Guest guest Posted October 20, 2004 Report Share Posted October 20, 2004 http://www.hsibaltimore.com/ea2004/ea_040908.shtml Fear Factor " You've probably heard the news by now: Doctors are running low on flu vaccines and are expected to run out completely before the flu season winds down. " That was the opening of the e-Alert " Does This Smell Bad? " that I sent you last December. Remember last year's flu vaccine crisis? Dire predictions that we were in for " the worst flu season in 30 years " – a possible pandemic! – arrived right alongside hand- wringing reports that there weren't enough flu vaccines to go around. And what actually happened? According to a recent Associated Press (AP) article: " In the end, some vaccine was leftover, and the season was no worse than usual. " Gee, the sky didn't fall or anything. The AP piece also notes that there may be a big demand for the vaccine this year because of " memories of shortages " and worries that are circulating about new flu strains. Worries circulating? I haven't heard any worries circulating. But you can be certain that we will. Because officials for the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) National Immunization Program (NIP) have developed a plan specifically designed to do one thing: circulate worries about the flu season. Yep – those are our tax dollars at work. Overcooking it Sherri J. Tenpenny, D.O., is an internationally known leader in vaccine research. For many years, Dr. Tenpenny has cautioned consumers about the dangers of blindly accepting flu, smallpox and other vaccines, including the wide range of inoculations for children. This week I came across a Red Flags Weekly article written by Dr. Tenpenny in which she reports on a communiqué from the NIP that contains a " Seven-Step Recipe for Generating Interest in, and Demand for, Flu (or any other) Vaccine. " Here are some of the recommendations in the " recipe " : * " Medical experts and public health authorities publicly (via media) state concern and alarm (and predict dire outcomes) and urge influenza vaccination. " * These actions are intended to result in, " significant media interest and attention " by " framing of the flu season in terms that motivate behavior (e.g., as 'very severe,' 'more severe than last or past years,' 'deadly'). " * " Continued reports (from health officials and media) that influenza is causing severe illness and/or affecting lots of people – helping foster the perception that many people are susceptible to a bad case of influenza. " * " References to, and discussions of, pandemic influenza – along with continued reference to the importance of vaccination. " Obviously, the recipe for flu vaccination success calls for a large portion of " alarm " to be blended with " dire outcomes " and then laid on as thick as possible. Get out your calculators The CDC especially likes to bring up the possibility of a flu pandemic. And the message is basic: This could be the year of the big one, so you better get your flu shot. Two weeks ago, the AP sounded the alarm that the U.S. might have to close schools, restrict travel and ration scarce medications in the event of a worldwide flu outbreak. And Dr. Gerberding – the head of the CDC – gave the report a dramatic flourish with this quote: " We're all holding our breath. " It's been 36 years since the last pandemic. That's a long time to keep up the amateur theatrics. The August AP article noted that about 36,000 Americans die from the flu every year. That number is a CDC estimate that was quoted again and again last year, and it appears that we'll be seeing it often again this year. There's just one little thing wrong with that number: it's off the mark. In fact it's wildly off the mark. How many American's died of the flu last year? Here's Dr. Tenpenny's comment from the Red Flags article: " Less than 175 people actually died from influenza in 2003. " Less than 175! Now THAT's good news! They expected 36,000 to die, and we lost less than 175. That's wonderful! But it's not wonderful if you're trying to sell flu vaccines. Where's the fear in 175 deaths? That's only half the number of Americans who die by drowning in bathtubs each year! You won't even get people off the couch, much less down to their doctor's office with only 175 " dire outcomes " hanging over their heads. So the CDC is sticking with the much scarier 36,000 estimate. The rub All of this would simply be annoying, if it weren't for the fact that the CDC and NIP are basically using taxpayer dollars to conduct a marketing campaign for the three drug companies that produce flu vaccines for the U.S. And add to that the little wrinkle that just last spring CDC reps announced their new recommendation that children aged 6 months to 23 months should now receive flu shots (which contain the mercury-based preservative thimerosal, associated with a high risk of autism). Annoying? How about infuriating? There are a couple of other flu issues " going around " right now. And since this is the time of year when I start to receive requests for advice on whether or not to get a flu shot, I'll fill you in on those issues in upcoming e-Alerts. In the meantime, it will be interesting to watch news reports over the next two or three months to see just how easily the media can be led into rubber stamping CDC- approved " information " (especially attention-grabbing SCARY information) and passing it along without question. ********************************************* > Waymon, > That is because the only ones they talk to are the ones standing in line to get it. > Suzi Have you noticed that the only people they can find to talk to in print or on screen are those who just " have " to get that poisonous shot?> Waymon Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.