly acceptable to have an opinion about depression and its varied causes and treatments. And while I agree that much of depression is catalyzed and/or exacerbated by circumstance and our responses to it, I do not agree that " there is no such thing as clinical depression " or that it is a " lie " to associate depressive symptoms with " chemical imbalance caused by genes " . We are indeed chemical beings, and how we function chemically is largely determined by our genetic makeup. Have one two many cocktails, smoke a joint, or take a hit of LSD or ecstasy and you will note immediately how subject to chemistry your sensory perception, cognition, and personality are. Even diet (again, routine chemistry) greatly informs who we are physically and mentally. There is no easy delineation of the Self independent of chemistry or genetics. Any ailment we encounter, whether cancer or autism, is tied in some way to the two. So too are depression and anxiety. Whether we are able to effectively treat such illnesses with chemical or genetic interventions is another matter entirely. Because of certain personal frustrations with our technical inadequacy to do so, some hastily leap to the conclusion that there is no basis whatsoever for chemical or genetic etiological descriptions of mental illnesses (and thus no chemical or genetic treatment for them either). That is simply unfounded and altogether ignorant. The presence of a partner's sympathetic ear, a therapist's objective advice, the conviction of prayer, or a timely hug from a friend all have chemical consequence. So too the lack of these. While there's no doubt that a mere " chemical imbalance caused by genes " is an oversimplification of the matter, I don't doubt that there is some genetic component to this condition. That is not to say there is a depression gene per se, but there may be certain genes which regulate, say, corticosteroid production and metabolism, or neurotransmitter release and receptor expression. In combination such things could produce a constellation of biological conditions which increase the likelihood of a depressed response to chronic stress or challenging emotional circumstances. It both ignorant and irresponsible to suppose that endogenous molecular relationships and events (healthy people aren't " chemically balanced " ) and genetic predisposition are ENTIRELY responsible for Depression, Anxiety, or issues of Attention. It is equally ignorant and irresponsible to suppose that they play no role at all. Furthermore, it is abundantly clear that despite their varied side-effects (and PSSD), anti-depressant medications DO work. Perhaps not as immediately or as " cleanly " as we have come to expect as consumers of medical science...perhaps not without temporary or even lasting consequence (PSSD), and perhaps not equally well for all people, but it is a " lie " to say outright that they do not work at all! Were it not for the complications of PSSD, I suspect many of us in this group would have more balanced and positive things to say about this class of medicines as a treatment for our various conditions. Personally, without these drugs, I would not likely be alive today to endure and criticize the lasting sexual effects of these drugs. I am not saying these things in defense of anti-depressants or in support of their widespread use. I do not mean to discount the tragedy of PSSD. I wrestle daily with the fact that to treat my depression in the past, I have consigned myself to a lifetime (possibly) of despair over my new sexual handicap. I am very angry that no one warned me of the risk, and that my choice at the time was not adequately informed. Like most of you, I have a new bias when I consider antidepressants, depression, and anxiety. It's hard not to think of the doctors, the pharmaceutical companies, the FDA, and the drugs themselves as one cooperative evil that conspired to capitalize heartlessly on my desperation and vulnerability and, in the end, make my life more miserable. But I know that is an irrational appraisal of the situation. The true etiologies of depression and anxiety as well as the safest, most durable, and efficient treatments for these conditions remain obscure. For now, we must suffer though our questions and hope for mercifully expeditious, honest answers. This will require time and patience. In the meantime, I will not tolerate unwarranted ignorance or an unbalanced, irrational perspective when I see it. For what it's worth. > > > > Ever since I took Zyprexa combined with Prozac I have had no libido > > whatsoever and also have had a very apathetic mood combined with > > lethargy and lack of creativity. The only exception to my mood > > symptoms was when I drank anough liquor. When i got drunk i > > experienced a high like nothing i had ever experienced before in > this > > lifetime. There was never an exception to the sexual dysfunction > > tragedy. I have lost all memories of my childhood and early > > adolescence- good and bad. I don't even feel human but I am too > > apathetic to get too excited about it. I feel like my growing years > > are the basis for my former life and that life as I know it now is > > pointless and I am worthless. I am not depressed. I just used to be > > something 100% different and i had a wonderful sex life. Now i never > > even think about sex. It does not repulse me but it fails to move > me. > > I sure hope that I live to see a cure and that if there ever is a > cure > > I hope I am still fairly young- like even 40,50,60's will do. Oh > yeah, > > i forgot another dimension of my ailiments- I lost belief in God > > altogether. That at least might be somewhat liberating but i would > not > > mind having it back if it would also mean that I would be happy and > > highly sexed. My doctor who is supposedly one of the best in his > > feild, claimed that he had never heard of such a thing as PSSD and I > > just emailed them a link to the free online encyclopedia page that > > goes into great depth about it. I feel like he was probably lying. > The > > mental health industry as it stands today is highly corrupt. Thanx > for > > reading this. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2008 Report Share Posted December 27, 2008 In my ACT books they say that research shows that genes are responsible for about 30% of our depression/anxiety. Having this tendancy doesn't mean we will get depression or that drugs are the answer if we do. They state that millions of antidepressants are presribed each year and yet depression is still rife in our society - the drugs don't really help most people that much. It is best to heal depression through therapy, which has been shown to be more far more effective. It's certainly safer. Kavy > > > > > > Ever since I took Zyprexa combined with Prozac I have had no libido > > > whatsoever and also have had a very apathetic mood combined with > > > lethargy and lack of creativity. The only exception to my mood > > > symptoms was when I drank anough liquor. When i got drunk i > > > experienced a high like nothing i had ever experienced before in > > this > > > lifetime. There was never an exception to the sexual dysfunction > > > tragedy. I have lost all memories of my childhood and early > > > adolescence- good and bad. I don't even feel human but I am too > > > apathetic to get too excited about it. I feel like my growing years > > > are the basis for my former life and that life as I know it now is > > > pointless and I am worthless. I am not depressed. I just used to be > > > something 100% different and i had a wonderful sex life. Now i never > > > even think about sex. It does not repulse me but it fails to move > > me. > > > I sure hope that I live to see a cure and that if there ever is a > > cure > > > I hope I am still fairly young- like even 40,50,60's will do. Oh > > yeah, > > > i forgot another dimension of my ailiments- I lost belief in God > > > altogether. That at least might be somewhat liberating but i would > > not > > > mind having it back if it would also mean that I would be happy and > > > highly sexed. My doctor who is supposedly one of the best in his > > > feild, claimed that he had never heard of such a thing as PSSD and I > > > just emailed them a link to the free online encyclopedia page that > > > goes into great depth about it. I feel like he was probably lying. > > The > > > mental health industry as it stands today is highly corrupt. Thanx > > for > > > reading this. > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2008 Report Share Posted December 27, 2008 Again - I am not advocating for the use of medications in all cases or as preferable to of other forms of therapy. I am simply trying to neutralize some of your rather black and white, sweeping statements which are simply not substantiated. Furthermore, you need to be careful when citing research that is reference selectively in a publication which advances a given treatment strategy - in your case the ACT books. Personally, I find it humorous that anyone would think that a number like " 30% " could be reasonably assigned to any one cause of human behavior (in this case, genes) - especially such complex and dynamic emotional states as depression and anxiety! The notion that genes are not overwhelmingly responsible for depressive symptoms is certainly reasonable -- perhaps not correct (we don't yet know), but not unreasonable. Yes, having a genetic predisposition toward any behavior (alcoholism, anger issues, sexual compulsivity, depression, anxiety, etc.) does not mean it will unavoidably manifest in a fatalistic I-can't-help-it sense. And it certainly does not mean that it cannot be mediated with non-invasive, cognitive and behavioral therapies. I agree with you on that. That said, there are genetic conditions which do in fact constrain our behavior. And these can and do resist non-invasive attempts to correct, avoid, or suppress them. The truth is that we do not yet know enough about the biological underpinnings of depression and anxiety to confidently say whether it is indeed 30%, 5%, or 85% genetic in origin. To be even more truthful, we must be careful not to speak in general terms which would seem to describe all depressed persons everywhere. Certainly " depression " for me is slightly, and in some cases greatly, different from others with the same diagnosis. What we term " Depression " is a series of behavioral and cognitive symptoms any of which are evaluated rather subjectively and vary from person to person. The symptoms themselves vary within a given individual from day to day, moment to moment. Certainly there cannot be a 30% causal relationship between my genes and my suicidal ideation this Tuesday at 1 PM! However, there CAN be a genetic cause for my inability to efficiently metabolize cortisol. And my extraordinarily high levels of cortisol (which is neurotoxic) might tax the healthy structure and function of certain areas of my brain which mediate perception, memory, mood, and cognition. Compromise these, and yes, my general sense of well-being and hopefulness may deteriorate into what we know as depression. And THIS, might have something to do with why I couldn't cope on Tuesday at 1 PM. Whether one meets depression with CBT, psychotherapy, prescription or non-prescription medications (including antidepressants, stimulants, alcohol, illicit drugs), or in some cases suicide will depend on the person and his or her resources. Whether any one or a combination of these will successfully resolve the depression depends largely on that individual and whether in his or her particular case, 30% is the right number...or not. > > > > > > > > Ever since I took Zyprexa combined with Prozac I have had no > libido > > > > whatsoever and also have had a very apathetic mood combined with > > > > lethargy and lack of creativity. The only exception to my mood > > > > symptoms was when I drank anough liquor. When i got drunk i > > > > experienced a high like nothing i had ever experienced before > in > > > this > > > > lifetime. There was never an exception to the sexual dysfunction > > > > tragedy. I have lost all memories of my childhood and early > > > > adolescence- good and bad. I don't even feel human but I am too > > > > apathetic to get too excited about it. I feel like my growing > years > > > > are the basis for my former life and that life as I know it now > is > > > > pointless and I am worthless. I am not depressed. I just used > to be > > > > something 100% different and i had a wonderful sex life. Now i > never > > > > even think about sex. It does not repulse me but it fails to > move > > > me. > > > > I sure hope that I live to see a cure and that if there ever is > a > > > cure > > > > I hope I am still fairly young- like even 40,50,60's will do. > Oh > > > yeah, > > > > i forgot another dimension of my ailiments- I lost belief in God > > > > altogether. That at least might be somewhat liberating but i > would > > > not > > > > mind having it back if it would also mean that I would be happy > and > > > > highly sexed. My doctor who is supposedly one of the best in his > > > > feild, claimed that he had never heard of such a thing as PSSD > and I > > > > just emailed them a link to the free online encyclopedia page > that > > > > goes into great depth about it. I feel like he was probably > lying. > > > The > > > > mental health industry as it stands today is highly corrupt. > Thanx > > > for > > > > reading this. > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2008 Report Share Posted December 28, 2008 thank you gwistik! it's a pleasure reading your posts! Subject: Re: Here is my personal history with PSSD. I am a new member.To: SSRIsex Date: Saturday, December 27, 2008, 9:09 PM Again - I am not advocating for the use of medications in all cases oras preferable to of other forms of therapy. I am simply trying toneutralize some of your rather black and white, sweeping statementswhich are simply not substantiated. Furthermore, you need to be careful when citing research that isreference selectively in a publication which advances a giventreatment strategy - in your case the ACT books. Personally, I find ithumorous that anyone would think that a number like "30%" could bereasonably assigned to any one cause of human behavior (in this case,genes) - especially such complex and dynamic emotional states asdepression and anxiety! The notion that genes are not overwhelmingly responsible fordepressive symptoms is certainly reasonable -- perhaps not correct (wedon't yet know), but not unreasonable. Yes, having a geneticpredisposition toward any behavior (alcoholism, anger issues, sexualcompulsivity, depression, anxiety, etc.) does not mean it willunavoidably manifest in a fatalistic I-can't-help- it sense. And itcertainly does not mean that it cannot be mediated with non-invasive,cognitive and behavioral therapies. I agree with you on that. Thatsaid, there are genetic conditions which do in fact constrain ourbehavior. And these can and do resist non-invasive attempts tocorrect, avoid, or suppress them. The truth is that we do not yet knowenough about the biological underpinnings of depression and anxiety toconfidently say whether it is indeed 30%, 5%, or 85% genetic inorigin. To be even more truthful, we must be careful not to speak ingeneral terms which would seem to describe all depressed personseverywhere. Certainly "depression" for me is slightly, and in somecases greatly, different from others with the same diagnosis.What we term "Depression" is a series of behavioral and cognitivesymptoms any of which are evaluated rather subjectively and vary fromperson to person. The symptoms themselves vary within a givenindividual from day to day, moment to moment. Certainly there cannotbe a 30% causal relationship between my genes and my suicidal ideationthis Tuesday at 1 PM! However, there CAN be a genetic cause for myinability to efficiently metabolize cortisol. And my extraordinarilyhigh levels of cortisol (which is neurotoxic) might tax the healthystructure and function of certain areas of my brain which mediateperception, memory, mood, and cognition. Compromise these, and yes, mygeneral sense of well-being and hopefulness may deteriorate into whatwe know as depression. And THIS, might have something to do with why Icouldn't cope on Tuesday at 1 PM. Whether one meets depression with CBT, psychotherapy, prescription ornon-prescription medications (including antidepressants, stimulants,alcohol, illicit drugs), or in some cases suicide will depend on theperson and his or her resources. Whether any one or a combination ofthese will successfully resolve the depression depends largely on thatindividual and whether in his or her particular case, 30% is the rightnumber...or not.> > > >> > > > Ever since I took Zyprexa combined with Prozac I have had no > libido> > > > whatsoever and also have had a very apathetic mood combined with> > > > lethargy and lack of creativity. The only exception to my mood> > > > symptoms was when I drank anough liquor. When i got drunk i> > > > experienced a high like nothing i had ever experienced before > in > > > this> > > > lifetime. There was never an exception to the sexual dysfunction> > > > tragedy. I have lost all memories of my childhood and early> > > > adolescence- good and bad. I don't even feel human but I am too> > > > apathetic to get too excited about it. I feel like my growing > years> > > > are the basis for my former life and that life as I know it now > is> > > > pointless and I am worthless. I am not depressed. I just used > to be> > > > something 100% different and i had a wonderful sex life. Now i > never> > > > even think about sex. It does not repulse me but it fails to > move > > > me.> > > > I sure hope that I live to see a cure and that if there ever is > a > > > cure> > > > I hope I am still fairly young- like even 40,50,60's will do. > Oh > > > yeah,> > > > i forgot another dimension of my ailiments- I lost belief in God> > > > altogether. That at least might be somewhat liberating but i > would > > > not> > > > mind having it back if it would also mean that I would be happy > and> > > > highly sexed. My doctor who is supposedly one of the best in his> > > > feild, claimed that he had never heard of such a thing as PSSD > and I> > > > just emailed them a link to the free online encyclopedia page > that> > > > goes into great depth about it. I feel like he was probably > lying. > > > The> > > > mental health industry as it stands today is highly corrupt. > Thanx > > > for> > > > reading this.> > > >> > >> >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.