Re: screwed up blood test, next round

[Guest guest]

I would insist that they do a new blood draw! Have all your info with you

so that you can see what tubes they are using and ask them about the process

before you pull out the info.

Smiles to you,

screwed up blood test, next round

>

> Last week I reported about a screwed up blood test, involving MGH (draw

lab)

> and Athena Diagnostics (test facility). They were supposedly going to do a

> " mitochondrial myopathy mtDNA " whole-blood evaluation test #519, but

instead

> three months later I found out that the lab did a " complete CMT "

evaluation,

> test #390 (which BTW was totally negative for mutations).

>

> My MGH doc's staffer left a message today saying (very indirectly) that it

> was the lab's fault not theirs, and that they were going to re-do the test

> " at no extra charge " (presumably this time doing the right test :-) ). To

my

> amazement, this does not require a new blood sample (though I'd be happy

to

> provide one), so I assume the lab has some FROZEN extra blood (or else,

some

> mighty gross mess). I think they've already gone ahead and started.

>

> Test 390 (CMT) says:

> Preferred Specimen Requirements

> Type: Whole blood

> Minimum Volume: 30ml

> Collection Tube: Yellow top, ACD-A

> Storage Conditions: Room temperature, avoid freezing

> Shipping Conditions: Room temperature, ship same day. Must arrive at

Athena

> within 48 hours after blood is drawn.

> Test Turnaround: 21-28 days

>

> Test 519 (mito) says:

> Preferred Specimen Requirements

> Type: Whole blood

> Minimum Volume: 20ml

> Collection Tube: Lavender top (EDTA)

> Storage Conditions: Do not freeze blood, refrigerate.

> Shipping Conditions: Ship blood at room temperature, avoid freezing and

ship

> blood within 24 hours of drawing.

> Test Turnaround: 14-21 days

>

> I don't know about these things, but the combination of " avoid freezing "

and

> urgency of shipping makes me wonder how in world they can do another test,

> now. Also, the collection tubes are different. The original blood draw was

> mid December (who knows what tubes were used?), about THREE MONTHS AGO. I

> wonder just how fast it was delivered to Athena the first time. Just BTW I

> was told that the " new " (additional) turnaround will be 6-8 weeks.

>

> Given that this is Athena, and the blood is supposedly frozen (or

stabilized

> somehow?), should I protest and offer to provide a new sample? With the

> current plan, they might use someone else's blood, or do the wrong test

> again but somehow REPORT the right test, or .... who knows? I could even

> offer to show up at Athena's test facility; if they can draw blood there,

if

> it might be worth it. The shipping page for Athena talks of specific kits

> for CMT and certain others, and I wonder about this too. I'm even thinking

> that perhaps the reason for the original screw up was that my blood

arrived

> in a CMT-specific kit. I'm convinced that the office staff at MGH has no

> expertise to even comment accurately on any of these issues.

>

> I feel so alone, unwilling to trust anyone I can contact, and unable to

> contact anyone I MIGHT trust. ANY opinions are welcome.

>

> Steve D.

>

>

>

> Medical advice, information, opinions, data and statements contained

herein are not necessarily those of the list moderators. The author of this

e mail is entirely responsible for its content. List members are reminded of

their responsibility to evaluate the content of the postings and consult

with their physicians regarding changes in their own treatment.

>

> Personal attacks are not permitted on the list and anyone who sends one is

automatically moderated or removed depending on the severity of the attack.

>

>