Guest guest Posted October 3, 2006 Report Share Posted October 3, 2006 I think that people are overestimating the inulin benefit of food inulin sources in general, so I'll do the calculation here, starting with garlic. From my site, the table at the bottom of this page, http://members.shaw.ca/duncancrow/inulin_prebiotic_probiotic.html The inulin content of garlic is 9%-16% (dry weight) so for this calculation I'll assume the inulin content is on the high side of average at 14%; it's likely to average a bit less. If we're looking for 10 grams of inulin, we'd have to eat 71 grams of garlic, dry weight. The dry weight of garlic is an average of 42.5% of the wet weight, so the fresh garlic weight of 167 grams would about do it. I just got out of my refrigerator a bag of three prepackaged garlic roots and weighed the three; the weight came to 143 grams. So, we're looking at eating about 3 1/2 regular commercial garlic bulbs, perhaps a bit more to allow for the part you don't eat, or 6 ounces of fresh chopped garlic daily, to approach the 10 grams of inulin. This is in addition to a regular diet that contributes the other 3 gams of inulin; remember, 12-15 grams is optimal. Garlic is a decent inulin source; most foods contain much lower inulin concentrations. Dandelion root would produce almost exactly the same calculation. You'd need about twice that or 12 ounces of Jerusalem artichoke root to get the 10 grams of inulin because it's wetter so the dry weight is lower. Again, that's a daily ration; you could eat it in two meals for best results because bifidogenic properties threshold at about five grams of inulin per dose according to the research. For most people eating 6 ounces of garlic daily is unfeasible. The comment that one would need to get several servings daily of high- inulin foods is consistent with good dietary practice of eating lots of vegetables, but the most popular vegetables have about the lowest inulin content. For example, even though onions are a fairly good inulin source you'd need to eat 6 pounds of fresh peeled onions to get the 10 grams of inulin. Not that it's unfeasible, but be aware that a LOT is required, so high-inulin foods should be predominant in the diet, and this is the difficult part because a lot of farmed foods just don't have the inulin content we'd like. This is the reason fo our bowel disorder epidemic in developed counties. In a healthy bowel ecology, some of the easy carbs one eats also feed probiotic bacteria in addition to the majority of organisms so the amount of inulin can be kept down a little. Duncan Crow Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.