Guest guest Posted March 5, 2005 Report Share Posted March 5, 2005 > > I usually hate it when people complain and worry about how much > weight they've lost, but here I am about to do the same thing... > > I weighed myself on my home scale before I went to Mexico, and I > weigh myself on the same scale now. According to it, I have lost a > total of 22 pounds since surgery (I am one month out) but am only 4 > pounds down in the two and a half weeks since I've gotten home. > > I seriously don't understand how it is physically possible for me to > have lost only 4 pounds in this time, since I barely take in enough > calories to feed a hamster! I am tracking my intake on fitday.com, > and I have to really *try* hard to get 600 calories a day in my > system. I am doing some very light exercise, but nothing that would > be muscle-building. > > I make sure I get 80 grams of protein in a day, and have been eating > small amounts of refried beans to give me extra protein and so forth. > I take two children's chewable vitamins every day. > > What in the world is going on????? What more can I do? > > Help! Help! Help! > > ------------------ > in Jamaica > RNY Feb 5, 2005 > ------------------ Hi , First off, don't let this upset you! I had surgery back in Sept. with Dr. A. I haven't visisted the board much lately but I do try to read them from time to time. Your body has to go thur an adjustment period from the weight you have lost. Also, did you take your body measurments? Your body also loses inches instead of weight. I took mine when I first got back from Mexico. A month later when I wasn't losing I went and took measurements ... and ohhh my what a surprise! I had lost a over all body total of like 20 inches! Also, with lapband you do not lose weight as fast as other surgery.. lossing 4-8 lbs. a month I have read is a good average. ( and honestly to me, much healthier) Also, I feel you need to be eating more then 600 cal. a day. Basicly you are placing your body in a starvation mode. It is clinging onto what is in your body. Hope that makes sense. Honestly I feel you should be at 1000 cal. a day. And also how much exercise are you getting? If its nothing more then walking around the block a few times a day... do it! Another mistake I found myself making.... just because something says( food) " DIET " or " Low Cal " it isn't! Watch the sugar count in foods. Something as simple as Yogart has a lot of sugar in one of those small containers. I have found the best one to be Beyers Ligth as far as the least amount of sugars. Alot of your protein drinks harbor alot of sugars. Keep a watch on that! ( and honestly after your 2nd month slow down on the protein shakes, you should be getting enough protein from foods to replace some of those drinks) I also can not stress enough ... water, water, water! Water helps to flush out your body and do so many wonderful things for you. Basicly when your urine is not clear when you go to the bathroom your not getting enough water. ( of course some meds can alter this) As of the end of March it will have been 6 months for me. I have lost some where around 55-60 lbs. Inches over all body around 35. And honestly I do not get no where near the exercise I should be doing, but I do make sure at least twice a week I go out walking some where if its only around a store for a hour. Read your food lables! Its funny how things you think shouldn't hurt are! I have had my 2nd fill and honestly at this point I am pretty much content with my restriction. Sometimes I wonder if its to tight, but then I stop and think... ok did you REALLY eat that slow enough or did you REALLY chew that as good as you could have... and usually that answer is NO Take your time, chew and tiny bits! Hope some of the information has eased your mind some.. if any questions please feel free to contact me. Or anyone for that matter Hope all the " older " group is doing well... miss talking to you all! Nina and Dr. A BIG HUGS You guys are the best! Debi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2005 Report Share Posted March 5, 2005 , That is actually really good weight loss! I am losing about a pound a week and have a lot of weight to lose. A lot of times your body is going through so much adjustment and just really holds onto that stored energy. Especially when you hit the starvation mode. I know it can be frustrating but consider the fact that your body has been used to getting a certain amount of calories a day and has a routine. Then you cut it down to 600 or less a day and your body starts to freak out thinking that you are going to starve it. Just hold out for a little while longer and your weight loss will resume. But also consider that if you lose 2 pounds a week on average, you will lose over 100 pounds in a year. Keep up the good work. You are doing great!! Maggie Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 6, 2005 Report Share Posted March 6, 2005 , 22 lbs in one month is alot, I know you have only done four of those in the last 2 and half weeks, but your body is probably trying to catch up with its self, my gosh, you lost 18 lbs in the first week and a half, give your self a hand.. that is awesome, just remember this is a life time change not some quick fix over night thing, once you take it off this time, it should be the last. Take care, and don't get discouraged, Tracie in Aledo, Texas. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2005 Report Share Posted July 5, 2005 > Yeah, fire that idiot. These doc will kill you and all they want is to put you drugs and take your money. Stay off that crap and find someone who will work with you. Maybe some one on here knows a doc in your area. Where are you located? Greg I've finally calmed down since last week and can explain what > happened. > > I saw the doc on Tues and took more tests. It's a long story but he > may be planning on taking me off the meds. He made the suggestion > that I may be depressed... if you feel like poopy kaka all the time > it's hard to not get depressed. I feel much better now since I > started the therapy but now he's saying my tests were read wrong and > I don't need this type of therapy. So after more than a year and > 25lbs gained I don't need this - I need brain drugs. After a survey > of friends about my mental condition they laughed at the idea that I > was depressed. A year ago I probably was because I felt bad all the > time, went through a divorce yadda yadda yadda. > > Basically this is the nut as told to me by my endo: my total > testosterone is made up of three items - 1. Free testosterone > (floating freely) and 2. Bound testosterone (attached to Hbg) and 3. > Albumen (testosterone bound to albumen). My bound and albumen are > very low and when added to free I get a very low reading. Basically > if you add two negatives to a positive you get a low number. This is > the case. My free testosterone is too high because of the meds but > the bound and albumen mean very little in the way of processing > testosterone. So he's saying that my testosterone is normal (ha!) but > when combined it appears low. Normal humans have hbg in the 25-30 > range - mine is 9-10, which is at the very bottom of the readable > range. > > So test results are due in today... depending on the results... maybe > new doc, new meds, or status quo with a bump in meds. Even my > chiropractor even has ideas about what is wrong and how to correct > because he has had something similar. > > Here is the time line on meds and treatment over the last year. > > March 04 – Finally went to doc complaining of fatigue and sexual > dysfunction, age 39. I thought chronic fatigue syndrome. PC doc hit > the nail on the head with andropause/hypogonadism and put me on the > patch first and then androgel. This moved my T level into normal > range. Initial test was 230's. > > June 04 – had to change PC to a new doc because of insurance. She > sent me to an endo with all my results. T level was still low but doc > took me off meds to establish baseline. I crashed! T level went to > 91! > > > Aug 04 - Went back to androgel once a day. Test results up to 250's. > > Oct 04 – Androgel up to twice a day. Test results went into the high > 400s. Starting to feel much better. > > Dec 04 – Asked to change to depo injections because the androgel was > so expensive under my insurance, $200+ a month. First dose was 1.5 x > 3 weeks. > > March 05 – test results drop to 200's again. Feel good first week, > fair second week and I crater on the 3rd week. Dose increased to 1.5 > x 2 weeks. > > May 05 – test results at 577 yippie! Starting to turn the corner. On > my own I split my meds to .75 every week to help with water retention > and peak and valley. Light at the end of the tunnel. > > Jun 05 – Go in to talk with doc about bumping to 1.0 every week per > info I have received from you guys and the net. Want to confirm a lot > of stuff and tell him I'm finally where I need to be. Then I get hit > with the above bombshell. > > > Any ideas, support, evidence would be greatly appreciated. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 12, 2010 Report Share Posted April 12, 2010 Hello! I'm new here too and I had exactly the same problem! I did the low carb diet for 3 months and was so constipated, I needed to do enemas. My bowel movement is better with a bit of carbs. I dont know how to deal with this I have stopped the diet and reintroduced grains and it is better but I dont know if I should have. some candida diet allow some grains while others dont.. > > Hello Bee, hello all. > > I'm new here and I'm extremely frustrated. I've been doing a version of the candida diet for 3 months. I thought I had it down but I became interested in Bee's version because it seemed to have less supplements than the other one I was on. > > I've been eating for my blood type for years which means very little meat and lots of fruits, grains and vegetables. A bout with c dificle 10 years ago and an excessive antibiotic treatment turned my digestive system upside down and I've been relying on cleanses and grain fibre to keep myself regular. This diet has shut everything down. > > I'm starting to feel like I'd rather just go back to my old life. I could handle the hypoglycemia and anemia as long as there was a glass of wine and a small peice of chocolate waiting for me at the end of every night. > > Does anyone know approximately how long it takes the bowels to adjust to this diet? > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2010 Report Share Posted April 13, 2010 > > Hello Bee, hello all. > > I'm new here and I'm extremely frustrated. I've been doing a version of the candida diet for 3 months. I thought I had it down but I became interested in Bee's version because it seemed to have less supplements than the other one I was on. > > I've been eating for my blood type for years which means very little meat and lots of fruits, grains and vegetables. A bout with c dificle 10 years ago and an excessive antibiotic treatment turned my digestive system upside down and I've been relying on cleanses and grain fibre to keep myself regular. This diet has shut everything down. > > I'm starting to feel like I'd rather just go back to my old life. I could handle the hypoglycemia and anemia as long as there was a glass of wine and a small peice of chocolate waiting for me at the end of every night. > > Does anyone know approximately how long it takes the bowels to adjust to this diet? +++Hi there. Welcome to our group. Is your name Rhonda? As you probably realize fibres actually cause bowel problems, and aren't healthy like we are led to believe. I don't recommend cleanses, but I do recommend enemas. All of this is explained in my candida articles, so please ensure you read two important articles so you understand what you need to do and why: 1) How to Successfully Overcome Candida http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/intro2.php 2) Curing Candida, How to Get Started http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/intro1.php For encouragement and inspiration see these wonderful Success Stories by members of this group: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/success/index.php After you have read and understand more about digestion, candida, etc. please get back to us with questions. The best in health, Bee Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2010 Report Share Posted April 13, 2010 > > Hello! I'm new here too and I had exactly the same problem! I did the low carb diet for 3 months and was so constipated, I needed to do enemas. My bowel movement is better with a bit of carbs. I dont know how to deal with this I have stopped the diet and reintroduced grains and it is better but I dont know if I should have. some candida diet allow some grains while others dont.. +++Hi Caroline. Grains are very damaging to the digestive system. The reason my program gets results is because of the high " good " fats, low-carbs (no grains, etc.), etc. That's why it isn't just for candida and is an overall healing program. You may need to start with the 9-Day Program, but first change over to all of the foods allowed. Ensure you carefully read two important articles so you understand candida, and know what you need to do and why: 1) How to Successfully Overcome Candida http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/intro2.php 2) Curing Candida, How to Get Started http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/intro1.php For encouragement and inspiration see these wonderful Success Stories by members of this group: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/success/index.php Bee Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2010 Report Share Posted April 13, 2010 Thank you Bee for answering my question. I've always been afraid of becoming dependant on enemas so I've avoided them entirely. I will consider them if it continues to be a problem. I have had some success with skin brushing so I will continue that daily. I have increased my fat intake to the 200 grams that I'm meant to take but I find after a couple of days that this diet is very rich for me. I've also never been a meat eater. Any suggestions? Thank you, Rhonda > > > > Hello Bee, hello all. > > > > I'm new here and I'm extremely frustrated. I've been doing a version of the candida diet for 3 months. I thought I had it down but I became interested in Bee's version because it seemed to have less supplements than the other one I was on. > > > > I've been eating for my blood type for years which means very little meat and lots of fruits, grains and vegetables. A bout with c dificle 10 years ago and an excessive antibiotic treatment turned my digestive system upside down and I've been relying on cleanses and grain fibre to keep myself regular. This diet has shut everything down. > > > > I'm starting to feel like I'd rather just go back to my old life. I could handle the hypoglycemia and anemia as long as there was a glass of wine and a small peice of chocolate waiting for me at the end of every night. > > > > Does anyone know approximately how long it takes the bowels to adjust to this diet? > > +++Hi there. Welcome to our group. Is your name Rhonda? > > As you probably realize fibres actually cause bowel problems, and aren't healthy like we are led to believe. > > I don't recommend cleanses, but I do recommend enemas. All of this is explained in my candida articles, so please ensure you read two important articles so you understand what you need to do and why: > > 1) How to Successfully Overcome Candida > http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/intro2.php > > 2) Curing Candida, How to Get Started > http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/articles/intro1.php > > For encouragement and inspiration see these wonderful Success Stories by members of this group: http://www.healingnaturallybybee.com/success/index.php > > After you have read and understand more about digestion, candida, etc. please get back to us with questions. > > The best in health, Bee > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Share Posted April 14, 2010 > > Thank you Bee for answering my question. I've always been afraid of becoming dependant on enemas so I've avoided them entirely. I will consider them if it continues to be a problem. I have had some success with skin brushing so I will continue that daily. +++Hi Rhonda. Your body doesn't become dependent upon enemas if you follow the schedule on the articles, which means slowly weaning off of them too. > > I have increased my fat intake to the 200 grams that I'm meant to take but I find after a couple of days that this diet is very rich for me. I've also never been a meat eater. +++What do you mean by rich for you? Meats and fats are the very easiest foods for any humans to digest and utilize. If you increase your good fats too quickly you will experience more detoxing symptoms, since they are the best antioxidants anyone can consume. Of course fats are processed on 2 pathways in the body so you need all of so processing can occur like it should, i.e. vitamins A, D, E, and omega 3. Of course they also require proteins, minerals, other vitamins, etc. - all nutrients work together. The best, Bee Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change. The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point. This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!! Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! Roxanna “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 Hi Roxanna,I fully understand you, and I am to let you know that having a bad OT or ST is not only a waste of time but also detrimental to your son because they only keep emphasizing what he does wrong, not what he does right, so it becomes a nagging thing that only makes our children feel more and more inadequate. I had the same problem with the Speech Therapy my son was 6 then (dyslexic and asp on the edges as you call it) he was with her with a year with NO progress at all, and she kept saying that it is because he is lazy and does not do the exercices, my son hated her, I should have listen to my son earlier, one day I was dropping him with the Speech Therapist after school, and she said in front of him "he is far behind, sometimes certain kids learn at a slower pace than other, I think your son is not doing well" then she looked at my son and said: " Well, let see if you do something right today". Immediately in that moment I confronted her, I sent my son to the library and I told her: "How can you to to any child like this? have you taken any course in Psychology? do you know that the most fragile part in dyslexic children is their self-esteem? Do you know that they already feel like a failure and is up to us to change that? I was furious, I terminated her in that moment, took my son back home and stop Speech Therapy all together for 6 months and we finally moved districts to a wonderful school where he is finally pronouncing the OR, he used to say: deer, instead or door, or flair instead of floor, now he is 8 and he has progressed tremendously, and ST is caring and he loves her because she makes him feel good about himself ( which I think is very important) so in my opinion, yes your not only waisting your time but you are also driving so long for your son to feel bad about himself, I don't think is a good idea, either you request another OT (some of them do not have a clue of what they are doing) or stop with that one and get one privately. My son is reading grade level after going to the University to a program for dyslexic children where he receives Orthon Guillingham program, so I don't have to worry about that, he loves reading! we read to him since he was born. He still has sensory issues, but for that I am hiring a private OT (insurance will cover 80%) to work with him. He is sensory seeker, he has vestibular and proprioceptive issues, he does swimming (which has helped tremendously) and this summer he is starting hippotherapy, he is very sweet, only loud when he gets frustrated, has lots of problems with Math like I told you before, but he tries very hard, he can't do spelling (oral) but if he practices the words,he can spell perfectly when he writes the word, so that is good enough for me. Have you tried to require in the IEP to do everything typed in the computer? In my son's school they told me that very soon in Middle School they will allow him to do everything in the computer (because he has so much trouble writing cursive). My heart goes to you Roxanne, I can tell you are doing so much for your son, but remember some of the helpers can damage his self stem in the way, some teacher have good intentions but no knowledge of Child Psychology, and some of them they don't even like children.Good luck, and have a nice Super Bowl Sunday, my son and my husband are going out to get me a present, my birthday is coming on Tuesday, Malls will be empty.All the best as always, From: Roxanna <MadIdeas@...> Sent: Sun, February 6, 2011 8:58:44 AMSubject: ( ) Argh! Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change. The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point. This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!! Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! Roxanna “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 My complaint of OT's is that they try to cover too many areas in one short 45 minute session. For us having the OT (any OT) focus on bi-lateral coordination only for 30m minutes and then give our daughter as a reward 15 minutes to pick what she likes to do (jump in ball pit, swing etc) made a noticeable difference. We only went to OT from age 5 - 9 and only in the summer for 8 weeks (this reduced her opposition to going). The OT's pointed out so many deficits it was just too much and I spent so much money on vision therapy, listening programs, fine motor skills, brushing programs etc. I think the money spent on working on large motor skills was worth the money. But we had to follow up with swimming, biking and roller skating (all bi-lateral skills). Pam Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 Hi Roxanne,You are way farther in this process than me but here are my thoughts.Most of our kids have pretty messy writing and from what I understand it doesn't improve very much after a certain age.It also sounds like this OT is trying to help a visual processing disorder with nagging.I would get rid of her and find another!Good luck! Careyhttp://www.GreenDiaperStore.comSent via BlackBerry from T-MobileFrom: Roxanna <MadIdeas@...>Sender: Date: Sun, 6 Feb 2011 08:58:44 -0500 (EST)< >Reply Subject: ( ) Argh! Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change.The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point.This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!!Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! Roxanna“Our lives begin to end the day webecome silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 My son has always had difficulty leaving spaces between words. Has anyone found a solution to it? On and off OT has not helped. > > > Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! > > I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is " aspie on the edges " but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to " being lazy. " Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change. > > The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is " aspie on the edges. " He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him " stupid. " That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. > > The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session " healing " his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to " erase a bad memory " and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. > > So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should " notice " he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, " He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem. " she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, " Should there be a space between those words? " and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, " Duh! " and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to " fix " with his writing and I thought, " If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own! " lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. > > I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this " theory " holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to " pay attention " when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point. > > This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. > > Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!! > > Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! > > I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! > > > > > Roxanna > “Our lives begin to end the day webecome silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 Happy Superbowl Sunday to you too Roxanna! Remember what you said to me one time. It's ok to vent! That is what we "the group" are here for. And anyway, you rarely vent. You're usually the one giving everyone else advice. You've definitely given me some. I've not had the issue you have with OT because we've never had OT services even though my son was assessed in the second grade. But we have had this issue with psychotherapists. Some just are so condesending that my son picks up on it and doesn't like them. He will even tell them he doesn't like them. Which doesn't help when they are suppose to get him to talk about his feelings. LOL! But I wouldn't worry about them thinking you're picky. You have to find someone that your son will respond to and that knows what the hell they're doing for one. With our kids it is typical for them to shut down if they feel that the person is treating them like they're stupid or if the person doesn't like them. My son can pick up on it right away and he will shut down and nothing will help. So you need to find someone that your son can make a connection with. This is key with our kids for any kind of therapy. Have you had your son tested for assistive technology? We did because our son had similar issues and also because he scored in the 7th percentile in written expression. He now has a word processor or computer written into his IEP to use as needed. That way he can consentrate on the quality of what he is writing and not have to focus so much on the mechanics of it. Well dear, good luck and like to told me one time, don't feel bad about venting. ;-)ne From: Roxanna <MadIdeas@...>Subject: ( ) Argh! Date: Sunday, February 6, 2011, 8:58 AM Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change.The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point.This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!!Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! Roxanna“Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 Happy Birthday ! I bet it would be a nice day to go to the mall. lol. I'm bumming a bit because my dh is working this weekend at the sleep lab. So I am here, watching the super bowl all alone. It's not as much fun. And the halftime show was so bad. lol. My ds screamed, "Turn that awful music off!!" from the other room. You are right, it isn't worth his self esteem, which is so fragile right now. He has dyslexia as well and we struggle with math a lot!!!!! One of his OT goals is about math - writing his problems correctly. He mixes the numbers up, subtracts going up instead of down, etc. The OT's have not helped him at all with this and having to do the math with them has been like torture for him. He can read fairly well now actually. We worked so hard for many years and it seems to have paid off. He had two teachers who specialized in orton gillingham also so that really helped. I think he can read better than he scores on testing but his score goes lower due to comprehension problems. My ds really does almost nothing with writing right now. Since he e-schools, all his stuff is online or on the computer. So he types everything. When he does his math, I am walking him through everything and I write it for him because he can't line it up or write small enough to use paper. I want to make him more independent but this OT isn't helping us get there and you are right - it is making it worse. Thanks for helping me think it through! Roxanna “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. ( ) Argh! Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change. The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point. This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!! Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! Roxanna “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 Thanks for the vote! I am thinking the same as you about it. Do you really believe the handwriting does not improve after a certain age? I need to find out how true that is. My ds has a terrible time printing. He sometimes forgets how to make a letter even. So he seems to be working twice as hard to write things because he has to know what to write and then think of how to form the letters. It hasn't seemed to become "automatic" for him yet. The thing is, he can't do any cursive. He did work hard to teach himself how to write his name in cursive. But he can't read cursive at all. The OT said a few things so far about handwriting. One, she does not plan to teach him how to write each letter because she feels after a certain age, it is better to let them do it how they do it, as long as we can read it. But my ds does not always make his letters the same way each time. And it's mostly legible - but not always. I had hoped she would work on forming the letters so he would eventually get a visual image burned into his brain at last. I wonder now if he is really too old to learn how to do it correctly and if I work with him on this, am I just wasting time? The other thing she has said is that she did not plan to teach him how to write in cursive - something I wanted him to learn as well. She said it is really not important to write in cursive any more. Well, I disagreed with that and told her I think it's important. Since he can't read cursive, whenever his teacher at school would write something, he had no idea what was going on. This year (he e-schools now) his spelling words are all written in cursive in his workbook even. I have to rewrite them for him or he couldn't even read the spelling list. Someone forgot to tell the makers of the workbooks that cursive is outdated. Roxanna “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. ( ) Argh! Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change. The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point. This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!! Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! Roxanna “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 ne, thanks for listening to my vent. It is sometimes just so frustrating. My oldest ds is like you describe your ds except my ds wouldn't tell them what he thought. But he would shut down and refuse to speak or look at them. And he would never give anyone a second chance either! My youngest ds is so similar to his brother this way. But then again, even I was frustrated watching therapy as it went so badly. We haven't tested for any AT but then again, since he e-schools, much of his stuff is on the computer already. When he has to write anything, we do it on the computer. This is helpful for right now. But I would really like him to learn to write well enough to "make it" without a computer, if possible. When he was tested for sped services, the psychologist noted in his report that is was really painful to watch my ds write. I was just happy that someone else saw what I was seeing! If he goes back to regular brick and mortar school, I will definitely have to write accommodations in for him. Roxanna “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. ( ) Argh! Date: Sunday, February 6, 2011, 8:58 AM Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change. The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point. This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!! Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! Roxanna “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 6, 2011 Report Share Posted February 6, 2011 I remember back at one of the boys' old schools, that they would have one of those tounge depressors that they used to help the younger kids remember to leave enough space between their words. Maybe you could try that.FawnFrom: KylieM <kyliemonty@...> Sent: Sun, February 6, 2011 2:27:38 PMSubject: ( ) Re: Argh! My son has always had difficulty leaving spaces between words. Has anyone found a solution to it? On and off OT has not helped. > > > Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! > > I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change. > > The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. > > The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. > > So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. > > I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point. > > This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. > > Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!! > > Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! > > I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! > > > > > Roxanna > “Our lives begin to end the day webecome silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 7, 2011 Report Share Posted February 7, 2011 Have you heard of or tried " Handwriting without Tears " ? It was created by an OT and has been a very successful program for kids who have trouble with writing. I actually went to the training seminars and looked at the " science " behind the program, and I really think it is worth looking into. If you go to the Handwriting without tears website, you may be able to find a professional that has been trained in the program in your area. Some are OT's, some are teachers. It is different from all other handwriting curriculum, and is being adopted by a lot of school systems and private schools here in Atlanta. Anyone that tells you that handwriting is no longer important is misinformed! Just thought I would mention it. Good Luck. North Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 7, 2011 Report Share Posted February 7, 2011 You mentioned that your son has trouble tracking and trouble copying things. My son had these issues as well and it was a visual function issue. We did 6 months of vision therapy and it made a big difference. The schedule was visit the doc every other week and work on therapy 1/2 hr day at home. VT is tedious but it worked for us. The doc didin't recommend doing more than 6 mos of therapy without a break because it has a high burnout rate. After the break my son didn't need it anymore. Is it possible that your son has visual function issues and could benefit from vision therapy? Here's a site with more info on visual function and vision therapy. http://www.pavevision.org/ As to handwriting, the OT gave up on my son's writing improving after he started middle school. Then at age 12 a neuropsych eval revealed that he had dysgraphia. It explained a lot. We gave up on writing cursive except for his signature. Ironically he can write almost picture perfect single letters in cursive but gets totally illegible when trying to write whole words in cursive. We have worked with him on reading cursive because there will be times he has no choice but to read it. Whenever he can for school assignments he types instead of manually writing it. Here's a site about dysgraphia. http://www.greatschools.org/special-education/LD-ADHD/dysgraphia-learning-disabi\ lity-writing.gs?content=860 Caroline > > > Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! > > I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is " aspie on the edges " but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to " being lazy. " Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change. > > The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is " aspie on the edges. " He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him " stupid. " That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. > > The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session " healing " his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to " erase a bad memory " and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. > > So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should " notice " he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, " He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem. " she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, " Should there be a space between those words? " and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, " Duh! " and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to " fix " with his writing and I thought, " If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own! " lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. > > I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this " theory " holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to " pay attention " when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point. > > This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. > > Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!! > > Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! > > I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!! > > > > > Roxanna > “Our lives begin to end the day webecome silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 7, 2011 Report Share Posted February 7, 2011 Our kids were always told to lay their pencil down after the word written.....or use a "finger width space". Robin ......A rich man is not one who has the most, but who needs the least..... From: Fawn Kazmierczak <lostfranklingirl@...>Subject: Re: ( ) Re: Argh! Date: Sunday, February 6, 2011, 10:19 PM I remember back at one of the boys' old schools, that they would have one of those tounge depressors that they used to help the younger kids remember to leave enough space between their words. Maybe you could try that.Fawn From: KylieM <kyliemonty@...> Sent: Sun, February 6, 2011 2:27:38 PMSubject: ( ) Re: Argh! My son has always had difficulty leaving spaces between words. Has anyone found a solution to it? On and off OT has not helped.>> > Happy Super Bowl Sunday everyone! > > I am having a life here. My youngest ds has dyslexia. He is "aspie on the edges" but that's kind of a family trait here. He is 11 yo and in 5th grade. He's smart enough to get by a lot of things and that is one reason it was so hard to get his dyslexia taken seriously at the school. He was always spotted for extra help, tutoring, fast forword, etc. He was RtI'd to death. But then once he got some help, he'd improve that much and they'd stop helping, where he'd continue to fall behind from there. For instance, his need to learn to read only mattered until he got good enough to pass the state test (by 4 points!). Granted, it took three years to get to there. lol. Then he went from needing help to "being lazy." Finally, we pulled him out and e-school him since the first quarter of 4th grade. He was coming home screaming and throwing things as soon as he walked in the door. So we had to make a change.> > The problem I am having is with OT's. In theory, I love these people. They should have so many answers to so many of our problems! I haven't been able to find one to work with my ds. Partly, the problem is that he is "aspie on the edges." He shuts down when things get too hard. He's failed so much that he is more apt to give up and preserve whatever dignity he has left. But he will try until he decides you are making fun of him or calling him "stupid." That's natural. But he is more likely to shut down than the average kid although it does take a bit of effort to tick him off that much. > > The school OT's never helped. He got OT in school off and on. They could tell he had trouble tracking with his eyes, for instance, but never had any clue what to do to help him work on that. Then the last eval they did, the OT did not even use his correct age to determine his scores (which were already poor enough) and kept saying handwriting was not important. The e-school of course, has to contract to private therapists for kids who need therapy. So he has one hour per week of OT. The first OT we saw did the new evaluation and she wrote a really good report and really got the problems he was having. I was elated. We worked to get the new school to let us see this one specifically. I did not realize she was also a Naturopath. She spent the whole hour long session "healing" his inner self. Very little fine motor work or help with visual alignment issues. Just a lot of hocus pocus (hold these, snap, it's all gone). I went anyway because we really need help with some of this stuff. And maybe she could help - her report was great! She did have some good ideas as well. So I tried to keep an open mind to see where it was going. But it wasn't working. She had him in tears finally one day as she tried to "erase a bad memory" and it was just so not OT. He refused to go back and I agreed it was not going to help to keep doing that sort of thing. > > So we switched to another OT that the school found. She has been not so great so far. She isn't doing anything weird but she isn't doing anything else. She has decided he should "notice" he's not leaving spaces between words and that will fix the problem. Only that is the problem. He can tell his writing is a mess just fine. He just can't make it better. I thought that would be her job - to do activities to improve his skills in these areas so he could notice these things and improve. But instead, her method seems to be, "He should just pay better attention and he won't have that problem." she makes him write paragraphs from a book - he has the worst time copying from things and hates doing it - and then she goes through it and nit picks at everything he has messed up. It's really defeating for him. And then she says, "Should there be a space between those words?" and he visibly looks like he wants to throw up on her. I know he is thinking, "Duh!" and feeling like she is talking down to him. He's not stupid and he knows this is a problem. But spacing is a problem he can't seem to figure out on his own....hence the OT!! Then the more she talks to him, the worse he feels, the more he refuses to cooperate or even speak to her and the more she decides he's just being obstinate and could do it if he just wanted to, so she talks more and pushes more, repeating this awful ugly circle for the whole hour long session. This week, for instance, I have a card I am supposed to place next to him when he writes things. It lists the 3 things he needs to "fix" with his writing and I thought, "If all it takes to fix this problem is to nag him about it, I can do that on my own!" lol) I guess I thought she would have exercises to do to improve his skills. > > I told her I didn't agree that this was something he could fix if he wanted to. She explained to me that when we hurry when we write, it comes out sloppy and that is what he is doing. I didn't even agree because I can write quickly and neatly at the same time. So I am not seeing how this "theory" holds water. But I said that was not really a problem he has. He's always had these issues of spacing whether he takes his time writing or writes quickly - and so do my other two ds's. I don't feel it's just laziness on his part. But she really implied that it was. I asked if there were not activities we could do to work on these skills (i.e. something even FUN?? Dare I say fun?) and she didn't answer me. She just repeated that he needs to "pay attention" when he is writing. I get the idea that OT is going to be a long dreary hour of making him write and then telling him it looks awful. Even if her method was a good one, it isn't working with my ds who is missing the point.> > This takes 3 hours. I drive almost an hour to get there, an hour in the therapy, an hour home. Then he is so ticked off he refuses to even speak to me. So any more schooling on these days is impossible. It's a wasted day. > > Somehow, I feel defeated. How many OT's do you have to go through to find one that is even passable and can work with this kid? I have a short list to discuss with her this next week in the hopes of salvaging the situation and have already read two books on visual perception to try and educate myself more about what he needs. But I'm not feeling confident that this is going to go well. I hope I am wrong. We'll see. Do you think the school will think we are just nit-picky people if we have to find yet another OT to work with him? Or should I give up and just figure out what things we can do on our own? Aren't these people supposed to be trained to work with kids just like this? WAAAAAAAAHHH!!!> > Has anyone else had to go through a series of therapists like this? How many did you go through before finding a real one? And is it worth it to take the kid to so many with so many failures? I am feeling like he is not going to even go to a new one at this point, he is so done with this nonsense. And frankly, I AM TOO!!! > > I am probably just venting here. It's just so frustrating to get to this point where I should be seeing my kid get help and not getting help. And wasting another year. Argh!!> > > > > Roxanna> “Our lives begin to end the day webecome silent about things that matter.†- Luther King, Jr.> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 7, 2011 Report Share Posted February 7, 2011 Thanks, , I'm gonna check it out..........don't know if it can help a kid who has Slow Processing Issues, but who knows? Robin ......A rich man is not one who has the most, but who needs the least..... From: billkatesr <katherinenorth@...>Subject: ( ) Re: Argh! Date: Monday, February 7, 2011, 6:54 AM Have you heard of or tried "Handwriting without Tears"? It was created by an OT and has been a very successful program for kids who have trouble with writing. I actually went to the training seminars and looked at the "science" behind the program, and I really think it is worth looking into. If you go to the Handwriting without tears website, you may be able to find a professional that has been trained in the program in your area. Some are OT's, some are teachers. It is different from all other handwriting curriculum, and is being adopted by a lot of school systems and private schools here in Atlanta. Anyone that tells you that handwriting is no longer important is misinformed!Just thought I would mention it. Good Luck. North Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 7, 2011 Report Share Posted February 7, 2011 heard of it and love it but private OT would do and school refused to use hear with my children From: billkatesr <katherinenorth@...> Sent: Mon, February 7, 2011 6:54:36 AMSubject: ( ) Re: Argh! Have you heard of or tried "Handwriting without Tears"? It was created by an OT and has been a very successful program for kids who have trouble with writing. I actually went to the training seminars and looked at the "science" behind the program, and I really think it is worth looking into. If you go to the Handwriting without tears website, you may be able to find a professional that has been trained in the program in your area. Some are OT's, some are teachers. It is different from all other handwriting curriculum, and is being adopted by a lot of school systems and private schools here in Atlanta. Anyone that tells you that handwriting is no longer important is misinformed!Just thought I would mention it. Good Luck. North Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 7, 2011 Report Share Posted February 7, 2011 Our OT actually just told us about Handwriting without tears today. My son is only 3 1/2, but he is really interested in learning to write (he can already read and spell, so he really wants to write out words). Our OT was concerned that he would learn to make the letters in the incorrect manner if not given instruction. She said that a lot of kids with sensory/ASD issues tend to make their letters inefficiently (starting at the bottom instead of the top), and that furthermore they do not teach handwriting in elementary school around here at all. She lent me a couple of the Handwriting without tears books to look through with my son and said the techniques are straightforward enough that I can easily use them at home (especially since my son does not have to un-learn any writing habits). It might be worth a try to help your son. Good luck! Bridget > > > From: billkatesr <katherinenorth@...> > Subject: ( ) Re: Argh! > > Date: Monday, February 7, 2011, 6:54 AM > > >  > > > > > > Have you heard of or tried " Handwriting without Tears " ? It was created by an OT and has been a very successful program for kids who have trouble with writing. I actually went to the training seminars and looked at the " science " behind the program, and I really think it is worth looking into. If you go to the Handwriting without tears website, you may be able to find a professional that has been trained in the program in your area. Some are OT's, some are teachers. It is different from all other handwriting curriculum, and is being adopted by a lot of school systems and private schools here in Atlanta. Anyone that tells you that handwriting is no longer important is misinformed! > > Just thought I would mention it. Good Luck. > North > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.