Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 16 over running non-emergent I almost have to wonder why your even asking this question Marcus and what is your companies position on this obvious violation of the traffic laws? Jim< Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. " Please sign here. " I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!! " I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. Questions: 1. Has anyone else had this happen? 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? Mr. Marcus Finney mdfinney@... ------------------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 Were I in your shoes, I'd fight it. Lights and Sirens aren't always indicated, even for an emergent patient, and I don't think that the full gamut of severity of injuries can be divided into two groups. So long as you operated with due regard, the officer should've given you time to explain yourself, and I think that his issuance of a citation was wrong. That being said, as a newbie and since I'm rather young as it is, I'd talk to my supervisor, and if he told me to just shut up and take it, I'd probably just shut up and take it. Alyssa Woods, NREMT-B > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120’s, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient’s history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient’s anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. “Please sign here.” > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read “REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!!” > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. > > Questions: > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > Mr. Marcus Finney > mdfinney@... > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 And how many cops have you seen speeding just because they can to get to the coffee shop or to get back to the station? I was nearly hit by a cop coming out of their own station because he was in a hurry. He got to the stop light a block away and turns on his lights to go through it and then turns them off. If he was going on an urgent call, he should have been running lights and siren coming out of the parking lot. Wayne Subject: RE: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance To: texasems-l Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 10:12 PM  16 over running non-emergent I almost have to wonder why your even asking this question Marcus and what is your companies position on this obvious violation of the traffic laws? Jim< Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. " Please sign here. " I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!! " I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. Questions: 1. Has anyone else had this happen? 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? Mr. Marcus Finney mdfinney@... ------------------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 If you take it to court, be prepared to deal with being painted with the same brush as all the other services in Houston. I don't know what type of service you work for, but I do know that Houston is crawling with private companies, and I'm sure the cops are targeting those companies. I do not know whether any of the patient's information would be admissable in court. You would have only your assertions that they were " emergent " -- I don't see how you could admit any evidence otherwise without violating HIPAA. I don't know if Houston has an aggressive driving surcharge program (similar but not the state's Driver Responsibility Program) - but if they do, and you get convicted, be prepared to pay a whole lot more than 245.00 Personally, I'd be on the horn asking what my options were concerning defensive driving and ticket dismissal. Unless the officer doesn't show up for court the day you have your hearing, you're likely to be toasted. I expect the court and juries view us as individuals who should have a greater degree of responsibility. Joe Percer, LP > Were I in your shoes, I'd fight it. > > Lights and Sirens aren't always indicated, even for an emergent patient, and I don't think that the full gamut of severity of injuries can be divided into two groups. > > So long as you operated with due regard, the officer should've given you time to explain yourself, and I think that his issuance of a citation was wrong. > > That being said, as a newbie and since I'm rather young as it is, I'd talk to my supervisor, and if he told me to just shut up and take it, I'd probably just shut up and take it. > > Alyssa Woods, NREMT-B > > > > > >> I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. >> >> I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. >> >> Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120’s, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient’s history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. >> >> He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient’s anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. “Please sign here.” >> >> I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read “REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!!” >> >> I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. >> >> Questions: >> 1. Has anyone else had this happen? >> 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? >> >> Mr. Marcus Finney >> mdfinney@... >> >> >> >> ------------------------------------ >> >> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 Heck, I've known many cops and police agencies that go emergent to scenes without lights or sirens -- sometimes going up to 80 in a 45. They're really ones to judge. But that doesn't matter. What does matter is what has happened in this situation. And in this case, I think you were in the right. So, if you have experience and self-confidence, fight it. If you're inexperienced, young, and not very well known or respected, take it as paying your dues. Alyssa Woods, NREMT-B CPR Instructor > And how many cops have you seen speeding just because they can to get to the coffee shop or to get back to the station? I was nearly hit by a cop coming out of their own station because he was in a hurry. He got to the stop light a block away and turns on his lights to go through it and then turns them off. If he was going on an urgent call, he should have been running lights and siren coming out of the parking lot. > > Wayne > > > > > Subject: RE: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > To: texasems-l > Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 10:12 PM > > > > 16 over running non-emergent I almost have to wonder why your even asking > > this question Marcus and what is your companies position on this obvious > > violation of the traffic laws? > > Jim< > > Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston > > PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston > > Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The > > flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing > > vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. > > This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 > > miles an hour. > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the > > Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An > > EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have > > known better. > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had > > a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not > > transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient > > was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further > > evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in > > need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more > > about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around > > 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. > > We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical > > center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a > > priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a > > patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to > > transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the > > Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and > > traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was > > traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that > > were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol > > cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us > > alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that > > we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of > > blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I > > advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need > > the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights > > and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he > > asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he > > stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting > > a citation. " Please sign here. " > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it > > read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A > > CITATION!!!! " > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and > > will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for > > speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you > > are not following ALL traffic laws. > > Questions: > > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did > > you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > Mr. Marcus Finney > > mdfinney@... > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 I generally suggest pleading challenging all violations even if you're clearly wrong with no mitigating factors. In most of the places I've lived/worked, they'll usually deal (either the PO or the ADA) before court, and offer something lesser or cheaper. Even if they don't, you can always plead guilty at that point if you think it might turn out worse (though in that case you'd pay court costs + the ticket, so it's a gamble.) Plus the cop may not show (which is exceptionally unlikely in most places). In this case, you are clearly wrong by the numbers, but with the limited information I've seen, you haven't done anything I find objectionable. I disagree with most speed limits on principle, as I feel any law that is more often in the breach then the observance is worthless. I also agree with Alyssa's statements that lights and sirens are not always appropriate even when the patient's situation may suggest it. I would suggest getting a court order to release information about the patient's condition (as subpoena overrides HIPPA). This information could be (and should be) " sanitized " of identifying information (as that isn't pertinent to the proceeding) but if the run sheet was written correctly it could show that your speeds were justified. You may need to hire a lawyer in order to get that done, but traffic lawyers (if they want to handle your case) are pretty cheap, relatively. A last point to consider (actually two): I don't know about Houston's politics at the moment, but if Joe is right about some sort of problem with private ambulances, you may just want to try for defensive driving or deferment. Further, it may still be illegal for an ambulance (even in exigent circumstances) to violate traffic laws in Texas--at that point with the wrong judge, it doesn't matter. Not a lawyer, Austin > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120’s, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient’s history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient’s anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. “Please sign here.” > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read “REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!!” > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. > > Questions: > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > Mr. Marcus Finney > mdfinney@... > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 I generally suggest pleading challenging all violations even if you're clearly wrong with no mitigating factors. In most of the places I've lived/worked, they'll usually deal (either the PO or the ADA) before court, and offer something lesser or cheaper. Even if they don't, you can always plead guilty at that point if you think it might turn out worse (though in that case you'd pay court costs + the ticket, so it's a gamble.) Plus the cop may not show (which is exceptionally unlikely in most places). In this case, you are clearly wrong by the numbers, but with the limited information I've seen, you haven't done anything I find objectionable. I disagree with most speed limits on principle, as I feel any law that is more often in the breach then the observance is worthless. I also agree with Alyssa's statements that lights and sirens are not always appropriate even when the patient's situation may suggest it. I would suggest getting a court order to release information about the patient's condition (as subpoena overrides HIPPA). This information could be (and should be) " sanitized " of identifying information (as that isn't pertinent to the proceeding) but if the run sheet was written correctly it could show that your speeds were justified. You may need to hire a lawyer in order to get that done, but traffic lawyers (if they want to handle your case) are pretty cheap, relatively. A last point to consider (actually two): I don't know about Houston's politics at the moment, but if Joe is right about some sort of problem with private ambulances, you may just want to try for defensive driving or deferment. Further, it may still be illegal for an ambulance (even in exigent circumstances) to violate traffic laws in Texas--at that point with the wrong judge, it doesn't matter. Not a lawyer, Austin > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120’s, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient’s history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient’s anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. “Please sign here.” > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read “REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!!” > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. > > Questions: > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > Mr. Marcus Finney > mdfinney@... > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 OMG......OMG... Really?? Never.. No. That Peace Officer would be frowned upon by the entire Law and EMS community. What the &*($!? Emergent transports occur frequently within our service with and without lights and sirens; long distance 1.5 to 3 hr transports. We reserve the right (with company support) to manage the use of lights and sirens as traffic, patient, and safety dictate (as do Peace Officers). OMG! I have passed 3 highway patrol vehicles, I am sure they have a nice snap shot, idling down from 70 to 55mph as I approached a highway entrance ramp and received nothing more than a wink from his overheads. If we speed, we mean to speed with good reason. J.Meere Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. " Please sign here. " I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!! " I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. Questions: 1. Has anyone else had this happen? 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? Mr. Marcus Finney mdfinney@... ------------------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 OMG......OMG... Really?? Never.. No. That Peace Officer would be frowned upon by the entire Law and EMS community. What the &*($!? Emergent transports occur frequently within our service with and without lights and sirens; long distance 1.5 to 3 hr transports. We reserve the right (with company support) to manage the use of lights and sirens as traffic, patient, and safety dictate (as do Peace Officers). OMG! I have passed 3 highway patrol vehicles, I am sure they have a nice snap shot, idling down from 70 to 55mph as I approached a highway entrance ramp and received nothing more than a wink from his overheads. If we speed, we mean to speed with good reason. J.Meere Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. " Please sign here. " I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!! " I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. Questions: 1. Has anyone else had this happen? 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? Mr. Marcus Finney mdfinney@... ------------------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 OMG......OMG... Really?? Never.. No. That Peace Officer would be frowned upon by the entire Law and EMS community. What the &*($!? Emergent transports occur frequently within our service with and without lights and sirens; long distance 1.5 to 3 hr transports. We reserve the right (with company support) to manage the use of lights and sirens as traffic, patient, and safety dictate (as do Peace Officers). OMG! I have passed 3 highway patrol vehicles, I am sure they have a nice snap shot, idling down from 70 to 55mph as I approached a highway entrance ramp and received nothing more than a wink from his overheads. If we speed, we mean to speed with good reason. J.Meere Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. " Please sign here. " I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!! " I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. Questions: 1. Has anyone else had this happen? 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? Mr. Marcus Finney mdfinney@... ------------------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 wrote: " ...A last point to consider (actually two): I don't know about Houston's politics at the moment, but if Joe is right about some sort of problem with private ambulances, you may just want to try for defensive driving or deferment. Further, it may still be illegal for an ambulance (even in exigent circumstances) to violate traffic laws in Texas--at that point with the wrong judge, it doesn't matter.... " Having worked in the Houston area for many years, many of the private services have been problems, traffic-wise, medically and fraud-wise. If you were a regional unit, they probably didn't recognize you and thought you were just another of the ~400 services in , Galveston and Montgomery counties. Add to that a serious city budget shortfall (non- public safety city employees are having to take a day off each month without pay for the next 6 months) and a flat sales tax infusion... they have to find the money somewhere (semi tongue in cheek). The Fickle Finger of Fate found you and has flown on. Try for the DDC; some of the comedy classes are pretty good, you get a buffet out of it and the humor helps you learn and remember. Larry MS LP NMCEMDirector, EMS Management ProgramENMU - Portales �The ignorance of one voter in a democracy impairs the security of all.� -- F. Kennedy, 1963 ____________________________________________________________ Refinance Rates at 2.8% $160,000 Mortgage $434/mo. No Hidden Fees- 3.1% APR! Get a Free Quote http://thirdpartyoffers.juno.com/TGL3141/4d2e8cfe217ecc083fcst02vuc Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 wrote: " ...A last point to consider (actually two): I don't know about Houston's politics at the moment, but if Joe is right about some sort of problem with private ambulances, you may just want to try for defensive driving or deferment. Further, it may still be illegal for an ambulance (even in exigent circumstances) to violate traffic laws in Texas--at that point with the wrong judge, it doesn't matter.... " Having worked in the Houston area for many years, many of the private services have been problems, traffic-wise, medically and fraud-wise. If you were a regional unit, they probably didn't recognize you and thought you were just another of the ~400 services in , Galveston and Montgomery counties. Add to that a serious city budget shortfall (non- public safety city employees are having to take a day off each month without pay for the next 6 months) and a flat sales tax infusion... they have to find the money somewhere (semi tongue in cheek). The Fickle Finger of Fate found you and has flown on. Try for the DDC; some of the comedy classes are pretty good, you get a buffet out of it and the humor helps you learn and remember. Larry MS LP NMCEMDirector, EMS Management ProgramENMU - Portales �The ignorance of one voter in a democracy impairs the security of all.� -- F. Kennedy, 1963 ____________________________________________________________ Refinance Rates at 2.8% $160,000 Mortgage $434/mo. No Hidden Fees- 3.1% APR! Get a Free Quote http://thirdpartyoffers.juno.com/TGL3141/4d2e8cfe217ecc083fcst02vuc Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 wrote: " ...A last point to consider (actually two): I don't know about Houston's politics at the moment, but if Joe is right about some sort of problem with private ambulances, you may just want to try for defensive driving or deferment. Further, it may still be illegal for an ambulance (even in exigent circumstances) to violate traffic laws in Texas--at that point with the wrong judge, it doesn't matter.... " Having worked in the Houston area for many years, many of the private services have been problems, traffic-wise, medically and fraud-wise. If you were a regional unit, they probably didn't recognize you and thought you were just another of the ~400 services in , Galveston and Montgomery counties. Add to that a serious city budget shortfall (non- public safety city employees are having to take a day off each month without pay for the next 6 months) and a flat sales tax infusion... they have to find the money somewhere (semi tongue in cheek). The Fickle Finger of Fate found you and has flown on. Try for the DDC; some of the comedy classes are pretty good, you get a buffet out of it and the humor helps you learn and remember. Larry MS LP NMCEMDirector, EMS Management ProgramENMU - Portales �The ignorance of one voter in a democracy impairs the security of all.� -- F. Kennedy, 1963 ____________________________________________________________ Refinance Rates at 2.8% $160,000 Mortgage $434/mo. No Hidden Fees- 3.1% APR! Get a Free Quote http://thirdpartyoffers.juno.com/TGL3141/4d2e8cfe217ecc083fcst02vuc Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 Ok... Cute Medic had a conversation with me and gave some insight into this topic. Now, neither of us are lawyers, but... The first thing I'd do is look at your citation. If it cites you for General Speeding, take it to court, because that's an automatic dismissal. You were speeding in an ambulance, and the laws are different. If it cites a specific transportation code, a deeper understanding of the law is warranted. 541.201 is the definition of an Emergency Vehicle. This includes an ambulance operated by someone with a Texas EMS license. 546 says that an ambulance may violate the speed limit, and that you must use a warning sign (lights and sirens), except at the discretion of the officer and in accordance with department policy. So, so long as you were operating within department policy, you should be ok. The exception to this is if the municipality has a law regulating the speed of the ambulances (which is what 545.365 allows for). So, check your citation, and if it gives you a specific law, look up that law. If it doesn't, look up Houston's Code of Ordinances, and see what their laws say about the speed of ambulances. And below are the laws I was talking about, with bold added for emphasis. I didn't read all of the Code of Ordinances, and I would love Gene or Wes' opinion on all of this. Because if I'm reading the Code of Ordinances right, NO ambulance save HFD can operate LS or emergency traffic in Houston unless they get permission from Houston dispatch. That's insane. But if I'm reading it wrong (and you CAN operate LS in Houston when coming from another municipality, which is what I'm more inclined to believe, as I've done so personally and not been pulled over), you actually have a valid defense. § 541.201. VEHICLES. In this subtitle: (1) " Authorized emergency vehicle " means: (A) a fire department or police vehicle; ( a public or private ambulance operated by a person who has been issued a license by the Texas Department of Health; © a municipal department or public service corporation emergency vehicle that has been designated or authorized by the governing body of a municipality; (D) a private vehicle of a volunteer firefighter or a certified emergency medical services employee or volunteer when responding to a fire alarm or medical emergency; (E) an industrial emergency response vehicle, including an industrial ambulance, when responding to an emergency, but only if the vehicle is operated in compliance with criteria in effect September 1, 1989, and established by the predecessor of the Texas Industrial Emergency Services Board of the State Firemen's and Fire Marshals' Association of Texas; or (F) a vehicle of a blood bank or tissue bank, accredited or approved under the laws of this state or the United States, when making emergency deliveries of blood, drugs, medicines, or organs. § 545.365. SPEED LIMIT EXCEPTION FOR EMERGENCIES; MUNICIPAL REGULATION. (a) The regulation of the speed of a vehicle under this subchapter does not apply to: (1) an authorized emergency vehicle responding to a call; (2) a police patrol; or (3) a physician or ambulance responding to an emergency call. ( A municipality by ordinance may regulate the speed of: (1) an ambulance; (2) an emergency medical services vehicle; or (3) an authorized vehicle operated by a blood or tissue bank. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.001. PERMISSIBLE CONDUCT. In operating an authorized emergency vehicle the operator may: (1) park or stand, irrespective of another provision of this subtitle; (2) proceed past a red or stop signal or stop sign, after slowing as necessary for safe operation; (3) exceed a maximum speed limit, except as provided by an ordinance adopted under Section 545.365, as long as the operator does not endanger life or property; and (4) disregard a regulation governing the direction of movement or turning in specified directions. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.002. WHEN CONDUCT PERMISSIBLE. (a) In this section, " police escort " means facilitating the movement of a funeral, oversized or hazardous load, or other traffic disruption for public safety purposes by a peace officer described by Articles 2.12(1)-(4), (8), and (22), Code of Criminal Procedure. ( Section 546.001 applies only when the operator is: (1) responding to an emergency call; (2) pursuing an actual or suspected violator of the law; (3) responding to but not returning from a fire alarm; (4) directing or diverting traffic for public safety purposes; or (5) conducting a police escort. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Amended by Acts 2003, 78th Leg., ch. 66, § 1, eff. May 16, 2003; Acts 2005, 79th Leg., ch. 834, § 1, eff. June 17, 2005. § 546.003. AUDIBLE OR VISUAL SIGNALS REQUIRED. Except as provided by Section 546.004, the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle engaging in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 shall use, at the discretion of the operator in accordance with policies of the department or the local government that employs the operator, audible or visual signals that meet the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.004. EXCEPTIONS TO SIGNAL REQUIREMENT. (a) A volunteer fire fighter who operates a private vehicle as an authorized emergency vehicle may engage in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 only when the fire fighter is using visual signals meeting the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702. ( An authorized emergency vehicle that is operated as a police vehicle is not required to be equipped with or display a red light visible from the front of the vehicle. © A police officer may operate an authorized emergency vehicle for a law enforcement purpose without using the audible or visual signals required by Section 546.003 if the officer is: (1) responding to an emergency call or pursuing a suspected violator of the law with probable cause to believe that: (A) knowledge of the presence of the officer will cause the suspect to: (i) destroy or lose evidence of a suspected felony; (ii) end a suspected continuing felony before the officer has obtained sufficient evidence to establish grounds for arrest; or (iii) evade apprehension or identification of the suspect or the suspect's vehicle; or ( because of traffic conditions on a multilaned roadway, vehicles moving in response to the audible or visual signals may: (i) increase the potential for a collision; or (ii) unreasonably extend the duration of the pursuit; or (2) complying with a written regulation relating to the use of audible or visible signals adopted by the local government that employs the officer or by the department. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.005. DUTY OF CARE. This chapter does not relieve the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle from: (1) the duty to operate the vehicle with appropriate regard for the safety of all persons; or (2) the consequences of reckless disregard for the safety of others. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.021. MUTUAL AID ORGANIZATIONS. (a) Two or more businesses whose activities require the maintenance of fire-fighting equipment may form a mutual aid organization in which the member businesses agree to assist each other during an emergency by supplying fire-fighting equipment or services. ( The presiding officer or director of an organization formed under this section shall deliver a list to the county fire marshal, or to the commissioners court of a county if the county does not have a fire marshal, in each county in which a member business is located. The list must contain the name of the registered owner and license plate number of each motor vehicle that each member intends to use in supplying fire-fighting equipment or services. © If the county fire marshal or commissioners court determines that the operation of the vehicles on the list is in the public interest and not a threat to public safety, the marshal or court shall approve the list. (d) On approval of the list by the county fire marshal or commissioners court, a person operating a listed motor vehicle in response to a call for emergency fire-fighting assistance from a member has the rights and restrictions placed by this subtitle on the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle. (e) A county is not liable for damage to a person or property caused by a person approved by the county under this section to operate a motor vehicle for emergency fire-fighting assistance. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Houston Code of Ordinances Regarding Ambulances: Sec. 4-1. - Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: (1) Ambulance. A motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of the transportation of sick or injured persons. (2) Ambulance service. A trip made by an ambulance to transport a sick or injured person from place to place under other than emergency circumstances. (3) Ambulance operator. The person holding a city ambulance permit. (4) Department. The department of health. (5) Direct call. A request for ambulance service made by telephone or other means directly to an ambulance operator, his agents or employees. (6) Driver's permit. A city emergency ambulance driver's permit. (7) Emergency ambulance. Any motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of transporting sick or injured persons under emergency circumstances, and the rendering of first aid or the performance of rescue work, or both, under such circumstances. (8) Emergency circumstances. The existence of circumstances in which the element of time in expeditiously transporting a sick or injured person for medical or surgical treatment is essential to the health or life of such person, and in which rescue operations or competent first aid or both at the place of emergency may be essential to the health or life of such person. (9) Emergency ambulance service. A trip made by an emergency ambulance under emergency circumstances to the place of emergency, performance of any necessary rescue operations, rendering of any necessary first aid assistance and the trip to the hospital or other place for medical attention. An ambulance is being operated in emergency ambulance service if all or any part of the above described trip to the place of emergency and any subsequent trip to the hospital is made on the streets within the corporate limits of the city. An emergency ambulance shall be considered to be rendering emergency ambulance service when it is responding to a call for emergency assistance even though, upon arrival at the place of emergency, it is found that the call was falsely made or that no further emergency ambulance assistance is required or when it is responding to a call for routine ambulance service and during such trip emergency circumstances develop. (Code 1968, § 5-1; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 1, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-2. - Ambulance advisory committee. An ambulance advisory committee is hereby created, to consist of the director of the health department, or in his absence a representative appointed by the director; the chief of the fire department, or in his absence a representative appointed by him; and a third member to be selected by the County Medical Society, or in his absence, an alternate member selected by such society. It shall be the duty of such committee to recommend to the city council, specifications for construction, equipment and numbers of emergency ambulances to be purchased by the city (which specifications shall include the essential equipment referred to in section 4-6 below). The committee shall meet at least two times per year. The committee shall submit to the city council from time to time, its recommendations as to new specifications for emergency ambulances and its recommendations as to revisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-2; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 19, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-3. - City emergency ambulance driver's permit. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person other than a member of the fire department assigned to drive a fire department ambulance to operate or drive an emergency ambulance upon the public streets of the city unless the driver thereof shall first have obtained a city emergency ambulance driver's permit. ( An application for such permit shall be submitted to the health officer upon a form or forms to be provided by him. Such application must be signed and sworn to before a notary public. The applicant shall have the following qualifications: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The applicant must be the holder of a Class C Texas driver license. © The health officer shall investigate the application and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the issuance of an emergency ambulance driver's permit. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such a permit, and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (d) A permit issued under this section shall be valid for two years from the date of issuance. (e) The fee for a permit required by this section shall be $100.00, payable at the time the application for said permit is submitted to the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-3; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 2, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 1, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 1, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 1, 12-5-78; Ord. No. 82-1109, § 1, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, §§ 1, 2, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-4. - Personnel required during operation of emergency ambulances; emergency ambulance technician certificate of proficiency. (a) It shall be unlawful to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven an emergency ambulance on a public street of the city when furnishing emergency ambulance service, including emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, unless there is aboard such emergency ambulance on each trip at least two persons, one of whom is the holder of a valid certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician issued by the health officer. The holder of such certificate must be the person attending the patient while such patient is being transported. ( Application for a certificate of proficiency as an emergency ambulance technician shall be made to the health officer on forms to be furnished by him, and shall be signed and sworn to before a notary public. © Qualifications for a certificate of proficiency shall be as follows: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The health officer shall establish standards of proficiency and training necessary for attainment in order for such person to qualify for a certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician. Such standards shall be filed with the city secretary and may be changed from time to time by filing such changes with the city secretary. The health officer shall cause regularly scheduled training courses and examinations to be conducted of all applicants for such certificate of proficiency. Such examinations may be oral or written or practical or a combination of such types of examinations, as the health officer determines will best demonstrate proficiency. The health officer shall limit the life of any certificate to not more than one year and shall provide for renewal of such certificate by the applicant's attending refresher courses and taking such renewal examinations as the health officer may prescribe. (d) The health officer shall investigate the application and the grades attained on such examination and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the certificate of proficiency. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such certificate and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (Code 1968, § 5-4; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 3, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 2, 12-5-78) Sec. 4-5. - Structural and licensing requirements. No emergency ambulance shall be operated on the public streets of the city unless it is free of structural defects and unless it has no serious impairment of any safety feature resulting from an accident or otherwise. No emergency ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service unless and until such ambulance has been duly licensed in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S. (Code 1968, § 5-5; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 4, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-6. - Required equipment. No emergency ambulance or transfer ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service unless such ambulance is equipped with the " Essential Equipment for Ambulances, " as set out in the bulletin of the American College of Surgeons, May issue, 1970, pages 7 through 13, a copy of which shall be filed in the office of the city secretary by the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-6; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 5, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-7. - Vehicle inspections. The health officer shall cause all emergency ambulances, including those operated by the fire department, to be inspected before being placed in service and thereafter annually, as well as on a spot inspection basis. In the event an emergency ambulance fails to pass inspection, the health officer shall notify the emergency ambulance operator or the chief of the fire department to correct the defects noted in the inspection and, after such notification, the health officer shall cause such ambulance to be reinspected for compliance. If, upon such reinspection, the defects noted in the original inspection have not been corrected, the vehicle decals shall be removed from the ambulance by the health officer and shall only be replaced upon such ambulance after the defects have been corrected. Inspections provided for herein may also be made by any police officer of the city or any authorized employee of the department of administration and regulatory affairs of the city. (Code 1968, § 5-7; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 6, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 1, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 05-939, § 3, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 9, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08) Sec. 4-8. - Decals and display of name. (a) When an ambulance operator's permit is issued or renewed under this article, the holder of the operator's permit shall present each ambulance that he proposes to operate thereunder to the health officer for inspection pursuant to the standards adopted in section 4-5, and if the operator proposes to use the ambulance in either or both of the instances described in section 4-9((3) or (4), then for additional inspection for compliance with section 4-6. Upon the successful completion of such inspection, the health officer will furnish the permittee two decals for each ambulance which has been inspected and is authorized to be used in service. One such decal shall be affixed to the front windshield at the lower right (passenger side) corner; the other such decal shall be affixed to the rear bumper or to a similar location in a manner as to be readily visible from a following vehicle. The color of such decals shall be changed annually. Additionally, all emergency ambulances shall have the name of the ambulance service prominently displayed on both exterior sides. ( It shall be unlawful to operate an ambulance on the streets of the city without having such decals affixed and, in the case of an emergency ambulance, without having the name of the ambulance service displayed as required by this section. (Code 1968, § 5-8; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 7, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 2, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 2, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 2, 10-23-79) Sec. 4-9. - Persons authorized to engage in emergency ambulance service. (a) The operation of emergency ambulances on the streets of the city for the furnishing of emergency ambulance service is hereby declared to be a governmental function of the city to be performed by the fire department in accordance with the terms of this chapter. It shall be unlawful for any person or persons, other than members of such fire department in its classified civil service, while driving emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, to furnish or to attempt to furnish emergency ambulance service or to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven any ambulance on the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service. ( It is an affirmative defense to prosecution under subsection (a) that: (1) The person operating an ambulance upon responding to a direct call for ambulance service determined that an emergency existed requiring the sick or injured person to be transported with all practical speed for medical treatment and attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency ambulance service; from the fire department dispatcher; (2) That the emergency ambulance service was provided by an ambulance based outside the city when not in use and operated by an ambulance company having an established place of business and permanent address outside the city, provided; a. The sick or injured person was picked up outside the corporate limits of the city and transported to a hospital within the city; and b. The ambulance performing such emergency ambulance service was, at the time, duly licensed and operated in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S.; and c. The driver of such ambulance complied with all speed and other traffic regulations of the city and the state. (3) That the person operating an ambulance within the city was performing a service under contract of maintaining an ambulance at a particular location, or event, for the purpose of transporting sick or injured persons for medical or hospital treatment, and determined that a sick or injured person at such location or event required immediate hospital or medical attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency service from the fire department dispatcher. (4) That the emergency ambulance service was provided at the request of the fire department dispatcher due to unavailability of a city ambulance. In each instance set out in (1) through (4) above, the driver or operator of such ambulance shall prior to commencement of each emergency ambulance run, notify the fire department dispatcher of the conditions requiring the operation of his vehicle in emergency ambulance service, the location from which he is proceeding, and the location to which he is proceeding under emergency ambulance service and obtain permission for such trip from the dispatcher. Each ambulance being operated under paragraphs (1) and (2) above shall comply with the requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances insofar as traffic safety is concerned. Each ambulance being operated under the provisions of paragraphs (3) and (4) above shall comply with all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances of every nature. Upon arriving at his destination, the ambulance driver or ambulance operator will again notify the fire department dispatcher that he has arrived and is no longer in emergency ambulance service. When the driver or operator of an ambulance is responding to a direct call for ambulance service, either under emergency conditions or otherwise, he shall inform the fire department ambulance dispatcher of the location of such call and such information as he may have concerning the circumstances surrounding the request for service, and if the fire department ambulance dispatcher reports that a fire department ambulance is either on route to the same location or has arrived there and instructs such ambulance driver or operator not to respond to such call, it shall be unlawful for such driver or operator to so respond when instructed not to do so by the fire department ambulance dispatcher. (Code 1968, § 5-9; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 8, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 3, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 3, 4-14-71) Sec. 4-10. - General authorization. Nothing herein shall prohibit any person owning an ambulance duly licensed and operated in accordance with article 4590b, V.T.C.S., from operating such ambulance on the public streets for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service only; provided, however, such person shall secure an operator's permit in compliance with the provisions of sections 4-15 and 4-16 hereof and shall cause his ambulance to have been inspected and be in display of a medallion issued in compliance with section 4-8 hereof. The driver of any such ambulance shall comply with all of the traffic laws of the state and ordinances of the city, including this chapter, in furnishing such ambulance service. The operator thereof shall not permit such ambulance to be used for emergency ambulance service unless all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulance service have been complied with. (Code 1968, § 5-10; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 9, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-736, § 4, 4-14-71) Cross reference— Traffic, Ch. 45. Sec. 4-11. - Use of signs or flashing emergency lights. The use of signs or flashing emergency lights on an ambulance upon the public streets of the city shall be unlawful except when furnishing emergency ambulance service in accordance with the terms of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-11; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 10, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-12. - Patient transport status; solicitation of business prohibited. (a) A patient's transport status shall be determined solely on the basis of the medical needs of the patient in accordance with the most current fire department guidelines as approved by the physician medical director. Under no circumstances shall the fact that a person is or appears to be indigent and unable to pay the cost of such service be considered in such determination. ( It shall be unlawful for any person, while operating or accompanying an emergency ambulance on the public streets or easements of the city, to solicit the business of transporting the sick or injured. (Code 1968, § 5-13; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 12, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 2010-525, § 2, 6-30-2010) Sec. 4-13. - Charges. (a) In order to partially defray the costs incurred by the city in providing emergency medical services and ambulance services, the following fees are hereby established to be collected for the provision of emergency ambulance service by the city: (1) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by the hospital from which the transportation originates, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance from one hospital to another hospital; and (2) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by or on behalf of the person served, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance other than from one hospital to another hospital. ( The fee specified above for transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall apply in each instance where a person is transported from one hospital to another hospital, except in those instances in which a person is picked up at a place other than a hospital and during the course of his transportation to the intended destination hospital the ambulance makes an intermediate stop at another hospital for emergency stabilization or other treatment en route. The fee specified above for the transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall in each instance be payable by the hospital from which the transportation of the person originates, and the transportation of the person shall not commence until and unless: (1) The physician in charge of the care of the person furnishes a written statement that the person's condition is suitable for safe transportation by ground ambulance to the intended destination hospital; and (2) The hospital furnishes a physician or other trained and qualified medical staff member who shall ride in the ambulance and assume the responsibility for the care of the person being transported en route; and (3) The administrator of the hospital or another responsible person signs a statement promising on behalf of the hospital to pay for the transportation of the person and furnishes the necessary billing information. © In addition to the base fees imposed under items (1) and (2) of subsection (a), above, the following variable fees shall be imposed, as applicable: (1) For use of oxygen (any quantity) $65.00 (2) For use of an oxygen mask or a nasal canula, or both 15.00 (3) For use of EKG (tracing only) 50.00 (4) For EKG pad(s) (any quantity) 16.89 (5) For IV prep kit(s) (any quantity) 10.00 (6) For IV administration set(s) (any quantity) 25.00 (7) For cervical collar 25.00 (8) For head immobilization 25.00 (9) For D5W (any quantity) 11.00 (10) For Adenosine (Adenocard) per 6 mg 33.25 (11) For Albuterol Sulfate (Proventil) for 0.5% sol. per ml 0.70 (12) For Atropine per 0.3 mg 0.49 (13) For Dextrose 50% 11.39 (14) For epam (Valium) 1.06 (15) For Dopamine (Intropin) per 250 mg 9.26 (16) For Epinephrine 1:1,000 1.09 (17) For Epinephrine 1:10,000 1.09 (18) For Furosemide (Lasix) 1.12 (19) For Lidocaine Drip per 50 cc 2.76 (20) For Lidocaine HCL—2% per 50 cc 2.76 (21) For Naloxone HCO (Narcan) 3.73 (22) For Cordarone IV per 300 mg 150.00 (23) For miscellaneous medical supplies (any amount, type or quantity) 25.00 (24) Actual costs (not subject to the adjustment in (d) below) of medications, equipment and labor to provide other medically necessary services during transport. In lieu of actual computed miles, the fire chief may authorize use of a zone system or other procedure, provided that the mileage charged does not exceed the actual mileage. (d) That the base fee plus the variable fees established in sections (a)(1), (a)(2) and © above shall be automatically increased on the first day of each subsequent fiscal year by a percentage equal to the percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index—All Urban Customers (CPI-U), if any, over the same date of the previous year. If there is a decrease or if there is no increase in any given year, the rates for that year shall remain the same as in the previous year. (e) The fire department shall submit to the tax assessor-collector a record of each instance in which emergency ambulance transportation service is provided. The tax assessor-collector shall be responsible for the billing and collection of the applicable fees. Except for the conditions expressly provided above in the instance of the transportation of a patient from one hospital to another hospital, no provision in this section shall be construed to authorize the fire department, under any circumstances, to refuse emergency ambulance assistance to any person upon the grounds that the person is indigent or unable to pay for the service. (Code 1968, § 5-15; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 14, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-2031, § 1, 11-23-76; Ord. No. 83-1318, § 1, 8-23-83; Ord. No. 86-1616, § 1, 9-10-86; Ord. No. 91-1178, § 1, 8-14-91; Ord. No. 93-918, § 1, 7-28-93; Ord. No. 96-665, § 7, 6-26-96; Ord. No. 97-1003, § 1, 8-20-97; Ord. No. 01-564, § 11, 6-20-01; Ord. No. 02-528, § 14a., 6-19-02; Ord. No. 2010-892, §§ 2—4, 11-17-2010) Sec. 4-14. - Uncollectible transport account. There is hereby created a list of ambulance accounts to be entitled " uncollectible transports. " The tax assessor-collector of the city shall have the power to place ambulance bills on the uncollectible transports list if he determines such ambulance bills to be uncollectible. An " uncollectible transport " shall be defined as any of the following: (1) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient whose name and/or address is unknown, or upon whom there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the patient, or a patient using a false name and/or, address, or a patient who is a minor and whose parents or next of kin are unknown, or there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the parents or next of kin. (2) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient who is in the custody of, or placed under arrest by, a police officer of the city. (3) Emergency ambulance service provided at least six months previously and upon which a diligent collection effort has been made. (Code 1968, § 5-15.1; Ord. No. 74-1778, § 1, 10-8-74) Sec. 4-15. - Ambulance service operator's permit, insurance required. Any person operating an ambulance service upon the streets of the city must secure a permit therefor from the health officer. Such applicant shall provide evidence to the health officer that he has in full force for such calendar year a public liability insurance policy on each ambulance, such insurance policy to be issued by an insurance company which is authorized by law to do business in the state. Such policy shall provide liability insurance in the amount of not less than $50,000.00 for any one accident and not less than $25,000.00 for injury to any one person. Such insurance policy shall not contain a passenger liability exclusion. Each policy shall contain a provision obligating the insurer to give to the health officer written notice of cancellation not less than ten days prior to the date of any cancellation. (Code 1968, § 5-16; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 15, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-235, § 1, 2-11-76) Sec. 4-16. - Fees for operator's permit, decals; term of decals. The fee for the ambulance operator's permit required pursuant to section 4-15 of this Code shall be $1,000.00, and all permits issued under this chapter shall be valid for one year from the date of issuance. Such permits may be renewed after the termination date of the initial permit and during that same year by paying a permit fee of $800.00. The charge for decals required pursuant to section 4-8 of this Code shall be $275.00 per pair of decals for each pair issued, renewed or replaced. Decals expire concurrently with the ambulance operator's permit under which they are issued. Such fees and charges shall be collected by the department of health and human services and transferred to the department of administration and regulatory affairs, together with an accounting of the permits and pairs of decals for which same were collected. (Code 1968, § 5-17; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 16, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 4, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 5, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 76-235, § 2, 2-11-76; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 3, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 82-1107, § 2, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, § 4, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 10, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-17. - Penalty for violations. Whenever in this chapter an act is prohibited or is made or declared to be unlawful or an offense or misdemeanor, or whenever in this chapter the doing of any thing or act is required or the failure to do any thing or act is prohibited, the violation of the provision shall be and constitute a misdemeanor punishable, upon conviction, by a fine of not more than $2,000.00. Each violation shall constitute and be punishable as a separate offense. Prosecution or conviction under this provision is cumulative of and shall never be a bar to any other civil or administrative remedy provided or allowed in this chapter or by law. In addition, the city attorney is hereby authorized to file suit in any court of competent jurisdiction to enjoin any person from violating or causing to be violated any of the provisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-18; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 18, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 92-1449, § 3, 11-4-92; Ord. No. 05-939, § 5, 8-3-05) Charter reference— Penalty for ordinance violation, Art. II, § 12. Cross reference— Assessment of fines against corporations, § 16-76; payment of fines, § 16-78; credit against fines for incarceration, § 35-6 et seq. Sec. 4-18. - Revocation or suspension of permits, licenses and certificates. Any permit, license or certificate issued pursuant to this chapter shall be subject to suspension or revocation upon the finding pursuant to a public hearing conducted by the health officer that the holder of such permit, license or certificate has failed to comply with the applicable provisions of this chapter or that the holder no longer meets the requirements which pertain to the issuance thereof, provided that the holder of such permit, license or certificate shall be given prior notice of the date, time and place of the hearing setting forth the grounds upon which the suspension or revocation is based and shall be afforded an opportunity to appear in person or through counsel to present evidence and to cross examine all witnesses appearing at such hearing. Sec. 4-19. - Disposition of certain fees. All fees collected under sections 4-3 and 4-16 of this Code shall be allocated to the health and human services department to fund the inspection of ambulances and permitting of ambulance operators as required by this chapter. (Ord. No. 05-939, § 6, 8-3-05) Alyssa Woods, NREMT-B CPR Instructor > Yep, you are correct. They speed just because they can. > > Wayne > > > > > > > > Subject: RE: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > To: texasems-l > > Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 10:12 PM > > > > > > > > 16 over running non-emergent I almost have to wonder why your even asking > > > > this question Marcus and what is your companies position on this obvious > > > > violation of the traffic laws? > > > > Jim< > > > > Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > > > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston > > > > PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston > > > > Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The > > > > flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing > > > > vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. > > > > This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 > > > > miles an hour. > > > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the > > > > Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An > > > > EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have > > > > known better. > > > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had > > > > a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not > > > > transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient > > > > was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further > > > > evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in > > > > need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more > > > > about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around > > > > 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. > > > > We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical > > > > center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a > > > > priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a > > > > patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to > > > > transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the > > > > Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and > > > > traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was > > > > traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that > > > > were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol > > > > cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us > > > > alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that > > > > we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of > > > > blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I > > > > advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need > > > > the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights > > > > and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he > > > > asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he > > > > stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting > > > > a citation. " Please sign here. " > > > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it > > > > read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A > > > > CITATION!!!! " > > > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and > > > > will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for > > > > speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you > > > > are not following ALL traffic laws. > > > > Questions: > > > > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > > > > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did > > > > you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > > > Mr. Marcus Finney > > > > mdfinney@... > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 Ok... Cute Medic had a conversation with me and gave some insight into this topic. Now, neither of us are lawyers, but... The first thing I'd do is look at your citation. If it cites you for General Speeding, take it to court, because that's an automatic dismissal. You were speeding in an ambulance, and the laws are different. If it cites a specific transportation code, a deeper understanding of the law is warranted. 541.201 is the definition of an Emergency Vehicle. This includes an ambulance operated by someone with a Texas EMS license. 546 says that an ambulance may violate the speed limit, and that you must use a warning sign (lights and sirens), except at the discretion of the officer and in accordance with department policy. So, so long as you were operating within department policy, you should be ok. The exception to this is if the municipality has a law regulating the speed of the ambulances (which is what 545.365 allows for). So, check your citation, and if it gives you a specific law, look up that law. If it doesn't, look up Houston's Code of Ordinances, and see what their laws say about the speed of ambulances. And below are the laws I was talking about, with bold added for emphasis. I didn't read all of the Code of Ordinances, and I would love Gene or Wes' opinion on all of this. Because if I'm reading the Code of Ordinances right, NO ambulance save HFD can operate LS or emergency traffic in Houston unless they get permission from Houston dispatch. That's insane. But if I'm reading it wrong (and you CAN operate LS in Houston when coming from another municipality, which is what I'm more inclined to believe, as I've done so personally and not been pulled over), you actually have a valid defense. § 541.201. VEHICLES. In this subtitle: (1) " Authorized emergency vehicle " means: (A) a fire department or police vehicle; ( a public or private ambulance operated by a person who has been issued a license by the Texas Department of Health; © a municipal department or public service corporation emergency vehicle that has been designated or authorized by the governing body of a municipality; (D) a private vehicle of a volunteer firefighter or a certified emergency medical services employee or volunteer when responding to a fire alarm or medical emergency; (E) an industrial emergency response vehicle, including an industrial ambulance, when responding to an emergency, but only if the vehicle is operated in compliance with criteria in effect September 1, 1989, and established by the predecessor of the Texas Industrial Emergency Services Board of the State Firemen's and Fire Marshals' Association of Texas; or (F) a vehicle of a blood bank or tissue bank, accredited or approved under the laws of this state or the United States, when making emergency deliveries of blood, drugs, medicines, or organs. § 545.365. SPEED LIMIT EXCEPTION FOR EMERGENCIES; MUNICIPAL REGULATION. (a) The regulation of the speed of a vehicle under this subchapter does not apply to: (1) an authorized emergency vehicle responding to a call; (2) a police patrol; or (3) a physician or ambulance responding to an emergency call. ( A municipality by ordinance may regulate the speed of: (1) an ambulance; (2) an emergency medical services vehicle; or (3) an authorized vehicle operated by a blood or tissue bank. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.001. PERMISSIBLE CONDUCT. In operating an authorized emergency vehicle the operator may: (1) park or stand, irrespective of another provision of this subtitle; (2) proceed past a red or stop signal or stop sign, after slowing as necessary for safe operation; (3) exceed a maximum speed limit, except as provided by an ordinance adopted under Section 545.365, as long as the operator does not endanger life or property; and (4) disregard a regulation governing the direction of movement or turning in specified directions. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.002. WHEN CONDUCT PERMISSIBLE. (a) In this section, " police escort " means facilitating the movement of a funeral, oversized or hazardous load, or other traffic disruption for public safety purposes by a peace officer described by Articles 2.12(1)-(4), (8), and (22), Code of Criminal Procedure. ( Section 546.001 applies only when the operator is: (1) responding to an emergency call; (2) pursuing an actual or suspected violator of the law; (3) responding to but not returning from a fire alarm; (4) directing or diverting traffic for public safety purposes; or (5) conducting a police escort. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Amended by Acts 2003, 78th Leg., ch. 66, § 1, eff. May 16, 2003; Acts 2005, 79th Leg., ch. 834, § 1, eff. June 17, 2005. § 546.003. AUDIBLE OR VISUAL SIGNALS REQUIRED. Except as provided by Section 546.004, the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle engaging in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 shall use, at the discretion of the operator in accordance with policies of the department or the local government that employs the operator, audible or visual signals that meet the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.004. EXCEPTIONS TO SIGNAL REQUIREMENT. (a) A volunteer fire fighter who operates a private vehicle as an authorized emergency vehicle may engage in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 only when the fire fighter is using visual signals meeting the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702. ( An authorized emergency vehicle that is operated as a police vehicle is not required to be equipped with or display a red light visible from the front of the vehicle. © A police officer may operate an authorized emergency vehicle for a law enforcement purpose without using the audible or visual signals required by Section 546.003 if the officer is: (1) responding to an emergency call or pursuing a suspected violator of the law with probable cause to believe that: (A) knowledge of the presence of the officer will cause the suspect to: (i) destroy or lose evidence of a suspected felony; (ii) end a suspected continuing felony before the officer has obtained sufficient evidence to establish grounds for arrest; or (iii) evade apprehension or identification of the suspect or the suspect's vehicle; or ( because of traffic conditions on a multilaned roadway, vehicles moving in response to the audible or visual signals may: (i) increase the potential for a collision; or (ii) unreasonably extend the duration of the pursuit; or (2) complying with a written regulation relating to the use of audible or visible signals adopted by the local government that employs the officer or by the department. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.005. DUTY OF CARE. This chapter does not relieve the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle from: (1) the duty to operate the vehicle with appropriate regard for the safety of all persons; or (2) the consequences of reckless disregard for the safety of others. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.021. MUTUAL AID ORGANIZATIONS. (a) Two or more businesses whose activities require the maintenance of fire-fighting equipment may form a mutual aid organization in which the member businesses agree to assist each other during an emergency by supplying fire-fighting equipment or services. ( The presiding officer or director of an organization formed under this section shall deliver a list to the county fire marshal, or to the commissioners court of a county if the county does not have a fire marshal, in each county in which a member business is located. The list must contain the name of the registered owner and license plate number of each motor vehicle that each member intends to use in supplying fire-fighting equipment or services. © If the county fire marshal or commissioners court determines that the operation of the vehicles on the list is in the public interest and not a threat to public safety, the marshal or court shall approve the list. (d) On approval of the list by the county fire marshal or commissioners court, a person operating a listed motor vehicle in response to a call for emergency fire-fighting assistance from a member has the rights and restrictions placed by this subtitle on the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle. (e) A county is not liable for damage to a person or property caused by a person approved by the county under this section to operate a motor vehicle for emergency fire-fighting assistance. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Houston Code of Ordinances Regarding Ambulances: Sec. 4-1. - Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: (1) Ambulance. A motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of the transportation of sick or injured persons. (2) Ambulance service. A trip made by an ambulance to transport a sick or injured person from place to place under other than emergency circumstances. (3) Ambulance operator. The person holding a city ambulance permit. (4) Department. The department of health. (5) Direct call. A request for ambulance service made by telephone or other means directly to an ambulance operator, his agents or employees. (6) Driver's permit. A city emergency ambulance driver's permit. (7) Emergency ambulance. Any motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of transporting sick or injured persons under emergency circumstances, and the rendering of first aid or the performance of rescue work, or both, under such circumstances. (8) Emergency circumstances. The existence of circumstances in which the element of time in expeditiously transporting a sick or injured person for medical or surgical treatment is essential to the health or life of such person, and in which rescue operations or competent first aid or both at the place of emergency may be essential to the health or life of such person. (9) Emergency ambulance service. A trip made by an emergency ambulance under emergency circumstances to the place of emergency, performance of any necessary rescue operations, rendering of any necessary first aid assistance and the trip to the hospital or other place for medical attention. An ambulance is being operated in emergency ambulance service if all or any part of the above described trip to the place of emergency and any subsequent trip to the hospital is made on the streets within the corporate limits of the city. An emergency ambulance shall be considered to be rendering emergency ambulance service when it is responding to a call for emergency assistance even though, upon arrival at the place of emergency, it is found that the call was falsely made or that no further emergency ambulance assistance is required or when it is responding to a call for routine ambulance service and during such trip emergency circumstances develop. (Code 1968, § 5-1; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 1, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-2. - Ambulance advisory committee. An ambulance advisory committee is hereby created, to consist of the director of the health department, or in his absence a representative appointed by the director; the chief of the fire department, or in his absence a representative appointed by him; and a third member to be selected by the County Medical Society, or in his absence, an alternate member selected by such society. It shall be the duty of such committee to recommend to the city council, specifications for construction, equipment and numbers of emergency ambulances to be purchased by the city (which specifications shall include the essential equipment referred to in section 4-6 below). The committee shall meet at least two times per year. The committee shall submit to the city council from time to time, its recommendations as to new specifications for emergency ambulances and its recommendations as to revisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-2; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 19, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-3. - City emergency ambulance driver's permit. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person other than a member of the fire department assigned to drive a fire department ambulance to operate or drive an emergency ambulance upon the public streets of the city unless the driver thereof shall first have obtained a city emergency ambulance driver's permit. ( An application for such permit shall be submitted to the health officer upon a form or forms to be provided by him. Such application must be signed and sworn to before a notary public. The applicant shall have the following qualifications: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The applicant must be the holder of a Class C Texas driver license. © The health officer shall investigate the application and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the issuance of an emergency ambulance driver's permit. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such a permit, and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (d) A permit issued under this section shall be valid for two years from the date of issuance. (e) The fee for a permit required by this section shall be $100.00, payable at the time the application for said permit is submitted to the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-3; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 2, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 1, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 1, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 1, 12-5-78; Ord. No. 82-1109, § 1, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, §§ 1, 2, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-4. - Personnel required during operation of emergency ambulances; emergency ambulance technician certificate of proficiency. (a) It shall be unlawful to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven an emergency ambulance on a public street of the city when furnishing emergency ambulance service, including emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, unless there is aboard such emergency ambulance on each trip at least two persons, one of whom is the holder of a valid certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician issued by the health officer. The holder of such certificate must be the person attending the patient while such patient is being transported. ( Application for a certificate of proficiency as an emergency ambulance technician shall be made to the health officer on forms to be furnished by him, and shall be signed and sworn to before a notary public. © Qualifications for a certificate of proficiency shall be as follows: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The health officer shall establish standards of proficiency and training necessary for attainment in order for such person to qualify for a certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician. Such standards shall be filed with the city secretary and may be changed from time to time by filing such changes with the city secretary. The health officer shall cause regularly scheduled training courses and examinations to be conducted of all applicants for such certificate of proficiency. Such examinations may be oral or written or practical or a combination of such types of examinations, as the health officer determines will best demonstrate proficiency. The health officer shall limit the life of any certificate to not more than one year and shall provide for renewal of such certificate by the applicant's attending refresher courses and taking such renewal examinations as the health officer may prescribe. (d) The health officer shall investigate the application and the grades attained on such examination and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the certificate of proficiency. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such certificate and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (Code 1968, § 5-4; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 3, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 2, 12-5-78) Sec. 4-5. - Structural and licensing requirements. No emergency ambulance shall be operated on the public streets of the city unless it is free of structural defects and unless it has no serious impairment of any safety feature resulting from an accident or otherwise. No emergency ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service unless and until such ambulance has been duly licensed in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S. (Code 1968, § 5-5; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 4, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-6. - Required equipment. No emergency ambulance or transfer ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service unless such ambulance is equipped with the " Essential Equipment for Ambulances, " as set out in the bulletin of the American College of Surgeons, May issue, 1970, pages 7 through 13, a copy of which shall be filed in the office of the city secretary by the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-6; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 5, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-7. - Vehicle inspections. The health officer shall cause all emergency ambulances, including those operated by the fire department, to be inspected before being placed in service and thereafter annually, as well as on a spot inspection basis. In the event an emergency ambulance fails to pass inspection, the health officer shall notify the emergency ambulance operator or the chief of the fire department to correct the defects noted in the inspection and, after such notification, the health officer shall cause such ambulance to be reinspected for compliance. If, upon such reinspection, the defects noted in the original inspection have not been corrected, the vehicle decals shall be removed from the ambulance by the health officer and shall only be replaced upon such ambulance after the defects have been corrected. Inspections provided for herein may also be made by any police officer of the city or any authorized employee of the department of administration and regulatory affairs of the city. (Code 1968, § 5-7; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 6, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 1, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 05-939, § 3, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 9, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08) Sec. 4-8. - Decals and display of name. (a) When an ambulance operator's permit is issued or renewed under this article, the holder of the operator's permit shall present each ambulance that he proposes to operate thereunder to the health officer for inspection pursuant to the standards adopted in section 4-5, and if the operator proposes to use the ambulance in either or both of the instances described in section 4-9((3) or (4), then for additional inspection for compliance with section 4-6. Upon the successful completion of such inspection, the health officer will furnish the permittee two decals for each ambulance which has been inspected and is authorized to be used in service. One such decal shall be affixed to the front windshield at the lower right (passenger side) corner; the other such decal shall be affixed to the rear bumper or to a similar location in a manner as to be readily visible from a following vehicle. The color of such decals shall be changed annually. Additionally, all emergency ambulances shall have the name of the ambulance service prominently displayed on both exterior sides. ( It shall be unlawful to operate an ambulance on the streets of the city without having such decals affixed and, in the case of an emergency ambulance, without having the name of the ambulance service displayed as required by this section. (Code 1968, § 5-8; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 7, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 2, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 2, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 2, 10-23-79) Sec. 4-9. - Persons authorized to engage in emergency ambulance service. (a) The operation of emergency ambulances on the streets of the city for the furnishing of emergency ambulance service is hereby declared to be a governmental function of the city to be performed by the fire department in accordance with the terms of this chapter. It shall be unlawful for any person or persons, other than members of such fire department in its classified civil service, while driving emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, to furnish or to attempt to furnish emergency ambulance service or to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven any ambulance on the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service. ( It is an affirmative defense to prosecution under subsection (a) that: (1) The person operating an ambulance upon responding to a direct call for ambulance service determined that an emergency existed requiring the sick or injured person to be transported with all practical speed for medical treatment and attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency ambulance service; from the fire department dispatcher; (2) That the emergency ambulance service was provided by an ambulance based outside the city when not in use and operated by an ambulance company having an established place of business and permanent address outside the city, provided; a. The sick or injured person was picked up outside the corporate limits of the city and transported to a hospital within the city; and b. The ambulance performing such emergency ambulance service was, at the time, duly licensed and operated in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S.; and c. The driver of such ambulance complied with all speed and other traffic regulations of the city and the state. (3) That the person operating an ambulance within the city was performing a service under contract of maintaining an ambulance at a particular location, or event, for the purpose of transporting sick or injured persons for medical or hospital treatment, and determined that a sick or injured person at such location or event required immediate hospital or medical attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency service from the fire department dispatcher. (4) That the emergency ambulance service was provided at the request of the fire department dispatcher due to unavailability of a city ambulance. In each instance set out in (1) through (4) above, the driver or operator of such ambulance shall prior to commencement of each emergency ambulance run, notify the fire department dispatcher of the conditions requiring the operation of his vehicle in emergency ambulance service, the location from which he is proceeding, and the location to which he is proceeding under emergency ambulance service and obtain permission for such trip from the dispatcher. Each ambulance being operated under paragraphs (1) and (2) above shall comply with the requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances insofar as traffic safety is concerned. Each ambulance being operated under the provisions of paragraphs (3) and (4) above shall comply with all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances of every nature. Upon arriving at his destination, the ambulance driver or ambulance operator will again notify the fire department dispatcher that he has arrived and is no longer in emergency ambulance service. When the driver or operator of an ambulance is responding to a direct call for ambulance service, either under emergency conditions or otherwise, he shall inform the fire department ambulance dispatcher of the location of such call and such information as he may have concerning the circumstances surrounding the request for service, and if the fire department ambulance dispatcher reports that a fire department ambulance is either on route to the same location or has arrived there and instructs such ambulance driver or operator not to respond to such call, it shall be unlawful for such driver or operator to so respond when instructed not to do so by the fire department ambulance dispatcher. (Code 1968, § 5-9; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 8, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 3, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 3, 4-14-71) Sec. 4-10. - General authorization. Nothing herein shall prohibit any person owning an ambulance duly licensed and operated in accordance with article 4590b, V.T.C.S., from operating such ambulance on the public streets for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service only; provided, however, such person shall secure an operator's permit in compliance with the provisions of sections 4-15 and 4-16 hereof and shall cause his ambulance to have been inspected and be in display of a medallion issued in compliance with section 4-8 hereof. The driver of any such ambulance shall comply with all of the traffic laws of the state and ordinances of the city, including this chapter, in furnishing such ambulance service. The operator thereof shall not permit such ambulance to be used for emergency ambulance service unless all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulance service have been complied with. (Code 1968, § 5-10; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 9, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-736, § 4, 4-14-71) Cross reference— Traffic, Ch. 45. Sec. 4-11. - Use of signs or flashing emergency lights. The use of signs or flashing emergency lights on an ambulance upon the public streets of the city shall be unlawful except when furnishing emergency ambulance service in accordance with the terms of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-11; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 10, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-12. - Patient transport status; solicitation of business prohibited. (a) A patient's transport status shall be determined solely on the basis of the medical needs of the patient in accordance with the most current fire department guidelines as approved by the physician medical director. Under no circumstances shall the fact that a person is or appears to be indigent and unable to pay the cost of such service be considered in such determination. ( It shall be unlawful for any person, while operating or accompanying an emergency ambulance on the public streets or easements of the city, to solicit the business of transporting the sick or injured. (Code 1968, § 5-13; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 12, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 2010-525, § 2, 6-30-2010) Sec. 4-13. - Charges. (a) In order to partially defray the costs incurred by the city in providing emergency medical services and ambulance services, the following fees are hereby established to be collected for the provision of emergency ambulance service by the city: (1) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by the hospital from which the transportation originates, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance from one hospital to another hospital; and (2) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by or on behalf of the person served, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance other than from one hospital to another hospital. ( The fee specified above for transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall apply in each instance where a person is transported from one hospital to another hospital, except in those instances in which a person is picked up at a place other than a hospital and during the course of his transportation to the intended destination hospital the ambulance makes an intermediate stop at another hospital for emergency stabilization or other treatment en route. The fee specified above for the transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall in each instance be payable by the hospital from which the transportation of the person originates, and the transportation of the person shall not commence until and unless: (1) The physician in charge of the care of the person furnishes a written statement that the person's condition is suitable for safe transportation by ground ambulance to the intended destination hospital; and (2) The hospital furnishes a physician or other trained and qualified medical staff member who shall ride in the ambulance and assume the responsibility for the care of the person being transported en route; and (3) The administrator of the hospital or another responsible person signs a statement promising on behalf of the hospital to pay for the transportation of the person and furnishes the necessary billing information. © In addition to the base fees imposed under items (1) and (2) of subsection (a), above, the following variable fees shall be imposed, as applicable: (1) For use of oxygen (any quantity) $65.00 (2) For use of an oxygen mask or a nasal canula, or both 15.00 (3) For use of EKG (tracing only) 50.00 (4) For EKG pad(s) (any quantity) 16.89 (5) For IV prep kit(s) (any quantity) 10.00 (6) For IV administration set(s) (any quantity) 25.00 (7) For cervical collar 25.00 (8) For head immobilization 25.00 (9) For D5W (any quantity) 11.00 (10) For Adenosine (Adenocard) per 6 mg 33.25 (11) For Albuterol Sulfate (Proventil) for 0.5% sol. per ml 0.70 (12) For Atropine per 0.3 mg 0.49 (13) For Dextrose 50% 11.39 (14) For epam (Valium) 1.06 (15) For Dopamine (Intropin) per 250 mg 9.26 (16) For Epinephrine 1:1,000 1.09 (17) For Epinephrine 1:10,000 1.09 (18) For Furosemide (Lasix) 1.12 (19) For Lidocaine Drip per 50 cc 2.76 (20) For Lidocaine HCL—2% per 50 cc 2.76 (21) For Naloxone HCO (Narcan) 3.73 (22) For Cordarone IV per 300 mg 150.00 (23) For miscellaneous medical supplies (any amount, type or quantity) 25.00 (24) Actual costs (not subject to the adjustment in (d) below) of medications, equipment and labor to provide other medically necessary services during transport. In lieu of actual computed miles, the fire chief may authorize use of a zone system or other procedure, provided that the mileage charged does not exceed the actual mileage. (d) That the base fee plus the variable fees established in sections (a)(1), (a)(2) and © above shall be automatically increased on the first day of each subsequent fiscal year by a percentage equal to the percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index—All Urban Customers (CPI-U), if any, over the same date of the previous year. If there is a decrease or if there is no increase in any given year, the rates for that year shall remain the same as in the previous year. (e) The fire department shall submit to the tax assessor-collector a record of each instance in which emergency ambulance transportation service is provided. The tax assessor-collector shall be responsible for the billing and collection of the applicable fees. Except for the conditions expressly provided above in the instance of the transportation of a patient from one hospital to another hospital, no provision in this section shall be construed to authorize the fire department, under any circumstances, to refuse emergency ambulance assistance to any person upon the grounds that the person is indigent or unable to pay for the service. (Code 1968, § 5-15; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 14, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-2031, § 1, 11-23-76; Ord. No. 83-1318, § 1, 8-23-83; Ord. No. 86-1616, § 1, 9-10-86; Ord. No. 91-1178, § 1, 8-14-91; Ord. No. 93-918, § 1, 7-28-93; Ord. No. 96-665, § 7, 6-26-96; Ord. No. 97-1003, § 1, 8-20-97; Ord. No. 01-564, § 11, 6-20-01; Ord. No. 02-528, § 14a., 6-19-02; Ord. No. 2010-892, §§ 2—4, 11-17-2010) Sec. 4-14. - Uncollectible transport account. There is hereby created a list of ambulance accounts to be entitled " uncollectible transports. " The tax assessor-collector of the city shall have the power to place ambulance bills on the uncollectible transports list if he determines such ambulance bills to be uncollectible. An " uncollectible transport " shall be defined as any of the following: (1) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient whose name and/or address is unknown, or upon whom there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the patient, or a patient using a false name and/or, address, or a patient who is a minor and whose parents or next of kin are unknown, or there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the parents or next of kin. (2) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient who is in the custody of, or placed under arrest by, a police officer of the city. (3) Emergency ambulance service provided at least six months previously and upon which a diligent collection effort has been made. (Code 1968, § 5-15.1; Ord. No. 74-1778, § 1, 10-8-74) Sec. 4-15. - Ambulance service operator's permit, insurance required. Any person operating an ambulance service upon the streets of the city must secure a permit therefor from the health officer. Such applicant shall provide evidence to the health officer that he has in full force for such calendar year a public liability insurance policy on each ambulance, such insurance policy to be issued by an insurance company which is authorized by law to do business in the state. Such policy shall provide liability insurance in the amount of not less than $50,000.00 for any one accident and not less than $25,000.00 for injury to any one person. Such insurance policy shall not contain a passenger liability exclusion. Each policy shall contain a provision obligating the insurer to give to the health officer written notice of cancellation not less than ten days prior to the date of any cancellation. (Code 1968, § 5-16; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 15, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-235, § 1, 2-11-76) Sec. 4-16. - Fees for operator's permit, decals; term of decals. The fee for the ambulance operator's permit required pursuant to section 4-15 of this Code shall be $1,000.00, and all permits issued under this chapter shall be valid for one year from the date of issuance. Such permits may be renewed after the termination date of the initial permit and during that same year by paying a permit fee of $800.00. The charge for decals required pursuant to section 4-8 of this Code shall be $275.00 per pair of decals for each pair issued, renewed or replaced. Decals expire concurrently with the ambulance operator's permit under which they are issued. Such fees and charges shall be collected by the department of health and human services and transferred to the department of administration and regulatory affairs, together with an accounting of the permits and pairs of decals for which same were collected. (Code 1968, § 5-17; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 16, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 4, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 5, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 76-235, § 2, 2-11-76; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 3, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 82-1107, § 2, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, § 4, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 10, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-17. - Penalty for violations. Whenever in this chapter an act is prohibited or is made or declared to be unlawful or an offense or misdemeanor, or whenever in this chapter the doing of any thing or act is required or the failure to do any thing or act is prohibited, the violation of the provision shall be and constitute a misdemeanor punishable, upon conviction, by a fine of not more than $2,000.00. Each violation shall constitute and be punishable as a separate offense. Prosecution or conviction under this provision is cumulative of and shall never be a bar to any other civil or administrative remedy provided or allowed in this chapter or by law. In addition, the city attorney is hereby authorized to file suit in any court of competent jurisdiction to enjoin any person from violating or causing to be violated any of the provisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-18; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 18, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 92-1449, § 3, 11-4-92; Ord. No. 05-939, § 5, 8-3-05) Charter reference— Penalty for ordinance violation, Art. II, § 12. Cross reference— Assessment of fines against corporations, § 16-76; payment of fines, § 16-78; credit against fines for incarceration, § 35-6 et seq. Sec. 4-18. - Revocation or suspension of permits, licenses and certificates. Any permit, license or certificate issued pursuant to this chapter shall be subject to suspension or revocation upon the finding pursuant to a public hearing conducted by the health officer that the holder of such permit, license or certificate has failed to comply with the applicable provisions of this chapter or that the holder no longer meets the requirements which pertain to the issuance thereof, provided that the holder of such permit, license or certificate shall be given prior notice of the date, time and place of the hearing setting forth the grounds upon which the suspension or revocation is based and shall be afforded an opportunity to appear in person or through counsel to present evidence and to cross examine all witnesses appearing at such hearing. Sec. 4-19. - Disposition of certain fees. All fees collected under sections 4-3 and 4-16 of this Code shall be allocated to the health and human services department to fund the inspection of ambulances and permitting of ambulance operators as required by this chapter. (Ord. No. 05-939, § 6, 8-3-05) Alyssa Woods, NREMT-B CPR Instructor > Yep, you are correct. They speed just because they can. > > Wayne > > > > > > > > Subject: RE: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > To: texasems-l > > Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 10:12 PM > > > > > > > > 16 over running non-emergent I almost have to wonder why your even asking > > > > this question Marcus and what is your companies position on this obvious > > > > violation of the traffic laws? > > > > Jim< > > > > Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > > > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston > > > > PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston > > > > Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The > > > > flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing > > > > vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. > > > > This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 > > > > miles an hour. > > > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the > > > > Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An > > > > EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have > > > > known better. > > > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had > > > > a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not > > > > transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient > > > > was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further > > > > evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in > > > > need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more > > > > about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around > > > > 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. > > > > We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical > > > > center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a > > > > priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a > > > > patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to > > > > transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the > > > > Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and > > > > traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was > > > > traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that > > > > were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol > > > > cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us > > > > alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that > > > > we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of > > > > blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I > > > > advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need > > > > the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights > > > > and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he > > > > asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he > > > > stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting > > > > a citation. " Please sign here. " > > > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it > > > > read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A > > > > CITATION!!!! " > > > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and > > > > will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for > > > > speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you > > > > are not following ALL traffic laws. > > > > Questions: > > > > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > > > > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did > > > > you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > > > Mr. Marcus Finney > > > > mdfinney@... > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 12, 2011 Report Share Posted January 12, 2011 Ok... Cute Medic had a conversation with me and gave some insight into this topic. Now, neither of us are lawyers, but... The first thing I'd do is look at your citation. If it cites you for General Speeding, take it to court, because that's an automatic dismissal. You were speeding in an ambulance, and the laws are different. If it cites a specific transportation code, a deeper understanding of the law is warranted. 541.201 is the definition of an Emergency Vehicle. This includes an ambulance operated by someone with a Texas EMS license. 546 says that an ambulance may violate the speed limit, and that you must use a warning sign (lights and sirens), except at the discretion of the officer and in accordance with department policy. So, so long as you were operating within department policy, you should be ok. The exception to this is if the municipality has a law regulating the speed of the ambulances (which is what 545.365 allows for). So, check your citation, and if it gives you a specific law, look up that law. If it doesn't, look up Houston's Code of Ordinances, and see what their laws say about the speed of ambulances. And below are the laws I was talking about, with bold added for emphasis. I didn't read all of the Code of Ordinances, and I would love Gene or Wes' opinion on all of this. Because if I'm reading the Code of Ordinances right, NO ambulance save HFD can operate LS or emergency traffic in Houston unless they get permission from Houston dispatch. That's insane. But if I'm reading it wrong (and you CAN operate LS in Houston when coming from another municipality, which is what I'm more inclined to believe, as I've done so personally and not been pulled over), you actually have a valid defense. § 541.201. VEHICLES. In this subtitle: (1) " Authorized emergency vehicle " means: (A) a fire department or police vehicle; ( a public or private ambulance operated by a person who has been issued a license by the Texas Department of Health; © a municipal department or public service corporation emergency vehicle that has been designated or authorized by the governing body of a municipality; (D) a private vehicle of a volunteer firefighter or a certified emergency medical services employee or volunteer when responding to a fire alarm or medical emergency; (E) an industrial emergency response vehicle, including an industrial ambulance, when responding to an emergency, but only if the vehicle is operated in compliance with criteria in effect September 1, 1989, and established by the predecessor of the Texas Industrial Emergency Services Board of the State Firemen's and Fire Marshals' Association of Texas; or (F) a vehicle of a blood bank or tissue bank, accredited or approved under the laws of this state or the United States, when making emergency deliveries of blood, drugs, medicines, or organs. § 545.365. SPEED LIMIT EXCEPTION FOR EMERGENCIES; MUNICIPAL REGULATION. (a) The regulation of the speed of a vehicle under this subchapter does not apply to: (1) an authorized emergency vehicle responding to a call; (2) a police patrol; or (3) a physician or ambulance responding to an emergency call. ( A municipality by ordinance may regulate the speed of: (1) an ambulance; (2) an emergency medical services vehicle; or (3) an authorized vehicle operated by a blood or tissue bank. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.001. PERMISSIBLE CONDUCT. In operating an authorized emergency vehicle the operator may: (1) park or stand, irrespective of another provision of this subtitle; (2) proceed past a red or stop signal or stop sign, after slowing as necessary for safe operation; (3) exceed a maximum speed limit, except as provided by an ordinance adopted under Section 545.365, as long as the operator does not endanger life or property; and (4) disregard a regulation governing the direction of movement or turning in specified directions. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.002. WHEN CONDUCT PERMISSIBLE. (a) In this section, " police escort " means facilitating the movement of a funeral, oversized or hazardous load, or other traffic disruption for public safety purposes by a peace officer described by Articles 2.12(1)-(4), (8), and (22), Code of Criminal Procedure. ( Section 546.001 applies only when the operator is: (1) responding to an emergency call; (2) pursuing an actual or suspected violator of the law; (3) responding to but not returning from a fire alarm; (4) directing or diverting traffic for public safety purposes; or (5) conducting a police escort. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Amended by Acts 2003, 78th Leg., ch. 66, § 1, eff. May 16, 2003; Acts 2005, 79th Leg., ch. 834, § 1, eff. June 17, 2005. § 546.003. AUDIBLE OR VISUAL SIGNALS REQUIRED. Except as provided by Section 546.004, the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle engaging in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 shall use, at the discretion of the operator in accordance with policies of the department or the local government that employs the operator, audible or visual signals that meet the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.004. EXCEPTIONS TO SIGNAL REQUIREMENT. (a) A volunteer fire fighter who operates a private vehicle as an authorized emergency vehicle may engage in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 only when the fire fighter is using visual signals meeting the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702. ( An authorized emergency vehicle that is operated as a police vehicle is not required to be equipped with or display a red light visible from the front of the vehicle. © A police officer may operate an authorized emergency vehicle for a law enforcement purpose without using the audible or visual signals required by Section 546.003 if the officer is: (1) responding to an emergency call or pursuing a suspected violator of the law with probable cause to believe that: (A) knowledge of the presence of the officer will cause the suspect to: (i) destroy or lose evidence of a suspected felony; (ii) end a suspected continuing felony before the officer has obtained sufficient evidence to establish grounds for arrest; or (iii) evade apprehension or identification of the suspect or the suspect's vehicle; or ( because of traffic conditions on a multilaned roadway, vehicles moving in response to the audible or visual signals may: (i) increase the potential for a collision; or (ii) unreasonably extend the duration of the pursuit; or (2) complying with a written regulation relating to the use of audible or visible signals adopted by the local government that employs the officer or by the department. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.005. DUTY OF CARE. This chapter does not relieve the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle from: (1) the duty to operate the vehicle with appropriate regard for the safety of all persons; or (2) the consequences of reckless disregard for the safety of others. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.021. MUTUAL AID ORGANIZATIONS. (a) Two or more businesses whose activities require the maintenance of fire-fighting equipment may form a mutual aid organization in which the member businesses agree to assist each other during an emergency by supplying fire-fighting equipment or services. ( The presiding officer or director of an organization formed under this section shall deliver a list to the county fire marshal, or to the commissioners court of a county if the county does not have a fire marshal, in each county in which a member business is located. The list must contain the name of the registered owner and license plate number of each motor vehicle that each member intends to use in supplying fire-fighting equipment or services. © If the county fire marshal or commissioners court determines that the operation of the vehicles on the list is in the public interest and not a threat to public safety, the marshal or court shall approve the list. (d) On approval of the list by the county fire marshal or commissioners court, a person operating a listed motor vehicle in response to a call for emergency fire-fighting assistance from a member has the rights and restrictions placed by this subtitle on the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle. (e) A county is not liable for damage to a person or property caused by a person approved by the county under this section to operate a motor vehicle for emergency fire-fighting assistance. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Houston Code of Ordinances Regarding Ambulances: Sec. 4-1. - Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: (1) Ambulance. A motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of the transportation of sick or injured persons. (2) Ambulance service. A trip made by an ambulance to transport a sick or injured person from place to place under other than emergency circumstances. (3) Ambulance operator. The person holding a city ambulance permit. (4) Department. The department of health. (5) Direct call. A request for ambulance service made by telephone or other means directly to an ambulance operator, his agents or employees. (6) Driver's permit. A city emergency ambulance driver's permit. (7) Emergency ambulance. Any motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of transporting sick or injured persons under emergency circumstances, and the rendering of first aid or the performance of rescue work, or both, under such circumstances. (8) Emergency circumstances. The existence of circumstances in which the element of time in expeditiously transporting a sick or injured person for medical or surgical treatment is essential to the health or life of such person, and in which rescue operations or competent first aid or both at the place of emergency may be essential to the health or life of such person. (9) Emergency ambulance service. A trip made by an emergency ambulance under emergency circumstances to the place of emergency, performance of any necessary rescue operations, rendering of any necessary first aid assistance and the trip to the hospital or other place for medical attention. An ambulance is being operated in emergency ambulance service if all or any part of the above described trip to the place of emergency and any subsequent trip to the hospital is made on the streets within the corporate limits of the city. An emergency ambulance shall be considered to be rendering emergency ambulance service when it is responding to a call for emergency assistance even though, upon arrival at the place of emergency, it is found that the call was falsely made or that no further emergency ambulance assistance is required or when it is responding to a call for routine ambulance service and during such trip emergency circumstances develop. (Code 1968, § 5-1; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 1, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-2. - Ambulance advisory committee. An ambulance advisory committee is hereby created, to consist of the director of the health department, or in his absence a representative appointed by the director; the chief of the fire department, or in his absence a representative appointed by him; and a third member to be selected by the County Medical Society, or in his absence, an alternate member selected by such society. It shall be the duty of such committee to recommend to the city council, specifications for construction, equipment and numbers of emergency ambulances to be purchased by the city (which specifications shall include the essential equipment referred to in section 4-6 below). The committee shall meet at least two times per year. The committee shall submit to the city council from time to time, its recommendations as to new specifications for emergency ambulances and its recommendations as to revisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-2; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 19, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-3. - City emergency ambulance driver's permit. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person other than a member of the fire department assigned to drive a fire department ambulance to operate or drive an emergency ambulance upon the public streets of the city unless the driver thereof shall first have obtained a city emergency ambulance driver's permit. ( An application for such permit shall be submitted to the health officer upon a form or forms to be provided by him. Such application must be signed and sworn to before a notary public. The applicant shall have the following qualifications: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The applicant must be the holder of a Class C Texas driver license. © The health officer shall investigate the application and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the issuance of an emergency ambulance driver's permit. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such a permit, and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (d) A permit issued under this section shall be valid for two years from the date of issuance. (e) The fee for a permit required by this section shall be $100.00, payable at the time the application for said permit is submitted to the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-3; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 2, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 1, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 1, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 1, 12-5-78; Ord. No. 82-1109, § 1, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, §§ 1, 2, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-4. - Personnel required during operation of emergency ambulances; emergency ambulance technician certificate of proficiency. (a) It shall be unlawful to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven an emergency ambulance on a public street of the city when furnishing emergency ambulance service, including emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, unless there is aboard such emergency ambulance on each trip at least two persons, one of whom is the holder of a valid certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician issued by the health officer. The holder of such certificate must be the person attending the patient while such patient is being transported. ( Application for a certificate of proficiency as an emergency ambulance technician shall be made to the health officer on forms to be furnished by him, and shall be signed and sworn to before a notary public. © Qualifications for a certificate of proficiency shall be as follows: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The health officer shall establish standards of proficiency and training necessary for attainment in order for such person to qualify for a certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician. Such standards shall be filed with the city secretary and may be changed from time to time by filing such changes with the city secretary. The health officer shall cause regularly scheduled training courses and examinations to be conducted of all applicants for such certificate of proficiency. Such examinations may be oral or written or practical or a combination of such types of examinations, as the health officer determines will best demonstrate proficiency. The health officer shall limit the life of any certificate to not more than one year and shall provide for renewal of such certificate by the applicant's attending refresher courses and taking such renewal examinations as the health officer may prescribe. (d) The health officer shall investigate the application and the grades attained on such examination and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the certificate of proficiency. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such certificate and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (Code 1968, § 5-4; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 3, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 2, 12-5-78) Sec. 4-5. - Structural and licensing requirements. No emergency ambulance shall be operated on the public streets of the city unless it is free of structural defects and unless it has no serious impairment of any safety feature resulting from an accident or otherwise. No emergency ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service unless and until such ambulance has been duly licensed in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S. (Code 1968, § 5-5; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 4, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-6. - Required equipment. No emergency ambulance or transfer ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service unless such ambulance is equipped with the " Essential Equipment for Ambulances, " as set out in the bulletin of the American College of Surgeons, May issue, 1970, pages 7 through 13, a copy of which shall be filed in the office of the city secretary by the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-6; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 5, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-7. - Vehicle inspections. The health officer shall cause all emergency ambulances, including those operated by the fire department, to be inspected before being placed in service and thereafter annually, as well as on a spot inspection basis. In the event an emergency ambulance fails to pass inspection, the health officer shall notify the emergency ambulance operator or the chief of the fire department to correct the defects noted in the inspection and, after such notification, the health officer shall cause such ambulance to be reinspected for compliance. If, upon such reinspection, the defects noted in the original inspection have not been corrected, the vehicle decals shall be removed from the ambulance by the health officer and shall only be replaced upon such ambulance after the defects have been corrected. Inspections provided for herein may also be made by any police officer of the city or any authorized employee of the department of administration and regulatory affairs of the city. (Code 1968, § 5-7; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 6, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 1, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 05-939, § 3, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 9, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08) Sec. 4-8. - Decals and display of name. (a) When an ambulance operator's permit is issued or renewed under this article, the holder of the operator's permit shall present each ambulance that he proposes to operate thereunder to the health officer for inspection pursuant to the standards adopted in section 4-5, and if the operator proposes to use the ambulance in either or both of the instances described in section 4-9((3) or (4), then for additional inspection for compliance with section 4-6. Upon the successful completion of such inspection, the health officer will furnish the permittee two decals for each ambulance which has been inspected and is authorized to be used in service. One such decal shall be affixed to the front windshield at the lower right (passenger side) corner; the other such decal shall be affixed to the rear bumper or to a similar location in a manner as to be readily visible from a following vehicle. The color of such decals shall be changed annually. Additionally, all emergency ambulances shall have the name of the ambulance service prominently displayed on both exterior sides. ( It shall be unlawful to operate an ambulance on the streets of the city without having such decals affixed and, in the case of an emergency ambulance, without having the name of the ambulance service displayed as required by this section. (Code 1968, § 5-8; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 7, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 2, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 2, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 2, 10-23-79) Sec. 4-9. - Persons authorized to engage in emergency ambulance service. (a) The operation of emergency ambulances on the streets of the city for the furnishing of emergency ambulance service is hereby declared to be a governmental function of the city to be performed by the fire department in accordance with the terms of this chapter. It shall be unlawful for any person or persons, other than members of such fire department in its classified civil service, while driving emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, to furnish or to attempt to furnish emergency ambulance service or to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven any ambulance on the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service. ( It is an affirmative defense to prosecution under subsection (a) that: (1) The person operating an ambulance upon responding to a direct call for ambulance service determined that an emergency existed requiring the sick or injured person to be transported with all practical speed for medical treatment and attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency ambulance service; from the fire department dispatcher; (2) That the emergency ambulance service was provided by an ambulance based outside the city when not in use and operated by an ambulance company having an established place of business and permanent address outside the city, provided; a. The sick or injured person was picked up outside the corporate limits of the city and transported to a hospital within the city; and b. The ambulance performing such emergency ambulance service was, at the time, duly licensed and operated in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S.; and c. The driver of such ambulance complied with all speed and other traffic regulations of the city and the state. (3) That the person operating an ambulance within the city was performing a service under contract of maintaining an ambulance at a particular location, or event, for the purpose of transporting sick or injured persons for medical or hospital treatment, and determined that a sick or injured person at such location or event required immediate hospital or medical attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency service from the fire department dispatcher. (4) That the emergency ambulance service was provided at the request of the fire department dispatcher due to unavailability of a city ambulance. In each instance set out in (1) through (4) above, the driver or operator of such ambulance shall prior to commencement of each emergency ambulance run, notify the fire department dispatcher of the conditions requiring the operation of his vehicle in emergency ambulance service, the location from which he is proceeding, and the location to which he is proceeding under emergency ambulance service and obtain permission for such trip from the dispatcher. Each ambulance being operated under paragraphs (1) and (2) above shall comply with the requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances insofar as traffic safety is concerned. Each ambulance being operated under the provisions of paragraphs (3) and (4) above shall comply with all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances of every nature. Upon arriving at his destination, the ambulance driver or ambulance operator will again notify the fire department dispatcher that he has arrived and is no longer in emergency ambulance service. When the driver or operator of an ambulance is responding to a direct call for ambulance service, either under emergency conditions or otherwise, he shall inform the fire department ambulance dispatcher of the location of such call and such information as he may have concerning the circumstances surrounding the request for service, and if the fire department ambulance dispatcher reports that a fire department ambulance is either on route to the same location or has arrived there and instructs such ambulance driver or operator not to respond to such call, it shall be unlawful for such driver or operator to so respond when instructed not to do so by the fire department ambulance dispatcher. (Code 1968, § 5-9; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 8, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 3, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 3, 4-14-71) Sec. 4-10. - General authorization. Nothing herein shall prohibit any person owning an ambulance duly licensed and operated in accordance with article 4590b, V.T.C.S., from operating such ambulance on the public streets for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service only; provided, however, such person shall secure an operator's permit in compliance with the provisions of sections 4-15 and 4-16 hereof and shall cause his ambulance to have been inspected and be in display of a medallion issued in compliance with section 4-8 hereof. The driver of any such ambulance shall comply with all of the traffic laws of the state and ordinances of the city, including this chapter, in furnishing such ambulance service. The operator thereof shall not permit such ambulance to be used for emergency ambulance service unless all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulance service have been complied with. (Code 1968, § 5-10; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 9, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-736, § 4, 4-14-71) Cross reference— Traffic, Ch. 45. Sec. 4-11. - Use of signs or flashing emergency lights. The use of signs or flashing emergency lights on an ambulance upon the public streets of the city shall be unlawful except when furnishing emergency ambulance service in accordance with the terms of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-11; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 10, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-12. - Patient transport status; solicitation of business prohibited. (a) A patient's transport status shall be determined solely on the basis of the medical needs of the patient in accordance with the most current fire department guidelines as approved by the physician medical director. Under no circumstances shall the fact that a person is or appears to be indigent and unable to pay the cost of such service be considered in such determination. ( It shall be unlawful for any person, while operating or accompanying an emergency ambulance on the public streets or easements of the city, to solicit the business of transporting the sick or injured. (Code 1968, § 5-13; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 12, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 2010-525, § 2, 6-30-2010) Sec. 4-13. - Charges. (a) In order to partially defray the costs incurred by the city in providing emergency medical services and ambulance services, the following fees are hereby established to be collected for the provision of emergency ambulance service by the city: (1) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by the hospital from which the transportation originates, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance from one hospital to another hospital; and (2) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by or on behalf of the person served, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance other than from one hospital to another hospital. ( The fee specified above for transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall apply in each instance where a person is transported from one hospital to another hospital, except in those instances in which a person is picked up at a place other than a hospital and during the course of his transportation to the intended destination hospital the ambulance makes an intermediate stop at another hospital for emergency stabilization or other treatment en route. The fee specified above for the transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall in each instance be payable by the hospital from which the transportation of the person originates, and the transportation of the person shall not commence until and unless: (1) The physician in charge of the care of the person furnishes a written statement that the person's condition is suitable for safe transportation by ground ambulance to the intended destination hospital; and (2) The hospital furnishes a physician or other trained and qualified medical staff member who shall ride in the ambulance and assume the responsibility for the care of the person being transported en route; and (3) The administrator of the hospital or another responsible person signs a statement promising on behalf of the hospital to pay for the transportation of the person and furnishes the necessary billing information. © In addition to the base fees imposed under items (1) and (2) of subsection (a), above, the following variable fees shall be imposed, as applicable: (1) For use of oxygen (any quantity) $65.00 (2) For use of an oxygen mask or a nasal canula, or both 15.00 (3) For use of EKG (tracing only) 50.00 (4) For EKG pad(s) (any quantity) 16.89 (5) For IV prep kit(s) (any quantity) 10.00 (6) For IV administration set(s) (any quantity) 25.00 (7) For cervical collar 25.00 (8) For head immobilization 25.00 (9) For D5W (any quantity) 11.00 (10) For Adenosine (Adenocard) per 6 mg 33.25 (11) For Albuterol Sulfate (Proventil) for 0.5% sol. per ml 0.70 (12) For Atropine per 0.3 mg 0.49 (13) For Dextrose 50% 11.39 (14) For epam (Valium) 1.06 (15) For Dopamine (Intropin) per 250 mg 9.26 (16) For Epinephrine 1:1,000 1.09 (17) For Epinephrine 1:10,000 1.09 (18) For Furosemide (Lasix) 1.12 (19) For Lidocaine Drip per 50 cc 2.76 (20) For Lidocaine HCL—2% per 50 cc 2.76 (21) For Naloxone HCO (Narcan) 3.73 (22) For Cordarone IV per 300 mg 150.00 (23) For miscellaneous medical supplies (any amount, type or quantity) 25.00 (24) Actual costs (not subject to the adjustment in (d) below) of medications, equipment and labor to provide other medically necessary services during transport. In lieu of actual computed miles, the fire chief may authorize use of a zone system or other procedure, provided that the mileage charged does not exceed the actual mileage. (d) That the base fee plus the variable fees established in sections (a)(1), (a)(2) and © above shall be automatically increased on the first day of each subsequent fiscal year by a percentage equal to the percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index—All Urban Customers (CPI-U), if any, over the same date of the previous year. If there is a decrease or if there is no increase in any given year, the rates for that year shall remain the same as in the previous year. (e) The fire department shall submit to the tax assessor-collector a record of each instance in which emergency ambulance transportation service is provided. The tax assessor-collector shall be responsible for the billing and collection of the applicable fees. Except for the conditions expressly provided above in the instance of the transportation of a patient from one hospital to another hospital, no provision in this section shall be construed to authorize the fire department, under any circumstances, to refuse emergency ambulance assistance to any person upon the grounds that the person is indigent or unable to pay for the service. (Code 1968, § 5-15; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 14, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-2031, § 1, 11-23-76; Ord. No. 83-1318, § 1, 8-23-83; Ord. No. 86-1616, § 1, 9-10-86; Ord. No. 91-1178, § 1, 8-14-91; Ord. No. 93-918, § 1, 7-28-93; Ord. No. 96-665, § 7, 6-26-96; Ord. No. 97-1003, § 1, 8-20-97; Ord. No. 01-564, § 11, 6-20-01; Ord. No. 02-528, § 14a., 6-19-02; Ord. No. 2010-892, §§ 2—4, 11-17-2010) Sec. 4-14. - Uncollectible transport account. There is hereby created a list of ambulance accounts to be entitled " uncollectible transports. " The tax assessor-collector of the city shall have the power to place ambulance bills on the uncollectible transports list if he determines such ambulance bills to be uncollectible. An " uncollectible transport " shall be defined as any of the following: (1) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient whose name and/or address is unknown, or upon whom there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the patient, or a patient using a false name and/or, address, or a patient who is a minor and whose parents or next of kin are unknown, or there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the parents or next of kin. (2) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient who is in the custody of, or placed under arrest by, a police officer of the city. (3) Emergency ambulance service provided at least six months previously and upon which a diligent collection effort has been made. (Code 1968, § 5-15.1; Ord. No. 74-1778, § 1, 10-8-74) Sec. 4-15. - Ambulance service operator's permit, insurance required. Any person operating an ambulance service upon the streets of the city must secure a permit therefor from the health officer. Such applicant shall provide evidence to the health officer that he has in full force for such calendar year a public liability insurance policy on each ambulance, such insurance policy to be issued by an insurance company which is authorized by law to do business in the state. Such policy shall provide liability insurance in the amount of not less than $50,000.00 for any one accident and not less than $25,000.00 for injury to any one person. Such insurance policy shall not contain a passenger liability exclusion. Each policy shall contain a provision obligating the insurer to give to the health officer written notice of cancellation not less than ten days prior to the date of any cancellation. (Code 1968, § 5-16; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 15, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-235, § 1, 2-11-76) Sec. 4-16. - Fees for operator's permit, decals; term of decals. The fee for the ambulance operator's permit required pursuant to section 4-15 of this Code shall be $1,000.00, and all permits issued under this chapter shall be valid for one year from the date of issuance. Such permits may be renewed after the termination date of the initial permit and during that same year by paying a permit fee of $800.00. The charge for decals required pursuant to section 4-8 of this Code shall be $275.00 per pair of decals for each pair issued, renewed or replaced. Decals expire concurrently with the ambulance operator's permit under which they are issued. Such fees and charges shall be collected by the department of health and human services and transferred to the department of administration and regulatory affairs, together with an accounting of the permits and pairs of decals for which same were collected. (Code 1968, § 5-17; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 16, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 4, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 5, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 76-235, § 2, 2-11-76; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 3, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 82-1107, § 2, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, § 4, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 10, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-17. - Penalty for violations. Whenever in this chapter an act is prohibited or is made or declared to be unlawful or an offense or misdemeanor, or whenever in this chapter the doing of any thing or act is required or the failure to do any thing or act is prohibited, the violation of the provision shall be and constitute a misdemeanor punishable, upon conviction, by a fine of not more than $2,000.00. Each violation shall constitute and be punishable as a separate offense. Prosecution or conviction under this provision is cumulative of and shall never be a bar to any other civil or administrative remedy provided or allowed in this chapter or by law. In addition, the city attorney is hereby authorized to file suit in any court of competent jurisdiction to enjoin any person from violating or causing to be violated any of the provisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-18; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 18, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 92-1449, § 3, 11-4-92; Ord. No. 05-939, § 5, 8-3-05) Charter reference— Penalty for ordinance violation, Art. II, § 12. Cross reference— Assessment of fines against corporations, § 16-76; payment of fines, § 16-78; credit against fines for incarceration, § 35-6 et seq. Sec. 4-18. - Revocation or suspension of permits, licenses and certificates. Any permit, license or certificate issued pursuant to this chapter shall be subject to suspension or revocation upon the finding pursuant to a public hearing conducted by the health officer that the holder of such permit, license or certificate has failed to comply with the applicable provisions of this chapter or that the holder no longer meets the requirements which pertain to the issuance thereof, provided that the holder of such permit, license or certificate shall be given prior notice of the date, time and place of the hearing setting forth the grounds upon which the suspension or revocation is based and shall be afforded an opportunity to appear in person or through counsel to present evidence and to cross examine all witnesses appearing at such hearing. Sec. 4-19. - Disposition of certain fees. All fees collected under sections 4-3 and 4-16 of this Code shall be allocated to the health and human services department to fund the inspection of ambulances and permitting of ambulance operators as required by this chapter. (Ord. No. 05-939, § 6, 8-3-05) Alyssa Woods, NREMT-B CPR Instructor > Yep, you are correct. They speed just because they can. > > Wayne > > > > > > > > Subject: RE: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > To: texasems-l > > Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 10:12 PM > > > > > > > > 16 over running non-emergent I almost have to wonder why your even asking > > > > this question Marcus and what is your companies position on this obvious > > > > violation of the traffic laws? > > > > Jim< > > > > Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > > > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston > > > > PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston > > > > Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The > > > > flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing > > > > vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. > > > > This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 > > > > miles an hour. > > > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the > > > > Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An > > > > EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have > > > > known better. > > > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had > > > > a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not > > > > transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient > > > > was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further > > > > evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in > > > > need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more > > > > about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around > > > > 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. > > > > We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical > > > > center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a > > > > priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a > > > > patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to > > > > transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the > > > > Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and > > > > traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was > > > > traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that > > > > were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol > > > > cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us > > > > alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that > > > > we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of > > > > blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I > > > > advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need > > > > the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights > > > > and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he > > > > asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he > > > > stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting > > > > a citation. " Please sign here. " > > > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it > > > > read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A > > > > CITATION!!!! " > > > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and > > > > will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for > > > > speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you > > > > are not following ALL traffic laws. > > > > Questions: > > > > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > > > > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did > > > > you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > > > Mr. Marcus Finney > > > > mdfinney@... > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 What really grinds my gears about this is, well professional courtesy..... Would that cop have pulled you over and given you a ticket if your ambulance said HFD, Cypress Creek, or ESD1 on the side? Probably not! Yes you were speeding but it sounds to me you were going with the flow of traffic (and I drive in Houston ALOT) in similar traffic condition as you describe and believe that you were not only With the flow of traffic I would dare to say you were probably being passed by many a car. That being said pay the ticket, it's not worth the fight especially in a time of economic hardship for the city of Houston, to take it in spite look on the bright side he has a huge chip on his shoulder about EMS, but at least your still gonna have health insurance and retirement at the end of your career. (that was meant soley as a Political joke and not to start a new argument, if you don't know what it means you prolly don't live in the Houston area my apologies) -Chris Sorry for the spelling and punctuation this was typed on the tiny keyboard on my iPhone Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 You guys are heading in the wrong direction here. I am a police officer and a paramedic in the D/FW area and here is a bit of an insight for you all. Look up the Texas Transportation Code and you will clearly see what is defined as an emergency and what is an emergency vehicle. I have know of several cases of a " private " non-EMS ambulance being ticketed for speeding. Here in the Dallas area there are MANY so called EMS services but they have no EMS responsibilities. In my honest opinion they put EMS on the side of their units to help promote business. Explaining the patients condition to an officer is pointless. You did all the explaining when you made the statement, " ....I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens " . Just curious but what did the ATTENDING medic say?? ADVICE==Drive the appropriate speed that is warranted to your patients condition. The condition you states does not warrant the speed. JB ________________________________ To: texasems-l Sent: Thu, January 13, 2011 12:15:48 AM Subject: Re: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance Ok... Cute Medic had a conversation with me and gave some insight into this topic. Now, neither of us are lawyers, but... The first thing I'd do is look at your citation. If it cites you for General Speeding, take it to court, because that's an automatic dismissal. You were speeding in an ambulance, and the laws are different. If it cites a specific transportation code, a deeper understanding of the law is warranted. 541.201 is the definition of an Emergency Vehicle. This includes an ambulance operated by someone with a Texas EMS license. 546 says that an ambulance may violate the speed limit, and that you must use a warning sign (lights and sirens), except at the discretion of the officer and in accordance with department policy. So, so long as you were operating within department policy, you should be ok. The exception to this is if the municipality has a law regulating the speed of the ambulances (which is what 545.365 allows for). So, check your citation, and if it gives you a specific law, look up that law. If it doesn't, look up Houston's Code of Ordinances, and see what their laws say about the speed of ambulances. And below are the laws I was talking about, with bold added for emphasis. I didn't read all of the Code of Ordinances, and I would love Gene or Wes' opinion on all of this. Because if I'm reading the Code of Ordinances right, NO ambulance save HFD can operate LS or emergency traffic in Houston unless they get permission from Houston dispatch. That's insane. But if I'm reading it wrong (and you CAN operate LS in Houston when coming from another municipality, which is what I'm more inclined to believe, as I've done so personally and not been pulled over), you actually have a valid defense. § 541.201. VEHICLES. In this subtitle:                        (1) " Authorized emergency vehicle " means:                           (A) a fire department or police vehicle;                           ( a public or private ambulance operated by a person who has been issued a license by the Texas Department of Health;          ©Â a municipal department or public service corporation emergency vehicle that has been designated or authorized by the governing body of a municipality;          (D) a private vehicle of a volunteer firefighter or a certified emergency medical services employee or volunteer when responding to a fire alarm or medical emergency;          (E) an industrial emergency response vehicle, including an industrial ambulance, when responding to an emergency, but only if the vehicle is operated in compliance with criteria in effect September 1, 1989, and established by the predecessor of the Texas Industrial Emergency Services Board of the State Firemen's and Fire Marshals' Association of Texas; or          (F) a vehicle of a blood bank or tissue bank, accredited or approved under the laws of this state or the United States, when making emergency deliveries of blood, drugs, medicines, or organs. § 545.365. SPEED LIMIT EXCEPTION FOR EMERGENCIES; MUNICIPAL REGULATION. (a) The regulation of the speed of a vehicle under this subchapter does not apply to:       (1) an authorized emergency vehicle responding to a call;               (2) a police patrol; or       (3) a physician or ambulance responding to an emergency call.          ( A municipality by ordinance may regulate the speed of:                (1) an ambulance;       (2) an emergency medical services vehicle; or       (3) an authorized vehicle operated by a blood or tissue bank.       Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.001. PERMISSIBLE CONDUCT. In operating an authorized emergency vehicle the operator may:       (1) park or stand, irrespective of another provision of this subtitle;        (2) proceed past a red or stop signal or stop sign, after slowing as necessary for safe operation;       (3) exceed a maximum speed limit, except as provided by an ordinance adopted under Section 545.365, as long as the operator does not endanger life or property; and       (4) disregard a regulation governing the direction of movement or turning in specified directions. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995.  § 546.002. WHEN CONDUCT PERMISSIBLE. (a) In this section, " police escort " means facilitating the movement of a funeral, oversized or hazardous load, or other traffic disruption for public safety purposes by a peace officer described by Articles 2.12(1)-(4), (8), and (22), Code of Criminal Procedure.    ( Section 546.001 applies only when the operator is:                  (1) responding to an emergency call;       (2) pursuing an actual or suspected violator of the law;               (3) responding to but not returning from a fire alarm;                 (4) directing or diverting traffic for public safety purposes; or          (5) conducting a police escort. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Amended by Acts 2003, 78th Leg., ch. 66, § 1, eff. May 16, 2003; Acts 2005, 79th Leg., ch. 834, § 1, eff. June 17, 2005. § 546.003. AUDIBLE OR VISUAL SIGNALS REQUIRED. Except as provided by Section 546.004, the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle engaging in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 shall use, at the discretion of the operator in accordance with policies of the department or the local government that employs the operator, audible or visual signals that meet the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.004. EXCEPTIONS TO SIGNAL REQUIREMENT. (a) A volunteer fire fighter who operates a private vehicle as an authorized emergency vehicle may engage in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 only when the fire fighter is using visual signals meeting the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702.    ( An authorized emergency vehicle that is operated as a police vehicle is not required to be equipped with or display a red light visible from the front of the vehicle.    ©Â A police officer may operate an authorized emergency vehicle for a law enforcement purpose without using the audible or visual signals required by Section 546.003 if the officer is:       (1) responding to an emergency call or pursuing a suspected violator of the law with probable cause to believe that:          (A) knowledge of the presence of the officer will cause the suspect to:             (i) destroy or lose evidence of a suspected felony;                       (ii) end a suspected continuing felony before the officer has obtained sufficient evidence to establish grounds for arrest; or             (iii) evade apprehension or identification of the suspect or the suspect's vehicle; or          ( because of traffic conditions on a multilaned roadway, vehicles moving in response to the audible or visual signals may:             (i) increase the potential for a collision; or             (ii) unreasonably extend the duration of the pursuit; or       (2) complying with a written regulation relating to the use of audible or visible signals adopted by the local government that employs the officer or by the department. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.005. DUTY OF CARE. This chapter does not relieve the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle from:       (1) the duty to operate the vehicle with appropriate regard for the safety of all persons; or       (2) the consequences of reckless disregard for the safety of others.   Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.021. MUTUAL AID ORGANIZATIONS. (a) Two or more businesses whose activities require the maintenance of fire-fighting equipment may form a mutual aid organization in which the member businesses agree to assist each other during an emergency by supplying fire-fighting equipment or services.    ( The presiding officer or director of an organization formed under this section shall deliver a list to the county fire marshal, or to the commissioners court of a county if the county does not have a fire marshal, in each county in which a member business is located. The list must contain the name of the registered owner and license plate number of each motor vehicle that each member intends to use in supplying fire-fighting equipment or services.    ©Â If the county fire marshal or commissioners court determines that the operation of the vehicles on the list is in the public interest and not a threat to public safety, the marshal or court shall approve the list.    (d) On approval of the list by the county fire marshal or commissioners court, a person operating a listed motor vehicle in response to a call for emergency fire-fighting assistance from a member has the rights and restrictions placed by this subtitle on the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle.    (e) A county is not liable for damage to a person or property caused by a person approved by the county under this section to operate a motor vehicle for emergency fire-fighting assistance. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995.   Houston Code of Ordinances Regarding Ambulances: Sec. 4-1. - Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: (1) Ambulance. A motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of the transportation of sick or injured persons. (2) Ambulance service. A trip made by an ambulance to transport a sick or injured person from place to place under other than emergency circumstances. (3) Ambulance operator. The person holding a city ambulance permit. (4) Department. The department of health. (5) Direct call. A request for ambulance service made by telephone or other means directly to an ambulance operator, his agents or employees. (6) Driver's permit. A city emergency ambulance driver's permit. (7) Emergency ambulance. Any motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of transporting sick or injured persons under emergency circumstances, and the rendering of first aid or the performance of rescue work, or both, under such circumstances. (8) Emergency circumstances. The existence of circumstances in which the element of time in expeditiously transporting a sick or injured person for medical or surgical treatment is essential to the health or life of such person, and in which rescue operations or competent first aid or both at the place of emergency may be essential to the health or life of such person. (9) Emergency ambulance service. A trip made by an emergency ambulance under emergency circumstances to the place of emergency, performance of any necessary rescue operations, rendering of any necessary first aid assistance and the trip to the hospital or other place for medical attention. An ambulance is being operated in emergency ambulance service if all or any part of the above described trip to the place of emergency and any subsequent trip to the hospital is made on the streets within the corporate limits of the city. An emergency ambulance shall be considered to be rendering emergency ambulance service when it is responding to a call for emergency assistance even though, upon arrival at the place of emergency, it is found that the call was falsely made or that no further emergency ambulance assistance is required or when it is responding to a call for routine ambulance service and during such trip emergency circumstances develop. (Code 1968, § 5-1; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 1, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-2. - Ambulance advisory committee. An ambulance advisory committee is hereby created, to consist of the director of the health department, or in his absence a representative appointed by the director; the chief of the fire department, or in his absence a representative appointed by him; and a third member to be selected by the County Medical Society, or in his absence, an alternate member selected by such society. It shall be the duty of such committee to recommend to the city council, specifications for construction, equipment and numbers of emergency ambulances to be purchased by the city (which specifications shall include the essential equipment referred to in section 4-6 below). The committee shall meet at least two times per year. The committee shall submit to the city council from time to time, its recommendations as to new specifications for emergency ambulances and its recommendations as to revisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-2; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 19, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-3. - City emergency ambulance driver's permit. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person other than a member of the fire department assigned to drive a fire department ambulance to operate or drive an emergency ambulance upon the public streets of the city unless the driver thereof shall first have obtained a city emergency ambulance driver's permit. ( An application for such permit shall be submitted to the health officer upon a form or forms to be provided by him. Such application must be signed and sworn to before a notary public. The applicant shall have the following qualifications: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The applicant must be the holder of a Class C Texas driver license. © The health officer shall investigate the application and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the issuance of an emergency ambulance driver's permit. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such a permit, and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (d) A permit issued under this section shall be valid for two years from the date of issuance. (e) The fee for a permit required by this section shall be $100.00, payable at the time the application for said permit is submitted to the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-3; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 2, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 1, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 1, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 1, 12-5-78; Ord. No. 82-1109, § 1, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, §§ 1, 2, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-4. - Personnel required during operation of emergency ambulances; emergency ambulance technician certificate of proficiency. (a) It shall be unlawful to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven an emergency ambulance on a public street of the city when furnishing emergency ambulance service, including emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, unless there is aboard such emergency ambulance on each trip at least two persons, one of whom is the holder of a valid certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician issued by the health officer. The holder of such certificate must be the person attending the patient while such patient is being transported. ( Application for a certificate of proficiency as an emergency ambulance technician shall be made to the health officer on forms to be furnished by him, and shall be signed and sworn to before a notary public. © Qualifications for a certificate of proficiency shall be as follows: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The health officer shall establish standards of proficiency and training necessary for attainment in order for such person to qualify for a certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician. Such standards shall be filed with the city secretary and may be changed from time to time by filing such changes with the city secretary. The health officer shall cause regularly scheduled training courses and examinations to be conducted of all applicants for such certificate of proficiency. Such examinations may be oral or written or practical or a combination of such types of examinations, as the health officer determines will best demonstrate proficiency. The health officer shall limit the life of any certificate to not more than one year and shall provide for renewal of such certificate by the applicant's attending refresher courses and taking such renewal examinations as the health officer may prescribe. (d) The health officer shall investigate the application and the grades attained on such examination and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the certificate of proficiency. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such certificate and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (Code 1968, § 5-4; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 3, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 2, 12-5-78) Sec. 4-5. - Structural and licensing requirements. No emergency ambulance shall be operated on the public streets of the city unless it is free of structural defects and unless it has no serious impairment of any safety feature resulting from an accident or otherwise. No emergency ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service unless and until such ambulance has been duly licensed in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S. (Code 1968, § 5-5; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 4, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-6. - Required equipment. No emergency ambulance or transfer ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service unless such ambulance is equipped with the " Essential Equipment for Ambulances, " as set out in the bulletin of the American College of Surgeons, May issue, 1970, pages 7 through 13, a copy of which shall be filed in the office of the city secretary by the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-6; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 5, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-7. - Vehicle inspections. The health officer shall cause all emergency ambulances, including those operated by the fire department, to be inspected before being placed in service and thereafter annually, as well as on a spot inspection basis. In the event an emergency ambulance fails to pass inspection, the health officer shall notify the emergency ambulance operator or the chief of the fire department to correct the defects noted in the inspection and, after such notification, the health officer shall cause such ambulance to be reinspected for compliance. If, upon such reinspection, the defects noted in the original inspection have not been corrected, the vehicle decals shall be removed from the ambulance by the health officer and shall only be replaced upon such ambulance after the defects have been corrected. Inspections provided for herein may also be made by any police officer of the city or any authorized employee of the department of administration and regulatory affairs of the city. (Code 1968, § 5-7; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 6, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 1, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 05-939, § 3, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 9, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08) Sec. 4-8. - Decals and display of name. (a) When an ambulance operator's permit is issued or renewed under this article, the holder of the operator's permit shall present each ambulance that he proposes to operate thereunder to the health officer for inspection pursuant to the standards adopted in section 4-5, and if the operator proposes to use the ambulance in either or both of the instances described in section 4-9((3) or (4), then for additional inspection for compliance with section 4-6. Upon the successful completion of such inspection, the health officer will furnish the permittee two decals for each ambulance which has been inspected and is authorized to be used in service. One such decal shall be affixed to the front windshield at the lower right (passenger side) corner; the other such decal shall be affixed to the rear bumper or to a similar location in a manner as to be readily visible from a following vehicle. The color of such decals shall be changed annually. Additionally, all emergency ambulances shall have the name of the ambulance service prominently displayed on both exterior sides. ( It shall be unlawful to operate an ambulance on the streets of the city without having such decals affixed and, in the case of an emergency ambulance, without having the name of the ambulance service displayed as required by this section. (Code 1968, § 5-8; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 7, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 2, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 2, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 2, 10-23-79) Sec. 4-9. - Persons authorized to engage in emergency ambulance service. (a) The operation of emergency ambulances on the streets of the city for the furnishing of emergency ambulance service is hereby declared to be a governmental function of the city to be performed by the fire department in accordance with the terms of this chapter. It shall be unlawful for any person or persons, other than members of such fire department in its classified civil service, while driving emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, to furnish or to attempt to furnish emergency ambulance service or to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven any ambulance on the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service. ( It is an affirmative defense to prosecution under subsection (a) that: (1) The person operating an ambulance upon responding to a direct call for ambulance service determined that an emergency existed requiring the sick or injured person to be transported with all practical speed for medical treatment and attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency ambulance service; from the fire department dispatcher; (2) That the emergency ambulance service was provided by an ambulance based outside the city when not in use and operated by an ambulance company having an established place of business and permanent address outside the city, provided; a. The sick or injured person was picked up outside the corporate limits of the city and transported to a hospital within the city; and b. The ambulance performing such emergency ambulance service was, at the time, duly licensed and operated in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S.; and c. The driver of such ambulance complied with all speed and other traffic regulations of the city and the state. (3) That the person operating an ambulance within the city was performing a service under contract of maintaining an ambulance at a particular location, or event, for the purpose of transporting sick or injured persons for medical or hospital treatment, and determined that a sick or injured person at such location or event required immediate hospital or medical attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency service from the fire department dispatcher. (4) That the emergency ambulance service was provided at the request of the fire department dispatcher due to unavailability of a city ambulance. In each instance set out in (1) through (4) above, the driver or operator of such ambulance shall prior to commencement of each emergency ambulance run, notify the fire department dispatcher of the conditions requiring the operation of his vehicle in emergency ambulance service, the location from which he is proceeding, and the location to which he is proceeding under emergency ambulance service and obtain permission for such trip from the dispatcher. Each ambulance being operated under paragraphs (1) and (2) above shall comply with the requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances insofar as traffic safety is concerned. Each ambulance being operated under the provisions of paragraphs (3) and (4) above shall comply with all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances of every nature. Upon arriving at his destination, the ambulance driver or ambulance operator will again notify the fire department dispatcher that he has arrived and is no longer in emergency ambulance service. When the driver or operator of an ambulance is responding to a direct call for ambulance service, either under emergency conditions or otherwise, he shall inform the fire department ambulance dispatcher of the location of such call and such information as he may have concerning the circumstances surrounding the request for service, and if the fire department ambulance dispatcher reports that a fire department ambulance is either on route to the same location or has arrived there and instructs such ambulance driver or operator not to respond to such call, it shall be unlawful for such driver or operator to so respond when instructed not to do so by the fire department ambulance dispatcher. (Code 1968, § 5-9; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 8, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 3, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 3, 4-14-71) Sec. 4-10. - General authorization. Nothing herein shall prohibit any person owning an ambulance duly licensed and operated in accordance with article 4590b, V.T.C.S., from operating such ambulance on the public streets for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service only; provided, however, such person shall secure an operator's permit in compliance with the provisions of sections 4-15 and 4-16 hereof and shall cause his ambulance to have been inspected and be in display of a medallion issued in compliance with section 4-8 hereof. The driver of any such ambulance shall comply with all of the traffic laws of the state and ordinances of the city, including this chapter, in furnishing such ambulance service. The operator thereof shall not permit such ambulance to be used for emergency ambulance service unless all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulance service have been complied with. (Code 1968, § 5-10; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 9, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-736, § 4, 4-14-71) Cross reference— Traffic, Ch. 45. Sec. 4-11. - Use of signs or flashing emergency lights. The use of signs or flashing emergency lights on an ambulance upon the public streets of the city shall be unlawful except when furnishing emergency ambulance service in accordance with the terms of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-11; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 10, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-12. - Patient transport status; solicitation of business prohibited. (a) A patient's transport status shall be determined solely on the basis of the medical needs of the patient in accordance with the most current fire department guidelines as approved by the physician medical director. Under no circumstances shall the fact that a person is or appears to be indigent and unable to pay the cost of such service be considered in such determination. ( It shall be unlawful for any person, while operating or accompanying an emergency ambulance on the public streets or easements of the city, to solicit the business of transporting the sick or injured. (Code 1968, § 5-13; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 12, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 2010-525, § 2, 6-30-2010) Sec. 4-13. - Charges. (a) In order to partially defray the costs incurred by the city in providing emergency medical services and ambulance services, the following fees are hereby established to be collected for the provision of emergency ambulance service by the city: (1) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by the hospital from which the transportation originates, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance from one hospital to another hospital; and (2) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by or on behalf of the person served, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance other than from one hospital to another hospital. ( The fee specified above for transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall apply in each instance where a person is transported from one hospital to another hospital, except in those instances in which a person is picked up at a place other than a hospital and during the course of his transportation to the intended destination hospital the ambulance makes an intermediate stop at another hospital for emergency stabilization or other treatment en route. The fee specified above for the transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall in each instance be payable by the hospital from which the transportation of the person originates, and the transportation of the person shall not commence until and unless: (1) The physician in charge of the care of the person furnishes a written statement that the person's condition is suitable for safe transportation by ground ambulance to the intended destination hospital; and (2) The hospital furnishes a physician or other trained and qualified medical staff member who shall ride in the ambulance and assume the responsibility for the care of the person being transported en route; and (3) The administrator of the hospital or another responsible person signs a statement promising on behalf of the hospital to pay for the transportation of the person and furnishes the necessary billing information. © In addition to the base fees imposed under items (1) and (2) of subsection (a), above, the following variable fees shall be imposed, as applicable: (1) For use of oxygen (any quantity) $65.00 (2) For use of an oxygen mask or a nasal canula, or both 15.00 (3) For use of EKG (tracing only) 50.00 (4) For EKG pad(s) (any quantity) 16.89 (5) For IV prep kit(s) (any quantity) 10.00 (6) For IV administration set(s) (any quantity) 25.00 (7) For cervical collar 25.00 (8) For head immobilization 25.00 (9) For D5W (any quantity) 11.00 (10) For Adenosine (Adenocard) per 6 mg 33.25 (11) For Albuterol Sulfate (Proventil) for 0.5% sol. per ml 0.70 (12) For Atropine per 0.3 mg 0.49 (13) For Dextrose 50% 11.39 (14) For epam (Valium) 1.06 (15) For Dopamine (Intropin) per 250 mg 9.26 (16) For Epinephrine 1:1,000 1.09 (17) For Epinephrine 1:10,000 1.09 (18) For Furosemide (Lasix) 1.12 (19) For Lidocaine Drip per 50 cc 2.76 (20) For Lidocaine HCL—2% per 50 cc 2.76 (21) For Naloxone HCO (Narcan) 3.73 (22) For Cordarone IV per 300 mg 150.00 (23) For miscellaneous medical supplies (any amount, type or quantity) 25.00 (24) Actual costs (not subject to the adjustment in (d) below) of medications, equipment and labor to provide other medically necessary services during transport. In lieu of actual computed miles, the fire chief may authorize use of a zone system or other procedure, provided that the mileage charged does not exceed the actual mileage. (d) That the base fee plus the variable fees established in sections (a)(1), (a)(2) and © above shall be automatically increased on the first day of each subsequent fiscal year by a percentage equal to the percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index—All Urban Customers (CPI-U), if any, over the same date of the previous year. If there is a decrease or if there is no increase in any given year, the rates for that year shall remain the same as in the previous year. (e) The fire department shall submit to the tax assessor-collector a record of each instance in which emergency ambulance transportation service is provided. The tax assessor-collector shall be responsible for the billing and collection of the applicable fees. Except for the conditions expressly provided above in the instance of the transportation of a patient from one hospital to another hospital, no provision in this section shall be construed to authorize the fire department, under any circumstances, to refuse emergency ambulance assistance to any person upon the grounds that the person is indigent or unable to pay for the service. (Code 1968, § 5-15; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 14, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-2031, § 1, 11-23-76; Ord. No. 83-1318, § 1, 8-23-83; Ord. No. 86-1616, § 1, 9-10-86; Ord. No. 91-1178, § 1, 8-14-91; Ord. No. 93-918, § 1, 7-28-93; Ord. No. 96-665, § 7, 6-26-96; Ord. No. 97-1003, § 1, 8-20-97; Ord. No. 01-564, § 11, 6-20-01; Ord. No. 02-528, § 14a., 6-19-02; Ord. No. 2010-892, §§ 2—4, 11-17-2010) Sec. 4-14. - Uncollectible transport account. There is hereby created a list of ambulance accounts to be entitled " uncollectible transports. " The tax assessor-collector of the city shall have the power to place ambulance bills on the uncollectible transports list if he determines such ambulance bills to be uncollectible. An " uncollectible transport " shall be defined as any of the following: (1) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient whose name and/or address is unknown, or upon whom there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the patient, or a patient using a false name and/or, address, or a patient who is a minor and whose parents or next of kin are unknown, or there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the parents or next of kin. (2) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient who is in the custody of, or placed under arrest by, a police officer of the city. (3) Emergency ambulance service provided at least six months previously and upon which a diligent collection effort has been made. (Code 1968, § 5-15.1; Ord. No. 74-1778, § 1, 10-8-74) Sec. 4-15. - Ambulance service operator's permit, insurance required. Any person operating an ambulance service upon the streets of the city must secure a permit therefor from the health officer. Such applicant shall provide evidence to the health officer that he has in full force for such calendar year a public liability insurance policy on each ambulance, such insurance policy to be issued by an insurance company which is authorized by law to do business in the state. Such policy shall provide liability insurance in the amount of not less than $50,000.00 for any one accident and not less than $25,000.00 for injury to any one person. Such insurance policy shall not contain a passenger liability exclusion. Each policy shall contain a provision obligating the insurer to give to the health officer written notice of cancellation not less than ten days prior to the date of any cancellation. (Code 1968, § 5-16; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 15, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-235, § 1, 2-11-76) Sec. 4-16. - Fees for operator's permit, decals; term of decals. The fee for the ambulance operator's permit required pursuant to section 4-15 of this Code shall be $1,000.00, and all permits issued under this chapter shall be valid for one year from the date of issuance. Such permits may be renewed after the termination date of the initial permit and during that same year by paying a permit fee of $800.00. The charge for decals required pursuant to section 4-8 of this Code shall be $275.00 per pair of decals for each pair issued, renewed or replaced. Decals expire concurrently with the ambulance operator's permit under which they are issued. Such fees and charges shall be collected by the department of health and human services and transferred to the department of administration and regulatory affairs, together with an accounting of the permits and pairs of decals for which same were collected. (Code 1968, § 5-17; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 16, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 4, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 5, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 76-235, § 2, 2-11-76; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 3, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 82-1107, § 2, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, § 4, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 10, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-17. - Penalty for violations. Whenever in this chapter an act is prohibited or is made or declared to be unlawful or an offense or misdemeanor, or whenever in this chapter the doing of any thing or act is required or the failure to do any thing or act is prohibited, the violation of the provision shall be and constitute a misdemeanor punishable, upon conviction, by a fine of not more than $2,000.00. Each violation shall constitute and be punishable as a separate offense. Prosecution or conviction under this provision is cumulative of and shall never be a bar to any other civil or administrative remedy provided or allowed in this chapter or by law. In addition, the city attorney is hereby authorized to file suit in any court of competent jurisdiction to enjoin any person from violating or causing to be violated any of the provisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-18; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 18, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 92-1449, § 3, 11-4-92; Ord. No. 05-939, § 5, 8-3-05) Charter reference— Penalty for ordinance violation, Art. II, § 12. Cross reference— Assessment of fines against corporations, § 16-76; payment of fines, § 16-78; credit against fines for incarceration, § 35-6 et seq. Sec. 4-18. - Revocation or suspension of permits, licenses and certificates. Any permit, license or certificate issued pursuant to this chapter shall be subject to suspension or revocation upon the finding pursuant to a public hearing conducted by the health officer that the holder of such permit, license or certificate has failed to comply with the applicable provisions of this chapter or that the holder no longer meets the requirements which pertain to the issuance thereof, provided that the holder of such permit, license or certificate shall be given prior notice of the date, time and place of the hearing setting forth the grounds upon which the suspension or revocation is based and shall be afforded an opportunity to appear in person or through counsel to present evidence and to cross examine all witnesses appearing at such hearing. Sec. 4-19. - Disposition of certain fees. All fees collected under sections 4-3 and 4-16 of this Code shall be allocated to the health and human services department to fund the inspection of ambulances and permitting of ambulance operators as required by this chapter. (Ord. No. 05-939, § 6, 8-3-05) Alyssa Woods, NREMT-B CPR Instructor > Yep, you are correct. They speed just because they can. > > Wayne > > > > > > > > Subject: RE: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > To: texasems-l > > Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 10:12 PM > > > > > > > > 16 over running non-emergent I almost have to wonder why your even asking > > > > this question Marcus and what is your companies position on this obvious > > > > violation of the traffic laws? > > > > Jim< > > > > Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > > > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston > > > > PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston > > > > Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The > > > > flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing > > > > vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. > > > > This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 > > > > miles an hour. > > > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the > > > > Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An > > > > EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have > > > > known better. > > > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had > > > > a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not > > > > transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient > > > > was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further > > > > evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in > > > > need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more > > > > about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around > > > > 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. > > > > We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical > > > > center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a > > > > priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a > > > > patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to > > > > transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the > > > > Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and > > > > traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was > > > > traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that > > > > were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol > > > > cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us > > > > alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that > > > > we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of > > > > blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I > > > > advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need > > > > the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights > > > > and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he > > > > asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he > > > > stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting > > > > a citation. " Please sign here. " > > > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it > > > > read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A > > > > CITATION!!!! " > > > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and > > > > will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for > > > > speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you > > > > are not following ALL traffic laws. > > > > Questions: > > > > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > > > > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did > > > > you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > > > Mr. Marcus Finney > > > > mdfinney@... > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 You guys are heading in the wrong direction here. I am a police officer and a paramedic in the D/FW area and here is a bit of an insight for you all. Look up the Texas Transportation Code and you will clearly see what is defined as an emergency and what is an emergency vehicle. I have know of several cases of a " private " non-EMS ambulance being ticketed for speeding. Here in the Dallas area there are MANY so called EMS services but they have no EMS responsibilities. In my honest opinion they put EMS on the side of their units to help promote business. Explaining the patients condition to an officer is pointless. You did all the explaining when you made the statement, " ....I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens " . Just curious but what did the ATTENDING medic say?? ADVICE==Drive the appropriate speed that is warranted to your patients condition. The condition you states does not warrant the speed. JB ________________________________ To: texasems-l Sent: Thu, January 13, 2011 12:15:48 AM Subject: Re: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance Ok... Cute Medic had a conversation with me and gave some insight into this topic. Now, neither of us are lawyers, but... The first thing I'd do is look at your citation. If it cites you for General Speeding, take it to court, because that's an automatic dismissal. You were speeding in an ambulance, and the laws are different. If it cites a specific transportation code, a deeper understanding of the law is warranted. 541.201 is the definition of an Emergency Vehicle. This includes an ambulance operated by someone with a Texas EMS license. 546 says that an ambulance may violate the speed limit, and that you must use a warning sign (lights and sirens), except at the discretion of the officer and in accordance with department policy. So, so long as you were operating within department policy, you should be ok. The exception to this is if the municipality has a law regulating the speed of the ambulances (which is what 545.365 allows for). So, check your citation, and if it gives you a specific law, look up that law. If it doesn't, look up Houston's Code of Ordinances, and see what their laws say about the speed of ambulances. And below are the laws I was talking about, with bold added for emphasis. I didn't read all of the Code of Ordinances, and I would love Gene or Wes' opinion on all of this. Because if I'm reading the Code of Ordinances right, NO ambulance save HFD can operate LS or emergency traffic in Houston unless they get permission from Houston dispatch. That's insane. But if I'm reading it wrong (and you CAN operate LS in Houston when coming from another municipality, which is what I'm more inclined to believe, as I've done so personally and not been pulled over), you actually have a valid defense. § 541.201. VEHICLES. In this subtitle:                        (1) " Authorized emergency vehicle " means:                           (A) a fire department or police vehicle;                           ( a public or private ambulance operated by a person who has been issued a license by the Texas Department of Health;          ©Â a municipal department or public service corporation emergency vehicle that has been designated or authorized by the governing body of a municipality;          (D) a private vehicle of a volunteer firefighter or a certified emergency medical services employee or volunteer when responding to a fire alarm or medical emergency;          (E) an industrial emergency response vehicle, including an industrial ambulance, when responding to an emergency, but only if the vehicle is operated in compliance with criteria in effect September 1, 1989, and established by the predecessor of the Texas Industrial Emergency Services Board of the State Firemen's and Fire Marshals' Association of Texas; or          (F) a vehicle of a blood bank or tissue bank, accredited or approved under the laws of this state or the United States, when making emergency deliveries of blood, drugs, medicines, or organs. § 545.365. SPEED LIMIT EXCEPTION FOR EMERGENCIES; MUNICIPAL REGULATION. (a) The regulation of the speed of a vehicle under this subchapter does not apply to:       (1) an authorized emergency vehicle responding to a call;               (2) a police patrol; or       (3) a physician or ambulance responding to an emergency call.          ( A municipality by ordinance may regulate the speed of:                (1) an ambulance;       (2) an emergency medical services vehicle; or       (3) an authorized vehicle operated by a blood or tissue bank.       Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.001. PERMISSIBLE CONDUCT. In operating an authorized emergency vehicle the operator may:       (1) park or stand, irrespective of another provision of this subtitle;        (2) proceed past a red or stop signal or stop sign, after slowing as necessary for safe operation;       (3) exceed a maximum speed limit, except as provided by an ordinance adopted under Section 545.365, as long as the operator does not endanger life or property; and       (4) disregard a regulation governing the direction of movement or turning in specified directions. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995.  § 546.002. WHEN CONDUCT PERMISSIBLE. (a) In this section, " police escort " means facilitating the movement of a funeral, oversized or hazardous load, or other traffic disruption for public safety purposes by a peace officer described by Articles 2.12(1)-(4), (8), and (22), Code of Criminal Procedure.    ( Section 546.001 applies only when the operator is:                  (1) responding to an emergency call;       (2) pursuing an actual or suspected violator of the law;               (3) responding to but not returning from a fire alarm;                 (4) directing or diverting traffic for public safety purposes; or          (5) conducting a police escort. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Amended by Acts 2003, 78th Leg., ch. 66, § 1, eff. May 16, 2003; Acts 2005, 79th Leg., ch. 834, § 1, eff. June 17, 2005. § 546.003. AUDIBLE OR VISUAL SIGNALS REQUIRED. Except as provided by Section 546.004, the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle engaging in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 shall use, at the discretion of the operator in accordance with policies of the department or the local government that employs the operator, audible or visual signals that meet the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.004. EXCEPTIONS TO SIGNAL REQUIREMENT. (a) A volunteer fire fighter who operates a private vehicle as an authorized emergency vehicle may engage in conduct permitted by Section 546.001 only when the fire fighter is using visual signals meeting the pertinent requirements of Sections 547.305 and 547.702.    ( An authorized emergency vehicle that is operated as a police vehicle is not required to be equipped with or display a red light visible from the front of the vehicle.    ©Â A police officer may operate an authorized emergency vehicle for a law enforcement purpose without using the audible or visual signals required by Section 546.003 if the officer is:       (1) responding to an emergency call or pursuing a suspected violator of the law with probable cause to believe that:          (A) knowledge of the presence of the officer will cause the suspect to:             (i) destroy or lose evidence of a suspected felony;                       (ii) end a suspected continuing felony before the officer has obtained sufficient evidence to establish grounds for arrest; or             (iii) evade apprehension or identification of the suspect or the suspect's vehicle; or          ( because of traffic conditions on a multilaned roadway, vehicles moving in response to the audible or visual signals may:             (i) increase the potential for a collision; or             (ii) unreasonably extend the duration of the pursuit; or       (2) complying with a written regulation relating to the use of audible or visible signals adopted by the local government that employs the officer or by the department. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.005. DUTY OF CARE. This chapter does not relieve the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle from:       (1) the duty to operate the vehicle with appropriate regard for the safety of all persons; or       (2) the consequences of reckless disregard for the safety of others.   Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. § 546.021. MUTUAL AID ORGANIZATIONS. (a) Two or more businesses whose activities require the maintenance of fire-fighting equipment may form a mutual aid organization in which the member businesses agree to assist each other during an emergency by supplying fire-fighting equipment or services.    ( The presiding officer or director of an organization formed under this section shall deliver a list to the county fire marshal, or to the commissioners court of a county if the county does not have a fire marshal, in each county in which a member business is located. The list must contain the name of the registered owner and license plate number of each motor vehicle that each member intends to use in supplying fire-fighting equipment or services.    ©Â If the county fire marshal or commissioners court determines that the operation of the vehicles on the list is in the public interest and not a threat to public safety, the marshal or court shall approve the list.    (d) On approval of the list by the county fire marshal or commissioners court, a person operating a listed motor vehicle in response to a call for emergency fire-fighting assistance from a member has the rights and restrictions placed by this subtitle on the operator of an authorized emergency vehicle.    (e) A county is not liable for damage to a person or property caused by a person approved by the county under this section to operate a motor vehicle for emergency fire-fighting assistance. Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995.   Houston Code of Ordinances Regarding Ambulances: Sec. 4-1. - Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: (1) Ambulance. A motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of the transportation of sick or injured persons. (2) Ambulance service. A trip made by an ambulance to transport a sick or injured person from place to place under other than emergency circumstances. (3) Ambulance operator. The person holding a city ambulance permit. (4) Department. The department of health. (5) Direct call. A request for ambulance service made by telephone or other means directly to an ambulance operator, his agents or employees. (6) Driver's permit. A city emergency ambulance driver's permit. (7) Emergency ambulance. Any motor vehicle used, designed or redesigned, and equipped for the primary purpose of transporting sick or injured persons under emergency circumstances, and the rendering of first aid or the performance of rescue work, or both, under such circumstances. (8) Emergency circumstances. The existence of circumstances in which the element of time in expeditiously transporting a sick or injured person for medical or surgical treatment is essential to the health or life of such person, and in which rescue operations or competent first aid or both at the place of emergency may be essential to the health or life of such person. (9) Emergency ambulance service. A trip made by an emergency ambulance under emergency circumstances to the place of emergency, performance of any necessary rescue operations, rendering of any necessary first aid assistance and the trip to the hospital or other place for medical attention. An ambulance is being operated in emergency ambulance service if all or any part of the above described trip to the place of emergency and any subsequent trip to the hospital is made on the streets within the corporate limits of the city. An emergency ambulance shall be considered to be rendering emergency ambulance service when it is responding to a call for emergency assistance even though, upon arrival at the place of emergency, it is found that the call was falsely made or that no further emergency ambulance assistance is required or when it is responding to a call for routine ambulance service and during such trip emergency circumstances develop. (Code 1968, § 5-1; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 1, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-2. - Ambulance advisory committee. An ambulance advisory committee is hereby created, to consist of the director of the health department, or in his absence a representative appointed by the director; the chief of the fire department, or in his absence a representative appointed by him; and a third member to be selected by the County Medical Society, or in his absence, an alternate member selected by such society. It shall be the duty of such committee to recommend to the city council, specifications for construction, equipment and numbers of emergency ambulances to be purchased by the city (which specifications shall include the essential equipment referred to in section 4-6 below). The committee shall meet at least two times per year. The committee shall submit to the city council from time to time, its recommendations as to new specifications for emergency ambulances and its recommendations as to revisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-2; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 19, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-3. - City emergency ambulance driver's permit. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person other than a member of the fire department assigned to drive a fire department ambulance to operate or drive an emergency ambulance upon the public streets of the city unless the driver thereof shall first have obtained a city emergency ambulance driver's permit. ( An application for such permit shall be submitted to the health officer upon a form or forms to be provided by him. Such application must be signed and sworn to before a notary public. The applicant shall have the following qualifications: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The applicant must be the holder of a Class C Texas driver license. © The health officer shall investigate the application and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the issuance of an emergency ambulance driver's permit. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such a permit, and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (d) A permit issued under this section shall be valid for two years from the date of issuance. (e) The fee for a permit required by this section shall be $100.00, payable at the time the application for said permit is submitted to the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-3; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 2, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 1, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 1, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 1, 12-5-78; Ord. No. 82-1109, § 1, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, §§ 1, 2, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-4. - Personnel required during operation of emergency ambulances; emergency ambulance technician certificate of proficiency. (a) It shall be unlawful to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven an emergency ambulance on a public street of the city when furnishing emergency ambulance service, including emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, unless there is aboard such emergency ambulance on each trip at least two persons, one of whom is the holder of a valid certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician issued by the health officer. The holder of such certificate must be the person attending the patient while such patient is being transported. ( Application for a certificate of proficiency as an emergency ambulance technician shall be made to the health officer on forms to be furnished by him, and shall be signed and sworn to before a notary public. © Qualifications for a certificate of proficiency shall be as follows: (1) The applicant must be 18 years of age or older. (2) The health officer shall establish standards of proficiency and training necessary for attainment in order for such person to qualify for a certificate of proficiency as a qualified emergency ambulance technician. Such standards shall be filed with the city secretary and may be changed from time to time by filing such changes with the city secretary. The health officer shall cause regularly scheduled training courses and examinations to be conducted of all applicants for such certificate of proficiency. Such examinations may be oral or written or practical or a combination of such types of examinations, as the health officer determines will best demonstrate proficiency. The health officer shall limit the life of any certificate to not more than one year and shall provide for renewal of such certificate by the applicant's attending refresher courses and taking such renewal examinations as the health officer may prescribe. (d) The health officer shall investigate the application and the grades attained on such examination and determine whether the applicant meets the qualifications required for the certificate of proficiency. If the applicant is so qualified, the health officer shall issue such certificate and if the applicant is not qualified, the health officer shall notify the applicant by writing to him at the applicant's address as given in the application. (Code 1968, § 5-4; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 3, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 78-2404, § 2, 12-5-78) Sec. 4-5. - Structural and licensing requirements. No emergency ambulance shall be operated on the public streets of the city unless it is free of structural defects and unless it has no serious impairment of any safety feature resulting from an accident or otherwise. No emergency ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service unless and until such ambulance has been duly licensed in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S. (Code 1968, § 5-5; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 4, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-6. - Required equipment. No emergency ambulance or transfer ambulance shall be operated upon the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service unless such ambulance is equipped with the " Essential Equipment for Ambulances, " as set out in the bulletin of the American College of Surgeons, May issue, 1970, pages 7 through 13, a copy of which shall be filed in the office of the city secretary by the health officer. (Code 1968, § 5-6; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 5, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-7. - Vehicle inspections. The health officer shall cause all emergency ambulances, including those operated by the fire department, to be inspected before being placed in service and thereafter annually, as well as on a spot inspection basis. In the event an emergency ambulance fails to pass inspection, the health officer shall notify the emergency ambulance operator or the chief of the fire department to correct the defects noted in the inspection and, after such notification, the health officer shall cause such ambulance to be reinspected for compliance. If, upon such reinspection, the defects noted in the original inspection have not been corrected, the vehicle decals shall be removed from the ambulance by the health officer and shall only be replaced upon such ambulance after the defects have been corrected. Inspections provided for herein may also be made by any police officer of the city or any authorized employee of the department of administration and regulatory affairs of the city. (Code 1968, § 5-7; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 6, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 1, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 05-939, § 3, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 9, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08) Sec. 4-8. - Decals and display of name. (a) When an ambulance operator's permit is issued or renewed under this article, the holder of the operator's permit shall present each ambulance that he proposes to operate thereunder to the health officer for inspection pursuant to the standards adopted in section 4-5, and if the operator proposes to use the ambulance in either or both of the instances described in section 4-9((3) or (4), then for additional inspection for compliance with section 4-6. Upon the successful completion of such inspection, the health officer will furnish the permittee two decals for each ambulance which has been inspected and is authorized to be used in service. One such decal shall be affixed to the front windshield at the lower right (passenger side) corner; the other such decal shall be affixed to the rear bumper or to a similar location in a manner as to be readily visible from a following vehicle. The color of such decals shall be changed annually. Additionally, all emergency ambulances shall have the name of the ambulance service prominently displayed on both exterior sides. ( It shall be unlawful to operate an ambulance on the streets of the city without having such decals affixed and, in the case of an emergency ambulance, without having the name of the ambulance service displayed as required by this section. (Code 1968, § 5-8; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 7, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 2, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 2, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 2, 10-23-79) Sec. 4-9. - Persons authorized to engage in emergency ambulance service. (a) The operation of emergency ambulances on the streets of the city for the furnishing of emergency ambulance service is hereby declared to be a governmental function of the city to be performed by the fire department in accordance with the terms of this chapter. It shall be unlawful for any person or persons, other than members of such fire department in its classified civil service, while driving emergency ambulances operated by the fire department, to furnish or to attempt to furnish emergency ambulance service or to operate or drive or cause to be operated or driven any ambulance on the streets of the city for the purpose of furnishing emergency ambulance service. ( It is an affirmative defense to prosecution under subsection (a) that: (1) The person operating an ambulance upon responding to a direct call for ambulance service determined that an emergency existed requiring the sick or injured person to be transported with all practical speed for medical treatment and attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency ambulance service; from the fire department dispatcher; (2) That the emergency ambulance service was provided by an ambulance based outside the city when not in use and operated by an ambulance company having an established place of business and permanent address outside the city, provided; a. The sick or injured person was picked up outside the corporate limits of the city and transported to a hospital within the city; and b. The ambulance performing such emergency ambulance service was, at the time, duly licensed and operated in accordance with Article 4590b, V.T.C.S.; and c. The driver of such ambulance complied with all speed and other traffic regulations of the city and the state. (3) That the person operating an ambulance within the city was performing a service under contract of maintaining an ambulance at a particular location, or event, for the purpose of transporting sick or injured persons for medical or hospital treatment, and determined that a sick or injured person at such location or event required immediate hospital or medical attention and obtained permission to operate such ambulance in emergency service from the fire department dispatcher. (4) That the emergency ambulance service was provided at the request of the fire department dispatcher due to unavailability of a city ambulance. In each instance set out in (1) through (4) above, the driver or operator of such ambulance shall prior to commencement of each emergency ambulance run, notify the fire department dispatcher of the conditions requiring the operation of his vehicle in emergency ambulance service, the location from which he is proceeding, and the location to which he is proceeding under emergency ambulance service and obtain permission for such trip from the dispatcher. Each ambulance being operated under paragraphs (1) and (2) above shall comply with the requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances insofar as traffic safety is concerned. Each ambulance being operated under the provisions of paragraphs (3) and (4) above shall comply with all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulances of every nature. Upon arriving at his destination, the ambulance driver or ambulance operator will again notify the fire department dispatcher that he has arrived and is no longer in emergency ambulance service. When the driver or operator of an ambulance is responding to a direct call for ambulance service, either under emergency conditions or otherwise, he shall inform the fire department ambulance dispatcher of the location of such call and such information as he may have concerning the circumstances surrounding the request for service, and if the fire department ambulance dispatcher reports that a fire department ambulance is either on route to the same location or has arrived there and instructs such ambulance driver or operator not to respond to such call, it shall be unlawful for such driver or operator to so respond when instructed not to do so by the fire department ambulance dispatcher. (Code 1968, § 5-9; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 8, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 3, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 3, 4-14-71) Sec. 4-10. - General authorization. Nothing herein shall prohibit any person owning an ambulance duly licensed and operated in accordance with article 4590b, V.T.C.S., from operating such ambulance on the public streets for the purpose of furnishing ambulance service only; provided, however, such person shall secure an operator's permit in compliance with the provisions of sections 4-15 and 4-16 hereof and shall cause his ambulance to have been inspected and be in display of a medallion issued in compliance with section 4-8 hereof. The driver of any such ambulance shall comply with all of the traffic laws of the state and ordinances of the city, including this chapter, in furnishing such ambulance service. The operator thereof shall not permit such ambulance to be used for emergency ambulance service unless all requirements of this chapter regarding emergency ambulance service have been complied with. (Code 1968, § 5-10; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 9, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-736, § 4, 4-14-71) Cross reference— Traffic, Ch. 45. Sec. 4-11. - Use of signs or flashing emergency lights. The use of signs or flashing emergency lights on an ambulance upon the public streets of the city shall be unlawful except when furnishing emergency ambulance service in accordance with the terms of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-11; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 10, 9-16-70) Sec. 4-12. - Patient transport status; solicitation of business prohibited. (a) A patient's transport status shall be determined solely on the basis of the medical needs of the patient in accordance with the most current fire department guidelines as approved by the physician medical director. Under no circumstances shall the fact that a person is or appears to be indigent and unable to pay the cost of such service be considered in such determination. ( It shall be unlawful for any person, while operating or accompanying an emergency ambulance on the public streets or easements of the city, to solicit the business of transporting the sick or injured. (Code 1968, § 5-13; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 12, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 2010-525, § 2, 6-30-2010) Sec. 4-13. - Charges. (a) In order to partially defray the costs incurred by the city in providing emergency medical services and ambulance services, the following fees are hereby established to be collected for the provision of emergency ambulance service by the city: (1) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by the hospital from which the transportation originates, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance from one hospital to another hospital; and (2) A base fee of $1,000.00, plus the variable fees established in subsection ©, below, payable by or on behalf of the person served, for the transportation of a person by fire department ambulance other than from one hospital to another hospital. ( The fee specified above for transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall apply in each instance where a person is transported from one hospital to another hospital, except in those instances in which a person is picked up at a place other than a hospital and during the course of his transportation to the intended destination hospital the ambulance makes an intermediate stop at another hospital for emergency stabilization or other treatment en route. The fee specified above for the transportation of a person from one hospital to another hospital shall in each instance be payable by the hospital from which the transportation of the person originates, and the transportation of the person shall not commence until and unless: (1) The physician in charge of the care of the person furnishes a written statement that the person's condition is suitable for safe transportation by ground ambulance to the intended destination hospital; and (2) The hospital furnishes a physician or other trained and qualified medical staff member who shall ride in the ambulance and assume the responsibility for the care of the person being transported en route; and (3) The administrator of the hospital or another responsible person signs a statement promising on behalf of the hospital to pay for the transportation of the person and furnishes the necessary billing information. © In addition to the base fees imposed under items (1) and (2) of subsection (a), above, the following variable fees shall be imposed, as applicable: (1) For use of oxygen (any quantity) $65.00 (2) For use of an oxygen mask or a nasal canula, or both 15.00 (3) For use of EKG (tracing only) 50.00 (4) For EKG pad(s) (any quantity) 16.89 (5) For IV prep kit(s) (any quantity) 10.00 (6) For IV administration set(s) (any quantity) 25.00 (7) For cervical collar 25.00 (8) For head immobilization 25.00 (9) For D5W (any quantity) 11.00 (10) For Adenosine (Adenocard) per 6 mg 33.25 (11) For Albuterol Sulfate (Proventil) for 0.5% sol. per ml 0.70 (12) For Atropine per 0.3 mg 0.49 (13) For Dextrose 50% 11.39 (14) For epam (Valium) 1.06 (15) For Dopamine (Intropin) per 250 mg 9.26 (16) For Epinephrine 1:1,000 1.09 (17) For Epinephrine 1:10,000 1.09 (18) For Furosemide (Lasix) 1.12 (19) For Lidocaine Drip per 50 cc 2.76 (20) For Lidocaine HCL—2% per 50 cc 2.76 (21) For Naloxone HCO (Narcan) 3.73 (22) For Cordarone IV per 300 mg 150.00 (23) For miscellaneous medical supplies (any amount, type or quantity) 25.00 (24) Actual costs (not subject to the adjustment in (d) below) of medications, equipment and labor to provide other medically necessary services during transport. In lieu of actual computed miles, the fire chief may authorize use of a zone system or other procedure, provided that the mileage charged does not exceed the actual mileage. (d) That the base fee plus the variable fees established in sections (a)(1), (a)(2) and © above shall be automatically increased on the first day of each subsequent fiscal year by a percentage equal to the percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index—All Urban Customers (CPI-U), if any, over the same date of the previous year. If there is a decrease or if there is no increase in any given year, the rates for that year shall remain the same as in the previous year. (e) The fire department shall submit to the tax assessor-collector a record of each instance in which emergency ambulance transportation service is provided. The tax assessor-collector shall be responsible for the billing and collection of the applicable fees. Except for the conditions expressly provided above in the instance of the transportation of a patient from one hospital to another hospital, no provision in this section shall be construed to authorize the fire department, under any circumstances, to refuse emergency ambulance assistance to any person upon the grounds that the person is indigent or unable to pay for the service. (Code 1968, § 5-15; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 14, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-2031, § 1, 11-23-76; Ord. No. 83-1318, § 1, 8-23-83; Ord. No. 86-1616, § 1, 9-10-86; Ord. No. 91-1178, § 1, 8-14-91; Ord. No. 93-918, § 1, 7-28-93; Ord. No. 96-665, § 7, 6-26-96; Ord. No. 97-1003, § 1, 8-20-97; Ord. No. 01-564, § 11, 6-20-01; Ord. No. 02-528, § 14a., 6-19-02; Ord. No. 2010-892, §§ 2—4, 11-17-2010) Sec. 4-14. - Uncollectible transport account. There is hereby created a list of ambulance accounts to be entitled " uncollectible transports. " The tax assessor-collector of the city shall have the power to place ambulance bills on the uncollectible transports list if he determines such ambulance bills to be uncollectible. An " uncollectible transport " shall be defined as any of the following: (1) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient whose name and/or address is unknown, or upon whom there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the patient, or a patient using a false name and/or, address, or a patient who is a minor and whose parents or next of kin are unknown, or there is otherwise insufficient information to locate the parents or next of kin. (2) Emergency ambulance service provided a patient who is in the custody of, or placed under arrest by, a police officer of the city. (3) Emergency ambulance service provided at least six months previously and upon which a diligent collection effort has been made. (Code 1968, § 5-15.1; Ord. No. 74-1778, § 1, 10-8-74) Sec. 4-15. - Ambulance service operator's permit, insurance required. Any person operating an ambulance service upon the streets of the city must secure a permit therefor from the health officer. Such applicant shall provide evidence to the health officer that he has in full force for such calendar year a public liability insurance policy on each ambulance, such insurance policy to be issued by an insurance company which is authorized by law to do business in the state. Such policy shall provide liability insurance in the amount of not less than $50,000.00 for any one accident and not less than $25,000.00 for injury to any one person. Such insurance policy shall not contain a passenger liability exclusion. Each policy shall contain a provision obligating the insurer to give to the health officer written notice of cancellation not less than ten days prior to the date of any cancellation. (Code 1968, § 5-16; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 15, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 76-235, § 1, 2-11-76) Sec. 4-16. - Fees for operator's permit, decals; term of decals. The fee for the ambulance operator's permit required pursuant to section 4-15 of this Code shall be $1,000.00, and all permits issued under this chapter shall be valid for one year from the date of issuance. Such permits may be renewed after the termination date of the initial permit and during that same year by paying a permit fee of $800.00. The charge for decals required pursuant to section 4-8 of this Code shall be $275.00 per pair of decals for each pair issued, renewed or replaced. Decals expire concurrently with the ambulance operator's permit under which they are issued. Such fees and charges shall be collected by the department of health and human services and transferred to the department of administration and regulatory affairs, together with an accounting of the permits and pairs of decals for which same were collected. (Code 1968, § 5-17; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 16, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 71-698, § 4, 4-7-71; Ord. No. 71-736, § 5, 4-14-71; Ord. No. 76-235, § 2, 2-11-76; Ord. No. 79-1817, § 3, 10-23-79; Ord. No. 82-1107, § 2, 7-13-82; Ord. No. 05-939, § 4, 8-3-05; Ord. No. 08-52, § 10, 1-16-08, eff. 1-26-08; Ord. No. 2010-1016, § 2, 12-8-2010, eff. 12-31-2010) Sec. 4-17. - Penalty for violations. Whenever in this chapter an act is prohibited or is made or declared to be unlawful or an offense or misdemeanor, or whenever in this chapter the doing of any thing or act is required or the failure to do any thing or act is prohibited, the violation of the provision shall be and constitute a misdemeanor punishable, upon conviction, by a fine of not more than $2,000.00. Each violation shall constitute and be punishable as a separate offense. Prosecution or conviction under this provision is cumulative of and shall never be a bar to any other civil or administrative remedy provided or allowed in this chapter or by law. In addition, the city attorney is hereby authorized to file suit in any court of competent jurisdiction to enjoin any person from violating or causing to be violated any of the provisions of this chapter. (Code 1968, § 5-18; Ord. No. 70-1518, § 18, 9-16-70; Ord. No. 92-1449, § 3, 11-4-92; Ord. No. 05-939, § 5, 8-3-05) Charter reference— Penalty for ordinance violation, Art. II, § 12. Cross reference— Assessment of fines against corporations, § 16-76; payment of fines, § 16-78; credit against fines for incarceration, § 35-6 et seq. Sec. 4-18. - Revocation or suspension of permits, licenses and certificates. Any permit, license or certificate issued pursuant to this chapter shall be subject to suspension or revocation upon the finding pursuant to a public hearing conducted by the health officer that the holder of such permit, license or certificate has failed to comply with the applicable provisions of this chapter or that the holder no longer meets the requirements which pertain to the issuance thereof, provided that the holder of such permit, license or certificate shall be given prior notice of the date, time and place of the hearing setting forth the grounds upon which the suspension or revocation is based and shall be afforded an opportunity to appear in person or through counsel to present evidence and to cross examine all witnesses appearing at such hearing. Sec. 4-19. - Disposition of certain fees. All fees collected under sections 4-3 and 4-16 of this Code shall be allocated to the health and human services department to fund the inspection of ambulances and permitting of ambulance operators as required by this chapter. (Ord. No. 05-939, § 6, 8-3-05) Alyssa Woods, NREMT-B CPR Instructor > Yep, you are correct. They speed just because they can. > > Wayne > > > > > > > > Subject: RE: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > To: texasems-l > > Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 10:12 PM > > > > > > > > 16 over running non-emergent I almost have to wonder why your even asking > > > > this question Marcus and what is your companies position on this obvious > > > > violation of the traffic laws? > > > > Jim< > > > > Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance > > > > I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston > > > > PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston > > > > Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The > > > > flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing > > > > vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. > > > > This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 > > > > miles an hour. > > > > I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the > > > > Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center. An > > > > EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have > > > > known better. > > > > Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had > > > > a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not > > > > transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient > > > > was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further > > > > evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in > > > > need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more > > > > about that later). The patient started with a blood pressure around > > > > 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120's, obvious signs of compensating shock. > > > > We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical > > > > center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a > > > > priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a > > > > patient priority traffic and the patient's history of anxiety; I chose to > > > > transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the > > > > Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and > > > > traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was > > > > traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that > > > > were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol > > > > cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us > > > > alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. > > > > He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that > > > > we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of > > > > blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I > > > > advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need > > > > the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights > > > > and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient's anxiety, he > > > > asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he > > > > stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting > > > > a citation. " Please sign here. " > > > > I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it > > > > read " REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A > > > > CITATION!!!! " > > > > I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and > > > > will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for > > > > speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you > > > > are not following ALL traffic laws. > > > > Questions: > > > > 1. Has anyone else had this happen? > > > > 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did > > > > you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? > > > > Mr. Marcus Finney > > > > mdfinney@... > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 Ok Heres my two cents. 1. This officer should have the presence of mind to have ,after the primary stop, to follow the Ambulance to the Receiving Hospital. Allowed the crew to drop the Pt off. Then Issued the citation. 2. Correct me if I am wrong, unless running EMERGENT, all traffic laws should be obeyed. And 3, Remember not all cops like EMS folks, but they sure want us to provide them with goodies, gloves and hand gel. Subject: Re: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance To: texasems-l Date: Thursday, January 13, 2011, 2:55 AM  What really grinds my gears about this is, well professional courtesy..... Would that cop have pulled you over and given you a ticket if your ambulance said HFD, Cypress Creek, or ESD1 on the side? Probably not! Yes you were speeding but it sounds to me you were going with the flow of traffic (and I drive in Houston ALOT) in similar traffic condition as you describe and believe that you were not only With the flow of traffic I would dare to say you were probably being passed by many a car. That being said pay the ticket, it's not worth the fight especially in a time of economic hardship for the city of Houston, to take it in spite look on the bright side he has a huge chip on his shoulder about EMS, but at least your still gonna have health insurance and retirement at the end of your career. (that was meant soley as a Political joke and not to start a new argument, if you don't know what it means you prolly don't live in the Houston area my apologies) -Chris Sorry for the spelling and punctuation this was typed on the tiny keyboard on my iPhone Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 As the wife of a Deputy, my husband has almost been run over by an ambulance Code 3 while setting up a landing zone for them when they chose to ignore the help and travel on without letting them know that they were going on after the ambulance had requesting their help! I know that this is not the norm for most of us on the road, but believe me that Paramedic will not have a second chance to run over him. My husband has been in law enforcement for 22 years. I have been a Paramedic for 17 and in EMS for 21 years. We both know if you chose to speed with or without lights and sirens you are still accountable for your actions - but if you get a judge that is sympathetic, the ticket might be dismissed, so if you feel that it was wrong for him to give you a ticket - fight it. What do you have to lose - the fine would be the same if you pay it or fight it and lose. Subject: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance To: texasems-l Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 9:56 PM I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center.   An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later).  The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120’s, obvious signs of compensating shock.   We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient’s history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient’s anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. “Please sign here.â€Â I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read “REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!!†I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. Questions: 1. Has anyone else had this happen? 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? Mr. Marcus Finney mdfinney@... ------------------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 As the wife of a Deputy, my husband has almost been run over by an ambulance Code 3 while setting up a landing zone for them when they chose to ignore the help and travel on without letting them know that they were going on after the ambulance had requesting their help! I know that this is not the norm for most of us on the road, but believe me that Paramedic will not have a second chance to run over him. My husband has been in law enforcement for 22 years. I have been a Paramedic for 17 and in EMS for 21 years. We both know if you chose to speed with or without lights and sirens you are still accountable for your actions - but if you get a judge that is sympathetic, the ticket might be dismissed, so if you feel that it was wrong for him to give you a ticket - fight it. What do you have to lose - the fine would be the same if you pay it or fight it and lose. Subject: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance To: texasems-l Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 9:56 PM I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center.   An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later).  The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120’s, obvious signs of compensating shock.   We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient’s history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient’s anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. “Please sign here.â€Â I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read “REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!!†I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. Questions: 1. Has anyone else had this happen? 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? Mr. Marcus Finney mdfinney@... ------------------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 As the wife of a Deputy, my husband has almost been run over by an ambulance Code 3 while setting up a landing zone for them when they chose to ignore the help and travel on without letting them know that they were going on after the ambulance had requesting their help! I know that this is not the norm for most of us on the road, but believe me that Paramedic will not have a second chance to run over him. My husband has been in law enforcement for 22 years. I have been a Paramedic for 17 and in EMS for 21 years. We both know if you chose to speed with or without lights and sirens you are still accountable for your actions - but if you get a judge that is sympathetic, the ticket might be dismissed, so if you feel that it was wrong for him to give you a ticket - fight it. What do you have to lose - the fine would be the same if you pay it or fight it and lose. Subject: Given a Speeding Ticket in an Ambulance To: texasems-l Date: Wednesday, January 12, 2011, 9:56 PM I am still dumbfounded over 24 hours after receiving a citation from Houston PD for speeding in an ambulance while transporting a patient to the Houston Medical Center yesterday. I was cited for 76 in a 60. A $245.00 fine. The flow of traffic was pretty much traveling at the same speed, I was passing vehicles on the road and at the same time was was being passed by vehicles. This occurred about 1/2 mile from the speed limit changing from 65 to 60 miles an hour. I am a paramedic with over 16 years experience. 13 years of this in the Gulf Coast Area transporting numerous patients into the medical center.   An EVOC instructor for over 6 years, so before you say it, YES I should have known better. Here is my justification for my actions. The patient I was transporting had a femur fracture from a fall that occurred on 01/10/2011, but was not transported to our local ER for evaluation until 01/11/2011. This patient was then being transferred to a hospital in the Medical Center for further evaluation and treatment. The patient had a low H&H, and therefore was in need of blood products. The patient has a history of HTN and anxiety (more about that later).  The patient started with a blood pressure around 100/60 with a heart rate in the 120’s, obvious signs of compensating shock.   We are transporting from a rural hospital about an hour from the medical center. The patient in my professional opinion meets the criteria for a priority emergency transport. Due to the increased risk of transporting a patient priority traffic and the patient’s history of anxiety; I chose to transport the patient non-priority traffic. While on the highway to the Medical Center the traffic as stated earlier was moving very well and traffic was for the most part light in nature for about 15:30. I was traveling in the left hand lane of the road with a group of vehicles that were all traveling about the same speed. We had just passed 2 other patrol cars that were sitting on the side of the road, but they chose to leave us alone. This officer chose me out of the group to pull over. He asked what is the reason for the excessive speed, and I advised him that we were transporting a patient to the medical center that is in need of blood products. He asked, " oh so you have a patient in the back? " and I advised him that we did. He responded " but they are not bad enough to need the lights and siren? " I advised him that I did not want to use the lights and sirens and before I could explain why, given the patient’s anxiety, he asked for my license and proceeded to his patrol car. Upon returning he stated that being that there is no explanation for the speed, I was getting a citation. “Please sign here.â€Â I can assure you that the look on my face was priceless, non-verbally it read “REALLY? YOU ARE GIVING ME A CITATION....REALLY?.....NO REALLY...A CITATION!!!!†I am just venting, and also putting the word out that obviously you can and will be pulled over and receive a citation in the City of Houston for speeding while transporting a patient to the hospital IN an ambulance if you are not following ALL traffic laws. Questions: 1. Has anyone else had this happen? 2. If so, what did you do about it? Did you go to court and fight, or did you just take it as a lesson learned and pay the fine? Mr. Marcus Finney mdfinney@... ------------------------------------ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 BINGO...My thoughts exactly! ____________________________________________________________ Get Free Email with Video Mail & Video Chat! http://www.juno.com/freeemail?refcd=JUTAGOUT1FREM0210 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 13, 2011 Report Share Posted January 13, 2011 Lights and Siren may not always be " indicated " but there are traffic laws that need to be followed. No excuse! ____________________________________________________________ Obama Urges Homeowners to Refinance If you owe under $729k you probably qualify for Obama's Refi Program http://thirdpartyoffers.juno.com/TGL3131/4d2f0f672b5c1649535st05vuc Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.