Guest guest Posted November 27, 2001 Report Share Posted November 27, 2001 Dianne, I think your post was thoughtful and reasonable. I try to give everyone the benefit of the doubt when they post and aim them in the direction of credible information. I do have to say that I have a lack of tolerance for trolls or folks who seek information by stating what they know to be fact when indeed they are still in a research mode. Instead of battling with these folks, I tend to delete em, as I have to many emails to read to begin with. On the other hand, what may be perceived as intolerant is actually dilligence on the part of many who will not risk even one undecided person perhaps making a lasting damaging decision because a new person espouses " facts " that arent' and rationale, that isn't. With that said, I have always preferred honey to sledge hammers...well unless its my kids! Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Theresa 11-19-01 Dr. Jossart > Hi, Y'all, > First, let me say I have gotten excellent info from this group in posts and personal email--thanks to you all. I'm a critical care nurse, and I still have hundreds of questions, concerns, and fears. How many more someone with no medical background must have boggles my mind. Without those of you who have gone before--thru surgery, insurance hassles, and pre and post operative complications where would those of us coming after be? Lost. That said............ > If someone is researching WLS s/he needs to be able to receive civil answers about WHY the DS procedure is so much superior to the RNY *in terms of quality of life issues* as well as weightloss/lack of regain issues. How is anyone supposed to ask which procedure is better if s/he doesn't use the *name* of the procedure they are asking about? As soon as RNY comes off someone's keyboard, y'all jump in their poop. > May I offer this suggestion--point them to the DS website where anatomy, comparisons, personal experience, surgeons, insurance, long term reports, and links aid them in their quest for the best procedure for them; then invite them back with their questions *about DS* after they have done their homework. If they have questions about RNY, they can go to the RNY groups. > Stupid doesn't enter into it here, either; misinformed, brainwashed, ignorant maybe; but stupid, no. Personally, I get more good info in a devil's advocate situation--but some folks are offended and feel personally attacked. > Easy Does It! > Dianne Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 27, 2001 Report Share Posted November 27, 2001 Dianne- In Valhalla, you would be right. However, the original posts did not ask questions. There was one that did include a question and it was answered. The rest were merely misstatements of fact which I suspect the authors well knew were untruthful and designed to mislead. I don't think that you can find many, if any, instances on this list of people being bashed for asking about the differences between the surgeries, unless those questions were loaded with misinformation as were the ones in question. Best- Nick DS vs. RNY Research > Hi, Y'all, > First, let me say I have gotten excellent info from this group in posts and personal email--thanks to you all. I'm a critical care nurse, and I still have hundreds of questions, concerns, and fears. How many more someone with no medical background must have boggles my mind. Without those of you who have gone before--thru surgery, insurance hassles, and pre and post operative complications where would those of us coming after be? Lost. That said............ > If someone is researching WLS s/he needs to be able to receive civil answers about WHY the DS procedure is so much superior to the RNY *in terms of quality of life issues* as well as weightloss/lack of regain issues. How is anyone supposed to ask which procedure is better if s/he doesn't use the *name* of the procedure they are asking about? As soon as RNY comes off someone's keyboard, y'all jump in their poop. > May I offer this suggestion--point them to the DS website where anatomy, comparisons, personal experience, surgeons, insurance, long term reports, and links aid them in their quest for the best procedure for them; then invite them back with their questions *about DS* after they have done their homework. If they have questions about RNY, they can go to the RNY groups. > Stupid doesn't enter into it here, either; misinformed, brainwashed, ignorant maybe; but stupid, no. Personally, I get more good info in a devil's advocate situation--but some folks are offended and feel personally attacked. > Easy Does It! > Dianne > > > > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.