Re: Re: Don't Start... don't misparaphrase, or mislead others/ Big picture

[Guest guest]

Dear Antoinette,

This is not about arguing, and we should not be taking quotes out of

context... It's about open, safe, nondominating discussion and sharing.

On balance, Dr NC's book does not recommend 'SCD only' or 'just SCD'...there

are other things she deems necessary for the 'psychology syndrome population'

....that's all I was trying to say... is that we should all read the book and

not give a narrow, misleading view of it, or use it to advance our own agendas.

Of course we need friends at Pecanbread... mothers of recovering children are

often not well received... the support here is comforting.

Agape,

kikijabunce wrote:

Dear and to all, I will for now on give exact pages. So that

I may not be misunderstood or accused of misunderstanding what I

read. This way the books and not me can be argued with. I don't

want confrontation any more. I need you guys and the friends I have

made at Pecan Bread. I am only sharing what our experience,

strength and hope have to share.....we all have a story to tell.

Some of our info can help others. God knows I have been helped by

this serve!

Thanks for letting me know that I need to give pages for now on.

Antoinette

> Dr. Haas, and Elaine...and now Dr. Natasha all say that

> mother nature alone can do this balancing act if we give her a

> chance through JUST this miraculous diet.

>

> Antoinette,

> Please do not misquote or misparaphase, Dr Natasha -

McBride... or mislead others as to what her book says... several of

us have read or are reading.

>

> She advocates SCD, with helpful customization for the

psychological syndrome population.

> She says the diet is most important, but that there are some

supplements that are necessary.

> She does not say 'just' SCD, or SCD 'alone'.

>

> Remember Pecanbread and GAPS were customized our children's

generation...

> Dr. Haas laid the foundation (different world, much less

toxins)... Elaine built on that... Pecanbread and GAPS have taken

into consideration our toxic world (immunizations, pollution,

hormones, antibiotics, pesticides, etc.)

>

> You seem to wave the 'just SCD' banner, and that seems to be

your agenda... and maybe that's all that you and your family

need...

> But some of us have a more complicated picture, and find

supplements, sensory, energy, chiropractic, and medical ( ozone,

homeopathics, HBOT, etc.) treatments helpful.

> We are trying to find out information... don't discourage us or

shut us down as we share and inquire.

> Agape,

>

>

>

> > For information on the Specific Carbohydrate Diet, please read

the

> book _Breaking the Vicious Cycle_ by Elaine Gottschall and read

the

> following websites:

> > http://www.breakingtheviciouscycle.info

> > and

> > http://www.pecanbread.com

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >