Guest guest Posted September 12, 2006 Report Share Posted September 12, 2006 Anyone care to comment on the nutrition advice from this college text on anatomy that I use for teaching (the wrap up of) 8th grade anatomy? It is _Human Anatomy and Physiology_ 4th Edition by W. Hole, Jr. It's been your standard fare, older (1st ed. 1978, 4th 1987) anatomy book, but now that we get into nutrition at the end of the semester, it just seems plain weird. At least to me. Here's what I mean from pages 539-40 with my questions in brackets [ ]: " Consequently, the presence of some carbohydrates in the body is essential; if an adequate supply is not received from foods, the liver may convert noncarbohydrates, such as amino acids from proteins, into glucose (gluconeogenesis). Thus, the need for glucose has priority over the need to manufacture proteins from available amino acids. " [is the last sentence misleading?] (social commentary on carbohydrate consumption based on economic status precedes this quote) " Furthermore, poor nutrition among people with limited economic resources is more likely to be related to low intake of essential amino acids, vitamins, and minerals than to an excessive use of carbohydrate foods. [uh, excessive carbs are displacing these foods, right?] " Since carbohydrates provide the primary source of fuel for cellular processes, the need for carbohydrates varies with individual energy requirements. Persons who are physically active require more fuel than those who are sedentary. The minimal requirement for carbohydrates in the human diet is unknown. It is estimated, however, that an intake of at least 100 grams daily is necessary to avoid excessive breakdown of protein and to avoid metabolic disorders that sometimes accompany excessive utilization of fats. Persons in the United States typically include 200-300 grams of carbohydrates in their daily diets. [First it's unknown, but let's put an arbitrary number in anyway? What metabolic disorders is he talking about?] " A nutritionist might recommend that an adult diet contain enough carbohydrates to maintain a desirable body weight, enough proteins to supply the cellular needs for essential amino acids, enough fats to supply essential fatty acids and fat soluble vitamins, and sufficient amounts of other essential vitamins and minerals. " [Enough carbs for desirable body weight: what is that?] Maybe I should use a different book for nutrition, because we haven't even gotten to lipids yet, and I'se is scared <g>. If so, what do you recommend? Online sources are fine with some chemistry sprinkled in, but not too heavy, if ya know what I mean. Thanks, Deanna Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.