Guest guest Posted May 10, 2006 Report Share Posted May 10, 2006 Becky, I hear you. Pecanbread itself is an extention of SCD... there were many things BTVC did not address for the ASD/GAPS population, and pecabread did. For example, the intro diet wasn't Elaine's idea, but she wasn't totally against it... she also didn't highly regard things like organic or range fed... She took Dr. Haas' idea and expanded, but I don't think he suggested Sweet and Low or came up with many of the recipes. She wasn't much concerned with MCS. She grew up in adifferent time, there were many problems she couldn't consider, because they didn't yet exsist. I think it was Pecanbread that came up with nut yogurt... I believe Pecanbread has and will continue to incorporared inovative thinking with regard to making SCD work for even the most sensitive, intolerant, kids. Pecanbread = Innovation/Customization + Out of the box thinking... no eggs, no nuts, no dairy-- I've been on this list for almost nine months, and I've seen Jody and others help even the toughest cases, to make SCD work. Yes, Pecanbread is the originator in PROGRESSIVE, INNOVATION for SCD use... No, Pecanbread is not the problem. Pecanbread is working to sort out the GAPS info to make SCD more useful... Wev'e got good minds and intentions...RECOVERY!!! Just like SCD progression did not stop when Dr. Haas died; SCD progression did not stop when Elaine died... and thank God for that. Let's keep progressing. I believe they would have wanted us to take the foundation/groundwork they laid, and keep going. Agape, i Becky Grant-Widen wrote: A profuse " Thank-You " Jeni Lynn, I was all ready to leave the list, but your post made me change my mind. I agree with every word. We all have different opinions on what is helpful and not helpful based on our experiences with our own kids and what we hear from other parents. Unless a parent on this list is making a suggestion to use something that is SCD ILLEGAL, I think the bullying ought to stop. I don't recall for example, digestive enzymes or chelation, being on the ILLEGAL list, so what's with the contstant harassment of people who use it. Likewise, SCD yogurt is not a REQUIREMENT of the diet last I checked. The drama is getting to be too much, and I am afraid there are several of us who will hesitate to offer a different opinion to avoid the bullying, then others will not benefit from hearing multiple opinions. There seems to be a need for a separate list for those choosing strict SCD as the ONLY intervention and those using strict SCD in ADDITION to other interventions. Which list is Pecanbread? I'm not sure. In my mind, this seems to be the only solution. I for one am tired of the domination on the list all in Elaine's name. I've never met her, but saw her at the Boston DAN conference. I would NEVER profess to know her intentions other than what I've read in the book and have from my conference notes. Becky mom to Noah (6, HFA) and (3, NT) SCD 2 months > > Antionette, > > " kikijabunce " wrote: > > > > AS for you , your tone is rude and bully and not very nice, > > considering that I am only a mother trying to heal my sick > > children. > > > I strongly suggest that you calm down please, and go get the book > > written from Dr. Haas to see what you may be doing wrong. Since it > > is clear that you do not trust Elaine, and her message. > > I find myself somewhat irritated at your response to . Quite > often your posts smack of rudeness and bullying to those of us who > incorporate other biomedical aspects into the healing process (which > is probably most of us). We, too, are only mothers trying to heal our > sick children. > > 's response to you was the first time that I have ever noted such > a " tone " from her, and I am certain that it was done out of sheer > frustration with you. You continue to dominate this board with your > narrow-minded approach to ASD. If SCD were the ONLY way to recover > than we wouldn't see children recovering through other means. > > We all believe in Elaine's message or we wouldn't be here, but she did > not know all the facets of ASD (and she didn't pretend to know all the > facets of ASD). There are other ways to supplement the healing > process of SCD, and it is bothersome that you harrass people that > choose these supplements. > > You claim to be Elaine's messanger and that you know Elaine's way > because of her writings and speaking to those that spoke with her > personally. Yet, we have seen here on this very board that people who > spoke with Elaine disagree with you and even resent that you have > exaggerated their conversations with you. > > It would be helpful for you to understand that the knowledge of ASD is > evolving. We are learning more about it everyday, and new helpful > treatments/supplements are being discovered. Elaine is now dead, but > the research and discoveries for help will continue to be made. SCD > is a big part of this dilemna, but it is not the COMPLETE answer for > the majority of us. What is absolutely frustrating is that she knew > this and readily acknowledged it to those that she personally spoke > with, but you (who never personally spoke to her) deny this. > > I think she would resent you drawing these absolutes for her which she > never intended to make. And I think she would not be pleased that you > have self-proclaimed yourself to be her messanger when you do not > thoroughly know her message. > > I imagine you think that you know everything about Elaine because of > her writings. But her writings did not speak to individual cases. > When you talk with those who spoke with her about their individual > children (as did my close friend who is also no longer active on this > list), Elaine would tell them things like, " Well, these children need > so much help that sometimes you have to break a minor SCD principle in > order for them to receive the benefit of another treatment they need. " > > In closing, I will say that I resent that you are now driving away > people from this list serve that are so helpful and resourceful. My > family and others that have already protested their exit, will suffer > in their absence. And it is not right that we should be deprived of > their insight and experience simply because you cannot control > yourself. > > I agree that this list has taken a wrong turn here with all the > drama. And I would appreciate if you could stop antagonizing list > members here with your bullying so that we can all get back to > learning and helping one another. > > Jeni Lynn > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 10, 2006 Report Share Posted May 10, 2006 Antoinette, I'm not convinced he saw ASD kids at all (especially not the ones after the the mid 70's, then again after the early 90's and since ... Vaccinations, toxins, pesticides, PCBs, boxed foods with perservatives to be rehydrated , partially hydronated oils, etc... just wasn't in play then, to the same extent. You are fortunate to have caught it so early with your little ones. Strict SCD maybe all you need,...at least you have the option of adding later and using complimentary treatments now, like sensory and cranial sacral, etc. Agape, kikijabunce wrote: I hear you , but lets not forget that some autistic kids like my KiKI and my son and many of Dr. Haas's sick kids; that would in to days standards be classified as autistic; healed with little or no intervention but diet. This could be good Hope for those that don't have much money. I agree that this may not be the case for some of us here. So please, people don't twist this message. Other interventions are a God send too. I'm just glad that my family is no longer repeating history by experimenting with other diet plans that did not work for us last year. What a set back and hold up on recovery, that could have been ours sooner if I had been ready for SCD. We are fortunate so far. Nock on wood and hope that we don't need further intervention, but know that we have a home at Pecan Bread if we do. And have used and implimented some of the ideas offered here, that where not from BTVC. Thank you all for helping us and supporting us on our journy with our " fanatical adherance " that Elaine suggested. If this become the case I will have to get a second job. We cna't afford much other than this SCD life style for five. LOL! It alone is soooo expensive. But worth it, thank God. Antoinette (2+ months entire family of five healing on SCD) > > > > > > AS for you , your tone is rude and bully and not very nice, > > > considering that I am only a mother trying to heal my sick > > > children. > > > > > I strongly suggest that you calm down please, and go get the book > > > written from Dr. Haas to see what you may be doing wrong. Since it > > > is clear that you do not trust Elaine, and her message. > > > > I find myself somewhat irritated at your response to . Quite > > often your posts smack of rudeness and bullying to those of us who > > incorporate other biomedical aspects into the healing process (which > > is probably most of us). We, too, are only mothers trying to heal our > > sick children. > > > > 's response to you was the first time that I have ever noted such > > a " tone " from her, and I am certain that it was done out of sheer > > frustration with you. You continue to dominate this board with your > > narrow-minded approach to ASD. If SCD were the ONLY way to recover > > than we wouldn't see children recovering through other means. > > > > We all believe in Elaine's message or we wouldn't be here, but she did > > not know all the facets of ASD (and she didn't pretend to know all the > > facets of ASD). There are other ways to supplement the healing > > process of SCD, and it is bothersome that you harrass people that > > choose these supplements. > > > > You claim to be Elaine's messanger and that you know Elaine's way > > because of her writings and speaking to those that spoke with her > > personally. Yet, we have seen here on this very board that people who > > spoke with Elaine disagree with you and even resent that you have > > exaggerated their conversations with you. > > > > It would be helpful for you to understand that the knowledge of ASD is > > evolving. We are learning more about it everyday, and new helpful > > treatments/supplements are being discovered. Elaine is now dead, but > > the research and discoveries for help will continue to be made. SCD > > is a big part of this dilemna, but it is not the COMPLETE answer for > > the majority of us. What is absolutely frustrating is that she knew > > this and readily acknowledged it to those that she personally spoke > > with, but you (who never personally spoke to her) deny this. > > > > I think she would resent you drawing these absolutes for her which she > > never intended to make. And I think she would not be pleased that you > > have self-proclaimed yourself to be her messanger when you do not > > thoroughly know her message. > > > > I imagine you think that you know everything about Elaine because of > > her writings. But her writings did not speak to individual cases. > > When you talk with those who spoke with her about their individual > > children (as did my close friend who is also no longer active on this > > list), Elaine would tell them things like, " Well, these children need > > so much help that sometimes you have to break a minor SCD principle in > > order for them to receive the benefit of another treatment they need. " > > > > In closing, I will say that I resent that you are now driving away > > people from this list serve that are so helpful and resourceful. My > > family and others that have already protested their exit, will suffer > > in their absence. And it is not right that we should be deprived of > > their insight and experience simply because you cannot control > > yourself. > > > > I agree that this list has taken a wrong turn here with all the > > drama. And I would appreciate if you could stop antagonizing list > > members here with your bullying so that we can all get back to > > learning and helping one another. > > > > Jeni Lynn > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 10, 2006 Report Share Posted May 10, 2006 , This is an interesting point that you make. The food that healed Judy, the quality of it, the trace selenium and other nutrients in the diet, even omega 3's, this diet of conventional food is not the same diet of conventional food we can procure these days. Let's step back into Dr. Haas time. The food was different, its not what I can just go over to the grocery store and pick up anymore! What about the hormones and antiobiotic traces in sick, overworked bees in argentine honey? What about those pesticides that change formulation every few years because of new proven carcinogens? Look at Round-up. For generations people go and buy that familiar brand, but their ingredient formulation changes every 2 or so years when FDA revokes ingredients in it do to carcinogen findings. But yet, who would know this, we keep still going out and buying the brand name. It is not the same product, has changed a zillion times. The herbicide, insecticide and pesticide industry has worked hard to keep the laws where they are, they do not have to list most of their ingredients! So who would know? Our soils are way more depleted than 30-50 years ago even. Our vaccination rates have soared! Even in the last 5 years! The Industrial Revolution has caught up with us, this generation, in a way like no other, childhood cancer is growing fast, autism and related disorders are growing fast, it seems anymore everyone I know is allergic to something...pollen, food, this or that, even people with no diagnosis or special needs. The food available to Elaine while healing her daughter and the food recommended by Dr. Haas in those days, its not the same food. I can barely find whole food that meets the criteria of SCD guidelines in grocery stores. I know some people like you, , have to use mailorder, and I have gone out of my way to pick up my food and have it raised to my specifications from surrounding farms. The quality of our food, the trace nutrients in our food, is not the same as yesteryear. Our basic available whole foods have gone up in toxin content and gone down in nutritional viability. Crops are chosen on larger size, not nutritional density, like many old varieties of tomato, cucumber, squash and apples have. I think your point is interesting. Summer I'm not convinced he saw ASD kids at all (especially not the ones after the the mid 70's, then again after the early 90's and since ... Vaccinations, toxins, pesticides, PCBs, boxed foods with perservatives to be rehydrated , partially hydronated oils, etc... just wasn't in play then, to the same extent. --------------------------------- Talk is cheap. Use Yahoo! Messenger to make PC-to-Phone calls. Great rates starting at 1 & cent;/min. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 10, 2006 Report Share Posted May 10, 2006 Thanks Summer, I want to come live with you :-) LOL You live on a farm?... You raise and grow your own food? You're the woman!!! Agape, Gertrude Snicklegrove wrote: , This is an interesting point that you make. The food that healed Judy, the quality of it, the trace selenium and other nutrients in the diet, even omega 3's, this diet of conventional food is not the same diet of conventional food we can procure these days. Let's step back into Dr. Haas time. The food was different, its not what I can just go over to the grocery store and pick up anymore! What about the hormones and antiobiotic traces in sick, overworked bees in argentine honey? What about those pesticides that change formulation every few years because of new proven carcinogens? Look at Round-up. For generations people go and buy that familiar brand, but their ingredient formulation changes every 2 or so years when FDA revokes ingredients in it do to carcinogen findings. But yet, who would know this, we keep still going out and buying the brand name. It is not the same product, has changed a zillion times. The herbicide, insecticide and pesticide industry has worked hard to keep the laws where they are, they do not have to list most of their ingredients! So who would know? Our soils are way more depleted than 30-50 years ago even. Our vaccination rates have soared! Even in the last 5 years! The Industrial Revolution has caught up with us, this generation, in a way like no other, childhood cancer is growing fast, autism and related disorders are growing fast, it seems anymore everyone I know is allergic to something...pollen, food, this or that, even people with no diagnosis or special needs. The food available to Elaine while healing her daughter and the food recommended by Dr. Haas in those days, its not the same food. I can barely find whole food that meets the criteria of SCD guidelines in grocery stores. I know some people like you, , have to use mailorder, and I have gone out of my way to pick up my food and have it raised to my specifications from surrounding farms. The quality of our food, the trace nutrients in our food, is not the same as yesteryear. Our basic available whole foods have gone up in toxin content and gone down in nutritional viability. Crops are chosen on larger size, not nutritional density, like many old varieties of tomato, cucumber, squash and apples have. I think your point is interesting. Summer I'm not convinced he saw ASD kids at all (especially not the ones after the the mid 70's, then again after the early 90's and since ... Vaccinations, toxins, pesticides, PCBs, boxed foods with perservatives to be rehydrated , partially hydronated oils, etc... just wasn't in play then, to the same extent. --------------------------------- Talk is cheap. Use Yahoo! Messenger to make PC-to-Phone calls. Great rates starting at 1 & cent;/min. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 10, 2006 Report Share Posted May 10, 2006 , LOL No, I do not live on a farm. I wish! I have farms around me though. My garden is very tiny. I get a good crop of tomatoes each year, some peppers and squash and fresh herbs, but that's about it. I am a farmer at heart who is imprisoned in surburbia. But you can come live me anyway! heehee Summer davis wrote: Thanks Summer, I want to come live with you :-) LOL You live on a farm?... You raise and grow your own food? You're the woman!!! Agape, Gertrude Snicklegrove wrote: , This is an interesting point that you make. The food that healed Judy, the quality of it, the trace selenium and other nutrients in the diet, even omega 3's, this diet of conventional food is not the same diet of conventional food we can procure these days. Let's step back into Dr. Haas time. The food was different, its not what I can just go over to the grocery store and pick up anymore! What about the hormones and antiobiotic traces in sick, overworked bees in argentine honey? What about those pesticides that change formulation every few years because of new proven carcinogens? Look at Round-up. For generations people go and buy that familiar brand, but their ingredient formulation changes every 2 or so years when FDA revokes ingredients in it do to carcinogen findings. But yet, who would know this, we keep still going out and buying the brand name. It is not the same product, has changed a zillion times. The herbicide, insecticide and pesticide industry has worked hard to keep the laws where they are, they do not have to list most of their ingredients! So who would know? Our soils are way more depleted than 30-50 years ago even. Our vaccination rates have soared! Even in the last 5 years! The Industrial Revolution has caught up with us, this generation, in a way like no other, childhood cancer is growing fast, autism and related disorders are growing fast, it seems anymore everyone I know is allergic to something...pollen, food, this or that, even people with no diagnosis or special needs. The food available to Elaine while healing her daughter and the food recommended by Dr. Haas in those days, its not the same food. I can barely find whole food that meets the criteria of SCD guidelines in grocery stores. I know some people like you, , have to use mailorder, and I have gone out of my way to pick up my food and have it raised to my specifications from surrounding farms. The quality of our food, the trace nutrients in our food, is not the same as yesteryear. Our basic available whole foods have gone up in toxin content and gone down in nutritional viability. Crops are chosen on larger size, not nutritional density, like many old varieties of tomato, cucumber, squash and apples have. I think your point is interesting. Summer I'm not convinced he saw ASD kids at all (especially not the ones after the the mid 70's, then again after the early 90's and since ... Vaccinations, toxins, pesticides, PCBs, boxed foods with perservatives to be rehydrated , partially hydronated oils, etc... just wasn't in play then, to the same extent. --------------------------------- Talk is cheap. Use Yahoo! Messenger to make PC-to-Phone calls. Great rates starting at 1 & cent;/min. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 10, 2006 Report Share Posted May 10, 2006 Summer, I'm still impressed. Well, maybe a visit anyway:-)... Where are you anyway? I'm in Lubbock Tx. Agape, Gertrude Snicklegrove wrote: , LOL No, I do not live on a farm. I wish! I have farms around me though. My garden is very tiny. I get a good crop of tomatoes each year, some peppers and squash and fresh herbs, but that's about it. I am a farmer at heart who is imprisoned in surburbia. But you can come live me anyway! heehee Summer davis wrote: Thanks Summer, I want to come live with you :-) LOL You live on a farm?... You raise and grow your own food? You're the woman!!! Agape, Gertrude Snicklegrove wrote: , This is an interesting point that you make. The food that healed Judy, the quality of it, the trace selenium and other nutrients in the diet, even omega 3's, this diet of conventional food is not the same diet of conventional food we can procure these days. Let's step back into Dr. Haas time. The food was different, its not what I can just go over to the grocery store and pick up anymore! What about the hormones and antiobiotic traces in sick, overworked bees in argentine honey? What about those pesticides that change formulation every few years because of new proven carcinogens? Look at Round-up. For generations people go and buy that familiar brand, but their ingredient formulation changes every 2 or so years when FDA revokes ingredients in it do to carcinogen findings. But yet, who would know this, we keep still going out and buying the brand name. It is not the same product, has changed a zillion times. The herbicide, insecticide and pesticide industry has worked hard to keep the laws where they are, they do not have to list most of their ingredients! So who would know? Our soils are way more depleted than 30-50 years ago even. Our vaccination rates have soared! Even in the last 5 years! The Industrial Revolution has caught up with us, this generation, in a way like no other, childhood cancer is growing fast, autism and related disorders are growing fast, it seems anymore everyone I know is allergic to something...pollen, food, this or that, even people with no diagnosis or special needs. The food available to Elaine while healing her daughter and the food recommended by Dr. Haas in those days, its not the same food. I can barely find whole food that meets the criteria of SCD guidelines in grocery stores. I know some people like you, , have to use mailorder, and I have gone out of my way to pick up my food and have it raised to my specifications from surrounding farms. The quality of our food, the trace nutrients in our food, is not the same as yesteryear. Our basic available whole foods have gone up in toxin content and gone down in nutritional viability. Crops are chosen on larger size, not nutritional density, like many old varieties of tomato, cucumber, squash and apples have. I think your point is interesting. Summer I'm not convinced he saw ASD kids at all (especially not the ones after the the mid 70's, then again after the early 90's and since ... Vaccinations, toxins, pesticides, PCBs, boxed foods with perservatives to be rehydrated , partially hydronated oils, etc... just wasn't in play then, to the same extent. --------------------------------- Talk is cheap. Use Yahoo! Messenger to make PC-to-Phone calls. Great rates starting at 1 & cent;/min. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.