Guest guest Posted April 24, 2007 Report Share Posted April 24, 2007 > > Hi, > > Is it ok to alternate chelators from round to round? So take DMPS + > ALA one round, then DMSA + ALA the next round? I'm sure this has been > asked before and think I remember either Andy or TK posting saying that > its not ok but I cant remember the reasons why. TK--- if it works for you fine but it is not recommended, use what works best dmps or dmsa and for what you are chelating. I want to alternate as > I cant take DMPS all the time as it is too expensive TK--- expensive but not worth using dmsa if it is causing problems dmps isn't, just my opinion but I cant > tolerate too much of DMSA either as it lowers neutrophils and mine are > already too low plus it exacerbates my candida. --- good reasons to use dmps I did switch from DMPS > to DMSA mid round for my last round as I ran out of DMPS and it seemed > to go fine. TK-- this is actually a bad idea and not recommended. Plan out your rounds and make sure of when you will need to stop a round and how much chelator you have. Also I'm not aware that I have any issues with lead or > arsenic which would make one of the chelators more necessary. TK--- do hair test DDI > > Thanks > > Anne > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 24, 2007 Report Share Posted April 24, 2007 > > Hi, > > Is it ok to alternate chelators from round to round? So take DMPS + > ALA one round, then DMSA + ALA the next round? I'm sure this has been > asked before and think I remember either Andy or TK posting saying that > its not ok but I cant remember the reasons why. TK--- if it works for you fine but it is not recommended, use what works best dmps or dmsa and for what you are chelating. I want to alternate as > I cant take DMPS all the time as it is too expensive TK--- expensive but not worth using dmsa if it is causing problems dmps isn't, just my opinion but I cant > tolerate too much of DMSA either as it lowers neutrophils and mine are > already too low plus it exacerbates my candida. --- good reasons to use dmps I did switch from DMPS > to DMSA mid round for my last round as I ran out of DMPS and it seemed > to go fine. TK-- this is actually a bad idea and not recommended. Plan out your rounds and make sure of when you will need to stop a round and how much chelator you have. Also I'm not aware that I have any issues with lead or > arsenic which would make one of the chelators more necessary. TK--- do hair test DDI > > Thanks > > Anne > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 24, 2007 Report Share Posted April 24, 2007 > > Hi, > > Is it ok to alternate chelators from round to round? So take DMPS + > ALA one round, then DMSA + ALA the next round? I'm sure this has been > asked before and think I remember either Andy or TK posting saying that > its not ok but I cant remember the reasons why. TK--- if it works for you fine but it is not recommended, use what works best dmps or dmsa and for what you are chelating. I want to alternate as > I cant take DMPS all the time as it is too expensive TK--- expensive but not worth using dmsa if it is causing problems dmps isn't, just my opinion but I cant > tolerate too much of DMSA either as it lowers neutrophils and mine are > already too low plus it exacerbates my candida. --- good reasons to use dmps I did switch from DMPS > to DMSA mid round for my last round as I ran out of DMPS and it seemed > to go fine. TK-- this is actually a bad idea and not recommended. Plan out your rounds and make sure of when you will need to stop a round and how much chelator you have. Also I'm not aware that I have any issues with lead or > arsenic which would make one of the chelators more necessary. TK--- do hair test DDI > > Thanks > > Anne > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 24, 2007 Report Share Posted April 24, 2007 Thanks TK, I will stick to one or the other and I think I will probably have to go with DMPS. I'm wondering why though it is not recommended to alternate, apart from if you have a specific issue with lead or arsenic. Do you know why? Thats a good idea to have another hair test, I had been thinking of doing that as I havent had one for a while. Thanks, Anne > > > > Hi, > > > > Is it ok to alternate chelators from round to round? So take DMPS > + > > ALA one round, then DMSA + ALA the next round? I'm sure this has > been > > asked before and think I remember either Andy or TK posting saying > that > > its not ok but I cant remember the reasons why. > > > TK--- if it works for you fine but it is not recommended, use what > works best dmps or dmsa and for what you are chelating. > > > I want to alternate as > > I cant take DMPS all the time as it is too expensive > > TK--- expensive but not worth using dmsa if it is causing problems > dmps isn't, just my opinion > > > but I cant > > tolerate too much of DMSA either as it lowers neutrophils and mine > are > > already too low plus it exacerbates my candida. > > > --- good reasons to use dmps > > > I did switch from DMPS > > to DMSA mid round for my last round as I ran out of DMPS and it > seemed > > to go fine. > > > TK-- this is actually a bad idea and not recommended. Plan out your > rounds and make sure of when you will need to stop a round and how > much chelator you have. > > > Also I'm not aware that I have any issues with lead or > > arsenic which would make one of the chelators more necessary. > > > TK--- do hair test DDI > > > > > > Thanks > > > > Anne > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.