Re: turnips

[Guest guest]

Hi Baden,

I just checked my book and the 12th edition has turnips in both the

'allowed' and 'not allowed' lists. Under the 'not allowed' list it says

they "may be tried after considerable improvement". To ask Iain to

update the site, you can email him at iain@....

Kim H.

husband, , CD 1999, SCD 2002

Hi folks,

In researching my radish question, I noticed that in two places on the

BTVC site, it says:

"In the most recent printing of BTVC (Ninth Printing - May 2002),

turnips were moved from the 'allowed' list to the 'not allowed' list."

I have the 12th Edition (January 2007) and it has turnips in the

allowed list. How can I submit this as a potential website update?

(Though I find the rest of the info at

http://www.breaking theviciouscycle. info/knowledge_ base/kb/turnips. htm

extremely helpful and hope it stays in.)

Baden

[Guest guest]

Turnips were taken off because some people had trouble with them. So it's a question of individual reaction again.MaraHi Baden,I just checked my book and the 12th edition has turnips in both the 'allowed' and 'not allowed' lists. Under the 'not allowed' list it says they "may be tried after considerable improvement". To ask Iain to update the site, you can email him atiain@....Kim H.husband, , CD 1999, SCD 2002

[Guest guest]

At 11:52 AM 11/15/2008, you wrote:

Turnips were taken off because

some people had trouble with them.

Another problem is the type of turnip. The legal turnips were the small

white ones. People started using all kinds of big, fibrous ones, and they

had trouble.

—

Marilyn

New Orleans, Louisiana, USA

Undiagnosed IBS since 1976, SCD since 2001

Darn Good SCD Cook

No Human Children

Shadow & Sunny Longhair Dachshund