Guest guest Posted September 24, 2012 Report Share Posted September 24, 2012 You did the right thing by pointing out her disrespect. You had boundaries and she crossed them and you told her so. However, you shouldn't have backed down and asked her to stay if she wanted to. She could see your weakness and I'm surprised she left anyway. It was a good day that she didn't call you raging about how terrible you made her feel. It is a good first step to boundaries - the next time will feel a little better. Remember - they don't hear what you say. She wanted to be there and see your son and even if she said it was her intention to help you she was not willing to listen that you didn't want her. My nada is the same way. We went shopping one day and she said I needed a black dress for special occasions. I told her I had a black dress I hadn't worn in several years. She didn't hear that. A week later she showed up with a black dress she found that she bought me. It wasn't my style - it was something she would have worn (just a different size). I did not express my boundaries then either like I should - I just gave the dress to Goodwill. I didn't know about BPD and boundaries then but to remember it makes me furious that she didn't listen or care about what I said. Even when they THINK it is about you it is really about THEM. :-( jwjrenslow@...> jwjrenslow@... _____ From: WTOAdultChildren1 [mailto:WTOAdultChildren1 ] On Behalf Of Sommer Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 11:35 AM To: WTOAdultChildren1 Subject: Nada just showed up when I said not to - feedback please My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've been updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her that we had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we were getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all up. She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different times. I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that something more serious is going on. I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she did. Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like this before. This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. She hugged my son and said that she would just go. Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. But she left instead. Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would have only prolonged the " conversation. " So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I did. I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let some things go? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2012 Report Share Posted September 24, 2012 , The most important thing is that you be there for your son. Nada does not deserve any of your energy. It's good that she left. She has nothing to contribute. I apologize for being brief, am at lab at school. I hope that your son is well soon. Hugs, - ________________________________ To: " WTOAdultChildren1 " WTOAdultChildren1 > Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 10:35 AM Subject: Nada just showed up when I said not to - feedback please  My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've been updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her that we had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we were getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all up. She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different times.  I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that something more serious is going on.  I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she did.  Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like this before.  This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that.  She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said.  She hugged my son and said that she would just go.  Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son.  But she left instead.  Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would have only prolonged the " conversation. "  So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I did.  I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let some things go? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2012 Report Share Posted September 24, 2012 You shouldn't feel guilty for the fact that this woman disrespected your boundary, was controlling and then turned it around on you. She played you and it worked. Please don't allow yourself to be controlled (emotionally) through guilt, for your sake and the sake of your family. I'm sad you're more on her side than yours. Good luck with this. On Mon, Sep 24, 2012 at 3:34 PM, Halloran laura.halloran@...>wrote: > ** > > > , > The most important thing is that you be there for your son. > Nada does not deserve any of your energy. > It's good that she left. > She has nothing to contribute. > I apologize for being brief, am at lab at school. > I hope that your son is well soon. > Hugs, > - > > ________________________________ > > To: " WTOAdultChildren1 " WTOAdultChildren1 > > > Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 10:35 AM > > Subject: Nada just showed up when I said not to - > feedback please > > > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've been > updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her that we > had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we were > getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all up. > She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different times. > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had > x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that > something more serious is going on. > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she did. > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my > annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like > this before. > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I just > wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her > visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > But she left instead. > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that she > wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad even > said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I should be > mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " And we > hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect what I > had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would have only > prolonged the " conversation. " > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting > to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I > did. > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. But > what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let some > things go? > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2012 Report Share Posted September 24, 2012 This sounds so harsh, sorry but please understand I don't intend to be mean but these people are NOT ON OUR SIDE. So we have to be. On Mon, Sep 24, 2012 at 5:07 PM, Millicent Kunstler < millicentkunstler@...> wrote: > You shouldn't feel guilty for the fact that this woman disrespected your > boundary, was controlling and then turned it around on you. She played you > and it worked. Please don't allow yourself to be controlled (emotionally) > through guilt, for your sake and the sake of your family. I'm sad you're > more on her side than yours. Good luck with this. > > > On Mon, Sep 24, 2012 at 3:34 PM, Halloran laura.halloran@...>wrote: > >> ** >> >> >> , >> The most important thing is that you be there for your son. >> Nada does not deserve any of your energy. >> It's good that she left. >> She has nothing to contribute. >> I apologize for being brief, am at lab at school. >> I hope that your son is well soon. >> Hugs, >> - >> >> ________________________________ >> >> To: " WTOAdultChildren1 WTOAdultChildren1 > >> Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 10:35 AM >> >> Subject: Nada just showed up when I said not to - >> feedback please >> >> >> >> My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've been >> updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her that we >> had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we were >> getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all up. >> She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different times. >> >> I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had >> x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that >> something more serious is going on. >> >> I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she >> did. >> >> Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my >> annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like >> this before. >> >> This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I >> just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. >> >> She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her >> visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. >> >> She hugged my son and said that she would just go. >> >> Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. >> >> But she left instead. >> >> Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that >> she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad >> even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I >> should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " >> And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect >> what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would >> have only prolonged the " conversation. " >> >> So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting >> to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I >> did. >> >> I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. >> But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let >> some things go? >> >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2012 Report Share Posted September 24, 2012 ((((())))) Don't be too hard on yourself. Its never easy to begin setting boundaries. And its harder to do when you are emotionally stressed out already. You were naturally very stressed and worried about your child. Still, no matter what the situation, you have a right to be heard and respected, not ignored and treated like a child yourself. Your nada perhaps isn't used to actually hearing what you are saying and respecting your decisions if you're saying something that is the opposite of what she wants to do. (Really similarly to the way a toddler who is determined to get a cookie out of the jar is not " hearing " you say NO, sweetie, please get down off the counter. " ) Your nada wanted to come over, so she wasn't really *hearing* you tell her " No. " Or, she wasn't processing it. Please do not let misplaced guilt or force of habit prevent you from assertively but calmly and politely set normal, reasonable adult boundaries for yourself. You have the right to say " NO " if you want to; we all do. The more you set boundaries, the less ALIEN it feels to say things like " No, thanks " or " This isn't a good time for me " or " I'm sorry but I need to go /hang up now. " to our nadas. I hope your little boy gets better very soon, that must be very upsetting to see him not able to eat and not know exactly why. -Annie > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've been updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her that we had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we were getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all up. She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different times. > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that something more serious is going on. > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she did. > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like this before. > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > But she left instead. > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would have only prolonged the " conversation. " > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I did. > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let some things go? > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2012 Report Share Posted September 24, 2012 Hope your boy recovers soon! On Mon, Sep 24, 2012 at 8:44 PM, anuria67854 anuria-67854@...>wrote: > ** > > > ((((())))) > Don't be too hard on yourself. Its never easy to begin setting boundaries. > And its harder to do when you are emotionally stressed out already. You > were naturally very stressed and worried about your child. > > Still, no matter what the situation, you have a right to be heard and > respected, not ignored and treated like a child yourself. Your nada perhaps > isn't used to actually hearing what you are saying and respecting your > decisions if you're saying something that is the opposite of what she wants > to do. (Really similarly to the way a toddler who is determined to get a > cookie out of the jar is not " hearing " you say NO, sweetie, please get down > off the counter. " ) > > Your nada wanted to come over, so she wasn't really *hearing* you tell her > " No. " Or, she wasn't processing it. > > Please do not let misplaced guilt or force of habit prevent you from > assertively but calmly and politely set normal, reasonable adult boundaries > for yourself. You have the right to say " NO " if you want to; we all do. > > The more you set boundaries, the less ALIEN it feels to say things like > " No, thanks " or " This isn't a good time for me " or " I'm sorry but I need to > go /hang up now. " to our nadas. > > I hope your little boy gets better very soon, that must be very upsetting > to see him not able to eat and not know exactly why. > > -Annie > > > > > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've > been updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her > that we had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we > were getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all > up. She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different > times. > > > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had > x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that > something more serious is going on. > > > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she > did. > > > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my > annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like > this before. > > > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I > just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. > > > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her > visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > > > But she left instead. > > > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that > she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad > even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I > should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " > And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect > what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would > have only prolonged the " conversation. " > > > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting > to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I > did. > > > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. > But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let > some things go? > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2012 Report Share Posted September 25, 2012 Of course you did the right thing, and your reaction is totally normal. It's the cycle- 1. You state a boundary. 2. She violates it. 3. She triggers your guilt. 4. You stew in guilt and question reality. 5. You either give in (and apologize), or hold firm yet dig yourself deeper into the cruel daughter self-image. 6. Cry and repeat. You hit step 5 and didn't give in, and you came here to short out the circuit with validation. I'd say that's a win. Go you! > > You did the right thing by pointing out her disrespect. You had boundaries > and she crossed them and you told her so. However, you shouldn't have > backed down and asked her to stay if she wanted to. She could see your > weakness and I'm surprised she left anyway. It was a good day that she > didn't call you raging about how terrible you made her feel. It is a good > first step to boundaries - the next time will feel a little better. > Remember - they don't hear what you say. She wanted to be there and see > your son and even if she said it was her intention to help you she was not > willing to listen that you didn't want her. > > > > My nada is the same way. We went shopping one day and she said I needed a > black dress for special occasions. I told her I had a black dress I hadn't > worn in several years. She didn't hear that. A week later she showed up > with a black dress she found that she bought me. It wasn't my style - it > was something she would have worn (just a different size). I did not > express my boundaries then either like I should - I just gave the dress to > Goodwill. I didn't know about BPD and boundaries then but to remember it > makes me furious that she didn't listen or care about what I said. Even > when they THINK it is about you it is really about THEM. :-( > > > > > > jwjrenslow@... > > > > _____ > > From: WTOAdultChildren1 > [mailto:WTOAdultChildren1 ] On Behalf Of Sommer > Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 11:35 AM > To: WTOAdultChildren1 > Subject: Nada just showed up when I said not to - > feedback please > > > > > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've been > updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her that we > had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we were > getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all up. She > asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different times. > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had x-rays > and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that > something more serious is going on. > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she did. > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my annoyance > to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like this before. > > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I just > wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her visit. > I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > But she left instead. > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that she > wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad even > said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I should be > mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " And we hung > up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect what I had > said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would have only > prolonged the " conversation. " > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting to > come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I did. > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. But > what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let some > things go? > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2012 Report Share Posted September 25, 2012 All of your replies helped so much. I kept repeating to myself throughout the day, " I said don't come over, and she didn't care and came over anyway. " I also noticed that I felt way better than I used to feel when I would let her do things like that. I'm prepared for her to further respond to this situation by saying that I'm a cold person and that's why I don't have any friends--the things she says when she's upset that I don't call her every day or ask her to do things with me, but that's okay. I had a nice quiet day with my son--who was finally able to eat something. : ) ________________________________ To: WTOAdultChildren1 Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 6:33 PM Subject: Re: Re: Nada just showed up when I said not to - feedback please Hope your boy recovers soon! On Mon, Sep 24, 2012 at 8:44 PM, anuria67854 anuria-67854@...>wrote: > ** > > > ((((())))) > Don't be too hard on yourself. Its never easy to begin setting boundaries. > And its harder to do when you are emotionally stressed out already. You > were naturally very stressed and worried about your child. > > Still, no matter what the situation, you have a right to be heard and > respected, not ignored and treated like a child yourself. Your nada perhaps > isn't used to actually hearing what you are saying and respecting your > decisions if you're saying something that is the opposite of what she wants > to do. (Really similarly to the way a toddler who is determined to get a > cookie out of the jar is not " hearing " you say NO, sweetie, please get down > off the counter. " ) > > Your nada wanted to come over, so she wasn't really *hearing* you tell her > " No. " Or, she wasn't processing it. > > Please do not let misplaced guilt or force of habit prevent you from > assertively but calmly and politely set normal, reasonable adult boundaries > for yourself. You have the right to say " NO " if you want to; we all do. > > The more you set boundaries, the less ALIEN it feels to say things like > " No, thanks " or " This isn't a good time for me " or " I'm sorry but I need to > go /hang up now. " to our nadas. > > I hope your little boy gets better very soon, that must be very upsetting > to see him not able to eat and not know exactly why. > > -Annie > > > > > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've > been updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her > that we had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we > were getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all > up. She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different > times. > > > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had > x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that > something more serious is going on. > > > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she > did. > > > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my > annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like > this before. > > > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I > just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. > > > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her > visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > > > But she left instead. > > > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that > she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad > even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I > should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " > And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect > what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would > have only prolonged the " conversation. " > > > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting > to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I > did. > > > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. > But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let > some things go? > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2012 Report Share Posted September 25, 2012 I've experienced this with my mom too --- her desire to " help " overrides her ability to HEAR and RESPECT what others have asked of her. As well all know, it gets twisted around eventually so that she looks like the victim when she was just trying to be helpful - and now everyone else carries the guilt around for making her feel so bad. ....on the other hand, how wonderful that you were able to stand your ground and be there for your son and spend the day together in a peaceful way (even if it wasn't peaceful in your head). I'm glad he's feeling better! > > > > > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've > > been updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her > > that we had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we > > were getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all > > up. She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different > > times. > > > > > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had > > x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that > > something more serious is going on. > > > > > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she > > did. > > > > > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my > > annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like > > this before. > > > > > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I > > just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. > > > > > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her > > visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > > > > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > > > > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > > > > > But she left instead. > > > > > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that > > she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad > > even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I > > should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " > > And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect > > what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would > > have only prolonged the " conversation. " > > > > > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting > > to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I > > did. > > > > > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. > > But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let > > some things go? > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2012 Report Share Posted September 25, 2012 I'm glad your son feels better. One thing that seems to help is depriving the nada of information. If " everything's fine " and we're just boring people who don't have much going on without much emotion they have nothing to " help " with or attach their games. You're so right, she trampled your boundary and then she turned it around on you. On Tue, Sep 25, 2012 at 9:21 AM, Sommer gunnysacked@...>wrote: > ** > > > All of your replies helped so much. I kept repeating to myself throughout > the day, " I said don't come over, and she didn't care and came over > anyway. " > > I also noticed that I felt way better than I used to feel when I would let > her do things like that. > > I'm prepared for her to further respond to this situation by saying that > I'm a cold person and that's why I don't have any friends--the things she > says when she's upset that I don't call her every day or ask her to do > things with me, but that's okay. I had a nice quiet day with my son--who > was finally able to eat something. : ) > > > ________________________________ > > To: WTOAdultChildren1 > Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 6:33 PM > Subject: Re: Re: Nada just showed up when I said not > to - feedback please > > Hope your boy recovers soon! > > On Mon, Sep 24, 2012 at 8:44 PM, anuria67854 anuria-67854@... > >wrote: > > > ** > > > > > > ((((())))) > > Don't be too hard on yourself. Its never easy to begin setting > boundaries. > > And its harder to do when you are emotionally stressed out already. You > > were naturally very stressed and worried about your child. > > > > Still, no matter what the situation, you have a right to be heard and > > respected, not ignored and treated like a child yourself. Your nada > perhaps > > isn't used to actually hearing what you are saying and respecting your > > decisions if you're saying something that is the opposite of what she > wants > > to do. (Really similarly to the way a toddler who is determined to get a > > cookie out of the jar is not " hearing " you say NO, sweetie, please get > down > > off the counter. " ) > > > > Your nada wanted to come over, so she wasn't really *hearing* you tell > her > > " No. " Or, she wasn't processing it. > > > > Please do not let misplaced guilt or force of habit prevent you from > > assertively but calmly and politely set normal, reasonable adult > boundaries > > for yourself. You have the right to say " NO " if you want to; we all do. > > > > The more you set boundaries, the less ALIEN it feels to say things like > > " No, thanks " or " This isn't a good time for me " or " I'm sorry but I need > to > > go /hang up now. " to our nadas. > > > > I hope your little boy gets better very soon, that must be very upsetting > > to see him not able to eat and not know exactly why. > > > > -Annie > > > > > > > > > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've > > been updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her > > that we had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that > we > > were getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all > > up. She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different > > times. > > > > > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had > > x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and > that > > something more serious is going on. > > > > > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she > > did. > > > > > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my > > annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like > > this before. > > > > > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I > > just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like > that. > > > > > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her > > visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > > > > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > > > > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > > > > > But she left instead. > > > > > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that > > she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my > dad > > even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I > > should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank > you. " > > And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect > > what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would > > have only prolonged the " conversation. " > > > > > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her > wanting > > to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I > > did. > > > > > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. > > But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and > let > > some things go? > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2012 Report Share Posted September 25, 2012 I've noticed that, too: the less info I give to my nada, the less she has to comment on/disrespect/try to " fix " /etc... " Everything's fine " (or in her eyes, boring -- I swear she thrives on drama) has become my standard reply and you know, as two working people with busy lives trying to raise kids in a peaceful environment, most often it's the truth! > > > > > > > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've > > > been updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her > > > that we had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that > > we > > > were getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all > > > up. She asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different > > > times. > > > > > > > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had > > > x-rays and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and > > that > > > something more serious is going on. > > > > > > > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she > > > did. > > > > > > > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my > > > annoyance to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like > > > this before. > > > > > > > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I > > > just wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like > > that. > > > > > > > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her > > > visit. I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > > > > > > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > > > > > > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > > > > > > > But she left instead. > > > > > > > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that > > > she wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my > > dad > > > even said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I > > > should be mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank > > you. " > > > And we hung up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect > > > what I had said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would > > > have only prolonged the " conversation. " > > > > > > > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her > > wanting > > > to come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I > > > did. > > > > > > > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. > > > But what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and > > let > > > some things go? > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2012 Report Share Posted September 25, 2012 Ouch! Number 4 is so me. It can be triggered by nada or any other bully. This is exactly what I'm working on these days. Kudos to you, elmtree, for saying it so plainly. Maybe hearing it like that will help me see what the truth is, rather than the FOG. ________________________________ To: WTOAdultChildren1 Sent: Tuesday, September 25, 2012 8:13 AM Subject: Re: Nada just showed up when I said not to - feedback please  Of course you did the right thing, and your reaction is totally normal. It's the cycle- 1. You state a boundary. 2. She violates it. 3. She triggers your guilt. 4. You stew in guilt and question reality. 5. You either give in (and apologize), or hold firm yet dig yourself deeper into the cruel daughter self-image. 6. Cry and repeat. You hit step 5 and didn't give in, and you came here to short out the circuit with validation. I'd say that's a win. Go you! > > You did the right thing by pointing out her disrespect. You had boundaries > and she crossed them and you told her so. However, you shouldn't have > backed down and asked her to stay if she wanted to. She could see your > weakness and I'm surprised she left anyway. It was a good day that she > didn't call you raging about how terrible you made her feel. It is a good > first step to boundaries - the next time will feel a little better. > Remember - they don't hear what you say. She wanted to be there and see > your son and even if she said it was her intention to help you she was not > willing to listen that you didn't want her. > > > > My nada is the same way. We went shopping one day and she said I needed a > black dress for special occasions. I told her I had a black dress I hadn't > worn in several years. She didn't hear that. A week later she showed up > with a black dress she found that she bought me. It wasn't my style - it > was something she would have worn (just a different size). I did not > express my boundaries then either like I should - I just gave the dress to > Goodwill. I didn't know about BPD and boundaries then but to remember it > makes me furious that she didn't listen or care about what I said. Even > when they THINK it is about you it is really about THEM. :-( > > > > > > jwjrenslow@... > > > > _____ > > From: WTOAdultChildren1 > [mailto:WTOAdultChildren1 ] On Behalf Of Sommer > Sent: Monday, September 24, 2012 11:35 AM > To: WTOAdultChildren1 > Subject: Nada just showed up when I said not to - > feedback please > > > > > > My 9-year old son has been throwing up for 7 days straight, and I've been > updating my mother each day. I called her this morning to tell her that we > had more tests done and that it is indeed just a virus and that we were > getting medication so that he could finally eat and not throw it all up. She > asked if I wanted her to come over. I said no. Three different times. > > I did not want her over because she adds more stress. Although we had x-rays > and blood work, she is insisting that " it's just not right " and that > something more serious is going on. > > I had this feeling that she would just show up. And, sure enough, she did. > > Before I knew about BPD, I would have just let her in and kept my annoyance > to myself--as I've done the many times she has done things like this before. > > > This time, I answered the door and said something like, " I told you I just > wanted to spend the day with me and my son " -- or something like that. > > She understandably got upset and didn't understand my response to her visit. > I told her it was because she didn't respect what I had said. > > She hugged my son and said that she would just go. > > Feeling guilty, I said she could stay with my son. > > But she left instead. > > Then, she called on her cell phone. I just let her talk. She said that she > wanted to give me moral support, be with her grandson, and that my dad even > said she should have come over. She said that she didn't think I should be > mad, and that it was not her intention. I just said " thank you. " And we hung > up. I wanted to repeat that it was because she didn't respect what I had > said, but I didn't think she would " get it " and that it would have only > prolonged the " conversation. " > > So, of course, I'm feeling like a jerk! I totally understand her wanting to > come over, and I know she must just feel awful that I reacted like I did. > > I want to establish my boundaries, and I really did not want her here. But > what do you think? Was I too harsh? Should I " pick my battles " and let some > things go? > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2012 Report Share Posted September 25, 2012 I'd agree it's a win. You set a boundary. You caved, but that's okay. Hard to stick with boundaries the first time around. When she started spouting nonsense, you just thanked her and didn't engage or try to justify how you feel. The thing is that it's your house. You can have whatever rules you want about it. You can even have strange, nonsensical and bizarre ones that make no sense to anyone but you. And you can also be angry about whatever you feel like being angry about. Those are the things you have absolute every right to define for yourself--your feelings and your limits. They don't have to make sense to your mom or even anyone else. Take care, Ashana Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.