Re: No chelation--any improvement?

[Guest guest]

In frequent-dose-chelation Marcia wrote:

By the way, if a person got all their merc out and did no chelation, would

they ever get rid of it ?

---------I'm assuming by the above you mean got all their amalgams out,

right?, and then did no chelation, what would happen?

My understanding is that some people improve just on amalgam removal, and

possibly have the ability to detox somewhat by themselves. And it is supposed

to be better to do nothing than to do *improper* chelation. But I believe most

of us that are sick from our amalgams are poor excretor of metals, and need help

getting the metals out of our bodies, especially our brains. I believe the half

life of mercury in the brain is like 25 years, so it doesn't come out very fast

on its own.

And we had some discussion on this before too, that if you had an actual

mercury allergy or if the electrical currents created by your fillings caused

you alot of problems, then those people could see alot of improvement just by

removing their fillings.---------Jackie

Marcia

[Guest guest]

Jackie,

thanks for your answer, thats exactly what I wanted to know! I do have mercury

allergy, plus galvanic current issues but also a poor excreter. I just wondered,

just in case I or others I know can't do the chelation process if they'd still

get better just removing amalgams.

You are such a help Jackie!

Marcia

And we had some discussion on this before too, that if you had an actual

mercury allergy or if the electrical currents created by your fillings caused

you alot of problems, then those people could see alot of improvement just by

removing their fillings.---------Jackie

Marcia

.

[Guest guest]

In frequent-dose-chelation Marcia wrote:

Jackie,

thanks for your answer, thats exactly what I wanted to know! I do have mercury

allergy

--------Have you done the Melisa test?--------Jackie

, plus galvanic current issues

---------I assume your dentist has measured these?-------Jackie

but also a poor excreter.

----------Are you assuming this based on a hair test, or what?--------Jackie

Just trying to understand how you came up with these conclusions.------Jackie

I just wondered, just in case I or others I know can't do the chelation

process if they'd still get better just removing amalgams.

---------I guess I want to make it clear that I still think that chelation is

very important, and probably necessary for most people, and explains this

well in her post,

http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/frequent-dose-chelation/message/24110 that

not much mercury will be removed without help from proper chelation.

But, like I said before, I believe Andy has said that *no chelation* is better

than *bad chelation*, so if they can't do it properly, then it's better if they

don't do it at all. And it would still be good, I would think, to have your

amalgams removed, because then you get rid of your source of constant exposure

to more mercury vapor, which would just continue to add to your body load.

And I can't promise you that you or your friends will get better with just

amalgam removal. Some people feel better, some feel worse, and some about the

same. And personally, I felt *so much better* while on rounds, that I strongly

encourage people to try proper chelation.

And DeanSA's story might be of interest to you also. He had his amalgams out

many years ago, but never did proper chelation until recently, and he said he

never really recovered his health until he did chelate, and now feels fully

recovered. So, if for some reason you or your friends want to wait and see, the

mercury will wait along with you, and if you decide to chelate in the future,

just know that it will still help. I believe Andy has posted about this also,

and you might find it in the onibasu/wiki.

I hope this helps.-----------Jackie

You are such a help Jackie!

Marcia

And we had some discussion on this before too, that if you had an actual

mercury allergy or if the electrical currents created by your fillings caused

you alot of problems, then those people could see alot of improvement just by

removing their fillings.---------Jackie

Marcia

.

[Guest guest]

In frequent-dose-chelation Marcia wrote:

Jackie,

thanks for your answer, thats exactly what I wanted to know! I do have mercury

allergy

--------Have you done the Melisa test?--------Jackie

, plus galvanic current issues

---------I assume your dentist has measured these?-------Jackie

but also a poor excreter.

----------Are you assuming this based on a hair test, or what?--------Jackie

Just trying to understand how you came up with these conclusions.------Jackie

I just wondered, just in case I or others I know can't do the chelation

process if they'd still get better just removing amalgams.

---------I guess I want to make it clear that I still think that chelation is

very important, and probably necessary for most people, and explains this

well in her post,

http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/frequent-dose-chelation/message/24110 that

not much mercury will be removed without help from proper chelation.

But, like I said before, I believe Andy has said that *no chelation* is better

than *bad chelation*, so if they can't do it properly, then it's better if they

don't do it at all. And it would still be good, I would think, to have your

amalgams removed, because then you get rid of your source of constant exposure

to more mercury vapor, which would just continue to add to your body load.

And I can't promise you that you or your friends will get better with just

amalgam removal. Some people feel better, some feel worse, and some about the

same. And personally, I felt *so much better* while on rounds, that I strongly

encourage people to try proper chelation.

And DeanSA's story might be of interest to you also. He had his amalgams out

many years ago, but never did proper chelation until recently, and he said he

never really recovered his health until he did chelate, and now feels fully

recovered. So, if for some reason you or your friends want to wait and see, the

mercury will wait along with you, and if you decide to chelate in the future,

just know that it will still help. I believe Andy has posted about this also,

and you might find it in the onibasu/wiki.

I hope this helps.-----------Jackie

You are such a help Jackie!

Marcia

And we had some discussion on this before too, that if you had an actual

mercury allergy or if the electrical currents created by your fillings caused

you alot of problems, then those people could see alot of improvement just by

removing their fillings.---------Jackie

Marcia

.