Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 I stand corrected. I knew should have asked the history teacher down the hall, and not taken a students word for it, I'm just responsible to teach 'em this medical stuff...... -MH >>> THEDUDMAN@... 2/17/2006 1:20 pm >>> , Small correction to your piece about a VP who has shot someone... Hamilton was not a VP who shot somebody...it was Burr, Jefferson's first VP from 1800 to 1804...who did so in a duel in July 1804...shortly after losing out on the NY Governor's election... Hamilton, unfortunately, was involved in that he was the receiver of the round from Burr....I also believe this was the last legal duel in the United States. Just wanted to correct the history piece...I am a little familiar with this as Mr. Burr is way back in my family ancestory.... Dudley Re: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident We have 2 sections of farmland south of Stratford(Pheasant Capital of Texas). The first couple of days of pheasant season, I'll guarantee that a few hunters will get peppered by shot. Usually not a big deal, ask Stratford EMS how many times they have called a helicopter for a 'peppering'. I suppose since this is the second VP who has shot somebody ( Hamilton was the first), the press has to overblow it. -MH >>> ExLngHrn@... 2/16/2006 4:19 pm >>> Comments on the aeromedical aspect? -Wes Ogilvie, MPA, JD, EMT-B Austin, Texas Anatomy of medical response to shooting Secret Service alerts an air ambulance at 6 p.m. initially By Corpus Christi Caller-Times February 16, 2006 In the minutes following Vice President Dick Cheney's accidental shooting of Austin lawyer Harry Whittington, Cheney's medical crew scrambled to treat the injured man while the Secret Service called for medical backup. Whittington, 78, was struck on the face, neck and chest between 5:30 and 5:50 p.m. Saturday while quail hunting at the 50,000-acre Armstrong Ranch in Kenedy County. " That's approximate from the information we have got, " Secret Service spokesman Zahren said of the accident's time. " That's coming from our people that were down there and the local agents from Mc. " Whittington had stepped away from Cheney and fellow hunter Pam Willeford, U.S. ambassador to Switzerland and Liechtenstein, to retrieve downed quail, and Cheney accidentally sprayed him with birdshot while firing on a second covey of quail. The Secret Service notified HALO-Flight dispatch about 6 p.m., putting the air ambulance service on standby in case Whittington needed to be flown to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial, the area's trauma center, said HALO-Flight executive director Randy Rowe. Minutes later, Christus Spohn Hospital Kleberg in Kingsville was notified that Whittington was en route. Both Cheney's office and the Secret Service have said the decision to take Whittington to Kingsville first was made by medical personnel who travel with Cheney, who has a history of heart problems. " I can't comment to why he wasn't flown, " Zahren said. " The medical folks that were there would have weighed more into that than our people on the scene. Decisions were made on their advice at that point. " Whittington was taken by ambulance to the Kingsville hospital about 6:20 p.m., Zahren said. " It was an ambulance on standby for the vice president's visit, " Zahren said. " It had been dedicated and it was given up to treat the victim. " The ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital between 6:45 and 6:50 p.m., Christus Spohn spokeswoman Wheeler said. HALO-Flight was called again at 7:07 p.m. after Spohn Kleberg medical personnel decided Whittington needed more advanced treatment. " Typically, why we get calls for transfers is for a higher level of care or a doctor preference, " Rowe said. The air ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital at 7:29 p.m. and landed at the Corpus Christi trauma center at 8:19 p.m., Rowe said. Whittington was awake and talking during the flight, he said. Contact at 886-3716 or HYPERLINK mailto:powellj@... powellj@... Copyright 2006, Caller.com. All Rights Reserved. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 I stand corrected. I knew should have asked the history teacher down the hall, and not taken a students word for it, I'm just responsible to teach 'em this medical stuff...... -MH >>> THEDUDMAN@... 2/17/2006 1:20 pm >>> , Small correction to your piece about a VP who has shot someone... Hamilton was not a VP who shot somebody...it was Burr, Jefferson's first VP from 1800 to 1804...who did so in a duel in July 1804...shortly after losing out on the NY Governor's election... Hamilton, unfortunately, was involved in that he was the receiver of the round from Burr....I also believe this was the last legal duel in the United States. Just wanted to correct the history piece...I am a little familiar with this as Mr. Burr is way back in my family ancestory.... Dudley Re: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident We have 2 sections of farmland south of Stratford(Pheasant Capital of Texas). The first couple of days of pheasant season, I'll guarantee that a few hunters will get peppered by shot. Usually not a big deal, ask Stratford EMS how many times they have called a helicopter for a 'peppering'. I suppose since this is the second VP who has shot somebody ( Hamilton was the first), the press has to overblow it. -MH >>> ExLngHrn@... 2/16/2006 4:19 pm >>> Comments on the aeromedical aspect? -Wes Ogilvie, MPA, JD, EMT-B Austin, Texas Anatomy of medical response to shooting Secret Service alerts an air ambulance at 6 p.m. initially By Corpus Christi Caller-Times February 16, 2006 In the minutes following Vice President Dick Cheney's accidental shooting of Austin lawyer Harry Whittington, Cheney's medical crew scrambled to treat the injured man while the Secret Service called for medical backup. Whittington, 78, was struck on the face, neck and chest between 5:30 and 5:50 p.m. Saturday while quail hunting at the 50,000-acre Armstrong Ranch in Kenedy County. " That's approximate from the information we have got, " Secret Service spokesman Zahren said of the accident's time. " That's coming from our people that were down there and the local agents from Mc. " Whittington had stepped away from Cheney and fellow hunter Pam Willeford, U.S. ambassador to Switzerland and Liechtenstein, to retrieve downed quail, and Cheney accidentally sprayed him with birdshot while firing on a second covey of quail. The Secret Service notified HALO-Flight dispatch about 6 p.m., putting the air ambulance service on standby in case Whittington needed to be flown to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial, the area's trauma center, said HALO-Flight executive director Randy Rowe. Minutes later, Christus Spohn Hospital Kleberg in Kingsville was notified that Whittington was en route. Both Cheney's office and the Secret Service have said the decision to take Whittington to Kingsville first was made by medical personnel who travel with Cheney, who has a history of heart problems. " I can't comment to why he wasn't flown, " Zahren said. " The medical folks that were there would have weighed more into that than our people on the scene. Decisions were made on their advice at that point. " Whittington was taken by ambulance to the Kingsville hospital about 6:20 p.m., Zahren said. " It was an ambulance on standby for the vice president's visit, " Zahren said. " It had been dedicated and it was given up to treat the victim. " The ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital between 6:45 and 6:50 p.m., Christus Spohn spokeswoman Wheeler said. HALO-Flight was called again at 7:07 p.m. after Spohn Kleberg medical personnel decided Whittington needed more advanced treatment. " Typically, why we get calls for transfers is for a higher level of care or a doctor preference, " Rowe said. The air ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital at 7:29 p.m. and landed at the Corpus Christi trauma center at 8:19 p.m., Rowe said. Whittington was awake and talking during the flight, he said. Contact at 886-3716 or HYPERLINK mailto:powellj@... powellj@... Copyright 2006, Caller.com. All Rights Reserved. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Mike, Lol, ya that's what I meant..I knew what I was talking about anyway.. > > > > > > The bullet moving > > into his coronary system happened well after he'd been in the > > hospital and reported by the press as " stable and in good condition " . > > > > For the record there was no bullet - only birdshot (which is much smaller > than buckshot). VERY different animals. IIRC, it was #8 shot - very tiny. > The trauma/kinetics are significantly different between the two (or three). > > Mike > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: <SNIPPED> For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: <SNIPPED> For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: <SNIPPED> For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Jay Leno said Cheney should get an award............... for shooting a lawyer. Sorry Gene, Wes, , and others.... That's funny right there, I don't care who ya are.... Tater Hudson wrote: We have 2 sections of farmland south of Stratford(Pheasant Capital of Texas). The first couple of days of pheasant season, I'll guarantee that a few hunters will get peppered by shot. Usually not a big deal, ask Stratford EMS how many times they have called a helicopter for a 'peppering'. I suppose since this is the second VP who has shot somebody ( Hamilton was the first), the press has to overblow it. -MH >>> ExLngHrn@... 2/16/2006 4:19 pm >>> Comments on the aeromedical aspect? -Wes Ogilvie, MPA, JD, EMT-B Austin, Texas Anatomy of medical response to shooting Secret Service alerts an air ambulance at 6 p.m. initially By Corpus Christi Caller-Times February 16, 2006 In the minutes following Vice President Dick Cheney's accidental shooting of Austin lawyer Harry Whittington, Cheney's medical crew scrambled to treat the injured man while the Secret Service called for medical backup. Whittington, 78, was struck on the face, neck and chest between 5:30 and 5:50 p.m. Saturday while quail hunting at the 50,000-acre Armstrong Ranch in Kenedy County. " That's approximate from the information we have got, " Secret Service spokesman Zahren said of the accident's time. " That's coming from our people that were down there and the local agents from Mc. " Whittington had stepped away from Cheney and fellow hunter Pam Willeford, U.S. ambassador to Switzerland and Liechtenstein, to retrieve downed quail, and Cheney accidentally sprayed him with birdshot while firing on a second covey of quail. The Secret Service notified HALO-Flight dispatch about 6 p.m., putting the air ambulance service on standby in case Whittington needed to be flown to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial, the area's trauma center, said HALO-Flight executive director Randy Rowe. Minutes later, Christus Spohn Hospital Kleberg in Kingsville was notified that Whittington was en route. Both Cheney's office and the Secret Service have said the decision to take Whittington to Kingsville first was made by medical personnel who travel with Cheney, who has a history of heart problems. " I can't comment to why he wasn't flown, " Zahren said. " The medical folks that were there would have weighed more into that than our people on the scene. Decisions were made on their advice at that point. " Whittington was taken by ambulance to the Kingsville hospital about 6:20 p.m., Zahren said. " It was an ambulance on standby for the vice president's visit, " Zahren said. " It had been dedicated and it was given up to treat the victim. " The ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital between 6:45 and 6:50 p.m., Christus Spohn spokeswoman Wheeler said. HALO-Flight was called again at 7:07 p.m. after Spohn Kleberg medical personnel decided Whittington needed more advanced treatment. " Typically, why we get calls for transfers is for a higher level of care or a doctor preference, " Rowe said. The air ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital at 7:29 p.m. and landed at the Corpus Christi trauma center at 8:19 p.m., Rowe said. Whittington was awake and talking during the flight, he said. Contact at 886-3716 or HYPERLINK mailto:powellj@... powellj@... Copyright 2006, Caller.com. All Rights Reserved. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Jay Leno said Cheney should get an award............... for shooting a lawyer. Sorry Gene, Wes, , and others.... That's funny right there, I don't care who ya are.... Tater Hudson wrote: We have 2 sections of farmland south of Stratford(Pheasant Capital of Texas). The first couple of days of pheasant season, I'll guarantee that a few hunters will get peppered by shot. Usually not a big deal, ask Stratford EMS how many times they have called a helicopter for a 'peppering'. I suppose since this is the second VP who has shot somebody ( Hamilton was the first), the press has to overblow it. -MH >>> ExLngHrn@... 2/16/2006 4:19 pm >>> Comments on the aeromedical aspect? -Wes Ogilvie, MPA, JD, EMT-B Austin, Texas Anatomy of medical response to shooting Secret Service alerts an air ambulance at 6 p.m. initially By Corpus Christi Caller-Times February 16, 2006 In the minutes following Vice President Dick Cheney's accidental shooting of Austin lawyer Harry Whittington, Cheney's medical crew scrambled to treat the injured man while the Secret Service called for medical backup. Whittington, 78, was struck on the face, neck and chest between 5:30 and 5:50 p.m. Saturday while quail hunting at the 50,000-acre Armstrong Ranch in Kenedy County. " That's approximate from the information we have got, " Secret Service spokesman Zahren said of the accident's time. " That's coming from our people that were down there and the local agents from Mc. " Whittington had stepped away from Cheney and fellow hunter Pam Willeford, U.S. ambassador to Switzerland and Liechtenstein, to retrieve downed quail, and Cheney accidentally sprayed him with birdshot while firing on a second covey of quail. The Secret Service notified HALO-Flight dispatch about 6 p.m., putting the air ambulance service on standby in case Whittington needed to be flown to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial, the area's trauma center, said HALO-Flight executive director Randy Rowe. Minutes later, Christus Spohn Hospital Kleberg in Kingsville was notified that Whittington was en route. Both Cheney's office and the Secret Service have said the decision to take Whittington to Kingsville first was made by medical personnel who travel with Cheney, who has a history of heart problems. " I can't comment to why he wasn't flown, " Zahren said. " The medical folks that were there would have weighed more into that than our people on the scene. Decisions were made on their advice at that point. " Whittington was taken by ambulance to the Kingsville hospital about 6:20 p.m., Zahren said. " It was an ambulance on standby for the vice president's visit, " Zahren said. " It had been dedicated and it was given up to treat the victim. " The ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital between 6:45 and 6:50 p.m., Christus Spohn spokeswoman Wheeler said. HALO-Flight was called again at 7:07 p.m. after Spohn Kleberg medical personnel decided Whittington needed more advanced treatment. " Typically, why we get calls for transfers is for a higher level of care or a doctor preference, " Rowe said. The air ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital at 7:29 p.m. and landed at the Corpus Christi trauma center at 8:19 p.m., Rowe said. Whittington was awake and talking during the flight, he said. Contact at 886-3716 or HYPERLINK mailto:powellj@... powellj@... Copyright 2006, Caller.com. All Rights Reserved. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Jay Leno said Cheney should get an award............... for shooting a lawyer. Sorry Gene, Wes, , and others.... That's funny right there, I don't care who ya are.... Tater Hudson wrote: We have 2 sections of farmland south of Stratford(Pheasant Capital of Texas). The first couple of days of pheasant season, I'll guarantee that a few hunters will get peppered by shot. Usually not a big deal, ask Stratford EMS how many times they have called a helicopter for a 'peppering'. I suppose since this is the second VP who has shot somebody ( Hamilton was the first), the press has to overblow it. -MH >>> ExLngHrn@... 2/16/2006 4:19 pm >>> Comments on the aeromedical aspect? -Wes Ogilvie, MPA, JD, EMT-B Austin, Texas Anatomy of medical response to shooting Secret Service alerts an air ambulance at 6 p.m. initially By Corpus Christi Caller-Times February 16, 2006 In the minutes following Vice President Dick Cheney's accidental shooting of Austin lawyer Harry Whittington, Cheney's medical crew scrambled to treat the injured man while the Secret Service called for medical backup. Whittington, 78, was struck on the face, neck and chest between 5:30 and 5:50 p.m. Saturday while quail hunting at the 50,000-acre Armstrong Ranch in Kenedy County. " That's approximate from the information we have got, " Secret Service spokesman Zahren said of the accident's time. " That's coming from our people that were down there and the local agents from Mc. " Whittington had stepped away from Cheney and fellow hunter Pam Willeford, U.S. ambassador to Switzerland and Liechtenstein, to retrieve downed quail, and Cheney accidentally sprayed him with birdshot while firing on a second covey of quail. The Secret Service notified HALO-Flight dispatch about 6 p.m., putting the air ambulance service on standby in case Whittington needed to be flown to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial, the area's trauma center, said HALO-Flight executive director Randy Rowe. Minutes later, Christus Spohn Hospital Kleberg in Kingsville was notified that Whittington was en route. Both Cheney's office and the Secret Service have said the decision to take Whittington to Kingsville first was made by medical personnel who travel with Cheney, who has a history of heart problems. " I can't comment to why he wasn't flown, " Zahren said. " The medical folks that were there would have weighed more into that than our people on the scene. Decisions were made on their advice at that point. " Whittington was taken by ambulance to the Kingsville hospital about 6:20 p.m., Zahren said. " It was an ambulance on standby for the vice president's visit, " Zahren said. " It had been dedicated and it was given up to treat the victim. " The ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital between 6:45 and 6:50 p.m., Christus Spohn spokeswoman Wheeler said. HALO-Flight was called again at 7:07 p.m. after Spohn Kleberg medical personnel decided Whittington needed more advanced treatment. " Typically, why we get calls for transfers is for a higher level of care or a doctor preference, " Rowe said. The air ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital at 7:29 p.m. and landed at the Corpus Christi trauma center at 8:19 p.m., Rowe said. Whittington was awake and talking during the flight, he said. Contact at 886-3716 or HYPERLINK mailto:powellj@... powellj@... Copyright 2006, Caller.com. All Rights Reserved. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Steve, How SURE are you? I just recently was in that region teaching, and I have driven that road a number of times. It is flat and pretty straight. There is a " back way " that the medics will know that cuts across the country and has very little traffic. I'm betting that if the Poor Harry had been loaded into the ambulance as soon as the transfer decision was made, he would have been at the hospital in Corpus just as soon as the helo, if not sooner, not even running Code 3. So I don't buy the " much faster " statement. Gene. > I sincerely doubt it. Do the math; generally ground transport is faster > for a short distance. What is the distance from Kingsville to Corpus Christi, > 50 miles+/-? Ground would have been much faster and not any less > comfortable. >   >  Tater >   >  > > STEVE BOWMAN wrote: >  The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there > much faster. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Steve, How SURE are you? I just recently was in that region teaching, and I have driven that road a number of times. It is flat and pretty straight. There is a " back way " that the medics will know that cuts across the country and has very little traffic. I'm betting that if the Poor Harry had been loaded into the ambulance as soon as the transfer decision was made, he would have been at the hospital in Corpus just as soon as the helo, if not sooner, not even running Code 3. So I don't buy the " much faster " statement. Gene. > I sincerely doubt it. Do the math; generally ground transport is faster > for a short distance. What is the distance from Kingsville to Corpus Christi, > 50 miles+/-? Ground would have been much faster and not any less > comfortable. >   >  Tater >   >  > > STEVE BOWMAN wrote: >  The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there > much faster. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Steve, How SURE are you? I just recently was in that region teaching, and I have driven that road a number of times. It is flat and pretty straight. There is a " back way " that the medics will know that cuts across the country and has very little traffic. I'm betting that if the Poor Harry had been loaded into the ambulance as soon as the transfer decision was made, he would have been at the hospital in Corpus just as soon as the helo, if not sooner, not even running Code 3. So I don't buy the " much faster " statement. Gene. > I sincerely doubt it. Do the math; generally ground transport is faster > for a short distance. What is the distance from Kingsville to Corpus Christi, > 50 miles+/-? Ground would have been much faster and not any less > comfortable. >   >  Tater >   >  > > STEVE BOWMAN wrote: >  The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there > much faster. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Tater, What's up brother? I think Dave's top ten was the best February 13, 2006 Top Ten Dick Cheney Excuses 10. " Heart palpitation caused trigger finger to spasm " 9. " Wanted to get the Iraq mess off the front page " 8. " Not enough Jim Beam " 7. " Trying to stop the spread of bird flu " 6. " I love to shoot people " 5. " Guy was making cracks about my lesbian daughter " 4. " I thought the guy was trying to go 'gay cowboy' on me " 3. " Excuse? I hit him, didn't I? " 2. " Until Democrats approve medicare reform, we have to make some tough choices for the elderly " 1. " Made a bet with Gretzky's wife " Danny > We have 2 sections of farmland south of Stratford(Pheasant Capital of Texas). The first couple of days of pheasant season, I'll guarantee that a few hunters will get peppered by shot. Usually not a big deal, ask Stratford EMS how many times they have called a helicopter for a 'peppering'. I suppose since this is the second VP who has shot somebody ( Hamilton was the first), the press has to overblow it. > > -MH > > >>> ExLngHrn@... 2/16/2006 4:19 pm >>> > Comments on the aeromedical aspect? > > -Wes Ogilvie, MPA, JD, EMT-B > Austin, Texas > > > Anatomy of medical response to shooting > Secret Service alerts an air ambulance at 6 p.m. initially > By Corpus Christi Caller-Times > February 16, 2006 > > In the minutes following Vice President Dick Cheney's accidental shooting of Austin lawyer Harry Whittington, Cheney's medical crew scrambled to treat the injured man while the Secret Service called for medical backup. > Whittington, 78, was struck on the face, neck and chest between 5:30 and 5:50 p.m. Saturday while quail hunting at the 50,000-acre Armstrong Ranch in Kenedy County. > " That's approximate from the information we have got, " Secret Service spokesman Zahren said of the accident's time. " That's coming from our people that were down there and the local agents from Mc. " > Whittington had stepped away from Cheney and fellow hunter Pam Willeford, U.S. ambassador to Switzerland and Liechtenstein, to retrieve downed quail, and Cheney accidentally sprayed him with birdshot while firing on a second covey of quail. > The Secret Service notified HALO-Flight dispatch about 6 p.m., putting the air ambulance service on standby in case Whittington needed to be flown to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial, the area's trauma center, said HALO-Flight executive director Randy Rowe. Minutes later, Christus Spohn Hospital Kleberg in Kingsville was notified that Whittington was en route. > Both Cheney's office and the Secret Service have said the decision to take Whittington to Kingsville first was made by medical personnel who travel with Cheney, who has a history of heart problems. > " I can't comment to why he wasn't flown, " Zahren said. " The medical folks that were there would have weighed more into that than our people on the scene. Decisions were made on their advice at that point. " > Whittington was taken by ambulance to the Kingsville hospital about 6:20 p.m., Zahren said. > " It was an ambulance on standby for the vice president's visit, " Zahren said. " It had been dedicated and it was given up to treat the victim. " > The ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital between 6:45 and 6:50 p.m., Christus Spohn spokeswoman Wheeler said. > HALO-Flight was called again at 7:07 p.m. after Spohn Kleberg medical personnel decided Whittington needed more advanced treatment. > " Typically, why we get calls for transfers is for a higher level of care or a doctor preference, " Rowe said. > The air ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital at 7:29 p.m. and landed at the Corpus Christi trauma center at 8:19 p.m., Rowe said. Whittington was awake and talking during the flight, he said. > Contact at 886-3716 or HYPERLINK mailto:powellj@... powellj@... > Copyright 2006, Caller.com. All Rights Reserved. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Tater, What's up brother? I think Dave's top ten was the best February 13, 2006 Top Ten Dick Cheney Excuses 10. " Heart palpitation caused trigger finger to spasm " 9. " Wanted to get the Iraq mess off the front page " 8. " Not enough Jim Beam " 7. " Trying to stop the spread of bird flu " 6. " I love to shoot people " 5. " Guy was making cracks about my lesbian daughter " 4. " I thought the guy was trying to go 'gay cowboy' on me " 3. " Excuse? I hit him, didn't I? " 2. " Until Democrats approve medicare reform, we have to make some tough choices for the elderly " 1. " Made a bet with Gretzky's wife " Danny > We have 2 sections of farmland south of Stratford(Pheasant Capital of Texas). The first couple of days of pheasant season, I'll guarantee that a few hunters will get peppered by shot. Usually not a big deal, ask Stratford EMS how many times they have called a helicopter for a 'peppering'. I suppose since this is the second VP who has shot somebody ( Hamilton was the first), the press has to overblow it. > > -MH > > >>> ExLngHrn@... 2/16/2006 4:19 pm >>> > Comments on the aeromedical aspect? > > -Wes Ogilvie, MPA, JD, EMT-B > Austin, Texas > > > Anatomy of medical response to shooting > Secret Service alerts an air ambulance at 6 p.m. initially > By Corpus Christi Caller-Times > February 16, 2006 > > In the minutes following Vice President Dick Cheney's accidental shooting of Austin lawyer Harry Whittington, Cheney's medical crew scrambled to treat the injured man while the Secret Service called for medical backup. > Whittington, 78, was struck on the face, neck and chest between 5:30 and 5:50 p.m. Saturday while quail hunting at the 50,000-acre Armstrong Ranch in Kenedy County. > " That's approximate from the information we have got, " Secret Service spokesman Zahren said of the accident's time. " That's coming from our people that were down there and the local agents from Mc. " > Whittington had stepped away from Cheney and fellow hunter Pam Willeford, U.S. ambassador to Switzerland and Liechtenstein, to retrieve downed quail, and Cheney accidentally sprayed him with birdshot while firing on a second covey of quail. > The Secret Service notified HALO-Flight dispatch about 6 p.m., putting the air ambulance service on standby in case Whittington needed to be flown to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial, the area's trauma center, said HALO-Flight executive director Randy Rowe. Minutes later, Christus Spohn Hospital Kleberg in Kingsville was notified that Whittington was en route. > Both Cheney's office and the Secret Service have said the decision to take Whittington to Kingsville first was made by medical personnel who travel with Cheney, who has a history of heart problems. > " I can't comment to why he wasn't flown, " Zahren said. " The medical folks that were there would have weighed more into that than our people on the scene. Decisions were made on their advice at that point. " > Whittington was taken by ambulance to the Kingsville hospital about 6:20 p.m., Zahren said. > " It was an ambulance on standby for the vice president's visit, " Zahren said. " It had been dedicated and it was given up to treat the victim. " > The ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital between 6:45 and 6:50 p.m., Christus Spohn spokeswoman Wheeler said. > HALO-Flight was called again at 7:07 p.m. after Spohn Kleberg medical personnel decided Whittington needed more advanced treatment. > " Typically, why we get calls for transfers is for a higher level of care or a doctor preference, " Rowe said. > The air ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital at 7:29 p.m. and landed at the Corpus Christi trauma center at 8:19 p.m., Rowe said. Whittington was awake and talking during the flight, he said. > Contact at 886-3716 or HYPERLINK mailto:powellj@... powellj@... > Copyright 2006, Caller.com. All Rights Reserved. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Tater, What's up brother? I think Dave's top ten was the best February 13, 2006 Top Ten Dick Cheney Excuses 10. " Heart palpitation caused trigger finger to spasm " 9. " Wanted to get the Iraq mess off the front page " 8. " Not enough Jim Beam " 7. " Trying to stop the spread of bird flu " 6. " I love to shoot people " 5. " Guy was making cracks about my lesbian daughter " 4. " I thought the guy was trying to go 'gay cowboy' on me " 3. " Excuse? I hit him, didn't I? " 2. " Until Democrats approve medicare reform, we have to make some tough choices for the elderly " 1. " Made a bet with Gretzky's wife " Danny > We have 2 sections of farmland south of Stratford(Pheasant Capital of Texas). The first couple of days of pheasant season, I'll guarantee that a few hunters will get peppered by shot. Usually not a big deal, ask Stratford EMS how many times they have called a helicopter for a 'peppering'. I suppose since this is the second VP who has shot somebody ( Hamilton was the first), the press has to overblow it. > > -MH > > >>> ExLngHrn@... 2/16/2006 4:19 pm >>> > Comments on the aeromedical aspect? > > -Wes Ogilvie, MPA, JD, EMT-B > Austin, Texas > > > Anatomy of medical response to shooting > Secret Service alerts an air ambulance at 6 p.m. initially > By Corpus Christi Caller-Times > February 16, 2006 > > In the minutes following Vice President Dick Cheney's accidental shooting of Austin lawyer Harry Whittington, Cheney's medical crew scrambled to treat the injured man while the Secret Service called for medical backup. > Whittington, 78, was struck on the face, neck and chest between 5:30 and 5:50 p.m. Saturday while quail hunting at the 50,000-acre Armstrong Ranch in Kenedy County. > " That's approximate from the information we have got, " Secret Service spokesman Zahren said of the accident's time. " That's coming from our people that were down there and the local agents from Mc. " > Whittington had stepped away from Cheney and fellow hunter Pam Willeford, U.S. ambassador to Switzerland and Liechtenstein, to retrieve downed quail, and Cheney accidentally sprayed him with birdshot while firing on a second covey of quail. > The Secret Service notified HALO-Flight dispatch about 6 p.m., putting the air ambulance service on standby in case Whittington needed to be flown to Christus Spohn Hospital Memorial, the area's trauma center, said HALO-Flight executive director Randy Rowe. Minutes later, Christus Spohn Hospital Kleberg in Kingsville was notified that Whittington was en route. > Both Cheney's office and the Secret Service have said the decision to take Whittington to Kingsville first was made by medical personnel who travel with Cheney, who has a history of heart problems. > " I can't comment to why he wasn't flown, " Zahren said. " The medical folks that were there would have weighed more into that than our people on the scene. Decisions were made on their advice at that point. " > Whittington was taken by ambulance to the Kingsville hospital about 6:20 p.m., Zahren said. > " It was an ambulance on standby for the vice president's visit, " Zahren said. " It had been dedicated and it was given up to treat the victim. " > The ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital between 6:45 and 6:50 p.m., Christus Spohn spokeswoman Wheeler said. > HALO-Flight was called again at 7:07 p.m. after Spohn Kleberg medical personnel decided Whittington needed more advanced treatment. > " Typically, why we get calls for transfers is for a higher level of care or a doctor preference, " Rowe said. > The air ambulance arrived at the Kingsville hospital at 7:29 p.m. and landed at the Corpus Christi trauma center at 8:19 p.m., Rowe said. Whittington was awake and talking during the flight, he said. > Contact at 886-3716 or HYPERLINK mailto:powellj@... powellj@... > Copyright 2006, Caller.com. All Rights Reserved. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 I think you are embellishing the facts. According to MapQuest, the distance from Spohn Hospital in Kingsville to Memorial Hospital in Corpus Christi by ground is 46.62 miles or 49 minutes average (driving the posted speed and stopping at all lights/signs). I doubt the helicopter was at Kingsville, so it probably came from Corpus Christi. Thus, when they made the decision to transport the wounded lawyer, had they put him in a ground ambulance he would have been at Memorial in 45 minutes. It would have taken 5 minutes to start the helicopter, 22 minutes for the flight. Shut down and ground time of about 30 minutes. Start-up and transport the Memorial would take about 35 minutes. He probably would have gotten there by ground in half the time. Unless the helicopters in Corpus are now capable of time travel. _____ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of STEVE BOWMAN Sent: Friday, February 17, 2006 3:28 PM To: Subject: Re: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What's stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 I think you are embellishing the facts. According to MapQuest, the distance from Spohn Hospital in Kingsville to Memorial Hospital in Corpus Christi by ground is 46.62 miles or 49 minutes average (driving the posted speed and stopping at all lights/signs). I doubt the helicopter was at Kingsville, so it probably came from Corpus Christi. Thus, when they made the decision to transport the wounded lawyer, had they put him in a ground ambulance he would have been at Memorial in 45 minutes. It would have taken 5 minutes to start the helicopter, 22 minutes for the flight. Shut down and ground time of about 30 minutes. Start-up and transport the Memorial would take about 35 minutes. He probably would have gotten there by ground in half the time. Unless the helicopters in Corpus are now capable of time travel. _____ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of STEVE BOWMAN Sent: Friday, February 17, 2006 3:28 PM To: Subject: Re: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What's stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 I think you are embellishing the facts. According to MapQuest, the distance from Spohn Hospital in Kingsville to Memorial Hospital in Corpus Christi by ground is 46.62 miles or 49 minutes average (driving the posted speed and stopping at all lights/signs). I doubt the helicopter was at Kingsville, so it probably came from Corpus Christi. Thus, when they made the decision to transport the wounded lawyer, had they put him in a ground ambulance he would have been at Memorial in 45 minutes. It would have taken 5 minutes to start the helicopter, 22 minutes for the flight. Shut down and ground time of about 30 minutes. Start-up and transport the Memorial would take about 35 minutes. He probably would have gotten there by ground in half the time. Unless the helicopters in Corpus are now capable of time travel. _____ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of STEVE BOWMAN Sent: Friday, February 17, 2006 3:28 PM To: Subject: Re: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What's stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 I am still at a loss as to why he was flown. Of course we do not have all the information but based on what I have read and seen on the news, the patient had A-fib and some minor gsw wounds from the pellets. His condition as I understand it was stable. So where was the good medical practice? All medical transportation has a certain level of risk of an accident occurring. But given the latest research on helicopter crashes, I would have to be 100 % sure that air transport is really needed and that the alternative of ground transport would have a detrimental outcome on the patient. Otherwise the ground transport wins out. I have had some really sick patients in my ambulance in the past that were inter-facility transports, even though air transport was available the ground option was chosen. With all the critical care units out there today, can they not handle this type of transport with good care, in a safer mode of transport and at a reasonable cost? Don’t get me wrong I agree that air transport, in particular helicopter transport has its place in the medical system but I do not think we are using the proper criteria to determine who goes by what means. That should be the issue that is addressed. We need to establish a protocol based on current research data, not speculation or just in case or because that is the way we have always done it! Just my opinion, Bernie Stafford EMTP _____ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of STEVE BOWMAN Sent: Friday, February 17, 2006 3:28 PM To: Subject: Re: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? HYPERLINK " http://www.TexasEMSAT.org " http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 I am still at a loss as to why he was flown. Of course we do not have all the information but based on what I have read and seen on the news, the patient had A-fib and some minor gsw wounds from the pellets. His condition as I understand it was stable. So where was the good medical practice? All medical transportation has a certain level of risk of an accident occurring. But given the latest research on helicopter crashes, I would have to be 100 % sure that air transport is really needed and that the alternative of ground transport would have a detrimental outcome on the patient. Otherwise the ground transport wins out. I have had some really sick patients in my ambulance in the past that were inter-facility transports, even though air transport was available the ground option was chosen. With all the critical care units out there today, can they not handle this type of transport with good care, in a safer mode of transport and at a reasonable cost? Don’t get me wrong I agree that air transport, in particular helicopter transport has its place in the medical system but I do not think we are using the proper criteria to determine who goes by what means. That should be the issue that is addressed. We need to establish a protocol based on current research data, not speculation or just in case or because that is the way we have always done it! Just my opinion, Bernie Stafford EMTP _____ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of STEVE BOWMAN Sent: Friday, February 17, 2006 3:28 PM To: Subject: Re: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? HYPERLINK " http://www.TexasEMSAT.org " http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 I sincerely doubt it. Do the math; generally ground transport is faster for a short distance. What is the distance from Kingsville to Corpus Christi, 50 miles+/-? Ground would have been much faster and not any less comfortable. Tater STEVE BOWMAN wrote: The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What’s stopping you from joining EMSAT? http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- Relax. Yahoo! Mail virus scanning helps detect nasty viruses! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 17, 2006 Report Share Posted February 17, 2006 Very Simple Answer: Why was he flown.....1. HE WAS A FRIEND OF THE VICE PRESIDENT . 2. HE HAD JUST BEEN SHOT BY THE SAME V.P. Wouldn't you have flow the same patient knowing that you actions would be under national scrutiny...Why is everyone missing this simple explanation and arguing a mute point? Time to move on to the next subject.. - ---- Original Message ----- To: < > Sent: Friday, February 17, 2006 4:00 PM Subject: RE: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident I am still at a loss as to why he was flown. Of course we do not have all the information but based on what I have read and seen on the news, the patient had A-fib and some minor gsw wounds from the pellets. His condition as I understand it was stable. So where was the good medical practice? All medical transportation has a certain level of risk of an accident occurring. But given the latest research on helicopter crashes, I would have to be 100 % sure that air transport is really needed and that the alternative of ground transport would have a detrimental outcome on the patient. Otherwise the ground transport wins out. I have had some really sick patients in my ambulance in the past that were inter-facility transports, even though air transport was available the ground option was chosen. With all the critical care units out there today, can they not handle this type of transport with good care, in a safer mode of transport and at a reasonable cost? Don't get me wrong I agree that air transport, in particular helicopter transport has its place in the medical system but I do not think we are using the proper criteria to determine who goes by what means. That should be the issue that is addressed. We need to establish a protocol based on current research data, not speculation or just in case or because that is the way we have always done it! Just my opinion, Bernie Stafford EMTP _____ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of STEVE BOWMAN Sent: Friday, February 17, 2006 3:28 PM To: Subject: Re: Corpus Christi newspaper reports on EMS response to Cheney incident " the risks outweighed the benefit in this case " - and you know this because? The doctor(s) in the ER at the hospital in Kingsville made the call to fly him (according to the newspaper article). What criteria they used in making their decision was not stated; however, good medical practice would normally dictate that such a decision be made in the manner that is of most benefit to the patient. Since we don't know the qualifications of the physician(s) involved or the criteria they applied, second-guessing them is dangerous. The only thing that we can be SURE of is that the helicopter got him there much faster. The comment about " smoother " that I made before was based on a fair amount of time spent in the back of both helicopters and ambulances - the latter as both patient and crew. Even on a reasonably smooth road, it's not a fun ride in teh back of an ambulance. You feel every bump, sway, turn, etc. The major movement in the back of a heklicopter in good weather is vibration (a fair amount of that, I admit). If I were the patient, I would rather fly, thank you - especially when the choices are flying for 30-40 minutes or driving for 2-3 hours. . . " E. Tate " wrote: To what end? The hospital should have been able to establish that this was not needed, and sent him by ground. Helicopters are not about creature comfort, and the risks outweighed the benefit in this case. Helo was a horrible call. I'd bet the rent-a-doc in the ER had some strange notion that the helo was some miracle working machine. STEVE BOWMAN wrote: For the transfer to the higher-level facility, transport by air was much faster and smoother for the patient. E. Tate, LP Whitehouse, Texas What's stopping you from joining EMSAT? HYPERLINK " http://www.TexasEMSAT.org " http://www.TexasEMSAT.org --------------------------------- What are the most popular cars? Find out at Yahoo! Autos Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.