RE: reward system - how effective is it ???

[Guest guest]

That's not an option anymore - we pulled him from the public school and he is at a private school and is doing better than we could have ever imagined. We also pulled our 9th grader and he goes there too and just loves it. We have the school district person coming to observe on Wednesday for our mediation meeting and then hearing. It ought to be interesting! He is now in a larger class than he was last year, yet he has made more progress already this year than all of last year. And he gets up and goes to school. Last year we started every day with an argument about going to school. This year he gets up and goes.

And the best testament of all: On Christmas morning he was looking to see what Santa had left and he couldn't find it. While he was looking, he said, "Oh well , we've already got our Christmas present. You know.....Flint!" Flint Academy is the school they both attend. And that was our Christmas present too. How many folks can say their child (typical or not) feels that way about their school?

Trish

( ) reward system - how effective is it ???

With my concern with my son's organization is still at a complete standstill. Including asking the school for help. They did help somewhat with an organization chart - check off list - with prompting. but my son still forgets/loses his winter clothes/boots/gloves forgets his books/homework folder, etc...(less often with that chart) The school came up with a reward system. If he ''remembers'' to take home his belongings, he should get a reward, if not, he should get a consequence. Now I'm not sure why they think this would work for him. If he remembers to bring home his winter clothes/homework assignments on Monday (because there was no distractions to help him forget) and he gets a reward. and again on Tuesday, and maybe Wednesday and he gets a reward but on Thursday there was lots of distractions and maybe a fire drill, change of activity etc.. and he forgets because his routine was changed. How would a consequence work? and the days that he did "happen" to remember to take everything home. Why should a reward make a difference ''as a teaching method''? was it a consequience that he remembered? no distractions, or somebody reminded him?..Now I do believe in the reward system for certain things.(younger age group). but not as a main idea for a teaching strategies. because when he doesn't remember his things and is clueless to forgetting them and its not intentionally but because its due to a change of routine, (he forgot). I feel this only makes the child feel bad about him/her self and lowers their self esteem...He is not doing this by choice.If someone had a fear of the dark, a real fear. would you tell them if you go into the basement without light, I'll give you a reward and if you don't, I'll give you a consequence, because there is nothing there for you to be afraid of? I know this is a poor example, but my point is, a reward/consequence doesn't work to teach a person without a strategy & routine to help them out.I also feel it's like a time out for a child. "Time out" doesn't teach the child anything. but it does give everybody a break for a few minutes. and I can add: with behavioral concerns: if the child was told:, If you behave today and not hit or yell at anyone today, ''you will get a reward''. that can set up your child for abuse. If another child was teasing your child and pushed your child. he/she won't do/say anything about it because he/she "wants that reward" and not a consequence.. meanwhile the child is being bullied and no one will know... so how effective is that reward?. I believe that might be a good idea for pre-school age children (with somethings) but older children need a strategy and routine to help them out. and if that doesn't work, it's the wrong strategy...just my experience Rose

Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.

Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.

[Guest guest]

Wow. That's awesome. You're doing something right, Trish. Hee hee. Keep fighting for what you know he deserves, then, and keep us posted. RobinTrisha Rice <rice.trish@...> wrote: That's not an option anymore - we pulled him from the public school and he is at a private school and is doing better than we could have ever imagined. We also pulled our 9th grader and he goes there too and just loves it.

We have the school district person coming to observe on Wednesday for our mediation meeting and then hearing. It ought to be interesting! He is now in a larger class than he was last year, yet he has made more progress already this year than all of last year. And he gets up and goes to school. Last year we started every day with an argument about going to school. This year he gets up and goes. And the best testament of all: On Christmas morning he was looking to see what Santa had left and he couldn't find it. While he was looking, he said, "Oh well , we've already got our Christmas present. You know.....Flint!" Flint Academy is the school they both attend. And that was our Christmas present

too. How many folks can say their child (typical or not) feels that way about their school? Trish

( ) reward system - how effective is it ??? With my concern with my son's organization is still at a complete standstill. Including asking the school for help. They did help somewhat with an organization chart - check off list - with prompting. but my son still forgets/loses his winter clothes/boots/gloves forgets his books/homework folder, etc...(less often with that chart) The school came up with a reward system. If he ''remembers'' to take home his belongings, he should get a reward, if not, he should get a consequence. Now I'm not sure why they think this would work for him. If he remembers to bring home his winter clothes/homework assignments on Monday (because there was no distractions to help him forget) and he gets a reward. and again on Tuesday, and maybe Wednesday and he gets a reward but on Thursday there was lots of distractions and

maybe a fire drill, change of activity etc.. and he forgets because his routine was changed. How would a consequence work? and the days that he did "happen" to remember to take everything home. Why should a reward make a difference ''as a teaching method''? was it a consequience that he remembered? no distractions, or somebody reminded him?..Now I do believe in the reward system for certain things.(younger age group). but not as a main idea for a teaching strategies. because when he doesn't remember his things and is clueless to forgetting them and its not intentionally but because its due to a change of routine, (he forgot). I feel this only makes the child feel bad about him/her self and lowers their self esteem...He is not doing this by choice.If someone had a fear of the dark, a real fear. would you tell them if you go into the basement without light, I'll give you a reward and if you don't, I'll give you a

consequence, because there is nothing there for you to be afraid of? I know this is a poor example, but my point is, a reward/consequence doesn't work to teach a person without a strategy & routine to help them out.I also feel it's like a time out for a child. "Time out" doesn't teach the child anything. but it does give everybody a break for a few minutes. and I can add: with behavioral concerns: if the child was told:, If you behave today and not hit or yell at anyone today, ''you will get a reward''. that can set up your child for abuse. If another child was teasing your child and pushed your child. he/she won't do/say anything about it because he/she "wants that reward" and not a consequence.. meanwhile the child is being bullied and no one will know... so how effective is that reward?. I believe that might be a good idea for pre-school age children (with somethings) but older children need a strategy and

routine to help them out. and if that doesn't work, it's the wrong strategy...just my experience Rose Never miss a thing. Make your homepage. Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.

Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Mobile. Try it now.

[Guest guest]

I understand what you are saying completely and I agree. Most of the time, these kinds of plans are what I call, "Let the parents deal with it at home." And basically, whether he remembers or forgets, you get to deal with it at home and they don't have to do anything at the school end to facilitate his learning. Kind of nice how that works. (sarcasm!)

I think the reward system works but it has to be designed to fit the child's needs and not the school's needs. For instance, someone could design a system for him to get his things together at school and go over it with him. Then teach whatever system is working to him in parts, rewarding him every time he is successful. I don't think giving him a consequence for not being successful would work either and I like your analogy of going into the dark basement because it's true. But through achieving goals and being successful small steps at a time, he could learn and improve his abilities. Perhaps he will always need help getting organized, perhaps it will kick into gear eventually or perhaps through working with someone, he will improve over time. But I agree, just telling you to punish or reward him at home, well after the fact, does nothing at all and teaches nothing at all. Plus, it puts you in charge of the problem when you have no way of helping him learn since you are not at school and there during the time the actual problem is happening.

RoxannaAutism Happens

( ) reward system - how effective is it ???

With my concern with my son's organization is still at a complete standstill. Including asking the school for help. They did help somewhat with an organization chart - check off list - with prompting. but my son still forgets/loses his winter clothes/boots/gloves forgets his books/homework folder, etc...(less often with that chart) The school came up with a reward system. If he ''remembers'' to take home his belongings, he should get a reward, if not, he should get a consequence. Now I'm not sure why they think this would work for him. If he remembers to bring home his winter clothes/homework assignments on Monday (because there was no distractions to help him forget) and he gets a reward. and again on Tuesday, and maybe Wednesday and he gets a reward but on Thursday there was lots of distractions and maybe a fire drill, change of activity etc.. and he forgets because his routine was changed. How would a consequence work? and the days that he did "happen" to remember to take everything home. Why should a reward make a difference ''as a teaching method''? was it a consequience that he remembered? no distractions, or somebody reminded him?..Now I do believe in the reward system for certain things.(younger age group). but not as a main idea for a teaching strategies. because when he doesn't remember his things and is clueless to forgetting them and its not intentionally but because its due to a change of routine, (he forgot). I feel this only makes the child feel bad about him/her self and lowers their self esteem...He is not doing this by choice.If someone had a fear of the dark, a real fear. would you tell them if you go into the basement without light, I'll give you a reward and if you don't, I'll give you a consequence, because there is nothing there for you to be afraid of? I know this is a poor example, but my point is, a reward/consequence doesn't work to teach a person without a strategy & routine to help them out.I also feel it's like a time out for a child. "Time out" doesn't teach the child anything. but it does give everybody a break for a few minutes. and I can add: with behavioral concerns: if the child was told:, If you behave today and not hit or yell at anyone today, ''you will get a reward''. that can set up your child for abuse. If another child was teasing your child and pushed your child. he/she won't do/say anything about it because he/she "wants that reward" and not a consequence.. meanwhile the child is being bullied and no one will know... so how effective is that reward?. I believe that might be a good idea for pre-school age children (with somethings) but older children need a strategy and routine to help them out. and if that doesn't work, it's the wrong strategy...just my experience Rose