Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 I think he must be doing some version. When I originally found out that baby had a clubfoot in utero, I did some research and learned a little about the Ponseti method, but didn't go into great detail learning about it. When I spoke with this doc and he explained that there would be a series of castings and a tenotomy, it sounded just like Ponseti to me, so I was happy with the idea, especially since I know someone who's son was treated by him with good results. Now that we're 11 weeks into the treatment, I'm a little upset with myself for not investigating much more thoroughly. I trust this doc and his results thus far have been good, but I'm very concerned about the AFO/KAFO/AKFO use vs the DBB. I intend to call Dr Lemke Monday morning and see her to get her opinion, and also call my current doc to see what he has to say--what explanation he has for the use of AFOs instead of the DBB. I am hoping to have a good comparison at that point and decide whether to continue with the current doc at all, or just move over to Dr Lemke and have her remove the cast and pick up treatment from now on. I'm SOOOOOO FRUSTRATED that I didn't look into things better. We could have been DONE with the casting by now... and for weeks, to boot!! Hindsight's always 20/20, huh? Thanks to all of you for the input. I will be checking into things tomorrow and will post back for everyone's advice and opinions!! Stacee > > > > > > Hi Stacee, good to have you on board. > > > > > > Not sure what I can say about your baby's > > treatment as it doesn't sound like Ponseti > > Method to me. Sounds like he's had quite a few > > casts, probably more than the Ponseti > > Method would have required (average of 5 casts, five > > to seven days between castings). My > > last son was treated by Dr. Ponseti in Iowa - he > > wore casts for 25 days pre-tenotomy, then > > 17 days post-tenotomy (42 days total). He's been > > wearing the FAB since then and has > > completely normal feet. > > > > > > Have you been satisfied with all the results so > > far though? Typically a child doesn't > > need 7 weeks to heal from a tenotomy, only 3, and > > often they out grow that cast and only > > go 2 weeks with excellent results. > > > > > > Are you interested in hearing more about the > > Ponseti Method or seeking a 2nd opinon > > from a P.M. doctor? > > > > > > Typically speaking AFO and AKFO style braces have > > had little success in maintaing the > > club foot correction after the casting phase often > > resulting in relapses, thus you'll notice > > all of us here have babies that wear what is called > > the Foot Abductin Brace (FAB, often > > called a DBB) which is shoes connected to a bar as > > that has been proven to maintain the > > correction as the child grows. > > > > > > Anyway, I won't hound you - but if there is every > > any question regarding your childs > > treatment/progress, etc., please don't hesitate to > > ask and know if he does not respond to > > your current treatment methods, he's young enough to > > back up and start over with the > > Ponseti Method before any surgical cures are > > attempted. Once he's operated on though > > you'll be stuck wtih those results, either good or > > bad (usually bad). > > > > > > If you haven't done so already I urge you to visit > > our Files and Links for lots of really > > great information about CF in general and > > treatments, etc. > > > > > > Good luck, > > > shawnee > > > First time > > posting... > > > > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous > > posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > > My > > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club > > foot and has been sequentially casted > > since > > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles > > tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast > > for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > > AKFO. > > > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was > > never treated the way kids are today. > > He's > > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a > > club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from > > what I have seen on the boards, most of > > the > > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure > > if the treatment post tenotomy is the > > same > > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in > > Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > > into > > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks > > of casting post surgery and he'll be > > in > > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which > > point I'm foggy on the course of > > treatment. > > > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in > > Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > > directly if you see this message! We live in > > Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended > > by a friend who's son was treated > > for > > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in > > and I apologize if I ask questions that > > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 Stacee, Don't beat your self up over this. When my son was born with bilateral club foot we didn't know so it was a huge surprise. The hospital we had him in called the ped. ortho in he explained to us he would be in casts and it was treatable. We didn't know any better we trusted the dr. He put the first set of casts on 20 mins. before we left the hospital, which made for a interesting 45 min. drive home. In the first year he was recasted 4 times, due to relapses. So at this we knew something was not right. As a mother I should have known ealier. That is when I found this board. I relized the treatment of our dr. was not correct. He never over corrected the feet, no tenotomy, and shoes were only set at 35 degrees, not 70. We are lucky enough that we only live an hour and 45 mins. from dr Ponseti himself. We emailed him pictures and he called us back personally and said he would see us as soon as we could get there. So, to make a long story short. We started over at 13.5 months old. He was recasted once again. This time correctly. The shoes now stay on they do not slip at all. We did have some blisters, but those are under control now. He is now 16 months old and walking. I really had my concerns that he would walk funny, but Dr. Ponseti fixed them and they are the most beautiful feet I have ever seen. At least you are doing this now and not 12 months down the road. Good Luck to you and please keep us posted. Tabitha Brittanie 6 years Karter 16 months blcf littleman1013 wrote: I think he must be doing some version. When I originally found out that baby had a clubfoot in utero, I did some research and learned a little about the Ponseti method, but didn't go into great detail learning about it. When I spoke with this doc and he explained that there would be a series of castings and a tenotomy, it sounded just like Ponseti to me, so I was happy with the idea, especially since I know someone who's son was treated by him with good results. Now that we're 11 weeks into the treatment, I'm a little upset with myself for not investigating much more thoroughly. I trust this doc and his results thus far have been good, but I'm very concerned about the AFO/KAFO/AKFO use vs the DBB. I intend to call Dr Lemke Monday morning and see her to get her opinion, and also call my current doc to see what he has to say--what explanation he has for the use of AFOs instead of the DBB. I am hoping to have a good comparison at that point and decide whether to continue with the current doc at all, or just move over to Dr Lemke and have her remove the cast and pick up treatment from now on. I'm SOOOOOO FRUSTRATED that I didn't look into things better. We could have been DONE with the casting by now... and for weeks, to boot!! Hindsight's always 20/20, huh? Thanks to all of you for the input. I will be checking into things tomorrow and will post back for everyone's advice and opinions!! Stacee > > > > > > Hi Stacee, good to have you on board. > > > > > > Not sure what I can say about your baby's > > treatment as it doesn't sound like Ponseti > > Method to me. Sounds like he's had quite a few > > casts, probably more than the Ponseti > > Method would have required (average of 5 casts, five > > to seven days between castings). My > > last son was treated by Dr. Ponseti in Iowa - he > > wore casts for 25 days pre-tenotomy, then > > 17 days post-tenotomy (42 days total). He's been > > wearing the FAB since then and has > > completely normal feet. > > > > > > Have you been satisfied with all the results so > > far though? Typically a child doesn't > > need 7 weeks to heal from a tenotomy, only 3, and > > often they out grow that cast and only > > go 2 weeks with excellent results. > > > > > > Are you interested in hearing more about the > > Ponseti Method or seeking a 2nd opinon > > from a P.M. doctor? > > > > > > Typically speaking AFO and AKFO style braces have > > had little success in maintaing the > > club foot correction after the casting phase often > > resulting in relapses, thus you'll notice > > all of us here have babies that wear what is called > > the Foot Abductin Brace (FAB, often > > called a DBB) which is shoes connected to a bar as > > that has been proven to maintain the > > correction as the child grows. > > > > > > Anyway, I won't hound you - but if there is every > > any question regarding your childs > > treatment/progress, etc., please don't hesitate to > > ask and know if he does not respond to > > your current treatment methods, he's young enough to > > back up and start over with the > > Ponseti Method before any surgical cures are > > attempted. Once he's operated on though > > you'll be stuck wtih those results, either good or > > bad (usually bad). > > > > > > If you haven't done so already I urge you to visit > > our Files and Links for lots of really > > great information about CF in general and > > treatments, etc. > > > > > > Good luck, > > > shawnee > > > First time > > posting... > > > > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous > > posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > > My > > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club > > foot and has been sequentially casted > > since > > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles > > tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast > > for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > > AKFO. > > > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was > > never treated the way kids are today. > > He's > > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a > > club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from > > what I have seen on the boards, most of > > the > > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure > > if the treatment post tenotomy is the > > same > > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in > > Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > > into > > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks > > of casting post surgery and he'll be > > in > > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which > > point I'm foggy on the course of > > treatment. > > > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in > > Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > > directly if you see this message! We live in > > Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended > > by a friend who's son was treated > > for > > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in > > and I apologize if I ask questions that > > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 Stacee, As I am reading your last post, it reminds me of myself a few weeks ago. We did not know about the club foot until my son was born. I did some research and just trusted our ped for referring us to the ortho. At that time I did not know there was a list of dr's certified in the method. We were fine until the orthotist fit us for shoes and the DBB. The first week was horrible and Logan got terrible blisters that turned into bigger soars. We kept going back to the orthotist with little change. Logan's soars got so bad we had to take him out of the shoes for two weeks. It turns out the shoes were outdated and too small and the bar was to short. Our ortho was also giving us advice on how to get Logan back into the shoes that was not part of the Ponseti method at all. That's when I found this board and with the help of everyone's advice, we went to Dr. Herzenberg and Dr. Lamm in MD. They were the ones that alerted us to the fact that the bar was too short. So my soar screaming son became this regular happy baby with his DBB and new shoes. The point of all this is that if you have any doubt at all, see a dr on the list, and one that someone in this group recommends. While our old ortho is a smart dr, he just doesn't do enough club foot. Good Luck, Re: First time posting... I think he must be doing some version. When I originally found out that baby had a clubfoot in utero, I did some research and learned a little about the Ponseti method, but didn't go into great detail learning about it. When I spoke with this doc and he explained that there would be a series of castings and a tenotomy, it sounded just like Ponseti to me, so I was happy with the idea, especially since I know someone who's son was treated by him with good results. Now that we're 11 weeks into the treatment, I'm a little upset with myself for not investigating much more thoroughly. I trust this doc and his results thus far have been good, but I'm very concerned about the AFO/KAFO/AKFO use vs the DBB. I intend to call Dr Lemke Monday morning and see her to get her opinion, and also call my current doc to see what he has to say--what explanation he has for the use of AFOs instead of the DBB. I am hoping to have a good comparison at that point and decide whether to continue with the current doc at all, or just move over to Dr Lemke and have her remove the cast and pick up treatment from now on. I'm SOOOOOO FRUSTRATED that I didn't look into things better. We could have been DONE with the casting by now... and for weeks, to boot!! Hindsight's always 20/20, huh? Thanks to all of you for the input. I will be checking into things tomorrow and will post back for everyone's advice and opinions!! Stacee > > > > > > Hi Stacee, good to have you on board. > > > > > > Not sure what I can say about your baby's > > treatment as it doesn't sound like Ponseti > > Method to me. Sounds like he's had quite a few > > casts, probably more than the Ponseti > > Method would have required (average of 5 casts, five > > to seven days between castings). My > > last son was treated by Dr. Ponseti in Iowa - he > > wore casts for 25 days pre-tenotomy, then > > 17 days post-tenotomy (42 days total). He's been > > wearing the FAB since then and has > > completely normal feet. > > > > > > Have you been satisfied with all the results so > > far though? Typically a child doesn't > > need 7 weeks to heal from a tenotomy, only 3, and > > often they out grow that cast and only > > go 2 weeks with excellent results. > > > > > > Are you interested in hearing more about the > > Ponseti Method or seeking a 2nd opinon > > from a P.M. doctor? > > > > > > Typically speaking AFO and AKFO style braces have > > had little success in maintaing the > > club foot correction after the casting phase often > > resulting in relapses, thus you'll notice > > all of us here have babies that wear what is called > > the Foot Abductin Brace (FAB, often > > called a DBB) which is shoes connected to a bar as > > that has been proven to maintain the > > correction as the child grows. > > > > > > Anyway, I won't hound you - but if there is every > > any question regarding your childs > > treatment/progress, etc., please don't hesitate to > > ask and know if he does not respond to > > your current treatment methods, he's young enough to > > back up and start over with the > > Ponseti Method before any surgical cures are > > attempted. Once he's operated on though > > you'll be stuck wtih those results, either good or > > bad (usually bad). > > > > > > If you haven't done so already I urge you to visit > > our Files and Links for lots of really > > great information about CF in general and > > treatments, etc. > > > > > > Good luck, > > > shawnee > > > First time > > posting... > > > > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous > > posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > > My > > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club > > foot and has been sequentially casted > > since > > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles > > tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast > > for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > > AKFO. > > > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was > > never treated the way kids are today. > > He's > > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a > > club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from > > what I have seen on the boards, most of > > the > > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure > > if the treatment post tenotomy is the > > same > > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in > > Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > > into > > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks > > of casting post surgery and he'll be > > in > > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which > > point I'm foggy on the course of > > treatment. > > > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in > > Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > > directly if you see this message! We live in > > Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended > > by a friend who's son was treated > > for > > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in > > and I apologize if I ask questions that > > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 Hi Stacee, GREAT that you are taking your little guy to Dr. Lemke! You are right! You should have seen much better results with casting and the fact that your doc. uses AFO's...so glad that you are going to see dr. Lemke!! I really think that you are saving your son from some major problems down the road =) I am sure she will have you on the right track in no time! Try to remember that your baby is still so young - you have caught this in plenty of time Stacee!! You will be finished casting and into the FAB in no time now I am sure! It still amazes me, the difference between 'true' Ponseti treatment and non or modified Ponseti treatment! We are just so lucky to have this board (kudos to Teressa =)) to help parents figure out the difference - our kids deserve the best! Make sure you explain the full situation to Dr. Lemke's assistant when you call so that they get you in ASAP. Good Luck and please let us know how it goes. & Grace 16 mos unilateral rcf corrected w/Ponseti method - 4 casts (no tenotomy) FAB 13 hrs > > > > > > > > Hi Stacee, good to have you on board. > > > > > > > > Not sure what I can say about your baby's > > > treatment as it doesn't sound like Ponseti > > > Method to me. Sounds like he's had quite a few > > > casts, probably more than the Ponseti > > > Method would have required (average of 5 casts, five > > > to seven days between castings). My > > > last son was treated by Dr. Ponseti in Iowa - he > > > wore casts for 25 days pre-tenotomy, then > > > 17 days post-tenotomy (42 days total). He's been > > > wearing the FAB since then and has > > > completely normal feet. > > > > > > > > Have you been satisfied with all the results so > > > far though? Typically a child doesn't > > > need 7 weeks to heal from a tenotomy, only 3, and > > > often they out grow that cast and only > > > go 2 weeks with excellent results. > > > > > > > > Are you interested in hearing more about the > > > Ponseti Method or seeking a 2nd opinon > > > from a P.M. doctor? > > > > > > > > Typically speaking AFO and AKFO style braces have > > > had little success in maintaing the > > > club foot correction after the casting phase often > > > resulting in relapses, thus you'll notice > > > all of us here have babies that wear what is called > > > the Foot Abductin Brace (FAB, often > > > called a DBB) which is shoes connected to a bar as > > > that has been proven to maintain the > > > correction as the child grows. > > > > > > > > Anyway, I won't hound you - but if there is every > > > any question regarding your childs > > > treatment/progress, etc., please don't hesitate to > > > ask and know if he does not respond to > > > your current treatment methods, he's young enough to > > > back up and start over with the > > > Ponseti Method before any surgical cures are > > > attempted. Once he's operated on though > > > you'll be stuck wtih those results, either good or > > > bad (usually bad). > > > > > > > > If you haven't done so already I urge you to visit > > > our Files and Links for lots of really > > > great information about CF in general and > > > treatments, etc. > > > > > > > > Good luck, > > > > shawnee > > > > First time > > > posting... > > > > > > > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous > > > posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > > > My > > > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club > > > foot and has been sequentially casted > > > since > > > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles > > > tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast > > > for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > > > AKFO. > > > > > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was > > > never treated the way kids are today. > > > He's > > > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a > > > club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from > > > what I have seen on the boards, most of > > > the > > > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure > > > if the treatment post tenotomy is the > > > same > > > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in > > > Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > > > into > > > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks > > > of casting post surgery and he'll be > > > in > > > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which > > > point I'm foggy on the course of > > > treatment. > > > > > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in > > > Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > > > directly if you see this message! We live in > > > Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended > > > by a friend who's son was treated > > > for > > > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in > > > and I apologize if I ask questions that > > > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 I am reading today this list of " testimonials " from all you momma's lately who have switched to a Ponseti Doctor and my heart is swelling with pride at your courage. It takes a lot to first admit to yourself perhaps you chose poorly to begin with, to admit these things are not right and then to admit them loud and publicly as you change doctors and change the courses of treatments and come here facing others with your story. I just want to hug you all today for being brave and wonderful mothers. s. First time > > posting... > > > > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous > > posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > > My > > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club > > foot and has been sequentially casted > > since > > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles > > tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast > > for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > > AKFO. > > > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was > > never treated the way kids are today. > > He's > > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a > > club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from > > what I have seen on the boards, most of > > the > > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure > > if the treatment post tenotomy is the > > same > > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in > > Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > > into > > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks > > of casting post surgery and he'll be > > in > > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which > > point I'm foggy on the course of > > treatment. > > > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in > > Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > > directly if you see this message! We live in > > Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended > > by a friend who's son was treated > > for > > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in > > and I apologize if I ask questions that > > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 No, don't be hard on yourself Stacee. It's not like babies are born with instructional booklets, nor do their birth defects arrive with one. All of us, we've done the best we could with the information we had at the time. So instead of feeling down that you did not investigate further, pat yourself on the back that you are investigating it further now. You honestly are early enough in to the whole thing to change if you decide to change, and still expect excellent results. Anyway, follow your mommy instinct and don't let any doctor bully your or make you feel inferior to his superior training and intellegence. Many times the situation is that a parent has the time adn resources to investigate treatment options a doctor has not even heard of yet. That is often the case with cf. The Ponseti Method seems too good to be true and lots of doctors just have no faith in it despite 50 years of success. s. First time > > posting... > > > > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous > > posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > > My > > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club > > foot and has been sequentially casted > > since > > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles > > tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast > > for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > > AKFO. > > > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was > > never treated the way kids are today. > > He's > > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a > > club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from > > what I have seen on the boards, most of > > the > > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure > > if the treatment post tenotomy is the > > same > > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in > > Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > > into > > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks > > of casting post surgery and he'll be > > in > > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which > > point I'm foggy on the course of > > treatment. > > > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in > > Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > > directly if you see this message! We live in > > Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended > > by a friend who's son was treated > > for > > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in > > and I apologize if I ask questions that > > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 ee, The testimonials this past week have been very touching. For us we are very greatful to this board and Dr. Ponseti (of course) that we could get our sons feet where they should be. He is walking now and still in DBB 16 hours a day. If our story can help just one family to not have the year of recasting and the hopeless feeling that we felt. I will type it a thousand times. It has been a long 16 months with Karter, but I finally feel like we are on a straight path now thanks to this board and all the wonderful poeple on it. I do not post all that much for I am just now getting the whole cf thing right. Hopefully in a little while I will be the one that posts something that will help someone like all of you have helped us. Good luck to you and your boys. I give your great credit for your strength and only hope that I have that someday. I would like someday, not soon, to have another child and if he or she has cf I am sure that I will think of you and your strength. THANK YOU. Tabitha Brittanie 6 years Karter 16 months blcf number23 wrote: I am reading today this list of " testimonials " from all you momma's lately who have switched to a Ponseti Doctor and my heart is swelling with pride at your courage. It takes a lot to first admit to yourself perhaps you chose poorly to begin with, to admit these things are not right and then to admit them loud and publicly as you change doctors and change the courses of treatments and come here facing others with your story. I just want to hug you all today for being brave and wonderful mothers. s. First time > > posting... > > > > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous > > posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > > My > > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club > > foot and has been sequentially casted > > since > > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles > > tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast > > for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > > AKFO. > > > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was > > never treated the way kids are today. > > He's > > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a > > club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from > > what I have seen on the boards, most of > > the > > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure > > if the treatment post tenotomy is the > > same > > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in > > Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > > into > > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks > > of casting post surgery and he'll be > > in > > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which > > point I'm foggy on the course of > > treatment. > > > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in > > Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > > directly if you see this message! We live in > > Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended > > by a friend who's son was treated > > for > > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in > > and I apologize if I ask questions that > > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 Stacee, Hello and welcome to the group. You do have reason for concern, whereas the AFO/KAFO's are not a part of the typical Ponseti protocol. I know Dr. Ponseti has prescribed them in exteme, rare cases with different situations. However, your situation would not fall into an extreme situation. At least not yet. My daughter 's first doctor was not following the Ponseti protocol and prescribed the KAFO's. Because we didn't know any better, we went along with it. Also, just to give you some background; her first doctor was also very highly recommended by her pediatrician and gyn. Please keep in mind just because they are highly recommended doesn't necessarily mean they are the best at the Ponseti method treatment for clubfoot. Anyway, after we went in the KAFO's, her feet (bcf) relapsed almost immediately. That is when I discovered this group and EVERYONE jumped on the bandwagon telling me to get a new doctor ASAP and the (K)AFO's are not the protocol and they just simply don't work. So we started treatment over with Dr. Herzenberg in Baltimore when she was 5 months old. We had to do casting and tenotomy over again. My daughter is 21 months old now, using the FAB/DBB as properly prescribed and her feet are doing great. So please consider another doctor (I think you have already, or I am trying to help you push your final decision if you haven't). I find it very interesting your husband remembers wearing the DBB. Well his (and yours) instincts are correct. There should be no AFO's if following the Ponseti method correctly. And like I said before, they simply don't work. One more thing I remember you mentioning was the final cast after the tenotomy. He should only wear the final cast for 3 weeks not 4. Also, there shouldn't be an additional cast after that. One the tenotomy 3-week cast is removed, they should immediately start the FAB 23/7. HTH. Good luck! littleman1013 wrote: I have to be honest and say that I didn't investigate as thoroughly as many of you did before having my baby... I know someone whose son was treated by the doc we chose with excellent results, so I went with him. I had heard about Dr. Lemke, but she is just so very young that I preferred to go with the doc we're with because he's older and has many more years of experience treating club feet. I'm starting to worry about the course of treatment after this cast comes off, though. My husband also has a club foot, as I posted earlier, and he remembers wearing the DBB -- or as he remembers, the shoes attached to the bar-- for many years. I'm almost positive that the doc we chose does not employ that method, and I don't know what his overall success rate is with the kids as they get older. You said that even if we don't obtain the results we're striving for, we could backtrack and start over, with the exception of surgery. What about our son's already having an achilles tenotomy? Are there any parents who did use the AKFO or AFO and obtained results that lasted? What is your recommendation, ee, as far as how to proceed now? What would you do if in our shoes? As far as I can tell, the doctor is using his own version of the Ponseti method. We have had 6 casts so far, including the one we're in now post tenotomy, and each looks almost identical to those shown in the sequential Ponseti photographs... each cast has turned the foot outward to the same approx degree as the Ponseti casts would, and they have been changed at either 7 or 10 day increments, with 2 short breaks to let the skin of my son's leg heal. (once for one week and once for 4 days) I'd happily entertain any input the experienced mommies (and daddies) have for us! My son is currently only 11 weeks old, so we're still extremely young and pliable, if you will! Stacee P.S. -- I may very well give you a call next week, if you really don't mind. I'd love to chat with someone who's going thru the same things!! > > Hi Stacee, good to have you on board. > > Not sure what I can say about your baby's treatment as it doesn't sound like Ponseti Method to me. Sounds like he's had quite a few casts, probably more than the Ponseti Method would have required (average of 5 casts, five to seven days between castings). My last son was treated by Dr. Ponseti in Iowa - he wore casts for 25 days pre-tenotomy, then 17 days post-tenotomy (42 days total). He's been wearing the FAB since then and has completely normal feet. > > Have you been satisfied with all the results so far though? Typically a child doesn't need 7 weeks to heal from a tenotomy, only 3, and often they out grow that cast and only go 2 weeks with excellent results. > > Are you interested in hearing more about the Ponseti Method or seeking a 2nd opinon from a P.M. doctor? > > Typically speaking AFO and AKFO style braces have had little success in maintaing the club foot correction after the casting phase often resulting in relapses, thus you'll notice all of us here have babies that wear what is called the Foot Abductin Brace (FAB, often called a DBB) which is shoes connected to a bar as that has been proven to maintain the correction as the child grows. > > Anyway, I won't hound you - but if there is every any question regarding your childs treatment/progress, etc., please don't hesitate to ask and know if he does not respond to your current treatment methods, he's young enough to back up and start over with the Ponseti Method before any surgical cures are attempted. Once he's operated on though you'll be stuck wtih those results, either good or bad (usually bad). > > If you haven't done so already I urge you to visit our Files and Links for lots of really great information about CF in general and treatments, etc. > > Good luck, > shawnee > First time posting... > > > I have been reading over many of the previous posts and thought I'd like to join in ... My > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club foot and has been sequentially casted since > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > AKFO. > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was never treated the way kids are today. He's > fully functional and you'd never know he had a club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > I'm completely new to this process, and from what I have seen on the boards, most of the > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure if the treatment post tenotomy is the same > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > It's my understanding that our ortho in Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son into > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks of casting post surgery and he'll be in > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which point I'm foggy on the course of treatment. > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > directly if you see this message! We live in Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended by a friend who's son was treated for > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in and I apologize if I ask questions that > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > Stacee > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 I just emailed Dr. Ponseti for his opinion on our situation. I hate to play devil's advocate, but I'm curious where I might find success stories from people who have NOT used the Ponseti method? As you all well know, there are at least two sides to every coin, and since everyone here has had success, of course the stories are happy. I'd like to hear from others who have had what they consider success using methods other than Ponseti's. Does that make sense? Although I believe all of you and my gut tells me to move ahead with strict Ponseti, I want to feel as though I've investigated EVERY avenue before jumping ship with our current doctor...We've already invested so much time and effort, not to mention emotional stress, ya know?! I just don't want to make a rash decision. I assume you all will understand that, to some extent anyway. I love reading the stories, though. It's so necessary to know that others are in the same boat and dealing with the same stresses as we are! It's wonderful to hear the stories of success, too! I can't wait to tell my own! Stacee > > > > Hi Stacee, good to have you on board. > > > > Not sure what I can say about your baby's treatment as it doesn't sound like Ponseti > Method to me. Sounds like he's had quite a few casts, probably more than the Ponseti > Method would have required (average of 5 casts, five to seven days between castings). My > last son was treated by Dr. Ponseti in Iowa - he wore casts for 25 days pre-tenotomy, then > 17 days post-tenotomy (42 days total). He's been wearing the FAB since then and has > completely normal feet. > > > > Have you been satisfied with all the results so far though? Typically a child doesn't > need 7 weeks to heal from a tenotomy, only 3, and often they out grow that cast and only > go 2 weeks with excellent results. > > > > Are you interested in hearing more about the Ponseti Method or seeking a 2nd opinon > from a P.M. doctor? > > > > Typically speaking AFO and AKFO style braces have had little success in maintaing the > club foot correction after the casting phase often resulting in relapses, thus you'll notice > all of us here have babies that wear what is called the Foot Abductin Brace (FAB, often > called a DBB) which is shoes connected to a bar as that has been proven to maintain the > correction as the child grows. > > > > Anyway, I won't hound you - but if there is every any question regarding your childs > treatment/progress, etc., please don't hesitate to ask and know if he does not respond to > your current treatment methods, he's young enough to back up and start over with the > Ponseti Method before any surgical cures are attempted. Once he's operated on though > you'll be stuck wtih those results, either good or bad (usually bad). > > > > If you haven't done so already I urge you to visit our Files and Links for lots of really > great information about CF in general and treatments, etc. > > > > Good luck, > > shawnee > > First time posting... > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > My > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club foot and has been sequentially casted > since > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > AKFO. > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was never treated the way kids are today. > He's > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from what I have seen on the boards, most of > the > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure if the treatment post tenotomy is the > same > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > into > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks of casting post surgery and he'll be > in > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which point I'm foggy on the course of > treatment. > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > directly if you see this message! We live in Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended by a friend who's son was treated > for > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in and I apologize if I ask questions that > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 Stacee, If you are going to be talking to your current doctor tomorrow, you might also want to ask him to describe the tenotomy that was performed on your baby. There are different kinds. Since your son is supposed to be in a cast for quite a few weeks post-op (more than what is typical here at least), you might want to ask just exactly what kind of surgery he had. Most kids here have had a percutaneous tenotomy, which is a small puncture made with the scalpel that requires no stitches to close the wound (done under local anesthesia or general based on the doctor's preference and age of child). There are other types of open-incision tenotomies, such as " z- lengthening " , that are considered more invasive and require stitches to close the incision. And some doctors " release " more than just the Achilles tendon when they're working " in there " . It would be good for you to know what kind of procedure your son had. If he had an open-incision tenotomy, he could still benefit from the Ponseti method (that is if more correction would be required), but there may be some challenges due to excess scar tissue to deal with. As for your question about good results using other methods- yes, there are a handful of families on the boards who have used the French Physiotherapy method that have had good results, and families using surgical correction that are happy with their results, but just like the majority of us, they're not too far along into their clubfoot journey. It's hard to find " adults " who are happy with their results who are on the internet because they're typically not seeking out a clubfoot board if clubfoot is not an issue in their life. There is a support board for adults who are having issues with their feet- but I don't think this is what you were asking for. Dr. Ponseti has published his long-term results (follow up on patients that he treated starting in 1948) and that info is pretty readily available for you to read. There were no " long-term " surgical studies available until recently. Dr. Dobbs just recently got permission from a retired surgeon to study the results of his surgically treated patients. He presented this at the clubfoot symposium held in Iowa in October. If you go to http://members.tripod.com/ponseti_links-ivil under the messageboard posts heading (http://members.tripod.com/ponseti_links- ivil/id5.html) there's a place to download Egbert's personal notes about the symposium and Dr. Dobbs' presentation about the study. I hope this helps!! Glad you're here! Regards, & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) http://ponseticlubfoot.freeservers.com/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 Absolutely Stacee - you gotta do your home work on both sides of the fence and have all the facts before you can make an intellegent decision that YOU are content with! You won't hear me bashing you on this one at all. Unfortunately, I do not know where to send you for such information as my non-Ponseti story isn't " happy. " Good luck to you though on your quest. s. First time posting... > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > My > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club foot and has been sequentially casted > since > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > AKFO. > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was never treated the way kids are today. > He's > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from what I have seen on the boards, most of > the > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure if the treatment post tenotomy is the > same > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > into > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks of casting post surgery and he'll be > in > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which point I'm foggy on the course of > treatment. > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > directly if you see this message! We live in Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended by a friend who's son was treated > for > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in and I apologize if I ask questions that > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2005 Report Share Posted December 11, 2005 I agree and good luck with your search. I need some help here with joining the group. I lost the e-mail that was sent to me. Please can someone send it back to me. It was the one about my profile and all the ?'s I had to answer. Thank you! Bri number23 wrote: Absolutely Stacee - you gotta do your home work on both sides of the fence and have all the facts before you can make an intellegent decision that YOU are content with! You won't hear me bashing you on this one at all. Unfortunately, I do not know where to send you for such information as my non-Ponseti story isn't " happy. " Good luck to you though on your quest. s. First time posting... > > > > > > I have been reading over many of the previous posts and thought I'd like to join in ... > My > > third child was born 9/24/05 with a right club foot and has been sequentially casted > since > > he was 2 days old. He just had an achilles tenotomy on Dec 6th and is currently in the > > cast for approx 4 weeks, then to another cast for ~3 more weeks before moving to the > > AKFO. > > > > My husband also has a right club foot, but was never treated the way kids are today. > He's > > fully functional and you'd never know he had a club foot unless you looked closely. :-) > > > > I'm completely new to this process, and from what I have seen on the boards, most of > the > > kids here have bilateral clubs, so I'm not sure if the treatment post tenotomy is the > same > > for unilateral vs bilateral? > > > > It's my understanding that our ortho in Arlington Heights, IL will be putting our son > into > > an AKFO as soon as he's done with approx 7 weeks of casting post surgery and he'll be > in > > that orthotic 23/7 until he's walking, at which point I'm foggy on the course of > treatment. > > > > I noticed another poster is seeing Dr Lemke in Geneva--- Would love to chat with you > > directly if you see this message! We live in Sugar Grove, but opted to see Dr Marty in > > Arlington Heights as he came highly recommended by a friend who's son was treated > for > > bilateral foot issues (not club foot.) > > > > Anyway, I hope you all don't mind my jumping in and I apologize if I ask questions that > > have been asked a thousand times before!! :-) > > > > Stacee > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 I will definitely ask about the type of tenotomy. My son did need stitches, and I remember the doc coming out and telling us that while he was in there, he used a tool to help separate the heel from the bone above it, which he said would help facilitate the heel moving downward. He was put under general anesthesia, though from the sounds of your post, that doesn't necessarily mean anything special. Any idea what the verdict would be if my son had a more invasive release than the Ponseti method calls for? I'm trying to figure out if we're at a point where we need to start over fresh or if we can just continue on. I suppose we won't be able to answer that until we've spoken with both docs, and hopefully also received a response from Dr Ponseti himself. Thanks again for the ongoing support and suggestions!! I will be back often, I'm sure. Stacee > > Stacee, > If you are going to be talking to your current doctor tomorrow, you > might also want to ask him to describe the tenotomy that was > performed on your baby. There are different kinds. Since your son > is supposed to be in a cast for quite a few weeks post-op (more than > what is typical here at least), you might want to ask just exactly > what kind of surgery he had. Most kids here have had a percutaneous > tenotomy, which is a small puncture made with the scalpel that > requires no stitches to close the wound (done under local anesthesia > or general based on the doctor's preference and age of child). > There are other types of open-incision tenotomies, such as " z- > lengthening " , that are considered more invasive and require stitches > to close the incision. And some doctors " release " more than just > the Achilles tendon when they're working " in there " . > It would be good for you to know what kind of procedure your son > had. If he had an open-incision tenotomy, he could still benefit > from the Ponseti method (that is if more correction would be > required), but there may be some challenges due to excess scar > tissue to deal with. > As for your question about good results using other methods- yes, > there are a handful of families on the boards who have used the > French Physiotherapy method that have had good results, and families > using surgical correction that are happy with their results, but > just like the majority of us, they're not too far along into their > clubfoot journey. It's hard to find " adults " who are happy with > their results who are on the internet because they're typically not > seeking out a clubfoot board if clubfoot is not an issue in their > life. There is a support board for adults who are having issues > with their feet- but I don't think this is what you were asking > for. Dr. Ponseti has published his long-term results (follow up on > patients that he treated starting in 1948) and that info is pretty > readily available for you to read. There were no " long-term " > surgical studies available until recently. Dr. Dobbs just recently > got permission from a retired surgeon to study the results of his > surgically treated patients. He presented this at the clubfoot > symposium held in Iowa in October. If you go to > http://members.tripod.com/ponseti_links-ivil under the messageboard > posts heading (http://members.tripod.com/ponseti_links- > ivil/id5.html) there's a place to download Egbert's personal > notes about the symposium and Dr. Dobbs' presentation about the > study. > I hope this helps!! > Glad you're here! > Regards, > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > http://ponseticlubfoot.freeservers.com/ > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 Stacee, It sounds like some kind of posterior release was performed, not just a tenotomy. I don't know what all of the ramifications might be. For sure there would be scar tissue to contend with. You probably won't be able to get a good " second opinion " with just pictures/email at this point as a doctor would probably want to physically examine the foot to give you decent feedback and to make decisions on what (if anything) more would need to be done. I don't know if Dr. Lemke has treated any patients who have previously undergone surgery- you might want to ask her this. I know that your son could still benefit from the Ponseti method, but the approach may be altered now. You're not too far from Iowa City either and might consider a trip there to see Dr. Ponseti as well! Keep us posted! & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 I just got off the phone with Dr Lemke's office and the secretary said that Dr Lemke would want to physically examine my son's foot, which would mean removing the cast. I'm not sure what to do and would love to hear everyone's input and opinions on the situation as it sits now. Would you let a different doc remove the cast to examine, only one week post tenotomy, or would you wait until the week between christmas and new year's (that's when her next appt is if we opt not to go Thursday)... or would you let anyone remove the cast at all?! We're not absolutely certain that Dr Lemke is who we will choose to continue treatment... We've also sent emails to Dr Ponseti, and two docs in Madison, WI, so any of those 3 docs could be in contention to finish treatment, ya know?! Not to mention the current doc. I'm in tears over this because I don't want to mess things up further, assuming things are messed up in the first place. My husband doesn't want to jump into any other treatment at all until he talks with our current doc, and is leery of everything in general, so I'm really having to convince him to take a chance and see someone else. I feel like I screwed up to begin with and now I'm stuck with my hands tied... no good solution (with little to no risk) at this time. Stacee > > Stacee, > It sounds like some kind of posterior release was performed, not just > a tenotomy. I don't know what all of the ramifications might be. For > sure there would be scar tissue to contend with. You probably won't > be able to get a good " second opinion " with just pictures/email at > this point as a doctor would probably want to physically examine the > foot to give you decent feedback and to make decisions on what (if > anything) more would need to be done. > I don't know if Dr. Lemke has treated any patients who have previously > undergone surgery- you might want to ask her this. I know that your > son could still benefit from the Ponseti method, but the approach may > be altered now. You're not too far from Iowa City either and might > consider a trip there to see Dr. Ponseti as well! > Keep us posted! > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 That sounds creepy to me Stacee, using a tool? But don't let my ignorance freak you out, it's just not something I have heard of and the visual image I had was creepy. s. Re: First time posting... I will definitely ask about the type of tenotomy. My son did need stitches, and I remember the doc coming out and telling us that while he was in there, he used a tool to help separate the heel from the bone above it, which he said would help facilitate the heel moving downward. He was put under general anesthesia, though from the sounds of your post, that doesn't necessarily mean anything special. Any idea what the verdict would be if my son had a more invasive release than the Ponseti method calls for? I'm trying to figure out if we're at a point where we need to start over fresh or if we can just continue on. I suppose we won't be able to answer that until we've spoken with both docs, and hopefully also received a response from Dr Ponseti himself. Thanks again for the ongoing support and suggestions!! I will be back often, I'm sure. Stacee > > Stacee, > If you are going to be talking to your current doctor tomorrow, you > might also want to ask him to describe the tenotomy that was > performed on your baby. There are different kinds. Since your son > is supposed to be in a cast for quite a few weeks post-op (more than > what is typical here at least), you might want to ask just exactly > what kind of surgery he had. Most kids here have had a percutaneous > tenotomy, which is a small puncture made with the scalpel that > requires no stitches to close the wound (done under local anesthesia > or general based on the doctor's preference and age of child). > There are other types of open-incision tenotomies, such as " z- > lengthening " , that are considered more invasive and require stitches > to close the incision. And some doctors " release " more than just > the Achilles tendon when they're working " in there " . > It would be good for you to know what kind of procedure your son > had. If he had an open-incision tenotomy, he could still benefit > from the Ponseti method (that is if more correction would be > required), but there may be some challenges due to excess scar > tissue to deal with. > As for your question about good results using other methods- yes, > there are a handful of families on the boards who have used the > French Physiotherapy method that have had good results, and families > using surgical correction that are happy with their results, but > just like the majority of us, they're not too far along into their > clubfoot journey. It's hard to find " adults " who are happy with > their results who are on the internet because they're typically not > seeking out a clubfoot board if clubfoot is not an issue in their > life. There is a support board for adults who are having issues > with their feet- but I don't think this is what you were asking > for. Dr. Ponseti has published his long-term results (follow up on > patients that he treated starting in 1948) and that info is pretty > readily available for you to read. There were no " long-term " > surgical studies available until recently. Dr. Dobbs just recently > got permission from a retired surgeon to study the results of his > surgically treated patients. He presented this at the clubfoot > symposium held in Iowa in October. If you go to > http://members.tripod.com/ponseti_links-ivil under the messageboard > posts heading (http://members.tripod.com/ponseti_links- > ivil/id5.html) there's a place to download Egbert's personal > notes about the symposium and Dr. Dobbs' presentation about the > study. > I hope this helps!! > Glad you're here! > Regards, > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > http://ponseticlubfoot.freeservers.com/ > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 Hmmm, decisions, decisions.... SO your son is currently wearing his post-tenotomy cast, correct? Man, I'm stumped. Not what you wanted to hear, is it? I wonder...if you let this cast ride and see what you have underneath when the foot comes out...then seek a 2nd opinion? I just dont' know because by the same token the foot is healing right now, and if it is healing in the wrong position or something.... I think at this point I would defer to a higher opinion - asking Dr.'s Ponseti and Dobbs and even this Lemeke (don't know that doc) what they advise. If the cast had to be removed for an evaulation, certainly they would replace it - but is that the best thing at this point? I don't know the answer to that. All this goes with out saying that there is also the possibility your son's foot is just fine. Keep digging for information and follow your Mommy Instinct; talk to these other doctors, explain your situation and see what info they can add to the mix for you to work with. s. Re: First time posting... I just got off the phone with Dr Lemke's office and the secretary said that Dr Lemke would want to physically examine my son's foot, which would mean removing the cast. I'm not sure what to do and would love to hear everyone's input and opinions on the situation as it sits now. Would you let a different doc remove the cast to examine, only one week post tenotomy, or would you wait until the week between christmas and new year's (that's when her next appt is if we opt not to go Thursday)... or would you let anyone remove the cast at all?! We're not absolutely certain that Dr Lemke is who we will choose to continue treatment... We've also sent emails to Dr Ponseti, and two docs in Madison, WI, so any of those 3 docs could be in contention to finish treatment, ya know?! Not to mention the current doc. I'm in tears over this because I don't want to mess things up further, assuming things are messed up in the first place. My husband doesn't want to jump into any other treatment at all until he talks with our current doc, and is leery of everything in general, so I'm really having to convince him to take a chance and see someone else. I feel like I screwed up to begin with and now I'm stuck with my hands tied... no good solution (with little to no risk) at this time. Stacee > > Stacee, > It sounds like some kind of posterior release was performed, not just > a tenotomy. I don't know what all of the ramifications might be. For > sure there would be scar tissue to contend with. You probably won't > be able to get a good " second opinion " with just pictures/email at > this point as a doctor would probably want to physically examine the > foot to give you decent feedback and to make decisions on what (if > anything) more would need to be done. > I don't know if Dr. Lemke has treated any patients who have previously > undergone surgery- you might want to ask her this. I know that your > son could still benefit from the Ponseti method, but the approach may > be altered now. You're not too far from Iowa City either and might > consider a trip there to see Dr. Ponseti as well! > Keep us posted! > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 Yes, my son is wearing the post tenotomy cast, but it's not just supposed to be on for your typical 3 weeks as with Ponseti's method... Our doc intends to keep this one on for 4 weeks from Dec 6th, then apply another for 3 more weeks. On the one hand, I'm figuring that if a Ponseti doctor removed the cast, they presumably would reapply it according to Ponseti, if possible, so that would probably be a good thing. At the same time, I just don't know if it's a good idea AT ALL to remove the cast before the foot is healed. And, as you pointed out, the foot may or may not be healing properly. Which means that we could either cause more damage or keep damage to a minimum. So many ifs and maybes!! I could go crazy. I have received an email back from Dr Noonan in Wisconsin, who stated my options are basically: 1) stick with current treatment and seek help if we encounter problems, or 2) wait until cast is off and go see him or his colleague. I responded and am awaiting his reply. It seems ludacris to wait 6 more weeks to seek a second opinon, since that's about how long good treatment should take!!! But at the same time, I don't want to cause more damage. I'm just so confused and angry! Stacee > > > > Stacee, > > It sounds like some kind of posterior release was performed, not just > > a tenotomy. I don't know what all of the ramifications might be. For > > sure there would be scar tissue to contend with. You probably won't > > be able to get a good " second opinion " with just pictures/email at > > this point as a doctor would probably want to physically examine the > > foot to give you decent feedback and to make decisions on what (if > > anything) more would need to be done. > > I don't know if Dr. Lemke has treated any patients who have previously > > undergone surgery- you might want to ask her this. I know that your > > son could still benefit from the Ponseti method, but the approach may > > be altered now. You're not too far from Iowa City either and might > > consider a trip there to see Dr. Ponseti as well! > > Keep us posted! > > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 I am not sure why any doctor would want to remove a cast so soon. Unless there was a problem with the cast it's self. So I guess I would say NO don't let him. But that is my opinion. I to know how you feel, I let my son's doctor take advantage of us and he wasn't even doing the job he was getting payed for. I felt like a bad mother for letting this happen to my son. We did find another doctor and it took me sometime to trust him. For most parents this is all new to us, we look for the best doctor we can find and want to trust him/her with our child. Just as long as you do something when your ( this is not right ) alarm gose off.( hope that made sense to you, I have been up for 24 hours now, so many things don't make sense to me right now )lol We are only humans here and sometimes even we find out that the person we are suppose to trust is not doing things the way we want for our child. Your are doing good for your child. Just follow what you think is best.Keep working on the dh and if he still isn't sure on what to do tell him that you think this is best for your child and you are going but would love him to be there for support. Good luck and let us know what you are going to do. Bri littleman1013 wrote: I just got off the phone with Dr Lemke's office and the secretary said that Dr Lemke would want to physically examine my son's foot, which would mean removing the cast. I'm not sure what to do and would love to hear everyone's input and opinions on the situation as it sits now. Would you let a different doc remove the cast to examine, only one week post tenotomy, or would you wait until the week between christmas and new year's (that's when her next appt is if we opt not to go Thursday)... or would you let anyone remove the cast at all?! We're not absolutely certain that Dr Lemke is who we will choose to continue treatment... We've also sent emails to Dr Ponseti, and two docs in Madison, WI, so any of those 3 docs could be in contention to finish treatment, ya know?! Not to mention the current doc. I'm in tears over this because I don't want to mess things up further, assuming things are messed up in the first place. My husband doesn't want to jump into any other treatment at all until he talks with our current doc, and is leery of everything in general, so I'm really having to convince him to take a chance and see someone else. I feel like I screwed up to begin with and now I'm stuck with my hands tied... no good solution (with little to no risk) at this time. Stacee > > Stacee, > It sounds like some kind of posterior release was performed, not just > a tenotomy. I don't know what all of the ramifications might be. For > sure there would be scar tissue to contend with. You probably won't > be able to get a good " second opinion " with just pictures/email at > this point as a doctor would probably want to physically examine the > foot to give you decent feedback and to make decisions on what (if > anything) more would need to be done. > I don't know if Dr. Lemke has treated any patients who have previously > undergone surgery- you might want to ask her this. I know that your > son could still benefit from the Ponseti method, but the approach may > be altered now. You're not too far from Iowa City either and might > consider a trip there to see Dr. Ponseti as well! > Keep us posted! > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 Stacee, If it were me, I would wait until after the 3rd week is over in this current cast. Then go see a second opinion from Dr. Noonan or other qualified Ponseti doctor. After the 3rd week, the heels should be completely healed (assuming) and removing them at that point should do no more harm. I would let whomever you choose to see at the second opinion remove the casts. Good luck. I know it is frustrating. Go with your gut instinct, it is almost always correct when referring to your own child. littleman1013 wrote: Yes, my son is wearing the post tenotomy cast, but it's not just supposed to be on for your typical 3 weeks as with Ponseti's method... Our doc intends to keep this one on for 4 weeks from Dec 6th, then apply another for 3 more weeks. On the one hand, I'm figuring that if a Ponseti doctor removed the cast, they presumably would reapply it according to Ponseti, if possible, so that would probably be a good thing. At the same time, I just don't know if it's a good idea AT ALL to remove the cast before the foot is healed. And, as you pointed out, the foot may or may not be healing properly. Which means that we could either cause more damage or keep damage to a minimum. So many ifs and maybes!! I could go crazy. I have received an email back from Dr Noonan in Wisconsin, who stated my options are basically: 1) stick with current treatment and seek help if we encounter problems, or 2) wait until cast is off and go see him or his colleague. I responded and am awaiting his reply. It seems ludacris to wait 6 more weeks to seek a second opinon, since that's about how long good treatment should take!!! But at the same time, I don't want to cause more damage. I'm just so confused and angry! Stacee > > > > Stacee, > > It sounds like some kind of posterior release was performed, not just > > a tenotomy. I don't know what all of the ramifications might be. For > > sure there would be scar tissue to contend with. You probably won't > > be able to get a good " second opinion " with just pictures/email at > > this point as a doctor would probably want to physically examine the > > foot to give you decent feedback and to make decisions on what (if > > anything) more would need to be done. > > I don't know if Dr. Lemke has treated any patients who have previously > > undergone surgery- you might want to ask her this. I know that your > > son could still benefit from the Ponseti method, but the approach may > > be altered now. You're not too far from Iowa City either and might > > consider a trip there to see Dr. Ponseti as well! > > Keep us posted! > > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 Stacee- Generally, I don't think it would be a good idea to take the cast off prior to the 4 weeks- especially if it was a doctor who did not perform the procedure so they wouldn't know what had been done. With releases like that, the typical protocol is 6-10 weeks of post-op casting, this is necessary to let it heal. If you could get in to see a doctor at the 4 week point when he's scheduled for the cast-change, then a new doc might be willing to remove the cast and see where the foot is at. Any sooner than that might be too risky. You'll have to do your own research and soul-searching, but my recommendation if you want a second opinion would be for you to take your son to Iowa initially. Get the input from the doctors there first and then decide if you want to do the rest of the follow ups with your current doc, Dr. Lemke or Noonan. Since you're dealing with something " different " at this point, I'd get the input from Iowa first since there's no other place in the world with more experience and research regarding clubfoot. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 Since this was more involved than the percutaneous tenotomy, I would think at that point that it might be closed " externally " so the risk of infection would be slim, but not completely healed " internally " - this is why they could do the cast change, but would need more time immobilized to allow the internal components to finish healing. Stacee, do you know if the cast change at the 4 week point was supposed to take place in an office setting or in the operating (sterile) room? This might help you decide how to proceed also. After the 3rd week, the heels should be completely healed (assuming) and removing them at that point should do no more harm. I would let whomever you choose to see at the second opinion remove the casts. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 Hi Stacee, Does Dr Lemke realise that your son had more than just the tenotomy? Maybe she wouldn't want to take the cast off that early if she did? On the other hand I can't think what could go wrong if she did take it off and replaced it straight away, as you said, it might be even better, difficult to know... On the other other hand (not enough hands... ) I suppose since your current doctor has already done the surgery anyway, all you can loose by waiting until the cast comes off is a few weeks which probably won't make much difference in the scheme of things... I realise this won't help you at all, sorry about that. I guess if this was my son what I would do is try and get in touch with Dr Ponseti himself and ask his opinion as to whether you should wait until the cast comes off or have the foot examined beforehand (and what difference it would make if any). I think if he suggests to take the cast off now for an examination then I would go for it but otherwise I would wait until the current doctor takes it off and go from there. Ideally you'd have an appointment set up for straight afterwards in case the foot turns out to be properly corrected after all so that you can get the proper brace for it there and then, otherwise you might loose any correction gained. Anyway, don't beat yourself up about not knowing more about this earlier. It sounds like you did research this beforehand but your doctor didn't give you the whole picture, you can hardly blame yourself for this! To be honest, I didn't know all that much about it all at the beginning either. In fact, my son was the first baby to be treated with the Ponseti method by our doctor so there was a risk of it not working as well. We decided to go with her after all and change doctors if after the first couple of weeks or so we didn't see an improvement. Luckily it seems that she did it right since she fixed his foot in 7 casts and a tenotomy and it looks and works absolutely perfectly now (I also sent some pictures to Dr Ponseti for his opinion and luckily he agreed). I guess it could have easily gone the other way... I hope it all works out ok for you! with (3y) and Alister (3y, RCF, Ponseti method, UK) --- littleman1013 wrote: > I just got off the phone with Dr Lemke's office and > the secretary said that Dr Lemke would > want to physically examine my son's foot, which > would mean removing the cast. I'm not > sure what to do and would love to hear everyone's > input and opinions on the situation as it > sits now. > > Would you let a different doc remove the cast to > examine, only one week post tenotomy, > or would you wait until the week between christmas > and new year's (that's when her next > appt is if we opt not to go Thursday)... or would > you let anyone remove the cast at all?! > We're not absolutely certain that Dr Lemke is who we > will choose to continue treatment... > We've also sent emails to Dr Ponseti, and two docs > in Madison, WI, so any of those 3 docs > could be in contention to finish treatment, ya > know?! Not to mention the current doc. > > I'm in tears over this because I don't want to mess > things up further, assuming things are > messed up in the first place. My husband doesn't > want to jump into any other treatment > at all until he talks with our current doc, and is > leery of everything in general, so I'm really > having to convince him to take a chance and see > someone else. I feel like I screwed up to > begin with and now I'm stuck with my hands tied... > no good solution (with little to no risk) > at this time. > > Stacee > > > > > > Stacee, > > It sounds like some kind of posterior release was > performed, not just > > a tenotomy. I don't know what all of the > ramifications might be. For > > sure there would be scar tissue to contend with. > You probably won't > > be able to get a good " second opinion " with just > pictures/email at > > this point as a doctor would probably want to > physically examine the > > foot to give you decent feedback and to make > decisions on what (if > > anything) more would need to be done. > > I don't know if Dr. Lemke has treated any patients > who have previously > > undergone surgery- you might want to ask her this. > I know that your > > son could still benefit from the Ponseti method, > but the approach may > > be altered now. You're not too far from Iowa City > either and might > > consider a trip there to see Dr. Ponseti as well! > > Keep us posted! > > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > > > > > > > ___________________________________________________________ To help you stay safe and secure online, we've developed the all new Yahoo! Security Centre. http://uk.security.yahoo.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 Hi Stacee, > I hate to play devil's advocate, but I'm curious > where I might find success stories from people who > have NOT used the Ponseti method? There is a Yahoo group for the French physio method (I forgot what it was called but searching for 'French' and 'clubfoot' might bring it up) that might have some success stories. I looked into this at the beginning as well since it involves no surgery at all, not even the tenotomy, so the long-term outcome is probably very good. But treatment lasts much longer and the success rate is not as high as with the Ponseti method (I think it was 60% but I can't quite remember). Then there are quite a few parents whose children have been treated with surgery. A lot of them seem very happy with the outcome but my personal fear would be the long-term effect again (pain, arthritis, etc). Of course I realise that this doesn't have to be the case and that sometimes there is no other choice! Then the only other treatment that I'm aware of is the kite method which I don't think is practiced much anymore since it involves 2 years of plaster casts (Dr Ponseti's 2 months sounds much better...). As to the long-term success, I noticed that you've already been pointed to Dr Ponseti's study on this. I'm a member of the 'TheFeetClub' group as well (there are mainly affected adults on there) in order to learn what might be in store for my son in future. So far it seems to me that most people with foot problems on there have been treated surgically (usually with lots of surgeries). Now that doesn't prove anything of course since not as many people were treated with the Ponseti method as were treated surgically but I still find it quite comforting... (or is that wrong?) Take care, with (3y) and Alister (3y, RCF, Ponseti method, UK) ___________________________________________________________ How much free photo storage do you get? Store your holiday snaps for FREE with Yahoo! Photos http://uk.photos.yahoo.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2005 Report Share Posted December 12, 2005 I was thinking the same. No reason to go forward with the second 3 week cast with the current doc until you get at least one other opinion and decide you are comfortable with the current course of treatment. I would be nervous though about removing the cast before the tendon has had a chance to heal completely though. Unless it was Dr. Ponseti himself, as with him you couldn't go wrong DO trust your gut, and from what you've written your gut is telling you that you need at least one more opinion, so get that! Good luck! Marcia Re: Re: First time posting... Stacee, If it were me, I would wait until after the 3rd week is over in this current cast. Then go see a second opinion from Dr. Noonan or other qualified Ponseti doctor. After the 3rd week, the heels should be completely healed (assuming) and removing them at that point should do no more harm. I would let whomever you choose to see at the second opinion remove the casts. Good luck. I know it is frustrating. Go with your gut instinct, it is almost always correct when referring to your own child. littleman1013 wrote: Yes, my son is wearing the post tenotomy cast, but it's not just supposed to be on for your typical 3 weeks as with Ponseti's method... Our doc intends to keep this one on for 4 weeks from Dec 6th, then apply another for 3 more weeks. On the one hand, I'm figuring that if a Ponseti doctor removed the cast, they presumably would reapply it according to Ponseti, if possible, so that would probably be a good thing. At the same time, I just don't know if it's a good idea AT ALL to remove the cast before the foot is healed. And, as you pointed out, the foot may or may not be healing properly. Which means that we could either cause more damage or keep damage to a minimum. So many ifs and maybes!! I could go crazy. I have received an email back from Dr Noonan in Wisconsin, who stated my options are basically: 1) stick with current treatment and seek help if we encounter problems, or 2) wait until cast is off and go see him or his colleague. I responded and am awaiting his reply. It seems ludacris to wait 6 more weeks to seek a second opinon, since that's about how long good treatment should take!!! But at the same time, I don't want to cause more damage. I'm just so confused and angry! Stacee > > > > Stacee, > > It sounds like some kind of posterior release was performed, not just > > a tenotomy. I don't know what all of the ramifications might be. For > > sure there would be scar tissue to contend with. You probably won't > > be able to get a good " second opinion " with just pictures/email at > > this point as a doctor would probably want to physically examine the > > foot to give you decent feedback and to make decisions on what (if > > anything) more would need to be done. > > I don't know if Dr. Lemke has treated any patients who have previously > > undergone surgery- you might want to ask her this. I know that your > > son could still benefit from the Ponseti method, but the approach may > > be altered now. You're not too far from Iowa City either and might > > consider a trip there to see Dr. Ponseti as well! > > Keep us posted! > > & (3-16-00, left clubfoot) > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.