Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 > or whomever can answer it... ~~~ Can share what I do -- I'm RnY short (12 " ) proximal, 2 years, 2 months out -- 15 months at goal and (with a little slippage) holding... 41, 5' 6 " and 120ish... no plastics yet. > I know a lot of you do not count calories, but there a some that do and I am one of them.<<< ~~ I don't count calories but maybe because I'm just not good at it *shrug* or maybe because that never worked for me -- I do count " sugars " and I do count " low end carbs " (low end = bread, pasta, rice... most anything that's white) I don't count veggie carbs cuz those are good ones. >> Do we count the calories in our protein drink in our daily total? If we don't why not?<< ~~ I don't count the calories in my protein because the calories don't come from sugar or carbs -- my shake has 0 sugars and 4 carbs so the calories are not coming from the bad places -- calories from protein I consider " fuel " as opposed to " calories " because we have to have fuel to keep going. There is some ratio (don't know the numbers) of calories burned needs to be around equal or less than calories taken in BUT at the same time our bodies have to have " enough " calories to burn fat -- in my head I just think of the calories in my protein shakes as the ones used to burn fat and to fuel my body (give me energy) to go go go all day long... so, I don't count them as calories as such... but, as fuel... good fuel. I do believe ALL of us need a healthy balance so carbs from veggies -- usually raw or lightly sautéed so I get the most I can from the food plus they are (some are) slightly bulky providing the " full " feeling and others are fibrous helping in that area. Fats I don't count I think because I just don't consume that much of them to count them -- my cholesterol levels over the last two years have gone from WAY over normal (a family thing I think) to mid/low normal now so I'm real happy about that. I do consume fats but more in the way of high end virgin olive oil to sauté my veggies in and so on... Balance.... For me, counting calories (other than what fitday.com would do for me if I did that all the time) is just too much work -- right now, I have a system and habits for the most part that if I do what has been working (to maintain) and keep doing the right things my weight is stable and my labs and DEXA are great so... for me, just keep doing what I'm doing as long as it works is the easy route (not easy always but the " right " thing for me.) If it quits working then I'll have to look at doing it another way. >>>I have had the pleasure of meeting Curran on numerous occasions<<< A lot of what " I " do is a direct result of what has shared about what she has done that works and what hasn't worked for her -- her and other longer term post-ops that are doing the deal successfully, to me, are invaluable assets to all of us... Not just because they share what has worked but also sharing what didn't work and being honest about it -- After gathering all the " longer term post-op " information -- then I put it to use in my own life, tweak it accordingly to fit my life style and so far have had really good results by doing it that way... For Me... each of us are different though. I do think if we are going to count the calories from protein shakes that we can't clump them together with the calories from say... a slice of toast -- the " type " of calorie we are getting is totally different -- so, I think if I do need to begin starting to count the calories I would have to put them in two different categories -- bad calories and good calories or something along those lines. hugz and welcome to the group, ~denise Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 > or whomever can answer it... ~~~ Can share what I do -- I'm RnY short (12 " ) proximal, 2 years, 2 months out -- 15 months at goal and (with a little slippage) holding... 41, 5' 6 " and 120ish... no plastics yet. > I know a lot of you do not count calories, but there a some that do and I am one of them.<<< ~~ I don't count calories but maybe because I'm just not good at it *shrug* or maybe because that never worked for me -- I do count " sugars " and I do count " low end carbs " (low end = bread, pasta, rice... most anything that's white) I don't count veggie carbs cuz those are good ones. >> Do we count the calories in our protein drink in our daily total? If we don't why not?<< ~~ I don't count the calories in my protein because the calories don't come from sugar or carbs -- my shake has 0 sugars and 4 carbs so the calories are not coming from the bad places -- calories from protein I consider " fuel " as opposed to " calories " because we have to have fuel to keep going. There is some ratio (don't know the numbers) of calories burned needs to be around equal or less than calories taken in BUT at the same time our bodies have to have " enough " calories to burn fat -- in my head I just think of the calories in my protein shakes as the ones used to burn fat and to fuel my body (give me energy) to go go go all day long... so, I don't count them as calories as such... but, as fuel... good fuel. I do believe ALL of us need a healthy balance so carbs from veggies -- usually raw or lightly sautéed so I get the most I can from the food plus they are (some are) slightly bulky providing the " full " feeling and others are fibrous helping in that area. Fats I don't count I think because I just don't consume that much of them to count them -- my cholesterol levels over the last two years have gone from WAY over normal (a family thing I think) to mid/low normal now so I'm real happy about that. I do consume fats but more in the way of high end virgin olive oil to sauté my veggies in and so on... Balance.... For me, counting calories (other than what fitday.com would do for me if I did that all the time) is just too much work -- right now, I have a system and habits for the most part that if I do what has been working (to maintain) and keep doing the right things my weight is stable and my labs and DEXA are great so... for me, just keep doing what I'm doing as long as it works is the easy route (not easy always but the " right " thing for me.) If it quits working then I'll have to look at doing it another way. >>>I have had the pleasure of meeting Curran on numerous occasions<<< A lot of what " I " do is a direct result of what has shared about what she has done that works and what hasn't worked for her -- her and other longer term post-ops that are doing the deal successfully, to me, are invaluable assets to all of us... Not just because they share what has worked but also sharing what didn't work and being honest about it -- After gathering all the " longer term post-op " information -- then I put it to use in my own life, tweak it accordingly to fit my life style and so far have had really good results by doing it that way... For Me... each of us are different though. I do think if we are going to count the calories from protein shakes that we can't clump them together with the calories from say... a slice of toast -- the " type " of calorie we are getting is totally different -- so, I think if I do need to begin starting to count the calories I would have to put them in two different categories -- bad calories and good calories or something along those lines. hugz and welcome to the group, ~denise Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 > or whomever can answer it... ~~~ Can share what I do -- I'm RnY short (12 " ) proximal, 2 years, 2 months out -- 15 months at goal and (with a little slippage) holding... 41, 5' 6 " and 120ish... no plastics yet. > I know a lot of you do not count calories, but there a some that do and I am one of them.<<< ~~ I don't count calories but maybe because I'm just not good at it *shrug* or maybe because that never worked for me -- I do count " sugars " and I do count " low end carbs " (low end = bread, pasta, rice... most anything that's white) I don't count veggie carbs cuz those are good ones. >> Do we count the calories in our protein drink in our daily total? If we don't why not?<< ~~ I don't count the calories in my protein because the calories don't come from sugar or carbs -- my shake has 0 sugars and 4 carbs so the calories are not coming from the bad places -- calories from protein I consider " fuel " as opposed to " calories " because we have to have fuel to keep going. There is some ratio (don't know the numbers) of calories burned needs to be around equal or less than calories taken in BUT at the same time our bodies have to have " enough " calories to burn fat -- in my head I just think of the calories in my protein shakes as the ones used to burn fat and to fuel my body (give me energy) to go go go all day long... so, I don't count them as calories as such... but, as fuel... good fuel. I do believe ALL of us need a healthy balance so carbs from veggies -- usually raw or lightly sautéed so I get the most I can from the food plus they are (some are) slightly bulky providing the " full " feeling and others are fibrous helping in that area. Fats I don't count I think because I just don't consume that much of them to count them -- my cholesterol levels over the last two years have gone from WAY over normal (a family thing I think) to mid/low normal now so I'm real happy about that. I do consume fats but more in the way of high end virgin olive oil to sauté my veggies in and so on... Balance.... For me, counting calories (other than what fitday.com would do for me if I did that all the time) is just too much work -- right now, I have a system and habits for the most part that if I do what has been working (to maintain) and keep doing the right things my weight is stable and my labs and DEXA are great so... for me, just keep doing what I'm doing as long as it works is the easy route (not easy always but the " right " thing for me.) If it quits working then I'll have to look at doing it another way. >>>I have had the pleasure of meeting Curran on numerous occasions<<< A lot of what " I " do is a direct result of what has shared about what she has done that works and what hasn't worked for her -- her and other longer term post-ops that are doing the deal successfully, to me, are invaluable assets to all of us... Not just because they share what has worked but also sharing what didn't work and being honest about it -- After gathering all the " longer term post-op " information -- then I put it to use in my own life, tweak it accordingly to fit my life style and so far have had really good results by doing it that way... For Me... each of us are different though. I do think if we are going to count the calories from protein shakes that we can't clump them together with the calories from say... a slice of toast -- the " type " of calorie we are getting is totally different -- so, I think if I do need to begin starting to count the calories I would have to put them in two different categories -- bad calories and good calories or something along those lines. hugz and welcome to the group, ~denise Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 Thanks for your response...what you have said sounds logical. I just may try it. I was hoping to hear several opinions, does this list generally not answer direct questions from new people? Just curious, does anyone know where I might post this questions to get more of a cross section of answers? Please let me know. Thanks A LOT . Jeanese M. " An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind " ~~Gandhi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 Thanks for your response...what you have said sounds logical. I just may try it. I was hoping to hear several opinions, does this list generally not answer direct questions from new people? Just curious, does anyone know where I might post this questions to get more of a cross section of answers? Please let me know. Thanks A LOT . Jeanese M. " An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind " ~~Gandhi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 Thanks for your response...what you have said sounds logical. I just may try it. I was hoping to hear several opinions, does this list generally not answer direct questions from new people? Just curious, does anyone know where I might post this questions to get more of a cross section of answers? Please let me know. Thanks A LOT . Jeanese M. " An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind " ~~Gandhi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 In a message dated 9/20/02 8:12:26 PM Central Daylight Time, JMabin@... writes: << Thanks for your response...what you have said sounds logical. I just may try it. I was hoping to hear several opinions, does this list generally not answer direct questions from new people? Just curious, does anyone know where I might post this questions to get more of a cross section of answers? Please let me know. Thanks A LOT . Jeanese M. >> ------------------------------- Sorry, Jeanese, don't know what your question was as u didn't copy your orig message into this reply..........maybe people assumed you were asking Vitalady a question. Feel free to ask again or email me privately. I will help if I can. Regards, Carol A Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 In a message dated 9/20/02 8:12:26 PM Central Daylight Time, JMabin@... writes: << Thanks for your response...what you have said sounds logical. I just may try it. I was hoping to hear several opinions, does this list generally not answer direct questions from new people? Just curious, does anyone know where I might post this questions to get more of a cross section of answers? Please let me know. Thanks A LOT . Jeanese M. >> ------------------------------- Sorry, Jeanese, don't know what your question was as u didn't copy your orig message into this reply..........maybe people assumed you were asking Vitalady a question. Feel free to ask again or email me privately. I will help if I can. Regards, Carol A Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 Some of us just don't get to our emails til later in the day! Thanks for saying nice stuff about me! I'll go hunt down your other email. Re: Intro and VitaLady Question... > Thanks for your response...what you have said sounds logical. I just may try > it. > > I was hoping to hear several opinions, does this list generally not answer > direct questions from new people? Just curious, does anyone know where I > might post this questions to get more of a cross section of answers? Please > let me know. > > Thanks A LOT . > > Jeanese M. > " An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind " ~~Gandhi > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 Some of us just don't get to our emails til later in the day! Thanks for saying nice stuff about me! I'll go hunt down your other email. Re: Intro and VitaLady Question... > Thanks for your response...what you have said sounds logical. I just may try > it. > > I was hoping to hear several opinions, does this list generally not answer > direct questions from new people? Just curious, does anyone know where I > might post this questions to get more of a cross section of answers? Please > let me know. > > Thanks A LOT . > > Jeanese M. > " An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind " ~~Gandhi > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 Some of us just don't get to our emails til later in the day! Thanks for saying nice stuff about me! I'll go hunt down your other email. Re: Intro and VitaLady Question... > Thanks for your response...what you have said sounds logical. I just may try > it. > > I was hoping to hear several opinions, does this list generally not answer > direct questions from new people? Just curious, does anyone know where I > might post this questions to get more of a cross section of answers? Please > let me know. > > Thanks A LOT . > > Jeanese M. > " An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind " ~~Gandhi > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 20, 2002 Report Share Posted September 20, 2002 I don't count my protein POWDER toward calories. Because it has a job, there is no loitering. If you had WAYYYYY too much protein on board, I've heard it can fatten you up. But it's pretty hard for an intact RNY or BPD to get " too much " . I use water, so I don't count it toward anything, even my water. I tried, but my body apparently had a different opinion about what is & is not water, darnit. If I use anything in my protein (like *I* would! be serious--I'm a purist), I WOULD count that toward calories. BUT I don't count calories at all, as such. I sort of have a score sheet, much as described much better. I have " things that can help me " and " things that can hurt me " . So, I'd file accordingly. I'd file peanut butter under OK. Banana would go under both categories (potassium * sugar). Funny filing system, but so far, so good. My mother used to tell me to avoid olives & avocado, after taking the time to get me hooked. BUT they both have food value for me, as well as ecstasy value. So, I file them under OK. I don't count the fat against me cuz whatever I absorb of it is " good " fat, anyway. How much can I eat, anyway? So, this probably only clouds the issue for you, but for me, protein powder has a job to do, places to go,. I have organs, tissue, muscles (& theoretically, a brain), all of whom are hungering for protein & just waiting for it. There is no left over, no loitering, nothing to turn INTO fatty tissue. SUGAR, however, has no possible use for me except as guilt-inducing entertainment. Is is filed under STOMACH for me, hips for most of the other girls. It can ONLY turn into fatty tissue. And I am convinced that turning the corner with the Winchell's Donuts costs me at least 2# when I have to go past there. Intro and Vitalady Question... > or whomever can answer it... > > I know a lot of you do not count calories, but there a some that do and I am > one of them. > > Do we count the calories in our protein drink in our daily total? If we > don't why not? > > Here is my data...I am a 32 year old female, been overweight since a very > young age, I had my surgery rny-proximal in June of 2001. I have lost > somewhere in the range of 130 pounds. I am satisfied with my weight loss (so > his my doc) but would like to lose more, although not more than 40 pounds. I > have also had my tummy done already and some lipo suction. I live in Seattle, > at Alki Beach. I have had the pleasure of meeting Curran on > numerous occasions and I know (or should have said saw many of you) on other > lists. > > Thanks in advance for you help... > > Jeanese M. > " An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind " ~~Gandhi > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2002 Report Share Posted September 21, 2002 > Do we count the calories in our protein drink in our daily total? If we > don't why not? > Calories are what nutritionists use to measure how much energy is stored in that food in your fridge. To be exact, 1 calorie equals the amount of energy it would take to raise the temperature of 1 kilogram (2.2 pounds) of water degree Celsius (1.8 degrees Fahrenheit). Fats yield 9 calories per gram, for instance, protein provides about 5 and carbohydrates provide about 4. Calories in protein drinks should be counted just like any other calorie. Many do not bother to count calories though. Ray Hooks For WLS nutrition info, visit http://www.bariatricsupplementsystem.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2002 Report Share Posted September 25, 2002 I'm not a calorie counter. But if you must count calories and decide you must eliminate something...make sure you are not eliminating your protein shakes, but cut back on the food calories only, since you are getting the most nutrition from the protein shakes, and the least from your food. Regards~ Jacque > Do we count the calories in our protein drink in our daily total? If we > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 25, 2002 Report Share Posted September 25, 2002 I'm not a calorie counter. But if you must count calories and decide you must eliminate something...make sure you are not eliminating your protein shakes, but cut back on the food calories only, since you are getting the most nutrition from the protein shakes, and the least from your food. Regards~ Jacque > Do we count the calories in our protein drink in our daily total? If we > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.