Guest guest Posted January 1, 2008 Report Share Posted January 1, 2008 I’m glad that finally someone initiated a discussion of Dr Peskin’s thesis on essential fatty acids. To resume that thesis in the shortest possible way would be that it is the EFAs which transport the oxygen to our cells preventing hypoxia and of the two EFAs omega-6 (linolenic acid) transports more than omega-3 (or olive oil) So we all have to rethink. So far we have been told that cold pressed olive oil is the healthiest thing on earth and that we all have to consume more omega-3s swallowing 3 grs of fish oil per day to keep cardiac problems and cancer away. Peskin, however, says “fish oil is worthless at best and harmful at worst” and “Fish oil supplements can significantly decrease the effectiveness of your immune system, increasing your risk of contracting cancer”. So if you want to avoid cardiac and cancer problems you better investigate this matter carefully. It might very well be the single most important nutritional issue of your life. You can do that by reading the synopsis of 3 pages mcnjnj has gracefully posted in digest 3434, or by going to www.townsendletter.com where Peskin has written an article of 7 pages, or to http://www.brianpeskin.com/efa-analysis.pdf where you will find 51 pages. Is Peskin right? As far as EFAs and cardiovascular problems are concerned, he probably is. But the focus of this comment is another. I’m a prostate cancer patient and am aware of the opinion of Dr Snuffy Meyers on EFAs. Meyers is one of the foremost oncologists in the country, specialized in PCa and very knowledgable in nutrition and PCa. He has written a book on it and publishes the health letter The Prostate Forum. All what Peskin says is in open contradiction to what Meyers recommends to his patients. Meyer says “I strongly recommend that men with prostate cancer do not use flax seed oil or a n y o t h e r oils rich in alpha-linolenic acids”. “...the inescapable conclusion is that the best way to get enough omega-3 fatty acids is to increase your intake of DHA and EPA, not alpha-linolenic acid”.”I strongly urge you to obtain ocean fish, fish oil capsules or algae-based neuromins” So, these two authorities are in flagrant contradiction to each other, at least as far as the treatment of cancer is concerned. It would probably be expecting too much that one of these doctors would manifest himself on this, so we will have to figure this out for ourselves, although the topic is really too complex to be within the grasp of a lay person. Can anybody make a contribution to this? Happy New Year --------------------------------- Looking for last minute shopping deals? Find them fast with Search. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.